In re Levi, 39 Cal. 2d 41 (1952). · Go Syfert
Copy Cite In re Levi, 39 Cal. 2d 41 (1952).
California Supreme CourtPublished opinionNo. Crim. No. 5282May 19, 1952

In re Levi

Quick Summary

A court may revoke probation solely on the basis of a probation officer's report.

A defendant convicted of assault was placed on probation with a jail term, and his probation was later revoked based on a probation officer's report. The defendant was sentenced to prison without counsel present at the pronouncement of judgment. The court holds that while probation revocation hearings do not require formal trial protections such as counsel or witness summoning, the pronouncement of judgment in a felony case is a critical stage of criminal prosecution. Because the defendant was not represented by counsel when judgment was pronounced, the judgment is invalid. The court orders the defendant discharged from state prison custody and committed to the county sheriff for a new arraignment to pronounce judgment with proper legal representation.

270 citation events (32 in the last 25 years) across 8 distinct courts.
Treatment trajectory · 1953 → 2026 · click a year to view as-of
1953 1989 2026
Cited for
At page 45Imposing judgment in absence of accused25 citing casesand defend, in person and with counsel.” (Art. I, §13.) The question thus arises whether the fact that petitioner was not represented by counsel at the time of…opening of page *45 (no citing court says what it cites this page for)
  • People v. Wagner, 45 Cal. 4th 1039 (2009).published
    (In re Levi (1952) ... 39 Cal.2d 41, 45-46 [ 244 P.2d 403 ] . . . .)” (People v. Banks (1959) 53 Cal.2d 370, 386-387 [ 1 Cal.Rptr. 669 , 348 P.2d 102 ]; see also Boles v. Superior Court, supra, 37 Cal.App.3d at pp. 483-484.) By its plain l…
  • People v. Wilen, 165 Cal. App. 4th 270 (Ct. App. 2008).published
    J.) [“Pronouncement of judgment ... is a critical stage in the criminal prosecution when the constitutional rights ‘to appear and defend, in person and with counsel’ [citation] apply, and a judgment pronounced in violation of those rights…
  • People v. Zackery, 147 Cal. App. 4th 380 (Ct. App. 2007).published
    (People v. Smith (2001) 24 Cal.4th 849, 854 [ 102 Cal.Rptr.2d 731 , 14 P.3d 942 ] [an unauthorized sentence may be corrected at any time whether or not there was an objection below].) IV Clerical Errors in Minutes of Sentencing “With certa…
  • In re Williams, 83 Cal. App. 4th 936 (Ct. App. 2000).published
    In other words, the trial court was required to afford petitioner his constitutional due process rights. (7 Witkin, Summary of Cal. Law (9th ed. 1988) Constitutional Law, § 502(b), pp. 694-695.) In re Levi (1952) 39 Cal.2d 41, 45 [ 244 P.2…
  • People v. Rose, 46 Cal. App. 4th 257 (Ct. App. 1996).published
    (People v. Taylor (1993) 19 Cal.App.4th 836, 840 [ 23 Cal.Rptr.2d 846 ]; People v. Hernandez (1988) 199 Cal.App.3d 768, 773 [ 245 Cal.Rptr. 156 ].) Citing In re Levi (1952) 39 Cal.2d 41, 45 [ 244 P.2d 403 ], and numerous California Court o…
  • People v. McGee, 232 Cal. App. 3d 620 (Ct. App. 1991).published
    (In re Levi (1952) 39 Cal.2d 41, 45 [ 244 P.2d 403 ]; People v. Hernandez (1988) 199 Cal.App.3d 768,771-773 [ 245 Cal.Rptr. 156 ].) Although we do not agree with the new trial analogy, we conclude that the court acted without jurisdiction…
  • People v. Snyder, 218 Cal. App. 3d 480 (Ct. App. 1990).published 2 cites
    It is well established that subject to limited exceptions not applicable here, 5 “ ‘ “ ‘[o]nce a motion for a new trial has been ruled upon in a criminal case and an order made either granting or denying such application . . . the court is…
  • People v. Stewart, 202 Cal. App. 3d 759 (Ct. App. 1988).published
    (People v. Hernandez, supra, 199 Cal.App.3d at p. 771 ; People v. Lindsey, supra, 275 Cal.App.2d at p. 343 ; People v. Paysen (1932) 123 Cal.App. 396, 399 [ 11 P.2d 431 ]; People v. Collins (1950) 97 Cal.App.2d 552, 554-555 [ 218 P.2d 87 ]…
  • People v. Kriss, 96 Cal. App. 3d 913 (Ct. App. 1979).published 3 cites
    If judgment is pronounced in his absence, he is deprived of these rights.” ( 39 Cal.2d 41 at p. 45, citations omitted.) 5 To those rights might be added the consideration that the defendant might be able to mitigate his sentence by making…
  • In re Pickett, 25 Cal. App. 3d 1158 (Ct. App. 1972).published
    (In re Levi, supra, 39 Cal.2d 41, 45 [ 244 P.2d 403 ].) Moreover a defendant has a right to appeal from the judgment.
Show 15 more citing cases
  • People v. Floyd, 71 Cal. 2d 879 (1969).published
    (Cf. In re Levi, 39 Cal.2d 41, 45-47 [ 244 P.2d 403 ].) The judgment is reversed, and the cause remanded for resentencing in accordance with the views expressed herein.
  • People v. Lindsey, 275 Cal. App. 2d 340 (Ct. App. 1969).published
    (In re Levi, 39 Cal.2d 41, 45 [ 244 P.2d 403 ].) The cases are numerous in holding that “ '" . . it is well settled in this state that when the trial court has made its order denying the motion for a new trial ‘the right to move for a new…
  • People v. Moore, 257 Cal. App. 2d 740 (Ct. App. 1968).published
    (Compare In re Levi, 39 Cal.2d 41, 45 [ 244 P.2d 403 ] ; People v. Martin, 199 Cal. 240, 242 [ 248 P. 908 ] with People v. Risenhoover, 240 Cal.App.2d 233 [ 49 Cal.Rptr. 526 ] ; and People v. Hensel, 233 Cal.App.2d 834, 837-838 [ 43 Cal.Rp…
  • People v. Rogers, 252 Cal. App. 2d 1015 (Ct. App. 1967).published
    Before judgment could be pronounced-the defendant had the right to be present with counsel in order that he might have the opportunity to show cause why judgment should not be pronounced (In re Levi, 39 Cal.2d 41, 45 [ 244 P.2d 403 ]; In r…
  • In re Smiley, 66 Cal. 2d 606 (1967).published
    The former inquiry turns ordinarily on an abstract consideration of the law governing that stage in any case tried in the same jurisdiction (see, e.g., In re Levi (1952) 39 Cal.2d 41, 45-46 [ 241 P.2d 403 ]), and does not authorize unbridl…
  • In re Grayson, 242 Cal. App. 2d 110 (Ct. App. 1966).published
    (In re Levi, 39 Cal.2d 41, 45 [ 244 P.2d 403 ]; People v. De Waele, 224 Cal.App.2d 512, 515 [ 36 Cal.Rptr. 825 ].) If the defendant is represented by counsel or has made an effective waiver, omission of the inquiry is only an error of law,…
  • People v. Ware, 241 Cal. App. 2d 143 (Ct. App. 1966).published
    (In re Levi, 39 Cal.2d 41, 45 [ 244 P.2d 403 ]; People v. De Waele, 224 Cal.App.2d 512 [ 36 Cal.Rptr. 825 ].) It is elemental, too, that the right to counsel includes an opportunity for counsel to consult with his client and to make reason…
  • People v. Risenhoover, 240 Cal. App. 2d 233 (Ct. App. 1966).published 2 cites
    (People v. Walker, 142 Cal. 90 [ 75 P. 658 ]; People v. Fice, 97 Cal. 459, 460 [ 32 P. 531 ]; People v. Martin, 199 Cal. 240 [ 248 P. 908 ]; In re Levi, 39 Cal.2d 41, 45 [ 244 P.2d 403 ]; People v. Paysen, 123 Cal.App. 396, 399 [ 11 P.2d 4…
  • People v. Hensel, 233 Cal. App. 2d 834 (Ct. App. 1965).published
    Preliminarily, the Attorney General argues that the trial court, having once denied a motion for a new trial, was without jurisdiction to vacate that order and entertain a new motion. 2 In support of this contention, he cites a footnote in…
  • People v. Cross, 213 Cal. App. 2d 678 (Ct. App. 1963).published
    That he has good cause to offer, either in arrest of judgment or for a new trial; ...” (See In re Levi, 39 Cal.2d 41, 45 [ 244 P.2d 403 ].) 4 On its own motion this court has had transmitted to it the file of the superior court (see Cal. R…
  • In re Klein, 197 Cal. App. 2d 58 (Ct. App. 1961).published 2 cites
    (In re Levi (1952) 39 Cal.2d 41, 44 [244 P.2d *63 403]; In re Davis (1951) 37 Cal.2d 872, 873 [ 236 P.2d 579 ]; People v. Fields (1948) 88 Cal.App.2d 30, 33 [ 198 P.2d 104 ].) The rendition of judgment and the imposition of sentence take p…
  • People v. Banks, 53 Cal. 2d 370 (1959).published
  • People v. Jennings, 129 Cal. App. 2d 120 (Ct. App. 1954).published
  • In re Roberts, 40 Cal. 2d 745 (1953).published
  • People v. Havel, 134 Cal. App. 2d 213 (Ct. App. 1955).published
At page 44Revocation of probation without hearing or counsel22 citing cases“the court may revoke probation solely on the basis of the probation officer's report.”2 citing courts quote it · 21 listed here
  • People v. Kriss, 96 Cal. App. 3d 913 (Ct. App. 1979).published 3 cites
    If judgment is pronounced in his absence, he is deprived of these rights.” ( 39 Cal.2d 41 at p. 45, citations omitted.) 5 To those rights might be added the consideration that the defendant might be able to mitigate his sentence by making…
  • Boles v. Superior Court, 37 Cal. App. 3d 479 (Ct. App. 1974).published
    (In re Larsen (1955) 44 Cal.2d 642, 646 [ 283 P.2d 1043 ]; In re Levi (1952) 39 Cal.2d 41, 44 [ 244 P.2d 403 ]; In re Davis (1951) 37 Cal.2d 872, 873 [ 236 P.2d 579 ].) All that is necessary to give the prison authority the right to his cu…
  • In re Solis, 274 Cal. App. 2d 344 (Ct. App. 1969).published
    (In re Levi, 39 Cal.2d 41, 44 [ 244 P.2d 403 ]; In re Davis, 37 Cal.2d 872 [ 236 P.2d 579 ]; People v. Jones, 263 Cal.App.2d 818, 821-822 [ 70 Cal.Rptr. 13 ]; People v. Clements, 202 Cal.App.2d 284, 287 [ 20 Cal.Rptr. 766 ].) This being th…
  • People v. Vanella, 265 Cal. App. 2d 463 (Ct. App. 1968).published
    (See In re Levi, 39 Cal.2d 41, 44 [ 244 P.2d 403 ]; People v. Walker, 215 Cal.App.2d 609, 612 [ 30 Cal.Rptr. 440 ]; Brown v. Kearney, 355 F.2d 199 .) Appellant incorrectly assumes that it was necessary for the People to establish that ther…
  • People v. Jones, 263 Cal. App. 2d 818 (Ct. App. 1968).published
    (In re Levi, 39 Cal.2d 41, 44 [ 244 P.2d 403 ]; People v. Wimberly, 215 Cal.App.2d 538, 550 [ 30 Cal.Rptr. 421 ].) If there is such a hearing the formal fules of evidence do not apply.
  • In re Griffin, 67 Cal. 2d 343 (1967).published
    (In re Levi (1952) 39 Cal.2d 41, 44 [ 244 P.2d 403 ] ; In re Davis (1951) 37 Cal.2d 872, 874-875 [ 236 P.2d 579 ].) It could then have continued the matter to a suitable time for hearing, for when imposition of sentence has been suspended…
  • Williams v. Commonwealth, 216 N.E.2d 779 (Mass. 1966).published 2 cites
    In re Levi, 39 Cal.2d 41, 44 (probation).
  • People v. Silva, 241 Cal. App. 2d 80 (Ct. App. 1966).published
    (I n re Levi, 39 Cal.2d 41, 44, 46 [ 244 P.2d 403 ] ; In re Klein, 197 Cal.App.2d 58, 63 [ 17 Cal.Rptr. 71 ]).
  • People v. Ector, 231 Cal. App. 2d 619 (Ct. App. 1965).published
    Case No. 276368, [No. 10Í28] a violation, that will be a revocation of probation, and a concurrent sentence. ’ ’ Defendant’s contentions as to the lack of notice of hearing and right to a hearing as to the violation proceeding are answered…
  • People v. De Waele, 224 Cal. App. 2d 512 (Ct. App. 1964).published
    The constitutional right to counsel in “criminal prosecutions’’ is not applicable then because a probation proceeding is not a part of a “prosecution.’’ (In re Levi, 39 Cal.2d 41, 44 [ 244 P.2d 403 ]; In re Davis, 37 Cal.2d 872 , [ 236 P.2…
Show 11 more citing cases
  • People v. Natividad, 222 Cal. App. 2d 438 (Ct. App. 1963).published
    (In re Levi, 39 Cal.2d 41, 44 [ 244 P.2d 403 ]; In re Dearo, 96 Cal.App.2d 141, 143 [ 214 P.2d 585 ].) It appears from the probation officer’s report in the instant case that after the defendant’s release from the county jail he was convic…
  • People v. Clark, 215 Cal. App. 2d 734 (Ct. App. 1963).published
    “The court may revoke probation solely on the basis of the probation officer’s report.” (In re Levi, 39 Cal.2d 41, 44 [ 244 P.2d 403 ].) It is apparent from the record at bar that the probation officer had reported adversely upon petitione…
  • People v. Wilson, 208 Cal. App. 2d 256 (Ct. App. 1962).published
    (In re Bine, supra; Penal Code, § 1203.1.) Thus, “The court may revoke probation solely on the basis of the probation officer’s report.” (In re Levi, 39 Cal.2d 41, 44 [ 244 P.2d 403 ].) Although the court has a wide range of discretion in…
  • In re Klein, 197 Cal. App. 2d 58 (Ct. App. 1961).published 2 cites
    (In re Levi (1952) 39 Cal.2d 41, 44 [244 P.2d *63 403]; In re Davis (1951) 37 Cal.2d 872, 873 [ 236 P.2d 579 ]; People v. Fields (1948) 88 Cal.App.2d 30, 33 [ 198 P.2d 104 ].) The rendition of judgment and the imposition of sentence take p…
  • People v. Root, 192 Cal. App. 2d 158 (Ct. App. 1961).published
    Code, § 1203.2, and In re Levi (1952), 39 Cal.2d 41, 44 [ 244 P.2d 403 ] ; see also the many cases cited in In re Davis (1951), 37 Cal.2d 872, 874 [ 236 P.2d 579 ].) Defendant relies, however, on In re Cook, 67 Cal.App.2d 20, 25 [ 153 P.2d…
  • People v. Mason, 184 Cal. App. 2d 182 (Ct. App. 1960).published
    Sections 1203.2 and 1203.3 of the Penal Code are in part set forth in the footnote. 1 *189 It was said in In re Levi, 39 Cal.2d 41, 44 [ 244 P.2d 403 ] as follows: “There is neither a constitutional nor a statutory right to a hearing prece…
  • People v. Yarter, 138 Cal. App. 2d 803 (Ct. App. 1956).published
  • People v. Sweeden, 116 Cal. App. 2d 891 (Ct. App. 1953).published
  • People v. Johns, 173 Cal. App. 2d 38 (Ct. App. 1959).published
  • People v. Slater, 152 Cal. App. 2d 814 (Ct. App. 1957).published
  • People v. Banks, 53 Cal. 2d 370 (1959).published
At page 47Determining waiver of right to counsel based on mental capacity10 citing casesa right to counsel. It did not ask him if he had any legal cause to show why judgment should not be pronounced against him. It made no attempt to ascertain if…opening of page *47 (no citing court says what it cites this page for)
  • People v. Harrison, 5 Cal. App. 3d 602 (Ct. App. 1970).published
    Code, § 2900.1; In re Levi (1952) 39 Cal.2d 41, 47 [ 244 P.2d 403 ].) Dictum in People v. Niles, supra, implying the applicability of Penal Code section 1191 (see p. 756 of 227 Cal.App.2d) was unnecessary to the decision, unsupported by ca…
  • People v. Guaracha, 272 Cal. App. 2d 839 (Ct. App. 1969).published
    Code, § 2900.1; In re Levi (1952) 39 Cal.2d 41, 47 [ 244 P.2d 403 ].) “The petition for habeas corpus is granted to the extent necessary to afford petitioner the following relief.
  • People v. Dyer, 269 Cal. App. 2d 209 (Ct. App. 1969).published
    (See In re Levi, 39 Cal.2d 41, 47 [ 244 P.2d 403 ] ; People v. Havel, 134 Cal.App.2d 213, 218 [ 285 P.2d 317 ]; In re Roberts, 40 Cal.2d 745, 748-749 [ 255 P.2d 782 ]; In re James, 38 Cal.2d 302, 314 [ 240 P.2d 596 ]; People v. Rogers, 252…
  • In re Helpman, 267 Cal. App. 2d 307 (Ct. App. 1968).published
    Code, § 2900.1; In re Levi, 39 Cal.2d 41, 47 [ 244 P.2d 403 ].) Petitioner, however, served no prison time at all under the invalid 1964 judgment.
  • In re Ricks, 260 Cal. App. 2d 702 (Ct. App. 1968).published
    (See People v. Thatcher, 255 Cal.App.2d 830, 832-833 [ 63 Cal.Rptr. 492 ]; In re Masching, 41 Cal.2d 530, 534 [ 261 P.2d 251 ]; In re Roberts, 40 Cal.2d 745, 748-749 [ 255 P.2d 782 ]; In re Levi, 39 Cal.2d 41, 47 [ 244 P.2d 403 ]; In re Ja…
  • People v. Thatcher, 255 Cal. App. 2d 830 (Ct. App. 1967).published
    (See In re Roberts, 40 Cal.2d 745, 748-749 [255 *829 P.2d 782]; In re Levi, 39 Cal.2d 41, 47 [ 244 P.2d 4031 ; In re James, 38 Cal.2d 302, 314 [ 240 P.2d 596 ].) Defendant-respondent’s motion to strike the order allowing augmentation of th…
  • People v. Santos, 245 Cal. App. 2d 337 (Ct. App. 1966).published
    Counsel argues that since defendant could neither read nor write English, he would be considered to be of “dull mentality,” thereby rendering ineffective his attempted waiver of counsel, as well as unduly handicapping his efforts to defend…
  • In re Turrieta, 54 Cal. 2d 816 (1960).published
    In fact, in our recent decisions on related issues wherein we have granted relief we have noted in doing so that there had been no prior waiver of counsel (In re Boyce, supra, 51 Cal.2d 699, 700 [ 336 P.2d 164 ] ; In re Roberts, supra, 40…
  • In re Roberts, 40 Cal. 2d 745 (1953).published
  • In re Masching, 41 Cal. 2d 530 (1953).published
At page 46Determining right to counsel at judgment pronouncement9 citing casesin court when judgment is pronounced against him does not include the right to have counsel present at that time. (See 24 C.J.S., Criminal Law, § 1574a.) In…opening of page *46 (no citing court says what it cites this page for)
  • Trinity Cnty. Dep't of Soc. Servs. v. Cynthia V., 211 Cal. App. 3d 1331 (Ct. App. 1989).published
    In its application of rule 31, our Supreme Court has generally begun to count the time to file a notice of appeal from the oral pronouncement of judgment in open court. 6 (See, e.g., People v. Howerton (1953) 40 Cal.2d 217, 218 [ 253 P.2d…
  • In re Markaus, 211 Cal. App. 3d 1331 (Ct. App. 1989).partially published
    In its application of rule 31, our Supreme Court has generally begun to count the time to file a notice of appeal from the oral pronouncement of judgment in open court. [6] (See, e.g., People v. Howerton (1953) 40 Cal.2d 217, 218 [ 253 P.2…
  • People v. Smyers, 261 Cal. App. 2d 690 (Ct. App. 1968).published
    His constitutional right to counsel applied at that stage of the criminal proceedings (see In re Levi, 39 Cal.2d 41, 46 [ 244 P.2d 403 ]) and unlike the situation in In re Fresquez, 67 Cal.2d 626, 634 [ 63 Cal.Rptr. 271 , 432 P.2d 959 ], a…
  • In re Perez, 65 Cal. 2d 224 (1966).published
    (In re Levi (1952) 39 Cal.2d 41, 46 [ 244 P.2d 403 ]; In re Roberts (1953) 40 Cal.2d 745, 748 [ 255 P.2d 782 ]; In re Boyce (1959) 51 Cal.2d 699 [ 336 P.2d 164 ] ; In re Klein (1961) 197 Cal.App.2d 58, 63 [ 17 Cal.Rptr. 71 ].) There are su…
  • People v. Collins, 220 Cal. App. 2d 563 (Ct. App. 1963).published
    Of course, the defendant is entitled to counsel at the time of arraignment for judgment, as held in In re Levi, 39 Cal.2d 41, 46 [ 244 P.2d 403 ], but this appellant had gotten rid of his attorney before the trial and gave no intimation of…
  • People v. Garner, 57 Cal. 2d 135 (1961).published 2 cites
    This court has zealously protected that right. ( In re Turrieta, 54 Cal.2d 816, 821-822 [ 356 P.2d 681 ]; People v. Mattson, 51 Cal.2d 777, 790 [ 336 P.2d 937 ]; In re Levi, 39 Cal.2d 41, 46-47 [ 244 P.2d 403 ]; In re James, 38 Cal.2d 302,…
  • In re Roberts, 40 Cal. 2d 745 (1953).published
  • People v. Mattson, 51 Cal. 2d 777 (1959).published
  • In re Boyce, 51 Cal. 2d 699 (1959).published
In re Troy M. Levi, on Behalf of EDDIE D. LEVI, on Habeas Corpus
Crim. No. 5282.
California Supreme Court.
May 19, 1952.
Published opinion
39 Cal. 2d 41
1952 Cal. LEXIS 233
David A. Pall for Petitioner., Edmund G. Brown, Attorney General, Clarence A. Linn, Assistant Attorney General, and Winslow Christian, Deputy Attorney General, for Respondent.
Carter, Traynor.
Cited by 106 opinions  |  Published

Lead Opinion

TRAYNOR, J.

Troy Levi seeks a writ of habeas corpus on behalf of his brother, Eddie Levi, an inmate of the California Institution for Men at Chino. Eddie Levi, hereinafter referred to as petitioner, was committed for the offense of assault by means of force likely to produce great bodily harm. (Pen. Code, § 245.) He contends that his detention is unauthorized because his constitutional rights were violated in proceedings leading to his confinement.

He was arrested in June, 1950, after inflicting severe wounds on one Everett Sykes with a pocket knife. The cause was submitted on the transcript of the preliminary hearing and the trial court, sitting without a jury, found him guilty of assault with intent to commit murder. On September 27, 1950, after hearing his application for probation and motion for a new trial, the court denied his motion for a new trial, reduced the offense to assault by means of force likely to produce great bodily harm, ordered that proceedings be suspended, and placed him on probation for five years on condition that he serve one year in the county jail “with good time allowed. ’ ’ Approximately five days after his release from the county jail, he was arrested for intoxication and sentenced to four days in jail. The probation officer filed a report that he was not a suitable subject for probation and should be sentenced to prison. On September 5, 1951, the court revoked probation and pronounced judgment. Petitioner was sentenced to the state prison for the term prescribed by law for the offense of an assault by means of force likely to produce great bodily harm. The entire transcript of the proceedings on. September 5th is set out in the footnote.*

[*44] Petitioner contends that his confinement is illegal on the grounds that he did not receive notice of the hearing preceding revocation of probation, that he was not represented by counsel at the hearing, and that he was not given the opportunity to summon witnesses in his behalf. Petitioner does not thereby show grounds for issuance of habeas corpus. There is neither a constitutional nor a statutory right to a hearing preceding revocation of probation. (In re Davis, 37 Cal.2d 872, 873-874 [236 P.2d 579].) If a hearing is held, it is not governed by the rules concerning formal criminal trials. The court may revoke probation solely on the basis of the probation officer's report. (In re Dearo, 96 Cal.App.2d 141, 143 [214 P.2d 585].) There is no right to present witnesses. (People v. Hayden, 99 Cal.App.2d 97, 99 [221 P.2d 221].) The constitutional right to have counsel in “criminal prosecutions” (art. I, § 13) is not applicable since a probation proceeding is not part of a “prosecution.” (In re Dearo, supra, 96 Cal.App.2d 141, 143; People v. Fields, 88 Cal.App.2d 30, 33 [198 P.2d 104].)

Although the foregoing contentions are without merit, the record discloses a serious defect in the proceedings in the trial court. It will be recalled that this case is not one in which judgment was pronounced and execution of sentence suspended during probation. (Cf. In re Davis, supra; People v. Blankenship, 16 Cal.App.2d 606 [61 P.2d 352].) Instead, sentence and judgment were never imposed until the date of revocation of probation. The record shows that petitioner was not represented by counsel at that time, although the Constitution provides that “in criminal prosecutions, in any court whatever, the party accused shall have the right ... to appear[*45] and defend, in person and with counsel.” (Art. I, §13.) The question thus arises whether the fact that petitioner was not represented by counsel at the time of pronouncement of judgment requires that the judgment be set aside on habeas corpus.

With certain exceptions not applicable here (see In re Ralph, 27 Cal.2d 866, 872 [168 P.2d 1] [sentence following decision on appeal]; People v. Brown, 102 Cal.App.2d 60, 62-63 [226 P.2d 609] [sentence after exercising reasonable diligence to procure missing defendant and finding that it is in interest of justice to pronounce judgment in his absence] ; People v. Weinstein, 298 Ill. 264, 268 [131 N.E. 631 [accused absconded after verdict]), judgment and sentence in felony cases may be imposed only in the presence of the accused. If judgment is pronounced in his absence, and no justifying circumstances are shown, the judgment must be set aside. (People v. Brown, supra; People v. Fields, 88 Cal.App.2d 30, 33 [198 P.2d 104] ; In re Klein, 75 Cal.App.2d 600, 603 [171 P.2d 471]; People v. Hawthorne, 63 Cal.App.2d 262, 264 [146 P.2d 517]; see People v. Williams, 24 Cal.2d 848, 853 [151 P.2d 244]; Staples v. Commonwealth, 140 Va. 583, 587 [125 S.E. 319]; Siegel v. State, 201 Wis. 12, 17 [229 N.W. 44]; cases collected in 24 C.J.S., Criminal Law, § 1574.)

A defendant has substantial rights at the time he is arraigned for judgment, because he may be able to show good cause why the judgment should not be pronounced against him. (Pen. Code, §§ 1200, 1201; see People v. Sarazzawski, 27 Cal.2d 7, 18 [161 P.2d 934] ; People v. Hawthorne, 63 Cal.App.2d 262, 264 [146 P.2d 517] ; People v. Megladdery, 40 Cal.App.2d 748 [106 P.2d 84] ; People v. Prudencio, 93 Cal.App. 241, 246 [269 P. 698].) He may be able to show that there is good cause to believe that he is insane (Pen. Code, §1201(1) ; see People v. Jackson, 105 Cal.App.2d 811, 814-815 [234 P.2d 261]), or that there is good cause to order a new trial (Pen. Code, §§ 1201(2), 1181),* or that there is good cause to grant a motion in arrest of judgment. (Pen. Code, §§ 1201(2), 1185.) If judgment is pronounced in his absence, he is deprived of.these rights.

Some states hold that the right of an accused to be present[*46] in court when judgment is pronounced against him does not include the right to have counsel present at that time. (See 24 C.J.S., Criminal Law, § 1574a.) In this state, however, it has been held that an arraignment for judgment is a “criminal prosecution” within the meaning of article I, section 13, and that an accused therefore has the right to counsel at the time of pronouncement of judgment. (People v. Fields, 88 Cal.App.2d 30, 33 [198 P.2d 104].) The Fields ease involved an appeal and is thus not directly in point, but we have concluded that a judgment pronounced in the absence of counsel is also vulnerable to attack by habeas corpus. It would be anomalous to hold that a defendant’s personal presence is so important that he may set aside the judgment on collateral attack and yet to hold that the constitutional right to counsel is not of equal importance. A defendant’s presence gives him an opportunity to show legal cause why judgment should not be pronounced against him. The average defendant, however, would be helpless to establish such cause without the aid of counsel. (See In re James, 38 Cal.2d 302, 309 [240 P.2d 596], and cases cited therein.) Moreover, a defendant has the right to appeal from the judgment. (Pen. Code, § 1237; In re Davis, 37 Cal.2d 872, 875 [236 P.2d 579].) When judgment is pronounced in the absence of counsel, there is danger that the defendant might allow the time for notice of appeal to run in ignorance of his rights, and thus lose his opportunity to obtain review of the judgment. (Rules on Appeal, rule 31; see People v. Slobodion, 30 Cal.2d 362, 365 [181 P.2d 868] ; People v. Lewis, 219 Cal. 410, 413-414 [27 P.2d 73].)

The attorney general contends that the Fields ease is in conflict with three earlier cases. (People v. Henry, 86 Cal.App.2d 785, 790 [195 P.2d 478]; People v. Hawthorne, 63 Cal.App.2d 262, 266 [146 P.2d 517]; People v. Swift, 140 Cal.App. 7 [34 P.2d 1041].) In the Swift case the defendant was represented by counsel at the time of pronouncement of judgment. In the Henry and Hawthorne cases the defendants were personally present at the time judgment was entered, but it cannot be ascertained from the opinions whether they were represented by counsel. The only question presented to the courts in those cases, however, was the effect of the failure of the trial court to arraign the defendants for judgment pursuant to Penal Code section 1200, a question not raised by petitioner in the present case.

The trial court did not inform petitioner that he had[*47] a right to counsel. It did not ask him if he had any legal cause to show why judgment should not be pronounced against him. It made no attempt to ascertain if he understood the pleas and defenses available under section 1201 of the Penal Code. The report of the probation officer is in the record and shows that petitioner has only a fifth grade education and is of “ dull mentality. ’ ’ His failure to request counsel cannot therefore be amplified into a waiver of his right to counsel. (In re James, supra, 38 Cal.2d 302, 313; People v. Chesser, 29 Cal.2d 815, 824 [178 P.2d 761] ; cf. In re Tedford, 31 Cal.2d 693, 695 [192 P.2d 3] ; In re Jingles, 27 Cal.2d 496, 498 [165 P.2d 12].)

Petitioner has requested that he be “restored to liberty” if the writ is granted. Nothing in his petition or the record, however, shows that there is any defect in the adjudication of guilt. The error in the pronouncement of judgment does not require either his release or a new trial. (In re McCoy, 32 Cal.2d 73, 77 [194 P.2d 531]; In re Mize, 11 Cal.2d 22, 26-27 [77 P.2d 472] ; People v. Fields, 88 Cal.App.2d 30, 33 [198 P.2d 104]; State ex rel. Shetsky v. Utecht, 228 Minn. 44, 54 [36 N.W.2d 126] ; Staples v. Commonwealth, 140 Va. 583, 587 [125 S.E. 319].) The delay since revocation of probation has not caused the trial court to lose jurisdiction to pronounce a valid judgment. (See People v. Williams, 24 Cal.2d 848, 854 [151 P.2d 244].) If petitioner should again be sentenced to prison, his confinement based upon the invalid judgment will be credited upon the new commitment. (Pen. Code, § 2900.1.)

The petitioner is discharged from the custody of the authorities at the California Institution for Men at Chino and committed to the custody of the sheriff of Los Angeles County with directions that petitioner be arraigned for pronouncement of judgment in accord with this opinion.

Gibson, C. J., Shenk, J., Edmonds, J., Schauer, J., and Spence, J., concurred.

Los Angeles, California, Wednesday, September 5, 1951, 10:52 a. m. On the above date the defendant appeared in court In Propria Persona; the People being represented by William 0. Russell, Deputy District Attorney of Los Angeles County; and also present, B. E. McEveety, Deputy Probation Officer; the following proceedings were had, to wit:

(August J. Goebel, Reporter.)
The Court: People v. Eddie D. Levi.
Mr. Levi, they tell me you have had some more trouble since you were out.
The Defendant : I went to Pedro to my brother Ts-'
[*44] The Court: You got into some sort of a drunken brawl?
The Defendant : Ño. They say I was drunk.
The Court: Yes. Your wife has never eome out here and your children are still back in Chicago, is that correct?
The Defendant: Sure.
The Court: Well, because of the serious nature of your offense and because the Court specifically admonished you that you were not under any circumstances to use intoxicating liquor and because you rewarded the consideration that was given you by going out and getting drunk within five days after your release, your probation is revoked.
It is the judgment and sentence of the Court that for the offense of Assault By Means of Torce Likely To Produce Great Bodily Harm, that you be now confined in the state prison for the term prescribed by law.
You are remanded into the custody of the Sheriff to be by him delivered into the custody of the Department of Corrections to serve the sentence.
You are remanded to custody.

In the present ease, however, the fact that petitioner made a motion for a new trial following his conviction in 1950 would deprive the trial court of jurisdiction to entertain a second motion for a new trial at the time of pronouncement of judgment. (People v. Martin, 199 Cal. 240, 242 [248 P. 908]; People v. Collins, 97 Cal.App.2d 552, 554 [218 P.2d 87].)

Concurrence

CARTER, J.

I concur in the conclusion reached but since the holding of the majority is based in part upon In re Davis, 37 Cal.2d 872 [236 P.2d 579], in which I dissented, I withhold my approval from the portion of the decision of the court in this case which is supported by what I believe to be an erroneous holding in In re Davis, supra.