Idaho Code homeSearch Idaho

Idaho Code § 16-2009 (2026)

Hearing. 

Edition and currency
text as last checked Oct. 2026 (this copy records no edition or section history). The text is the edition Syfert holds; for a past event, check the version in force on that date.
Other sources
CURRENTtext as last checked Oct. 2026 (this copy records no edition or section history) ACTIVE · 123 IN 5Y cited 1970–2026 290citing cases
At a glance

Courts have cited this section in 290 opinions since 1970, 123 of them in the last five years. The most litigated part is subsection (3) (2 cases).

Hearing. 

(1) Cases under this act shall be heard by the court without a jury. The hearing may be conducted in an informal manner and may be adjourned from time to time. Stenographic notes or mechanical recording of the hearing shall be required. The general public shall be excluded and only such persons admitted whose presence is requested by any person entitled to notice under the provisions of section 16-2007, Idaho Code, or as the judge shall find to have a direct interest in the case or in the work of the court; provided that persons so admitted shall not disclose any information secured at the hearing which would identify an individual child or parent. The court may require the presence of witnesses deemed necessary to the disposition of the petition, except that a parent who has executed a waiver pursuant to section 16-2007, Idaho Code, shall not be required to appear at the hearing.

(2)  The parent or guardian ad litem shall be notified as soon as practicable after the filing of a petition and prior to the start of a hearing of his right to have counsel and, if counsel is requested and the parent or guardian is financially unable to employ counsel, counsel shall be provided only if such representation is constitutionally required. The prosecuting attorneys of the several counties shall represent the department at all stages of the hearing.
(3)  The court’s finding with respect to grounds for termination shall be based upon clear and convincing evidence under rules applicable to the trial of civil causes, provided that relevant and material information of any nature, including that contained in reports, studies or examinations, may be admitted and relied upon to the extent of its probative value. When information contained in a report, study or examination is admitted in evidence, the person making such report, study or examination shall be subject to both direct and cross-examination.
The 20 cases that cite Idaho Code § 16-2009 most heavily, weighted by court and treatment. RelevanceNewestTreatment
1
GREENTanner v. State, Dep't of Health & Welfare, 818 P.2d 310 (Idaho 1991).
cites § 16-2009 12×cited by 275 cases
Where it cites § 16-2009
“Idaho Code § 16-2009 , unlike the deficient New York statutory standard in Santosky v.”
The case’s holding
Termination of parental rights may be granted if any one or more of the independent statutory grounds for termination are established.
Later courts cite it for
“observe witnesses' demeanor, to assess their credibility, to detect prejudice or motive and to judge the character of the parties.” · 8 citing courts
2
GREENIdaho Dep't of Health & Welfare v. Doe, 249 P.3d 362 (Idaho 2011).
cites § 16-2009 12×cited by 19 cases
Where it cites § 16-2009
“Idaho Code § 16-2009 provides the right to appointed counsel in terminations of parental rights.”
Later courts cite it for
“in the absence of a motion for disqualification, this court will not review that issue on appeal.” · 2 citing courts
3
GREENIdaho Dep't of Health & Welfare v. Doe, 277 P.3d 400 (Idaho Ct. App. 2012).
cites § 16-2009 4×cited by 210 cases
The case’s holding
A magistrate may consider both past and current conduct when determining whether grounds exist for terminating parental rights.
Later courts cite it for
“magistrate may consider both past and current conduct when determining whether grounds exist for terminating a person's parental rights.” · 1 citing court
4
GREENIdaho Dep't of Health & Welfare v. Doe, 389 P.3d 141 (Idaho 2016).
cites § 16-2009 4×cited by 41 cases
Where it cites § 16-2009
“3d 1262 , 1264–65 (2014); see also I.C. § 16-2009. “Clear and convincing evidence is evidence that indicates the thing to be proved is highly probable or reasonably certain.”
The case’s holding
Impossibility serves as a defense to neglect claims based on failure to comply with a case plan if the circumstances are beyond the parent's control.
Later courts cite it for
“impossibility may be asserted as a defense to a claim of neglect founded upon failure to comply with the requirements of a case plan.” · 9 citing courts
5
GREENDHW v. John Doe, 450 P.3d 323 (Idaho Ct. App. 2019).
cites § 16-2009 16×cited by 3 cases
Where it cites § 16-2009
“Doe’s attorney objected to the admission of the report of investigation as hearsay. The court responded that the objection was valid but “the legislature has determined and stated that this Court may admit any report, study or examination and rely upon it to the extent of its…”
Later courts cite it for
“relevant and material information of any nature, including that contained in reports, studies or examinations,” · 3 citing courts
6
GREENIdaho Dep't of Health & Welfare v. Doe, 390 P.3d 1281 (Idaho 2017).
cites § 16-2009 4×cited by 21 cases
Where it cites § 16-2009
“In relevant part, the magistrate’s order provides: The court finds by clear and convincing evidence, pursuant to Idaho Code § 16-2009 , that the termination of the parent-child relationship between the Mother and the children, (a) is in the best interests of said children and…”
The case’s holding
A parent's recent modest improvements are insufficient to overcome a demonstrated history of unfitness (finding no error in the magistrate's conclusion regarding insufficient improvement).
Later courts cite it for
“we find no error in the trial court's conclusion that mother's recent and modest improvements were insufficient to overcome her history of demonstrated unfitness.” · 3 citing courts
cites § 16-2009 4×cited by 19 cases
Where it cites § 16-2009
“" I.C. § 16-2009 (emphasis added). Since an official transcript was created by a court reporter, we hold that this requirement was achieved here.”
The case’s holding
An appellant who fails to provide argument and authority supporting an issue on appeal waives it, so the appellate court will not consider that issue.
Later courts cite it for
“where a petition to terminate parental rights has been filed in a c.p.a. case, the idaho rules of evidence shall apply to proceedings on the petition to terminate.” · 4 citing courts
cites § 16-2009 2×cited by 75 cases
Where it cites § 16-2009
“I.C. § 16-2009. In an action to terminate parental rights, where the trial court has explicitly determined the case by application of the clear and convincing evidentiary standard, this Court must determine if the decision was supported by substantial and competent evidence.”
The case’s holding
An appellate court generally does not address issues on appeal that are not supported by cogent argument and citation to legal authority.
Later courts cite it for
“once a child has been placed in the legal custody of the state, the department must make reasonable efforts to reunify children with their parents if there are no aggravating circumstances.” · 2 citing courts
9
GREENRoe v. Doe, 141 P.3d 1057 (Idaho 2006).
cites § 16-2009 2×cited by 315 cases
Where it cites § 16-2009
“2d 492, 495 (1988); I.C. § 16-2009. Clear and convincing evidence is generally understood to be “[e]vidence indicating that the thing to be proved is highly probable or reasonably certain.”
The case’s holding
A trial court must consider all relevant evidence when a fundamental liberty interest in maintaining a parental relationship is at stake.
Later courts cite it for
“clear and convincing evidence is generally understood to be 'evidence indicating that the thing to be proved is highly probable or reasonably certain.” · 13 citing courts
10
GREENDoe v. State, 53 P.3d 341 (Idaho 2002).
cites § 16-2009 2×cited by 292 cases
Where it cites § 16-2009
“I.C. § 16-2009. This Court will not disturb the trial court’s findings so long as it they are based on substantial competent evidence.”
The case’s holding
Incarceration alone does not establish willful abandonment if the parent attempts to maintain a relationship with the child under the circumstances.
Later courts cite it for
“that the failure to complete the 'rider' program after the child was born demonstrated a lack of interest in the child.” · 2 citing courts
11
GREENIn Interest of Bush, 749 P.2d 492 (Idaho 1988).
cites § 16-2009 6×cited by 42 cases
Where it cites § 16-2009
“Idaho Code § 16-2009 (Supp.1987) reads in pertinent part: The court’s finding with respect to grounds for termination shall be based upon clear and convincing evidence under rules applicable to the trial of civil causes, provided that relevant and material information of any…”
The case’s holding
The substantial evidence test requires a greater quantum of evidence in cases where the trial court finding must be supported by clear and convincing evidence.
Later courts cite it for
“obviously, the substantial evidence test requires a greater quantum of evidence in cases where the trial court finding must be supported by clear and convincing evidence, than in cases where a mere preponderance is required.” · 3 citing courts
12
GREENRhodes v. State, Dept. of Health & Welfare, 695 P.2d 1259 (Idaho 1985).
cites § 16-2009 8×cited by 18 cases
Where it cites § 16-2009
“Idaho Code § 16-2009 , as amended in 1983, provides in part: The court's finding with respect to grounds for termination shall be based upon clear and convincing evidence under rules applicable to the trial of civil causes, provided that relevant and material information of any…”
The case’s holding
Termination of parental rights may be upheld on evidence of physical abuse and neglect, and findings supported by substantial and competent evidence, even if conflicting, will be sustained on appeal.
13
GREENIdaho Dep't of Health & Welfare v. Doe, 318 P.3d 886 (Idaho 2014).
cites § 16-2009 6×cited by 13 cases
Where it cites § 16-2009
“” Here, the Consent included the following language regarding the burden of proof: I understand that the determination of whether this consent is implemented shall rest with the court, and that such determination shall not be made until a hearing on the allegations of…”
Later courts cite it for
“parents have a fundamental right to maintain a familial relationship, and to the 'custody, care and control' of their children; this right is protected by the fourteenth amendment.” · 4 citing courts
14
GREENIdaho Dep't of Health & Welfare v. Doe, 250 P.3d 803 (Idaho Ct. App. 2011).
cites § 16-2009 4×cited by 24 cases
Where it cites § 16-2009
“The United States Supreme Court noted three factors that called for employment of this elevated standard of proof: the permanence and irrevocability of a termination of parental rights; the reality that "the State's ability to assemble its case almost inevitably dwarfs the…”
The case’s holding
A trial court abuses its discretion by terminating parental rights while disregarding compelling evidence of a parent's substantial progress in overcoming addiction and rebuilding a relationship with the children.
Later courts cite it for
“while disregarding or giving minimal attention to the compelling evidence of father's success in overcoming alcoholism, complying with treatment requirements, maintaining remunerative employment, and becoming a nurturing parent with whom the children had developed a strong bond.” · 4 citing courts
15
GREENJohn Doe v. Jane Doe, 314 P.3d 187 (Idaho 2013).
cites § 16-2009 4×cited by 16 cases
Where it cites § 16-2009
“Thus, under Idaho Code § 16-2009 , grounds for termination of parental rights must be “based upon clear and convincing evidence .”
The case’s holding
A parent's failure to maintain a normal relationship with a child is willful if the parent is capable of maintaining that relationship.
Later courts cite it for
“the key issue regarding willfulness is whether the parent is capable of maintaining a normal relationship with the child.” · 2 citing courts
16
GREENState, Dep't of Health & Welfare v. Doe, 182 P.3d 1196 (Idaho 2008).
cites § 16-2009 3×cited by 24 cases
Where it cites § 16-2009
“Jane Doe appealed the magistrate’s findings as not supported by clear and convincing evidence as required by I.C. § 16-2009, and the district court, Honorable G.”
The case’s holding
A finding of neglect is supported by substantial and competent evidence if the evidence directly relates to unaccomplished case plan tasks.
Later courts cite it for
“the magistrate judge has a better 'opportunity to observe witnesses' demeanor, to assess their credibility, to detect prejudice or motive and to judge the character of the parties.” · 2 citing courts
17
GREENJohn & Jane Doe I v. Jane Doe, 432 P.3d 60 (Idaho 2018).
cites § 16-2009 2×cited by 18 cases
Where it cites § 16-2009
“3d 1262 , 1264-65 (2014) ; I.C. § 16-2009. As generally understood, the clear and convincing evidentiary standard is met when there is "evidence indicating that the thing to be proved is highly probable or reasonably certain.”
The case’s holding
Under Idaho's best-interests termination analysis, a parent's ability to change conduct and assume parental responsibilities is only one of many factors, and the analysis is expansive with no set list of factors.
Later courts cite it for
“the best interests analysis is an expansive analysis with 'no set list of factors a court must consider' . . . .” · 4 citing courts
18
GREENIn re Adoption of Doe, 141 P.3d 1057 (Idaho 2006).
cites § 16-2009 2×cited by 47 cases
Where it cites § 16-2009
“2d 492, 495 (1988); I.C. § 16-2009. Clear and convincing evidence is generally understood to be "[e]vidence indicating that the thing to be proved is highly probable or reasonably certain.”
The case’s holding
A petitioning party meets the burden of persuasion for abandonment only if the trier of fact finds that no valid defenses or just causes exist.
19
GREENDoe I v. Doe II, 228 P.3d 980 (Idaho 2010).
cites § 16-2009 2×cited by 46 cases
Where it cites § 16-2009
“…. "The court’s finding with respect to grounds for termination shall he based upon clear and convincing evidence....” I.C. § 16-2009.”
The case’s holding
A parent willfully fails to maintain a normal parental relationship only if they have the ability to do so.
Later courts cite it for
“for one to willfully fail to do something, he or she must have the ability to do it.” · 13 citing courts
20
GREENIdaho Dep't of Health & Welfare v. Doe, 397 P.3d 1159 (Idaho Ct. App. 2017).
cites § 16-2009 2×cited by 16 cases
Where it cites § 16-2009
“See also I.C. § 16-2009; In re Doe, 146 Idaho 759, 761-62 , 203 P.”
The case’s holding
A parent's inability to care for a child due to incarceration constitutes neglect under Idaho's termination statute, and willfulness is not required to establish that neglect.

Show all 290 citing cases (list view) →

The flag is Syfertize’s treatment of the citing case itself, not of the statute. “Where it cites” is the passage in the opinion; the holding is a summary of the whole case and may concern another point. Annotations are extracted automatically from the opinions in the Syfert caselaw corpus.

Citing cases by year
197019982026

One bar per year. Tallest: 31 cases in 2020. 2026 is a partial year. These are opinions in the Syfert collection, which holds more of some courts’ recent opinions than their older ones, so a rise can reflect what the collection holds and not more litigation.

By court
Idaho Ct. App.237Idaho52Miss.1
By subsection
(2)1 case
Jane Doe v. John Doe, No. 53148, 53137 (Idaho May 12, 2026).
(3)2 cases
Jane Doe v. John Doe, No. 53148, 53137 (Idaho May 12, 2026).
State of Idaho v. John Doe, No. 53692 (Idaho Ct. App. June 18, 2026).

Show all 290 citing cases (list view) →

Enactment and amendments

Syfert holds no separate history line for this section. Where this code prints a source or history note, it appears with the text, usually at the end.

Versions

Edition shown: text as last checked Oct. 2026 (this copy records no edition or section history). Syfert holds no earlier or later version of this section.

Idaho Code Home  |  Search Idaho  |  Search cases for this section  |  syfert.com