Thurman v. Yellow Freight Sys., Inc.
Vague references to an issue fail to clearly present it to the district court and waive the issue for appeal.
In an employment discrimination appeal, the plaintiff sought front pay but had not raised the issue in the amended complaint, pretrial order, or at trial, raising it only in a motion to alter or amend the judgment. The question presented is whether vague references to an issue in appellate briefing preserve it for review when the issue was not squarely presented to the district court. The court applies the rule that vague references fail to clearly present an issue to the district court, thereby waiving the issue for appeal. Additionally, the court notes that front pay is an equitable remedy within the trial court's discretion. The result is that the issue is waived, and the district court's denial of front pay is affirmed because the award of backpay and fees made the plaintiff whole.
At page 835Failing to preserve issues for appeal by raising them late13 citing cases“vague references to an issue fail to clearly present it to the district court so as to preserve the issue for appeal.”
- United States v. Thomas Smith, No. 12-2659 (6th Cir. Apr. 8, 2013).unpublished ([Plaintiff] raised the issue for the first time in his motion to alter or amend the judgment. Thus, he failed to preserve the issue for appeal.)
- A. K. v. Durham Sch. Servs., L.P., 969 F.3d 625 (6th Cir. 2020).published([V]ague references to an issue fail to clearly present it to the district court so as to preserve the issue for appeal.)
- Contract Design Grp., Inc. v. Wayne State Univ., 635 F. App'x 222 (6th Cir. 2015).unpublished(R. 262.) Because Plaintiffs failed to properly raise this issue in the district court, we cannot address it now on appeal. "[Vjague references to an issue fail to clearly present it to the district court so as to preserve the issue for ap…
- Six L's Packing Co. v. Beale, 524 F. App'x 148 (6th Cir. 2013).unpublished Thurman v. Yellow Freight Sys., Inc., 97 F.3d 833, 835 (6th Cir.1996) (“[Plaintiff] raised the issue for the first time in his motion to alter or amend the judgment.
- R.H. Cochran & Assocs., Inc. v. Sheet Metal Workers Int'l Ass'n Local Union No. 33, 335 F. App'x 516 (6th Cir. 2009).unpublished (vague reference to an issue in the district court does not preserve it for appeal)
- United States v. Universal Mgmt. Servs., Inc., 191 F.3d 750 (6th Cir. 1999).published (claims not raised before the district court must be considered waived)
- Lawrence v. Lawrence (In re Lawrence), 237 B.R. 61 (Bankr. D.N.J. 1999).publishedThurman v. Yellow Freight Systems, Inc., 97 F.3d 833, 835 (6th Cir.1996); Daniel v. Taylor, 808 F.2d 1401, 1405 (11th Cir.1986); Hoffman v. Bankers Trust Co., 925 F.Supp. 315, 318 (M.D.Pa.1995).
- In re Frank Lawrence, Jr., No. 21-1426 (6th Cir. Dec. 29, 2022).unpublishedSee Thurman v. Yellow Freight Systems, Inc., 97 F.3d 833, 835 (6th Cir. 1996) -9- (determining that an argument must be first raised and clearly presented before the district court to be preserved properly for appeal).
- Drake v. City of Detroit, 266 F. App'x 444 (6th Cir. 2008).unpublishedSee Thurman v. Yellow Freight Systems, Inc., 97 F.3d 833, 835 (6th Cir.1996).
- Arnold v. Luedtke Eng'g Co., 196 F. App'x 331 (6th Cir. 2006).unpublished (raising an “issue for the first time in [a] motion to alter or amend the judgment . . . [does not] preserve the issue for appeal.)
Show 3 more citing cases
- Jessica Frye v. CSX Transp., Inc., 933 F.3d 591 (6th Cir. 2019).published(holding that vague references to an issue fail to preserve it for appeal)
- Knall Beverage, Inc. v. Teamsters Local Union No. 293 Pension Plan, 744 F.3d 419 (6th Cir. 2014).published
- H&H Wholesale Servs., Inc. v. Kamstra Int'l, B.V., No. 21-1533 (6th Cir. Nov. 24, 2021).unpublished
holding that arguments not raised before the district court are waived
- Philip Workman v. Governor Phil Bredesen, 486 F.3d 896 (6th Cir. 2007).published (holding that arguments not raised before the district court are waived)
- Workman v. Bredesen, No. 07-5562 (6th Cir. May 7, 2007).published(holding that arguments not raised before the district court are waived)
- In re Nat'l Century Fin. Enter., Inc., Debtor. Amedisys, Inc. v. Nat'l Century Fin. Enter., Inc., 423 F.3d 567 (6th Cir. 2005).published (holding that arguments not raised before the district court are waived)
At page 833Adhering to original disposition regarding front pay issue2 citing casesplaintiff waived issue of front pay by first raising it in a motion to alter or amend the judgment
- Timothy L. Moysis v. DTG Datanet, 278 F.3d 819 (8th Cir. 2002).published (plaintiff waived issue of front pay by first raising it in a motion to alter or amend the judgment)
Other citing cases
- McDowell, No. 3:23-cv-00599 (W.D. Ky. Dec. 11, 2025).
- Marvin Gerber v. Henry Herskovitz, No. 22-1131 (6th Cir. Feb. 22, 2023).unpublished
- Barnes, Verla v. State of Wisconsin Dep't of Corr., No. 3:18-cv-00105, 2020 WL 94799 (W.D. Wis. Jan. 8, 2020).
- Boards of Trs. of the Ohio Laborers' Fringe Benefit Programs v. Jenkins, 283 F. App'x 315 (6th Cir. 2008).unpublished
- Simpson v. Comm'r, 23 F. App'x 425 (6th Cir. 2001).unpublished
- Floyd v. Sverdrup Corp., 23 F. App'x 223 (6th Cir. 2001).unpublished
- LPG Holdings, Inc. v. Casino Am., Inc., No. 99-1037 (10th Cir. Nov. 1, 2000).unpublished
- Daryl Monday v. Officer John Oullette & the City of Monroe, 118 F.3d 1099 (6th Cir. 1997).published
- Jack Wehr v. Ryan's Fam. Steak Houses, Inc., 99 F.3d 1140 (6th Cir. 1996).unpublished
- Carl Bennett v. MDOC, No. 22-1863 (6th Cir. July 21, 2023).unpublished
Show 4 more citing cases
- Shrivastava v. RBS Citizens Bank, N.A., 227 F. Supp. 3d 824 (E.D. Mich. 2017).published
- Anton v. Nat. Union Fire Ins. Co. of Pittsburgh, 634 F.3d 364 (6th Cir. 2011).published
- Edwards v. Hocking Valley Cmty. Hosp., 87 F. App'x 542 (6th Cir. 2004).unpublished
- Best v. Shell Oil Co., 4 F. Supp. 2d 770 (N.D. Ill. 1998).published
v.
YELLOW FREIGHT SYSTEMS, INC., Defendant-Appellant/Cross-Appellee
ORDER
On July 26, 1996, this Court rendered its decision on the appeal of this ease. On August 9, 1996, Yellow Freight petitioned for rehearing en banc and Thurman petitioned for rehearing en banc on August 21, 1996. The petitions having been circulated not only to the original panel members but to all other active judges of this court, and no judge of this court having requested a vote on the suggestions for rehearing en banc, the petitions for rehearing en banc have been referred to the original panel. The panel adheres to its original disposition with the following amendment regarding the issue of front pay:
The July 26 decision states, “In the conclusion to his appeal brief, Thurman also appeals the denial of front pay. He failed to[*835] brief the issue, however, and therefore the court considers the claim abandoned and un-reviewable.” As Thurman points out in his petition for rehearing, he did summarily brief the issue of front pay in the section of his brief requesting instatement. Thus, the issue was not abandoned on appeal.
Even so, vague references to an issue fail to clearly present it to the district court so as to preserve the issue for appeal. Building Serv. Local 47 Cleaning Contractors Pension Plan v. Grandview Raceway, 46 F.3d 1392, 1399 (6th Cir.1995). Thurman waived the issue of front pay by not presenting it squarely before the trial court. Thurman did not raise the issue of front pay in the amended complaint nor did he raise it in the pretrial order. He did not litigate it at trial, and the district court did not address it. Thurman raised the issue for the first time in his motion to alter or amend the judgment. Thus, he failed to preserve the issue for appeal.
Even if there was no waiver, the trial court did not err by failing to award front pay. The award of front pay is an equitable remedy within the discretion of the trial court. Shore v. Federal Express Corp., 42 F.3d 373, 377-78 (6th Cir.1994). See also Suggs v. ServiceMaster Education Food Management, 72 F.3d 1228, 1234 (6th Cir.1996) (“Determination of when to award front pay is within the discretion of the trial court, and such awards are reviewed under the abuse of discretion standard.”)
A district court has wide discretion to make a victim of unlawful discrimination whole. Albemarle Paper Co. v. Moody, 422 U.S. 405, 95 S.Ct. 2362, 45 L.Ed.2d 280 (1975). “[V]iewing a front pay award in isolation for the purpose of measuring its contribution toward the goals of an antidiscrimi-nation statute is risky business. A front pay award — like any other single strand in a tapestry of relief — must be assessed as a part of the entire remedial fabric that the trial court has fashioned in a particular case.” Lussier v. Runyon, 50 F.3d 1103, 1112 (1st Cir.), cert. denied, — U.S. -, 116 S.Ct. 69, 133 L.Ed.2d 30 (1995). For example, in Barbano v. Madison County, 922 F.2d 139, 146 (2d Cir.1990), the court held that a plaintiff was made whole by an award of backpay over an eight year period, plus prejudgment interest and attorney fees, and the court affirmed the district court’s denial of instatement and front pay.
Similarly in this case, the district court awarded backpay over a five year period together with attorney fees and costs.[1] The court was within its discretion in determining that such an award made Thurman whole. Accordingly, the district court’s denial of front pay is affirmed.
For the foregoing reasons, the petitions for rehearing en banc are DENIED. This panel’s July 26, 1996 order is amended with regard to the issue of front pay as set forth above. The district court’s denial of front pay is AFFIRMED. The panel adheres to its original disposition in all other respects.
The trial court originally denied Thurman's request for prejudgment interest, but this Court reversed and remanded for an award of such interest.