C.F.R. homeSearch C.F.R.
C.F.R.Title 49Chapter X—Surface Transportation BoardSubchapter B—Rules of PracticePart 1115—Appellate Procedures

49 C.F.R. § 1115.3 (2026)

Board actions other than initial decisions

Edition and currency
eCFR text as of Sept. 29, 2026. The text is the edition Syfert holds; for a past event, check the version in force on that date.
Other sources
CURRENTeCFR text as of Sept. 29, 2026 cited 1984–2025 14citing cases
At a glance

Courts have cited this section in 14 opinions since 1984, 1 of them in the last five years.

(a) A discretionary appeal of an entire Board action is permitted. Such an appeal should be designated a “petition for reconsideration.”

(b) The petition will be granted only upon a showing of one or more of the following points:

(1) The prior action will be affected materially because of new evidence or changed circumstances.

(2) The prior action involves material error.

(c) The petition must state in detail the nature of and reasons for the relief requested. When, in a petition filed under this section, a party seeks an opportunity to introduce evidence, the evidence must be stated briefly and must not appear to be cumulative, and an explanation must be given why it was not previously adduced.

(d) The petition and any reply must not exceed 20 pages in length. A separate preface and summary of argument, not exceeding 3 pages, may accompany petitions and replies and must accompany those that exceed 10 pages in length.

(e) Petitions must be filed within 20 days after the service of the action or within any further period (not to exceed 20 days) as the Board may authorize. However, in cases seeking expedited relief for service emergencies under the accelerated process at 49 CFR 1146.2, petitions must be filed within 5 days after the service of the action, and replies to petitions must be filed within 10 days after the service of the action.

(f) The filing of a petition will not automatically stay the effect of a prior action, but the Board may stay the effect of the action on its own motion or on petition. A petition to stay may be filed in advance of the petition for reconsideration and shall be filed within 10 days of service of the action. No reply need be filed. However, if a party elects to file a reply, it must reach the Board no later than 16 days after service of the action. In all proceedings, the action, if not stayed, will become effective 30 days after it is served, unless the Board provides for the action to become effective at a different date. On the day the action is served parties may initiate judicial review.

[61 FR 52714, Oct. 8, 1996, as amended at 61 FR 58491, Nov. 15, 1996; 88 FR 320, Jan. 4, 2023; 89 FR 4578, Jan. 24, 2024; 90 FR 24080, June 6, 2025]
The 14 cases that cite 49 C.F.R. § 1115.3 most heavily, weighted by court and treatment. RelevanceNewestTreatment
cites § 1115.3 8×cited by 442 cases
Where it cites § 1115.3
“Within the period prescribed by Commission rules for filing petitions for administrative review, see 49 CFR § 1115.3 (e) (1986), both BLE and UTU sought "reconsideration" of the Commission's denial.”
The case’s holding
An agency refusal to reopen a proceeding based solely on a claim of material error is committed to agency discretion and is not subject to judicial review.
Later courts cite it for
“where a party petitions an agency for reconsideration on the ground of 'material error,' i.e., on the same record that was before the agency when it rendered its original decision, 'an order which merely denies rehearing of ... the prior order is not itself reviewable.” · 21 citing courts
2
GREENRosler v. Derwinski, 1 Vet. App. 241 (Vet. App. 1991).
cites § 1115.3 1×cited by 154 cases
Where it cites § 1115.3
“49 C.F.R. § 1115.3 (e) (1986) (seeming to restrict period for filing petition for reconsideration when grounds are essentially the same as could be used for petition for reopening).”
The case’s holding
A motion for reconsideration filed during the judicial appeal period abates the finality of the initial board decision and triggers a new 120-day period to file an appeal.
Later courts cite it for
“the finality of the initial board decision is abated by that motion for reconsideration.” · 4 citing courts
3
GREENAlaska Survival v. Surface Transp. Bd., 705 F.3d 1073 (9th Cir. 2013).
cites § 1115.3 1×cited by 33 cases
Where it cites § 1115.3
“§ 722 (c)(d) (stating that parties may petition to reopen and reconsider an STB action or seek judicial review); 49 C.F.R. § 1115.3 (same); see also 5 U.S.”
The case’s holding
An agency purpose and need statement fails if it unreasonably narrows the consideration of alternatives such that the outcome is preordained.
Later courts cite it for
“perfunctory descriptions or mere lists of mitigation measures are insufficient.” · 4 citing courts
4
GREENSnohomish Cnty. v. STB, 954 F.3d 290 (D.C. Cir. 2020).
cites § 1115.3 2×cited by 4 cases
Where it cites § 1115.3
“487; see also 49 C.F.R. § 1115.3 (b) (permitting a petition for reconsideration on the ground of “material error”).”
Later courts cite it for
“under the administrative procedure act, examining whether the agency's action was 'arbitrary, capricious, an abuse of discretion, or otherwise not in accordance with law.” · 2 citing courts
5
GREENKevin Jost v. Surface Transp. Bd. & United States, 194 F.3d 79 (D.C. Cir. 1999).
cites § 1115.3 1×cited by 31 cases
Where it cites § 1115.3
“See 49 C.F.R. §§ 1115.3 , 1115.4. Accordingly, we will review the Board’s decision not to reopen the proceeding under the familiar arbitrary and capricious standard.”
The case’s holding
An agency must articulate the reasoning behind its decision with sufficient clarity to enable a reviewing court to understand the basis for that decision.
Later courts cite it for
“articulate the reasoning behind its decision with sufficient clarity to enable petitioners and the court to understand the basis for its decision.” · 4 citing courts
6
cites § 1115.3 1×cited by 27 cases
Where it cites § 1115.3
“Under 49 C.F.R. § 1115.3 (e), a party has twenty days from the service date of a decision to seek reconsideration.”
The case’s holding
A public use condition under 49 U.S.C. § 10906 does not stay consummation of a rail abandonment; once abandoned, ICC jurisdiction terminates and the Commission cannot undo the abandonment.
Later courts cite it for
“jurisdiction over a line terminates when the line is completely abandoned....” · 1 citing court
7
GREENM.M. Winter v. Interstate Com. Comm'n & United States, 851 F.2d 1056 (8th Cir. 1988).
cites § 1115.3 1×cited by 26 cases
Where it cites § 1115.3
“§ 10327 (g)(1); 49 C.F.R. § 1115.3 (1987). The Commission denied the unions’ subsequent request for a stay.”
The case’s holding
An agency decision is not a final, reviewable order while petitions for reconsideration or reopening remain pending before the agency, even if other parties may seek judicial review of it.
Later courts cite it for
“in multi-party proceedings one party may seek judicial review of an agency decision while another party seeks administrative reconsideration, resulting in both tribunals having jurisdiction.” · 2 citing courts
8
GREENM.M. Winter v. Interstate Com. Comm'n & United States, 828 F.2d 1320 (8th Cir. 1987).
cites § 1115.3 1×cited by 11 cases
Where it cites § 1115.3
“49 C.F.R. § 1115.3 (b). It found that BN had complied with the regulatory requirements and had properly abandoned the Hutchinson line.”
9
GREENTown of Springfield v. Surface Transp. Bd., 412 F.3d 187 (D.C. Cir. 2005).
cites § 1115.3 1×cited by 3 cases
Where it cites § 1115.3
“To state the matter differently, the municipalities cannot show&emdash;-as they must&emdash;'that the resolution or the letters materially affected the Board’s disposition.”
Later courts cite it for
“when a reopening petition rested on 'material error,' the court has no jurisdiction to review a denial of the petition.” · 2 citing courts
cites § 1115.3 1×cited by 5 cases
Where it cites § 1115.3
“We, in no way, mean to discourage resort to discretionary agency review available pursuant to 49 CFR § 1115.3 (1986). A party petitioning an agency for reconsideration of the agency's original order will not lose the right to appeal the original order: the petition for…”
11
GREENSchneider Nat'l, Inc. v. Interstate Com. Comm'n, 948 F.2d 338 (7th Cir. 1991).
cites § 1115.3 3×cited by 2 cases
Where it cites § 1115.3
“Schneider did not appeal the ICC’s revocation order within 20 days of service; thus, the order became final as of the date that the ICC served the order to Schneider.”
12
GREENUnited Transp. Union v. Interstate Com. Comm'n, 871 F.2d 1114 (D.C. Cir. 1989).
cites § 1115.3 1×cited by 4 cases
Where it cites § 1115.3
“On June 7, 1988, UTU petitioned the Commission for an administrative stay of the proceeding and, pursuant to 49 C.F.R. § 1115.3 (a), either administrative reconsideration of the Purchase Decision or review of the May 2, 1988 arbitral award.”
13
GREENAuville v. Interstate Com. Comm'n, 747 F.2d 179 (4th Cir. 1984).
cites § 1115.3 1×cited by 2 cases
Where it cites § 1115.3
“We think that the ICC’s determination that material error is an “extraordinary circumstance” is not only entitled to great weight to which we should defer, but that it is reasonable and consistent with the Act, § 10322, and the ICC’s regulations, 49 C.F.R. § 1115.3 (b)(3).…”
14
NO FLAGWilmington Sav. Fund Soc'y, FSB v. Canadian Pac. Ry., No. 24-2084 (2d Cir. Feb. 27, 2025).
cites § 1115.3 1×cited by 0 casesunpublished
Where it cites § 1115.3
“” 49 C.F.R. § 1115.3 (f) (emphasis added). The regulatory scheme thus anticipates that in the ordinary course there will be a 30-day period between the date a 5 decision is issued and its effective date.”

The flag is Syfertize’s treatment of the citing case itself, not of the statute. “Where it cites” is the passage in the opinion; the holding is a summary of the whole case and may concern another point. Annotations are extracted automatically from the opinions in the Syfert caselaw corpus.

Citing cases by year
198420042025

One bar per year. Tallest: 2 cases in 1987. These are opinions in the Syfert collection, which holds more of some courts’ recent opinions than their older ones, so a rise can reflect what the collection holds and not more litigation.

By court
D.C. Cir.57th Cir.28th Cir.22d Cir.14th Cir.19th Cir.1Vet. App.1SCOTUS1
By subsection

Courts have not cited this section by subsection, so its cases are not split up here. The Leading cases tab lists the cases that cite it most heavily.

Enactment and amendments

Syfert holds no separate history line for this section. Where this code prints a source or history note, it appears with the text, usually at the end.

Versions

Edition shown: eCFR text as of Sept. 29, 2026. Syfert holds no earlier or later version of this section.

C.F.R. Home  |  Search C.F.R.  |  Search cases for this section  |  syfert.com