Providence Journal Co. v. Fed. Bureau of Investigation
Appellants need not show an absolute probability of success to obtain a stay if denial irreparably destroys the status quo and granting the stay causes only slight harm.
The FBI and an intervenor sought stays pending appeal of a district court order requiring disclosure of FBI documents, the results of an unauthorized 1962-65 wiretap, to a newspaper publisher. The question is whether appellants must show a strong likelihood of success to obtain a stay when denial would destroy the status quo. The court holds that where denial of a stay would irreparably harm appellants and destroy the status quo, while a stay causes only slight harm to the appellee, appellants need not show an absolute probability of success. The court found serious legal questions presented and balanced the hardships in favor of a stay, impounding the materials pending appeal.
At page 890Determining necessity of stay pending appeal25 citing cases“(w)here . . . the denial of a stay will utterly destroy the status quo, irreparably harming appellants, but the granting of a stay will cause relatively slight harm to appellee, appellants need not show an absolute probability of success in order to be entitled to a stay.”
- Brennan Ctr. For Just. At New York Univ. Sch. Of Law v. United States Dep't of State, No. 1:17-cv-07520 (S.D.N.Y. Mar. 13, 2025). (Weighing [the postponement of disclosure] against the total and immediate divestiture of appellants’ rights to have effective review in this court, we find the balance of hardship to favor the issuance of a stay.)
- Knight First Amendment Inst. at Columbia Univ. v. Centers for Disease Control & Prevention, 560 F. Supp. 3d 810 (S.D.N.Y. 2021).published (Weighing [the postponement of disclosure] against the total and immediate divestiture of appellants’ rights to have effective review in this court, we find the balance of hardship to favor the issuance of a stay.)
- Ferrara v. United States, 370 F. Supp. 2d 351 (D. Mass. 2005).published(Where ... denial of a stay will utterly destroy the status quo, irreparably harming appellants, but the granting of a stay will cause relatively slight harm to appellee, appellants need not show an absolute probability…)
- Rudd Equip. Co. v. John Deere Constr. & Forestry Co., 834 F.3d 589 (6th Cir. 2016).published(Once the documents are surrendered pursuant to the lower court’s order, confidentiality will be lost for all time. The status quo could never be restored.)
- PDS Consultants, Inc. v. United States, 133 Fed. Cl. 810 (Fed. Cl. 2017).publishedId. (citing Providence Journal Co. v. Federal Bureau of Investigation, 595 F.2d 889, 890 (1st Cir. 1979)).
- Akima Intra-Data, LLC v. United States, 120 Fed. Cl. 25 (Fed. Cl. 2015).publishedId. (citing Providence Journal Co. v. Federal Bureau of Investigation, 595 F.2d 889, 890 (1st Cir.1979)).
- Sheldon Peters Wolfchild v. United States 03-2684l &, 108 Fed. Cl. 578 (Fed. Cl. 2013).publishedThe four factors “contemplate individualized judgments,” Hilton, 481 U.S. at 777 , 107 S.Ct. 2113 , but the factors need not be given equal weight, Standard Havens Prods., 897 F.2d at 512 (citing Providence Journal Co. v. Federal Bureau of…
- In re Special Proceedings, 840 F. Supp. 2d 370 (D.D.C. 2012).publishedThe court found that the movant established "serious legal questions” on the merits, and further found that "once the documents are surrendered ... confidentiality will be lost for all time.” Id. at 890.
- Vaqueria Tres Monjitas, Inc. v. Laboy, 448 F. Supp. 2d 340 (D.P.R. 2006).published“[wjhere, ..., the denial of a stay will utterly destroy the status quo, irreparably harming appellants, but the granting of a stay will cause relatively slight harm to appellee, appellants need not show an absolute prob…”
- Ctr. for Int'l Env't Law v. Off. of the United States Trade Rep., 240 F. Supp. 2d 21 (D.D.C. 2003).publishedFailure to grant a stay will entirely destroy appellants’ rights to secure meaningful review.” Id. at 890.
Show 15 more citing cases
- Canterbury Liquors & Pantry v. Sullivan, 999 F. Supp. 144 (D. Mass. 1998).published (Where ... the denial of a stay will utterly destroy the status quo, irreparably harming appellants,, but the granting of a stay will cause relatively slight harm to appellee, appellants need not show an *150 absolute p…)
- Thiry v. Carlson, 891 F. Supp. 563 (D. Kan. 1995).publishedA number of courts have held that when equitable factors strongly favor interim relief, the court “is not required to find that ultimate success by the movant is a mathematical probability” and “may grant a stay even though its own approac…
- Cane v. Worcester Cnty., 874 F. Supp. 695 (D. Md. 1995).publishedMoreover, the County’s assertion that Providence Journal Co. v. Federal Bureau of Investigation, 595 F.2d 889, 890 (1st Cir.1979), warns against the denial of a stay which will “utterly destroy the status quo” is irrelevant when, as here,…
- Shick v. Farmers Home Admin., 583 F. Supp. 534 (D. Mass. 1984).published“are not, of course, entitled to a stay pending appeal without showing that their appeals have potential merit”
- Angel Manuel Cintron Garcia v. Carlos Romero Barcelo, 671 F.2d 1 (1st Cir. 1982).publishedExcept in the unusual case, however, where the harm to plaintiffs is particularly severe and disproportionate, see Providence Journal Co. v. Federal Bureau of Investigation, 595 F.2d 889, 890 (1st Cir. 1979), in this circuit a probability…
- Conservation Law Found. of New England, Inc. v. Andrus, 617 F.2d 296 (1st Cir. 1979).published In Providence Journal Co. we ruled that “[w]here . . . the denial of a stay will utterly destroy the status quo, irreparably harming appellants, but the granting of a stay will cause relatively slight harm to appellee, appellants need not…
- Ne. Patients Grp. v. Maine Dep't of Admin. & Fin. Servs., No. 1:20-cv-00468 (D. Me. Oct. 27, 2021).See id.
- Diamond Ventures v. Barreto, Hector, 452 F.3d 892 (D.C. Cir. 2006).published (confidentiality lost once documents were surrendered pursuant to court order; “[t]he status quo could never be restored)
- Stand. Havens Prods., Inc. v. Gencor Indus., Inc., 897 F.2d 511 (Fed. Cir. 1990).published(granting stay pending appeal)
- Unknown case name, No. 92-2226 (1st Cir. Jan. 8, 1993).unpublishedCompare Providence Journal, 595 F.2d at 889 (where failure to stay district court's disclosure order would so utterly destroy the status quo as to render any later appeal moot, but grant of stay would cause relatively slight harm, appellan…
- In re GHR Companies, Inc., 41 B.R. 666 (Bankr. D. Mass. 1984).published
- AARP v. Equal Emp. Opportunity Comm'n, 390 F. Supp. 2d 437 (E.D. Pa. 2005).published
- State of Maine v. BP P.L.C., No. 2:25-cv-00001 (D. Me. Jan. 9, 2026).
- Isla Petroleum Corp. v. Dep't of Consum. Affairs, 640 F. Supp. 474 (D.P.R. 1986).published
- Corporacion De Servicios Medicos Hospitalarios De Fajardo v. Izquierdo Mora (In re Corporacion De Servicios Medicos Hospitalarios De Fajardo), 60 B.R. 935 (D.P.R. 1986).published
At page 889Determining necessity of showing absolute probability for stay2 citing caseswhere failure to stay district court's disclosure order would so utterly destroy the status quo as to render any later appeal moot, but grant of stay would cause relatively slight harm, appellants need not show an "absolute probability of success
- Am. Civil Liberties Union v. Dep't of Def., 357 F. Supp. 2d 708 (S.D.N.Y. 2005).publishedSee Mohammed, 309 F.3d at 102 (applying stay criteria “[i]n the context of a stay of removal of an alien pending appeal of an adverse habeas decision”); State of Maine v. U.S. Dept. of Interior, 298 F.3d 60 , 64-65 (1st Cir.2002) (finding…
- Unknown case name, No. 92-2226 (1st Cir. Jan. 8, 1993).unpublished(where failure to stay district court's disclosure order would so utterly destroy the status quo as to render any later appeal moot, but grant of stay would cause relatively slight harm, appellants need not show an "abso…)
Other citing cases
- United States v. Adams, 473 F. Supp. 2d 108 (D. Me. 2007).published
- Action for Boston Cmty. Dev., Inc. v. Shalala, 983 F. Supp. 222 (D. Mass. 1997).published
- Holy Spirit Ass'n for the Unification of World Christianity v. Cent. Intelligence Agency & Stansfield Turner, 636 F.2d 838 (D.C. Cir. 1981).published
- In re Search Warrant for Second Floor Bedroom, 489 F. Supp. 207 (D.R.I. 1980).published
v.
Federal Bureau of Investigation v. Raymond L. S. Patriarca, Intervenor, Appeal of United States Department of Justice, Providence Journal Company v. Federal Bureau of Investigation, Appeal of Raymond L. S. Patriarca, Intervenor
Defendants, Federal Bureau of Investigation and others, and Intervenor, Raymond L. S. Patriarca, have requested stays pending their appeals of the district court’s order that certain FBI documents be forthwith disclosed to the plaintiff, Providence Journal Company. These documents reflect the results of an unauthorized and illegal wiretap which the FBI maintained at Patriarca’s place of business in 1962-65. Defendants and the Intervenor appeal from the district court’s ruling that, with certain exceptions, all this material be made available to the Journal.
[*890] The district court, while issuing a stay of several days in order to permit this court to orient itself and, if so inclined, grant a further stay, declined to do more. The court pointed out that, in effect, it had analyzed the case fully, that its order reflected its considered judgment, and that it would be “expecting too much to have it critically determine, as would be done through the mind of a stranger,” whether appellants had made a strong showing of likely success on appeal. In view of the decision it had reached in the ease, the district court thought that more than a brief stay would be a “prior restraint” on the Journal’s publication rights as it had found them to be.
This court necessarily approaches the matter from a different perspective. While we give weight to the views of the district court, the Constitution and laws entitle litigants to have their cases independently reviewed by an appellate tribunal. Meaningful review entails having the reviewing court take a fresh look at the decision of the trial court before it becomes irrevocable. Appellants’ right of appeal here will become moot unless the stay is continued pending determination of the appeals. Once the documents are surrendered pursuant to the lower court’s order, confidentiality will be lost for all time. The status quo could never be restored.
Appellants are not, of course, entitled to a stay pending appeal without showing that their appeals have potential merit. We believe that they have made a sufficient showing on this score. Where, as here, the denial of a stay will utterly destroy the status quo, irreparably harming appellants, but the granting of a stay will cause relatively slight harm to appellee, appellants need not show an absolute probability of success in order to be entitled to a stay. See Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Commission v. Holiday Tours, 182 U.S.App.D.C. 220, 559 F.2d 841 (1977). Our reading of the district court’s opinions and of the briefs indicates that there are serious legal questions presented. The district court itself stated,
“[T]his is a case of initial impression wherein respectable minds might differ and [embodies] a strong public policy
Failure to grant a stay will entirely destroy appellants’ rights to secure meaningful review. On the other hand, the granting of a stay will be detrimental to the Journal (and to the public’s interest in disclosure) only to the extent that it postpones the moment of disclosure — assuming the Journal prevails— by whatever period of time may be required for us to hear and decide the appeals. Weighing this latter hardship against the total and immediate divestiture of appellants’ rights to have effective review in this court, we find the balance of hardship to favor the issuance of a stay.
The motions for stay pending appeal are allowed. All materials which are the subject matter of these appeals, now in possession of the district court, are to remain impounded until further order of this court.