Massachusetts General Laws homeSearch Massachusetts
Mass. Gen. LawsPart III Title IV Chapter 258D

Mass. Gen. Laws ch. 258D, § 1 (2026)

Erroneous felony conviction claims; class of eligible persons; burden of proof; definitions; right to jury trial; preliminary relief

Edition and currency
text as last checked Sept. 2026 (this copy records no edition or section history). The text is the edition Syfert holds; for a past event, check the version in force on that date.
Other sources
CURRENTtext as last checked Sept. 2026 (this copy records no edition or section history) cited 2004–2024 20citing cases
At a glance

Courts have cited this section in 20 opinions since 2004, 4 of them in the last five years. The most litigated part is subsection (B)(ii) (4 cases).

Section 1. (A) A claim may be brought against the commonwealth for an erroneous felony conviction resulting in incarceration as provided in this chapter.

(B) The class of persons eligible to obtain relief under this chapter shall be limited to the following:—

(i) those that have been granted a full pardon pursuant to section 152 of chapter 127, if the governor expressly states in writing his belief in the individual's innocence, or

(ii) those who have been granted judicial relief by a state court of competent jurisdiction, on grounds which tend to establish the innocence of the individual as set forth in clause (vi) of subsection (C), and if (a) the judicial relief vacates or reverses the judgment of a felony conviction, and the felony indictment or complaint used to charge the individual with such felony has been dismissed, or if a new trial was ordered, the individual was not retried and the felony indictment or complaint was dismissed or a nolle prosequi was entered, or if a new trial was ordered the individual was found not guilty at the new trial; and (b) at the time of the filing of an action under this chapter no criminal proceeding is pending or can be brought against the individual by a district attorney or the attorney general for any act associated with such felony conviction.

(C) In order for an individual to prevail and recover damages against the commonwealth in a cause of action brought under this chapter, the individual must establish, by clear and convincing evidence, that:—

(i) he is a member of the class of persons defined in subsection (B);

(ii) he was convicted of an offense classified as a felony;

(iii) he did not plead guilty to the offense charged, or to any lesser included offense, unless such guilty plea was withdrawn, vacated or nullified by operation of law on a basis other than a claimed deficiency in the plea warnings required by section 29D of chapter 278;

(iv) he was sentenced to incarceration for not less than 1 year in state prison or a house of correction as a result of the conviction and has served all or any part of such sentence;

(v) he was incarcerated solely on the basis of the conviction for the offense that is the subject of the claim;

(vi) he did not commit the crimes or crime charged in the indictment or complaint or any other felony arising out of or reasonably connected to the facts supporting the indictment or complaint, or any lesser included felony; and

(vii) to the extent that he is guilty of conduct that would have justified a conviction of any lesser included misdemeanor arising out of or reasonably connected to facts supporting the indictment or complaint, that he has served the maximum sentence he would have received for such lesser included misdemeanor and not less than one additional year in a prison.

(D) The claimant shall attach to his claim certified copies of: the mittimus that shows the claimant's sentence to incarceration and; the warrants necessary to grant a pardon pursuant to section 152 of chapter 127 or; criminal case docket entries or documents related thereto in the case of judicial relief.

(E) For the purposes of this chapter ''conviction'' or ''convicted'' shall include an adjudication as a youthful offender, if such adjudication resulted in the youthful offender's incarceration in a house of correction or state prison.

(F) The commonwealth and any individual filing an action for compensation under this chapter shall have the right to a jury trial on any action so filed. In the interest of doing substantial justice, with regard to weight and admissibility of evidence submitted by the claimant or the commonwealth, the court presiding at a jury-waived trial shall exercise its discretion by giving due consideration to any difficulties of proof caused by the passage of time, the death or unavailability or witnesses, or other factors not caused by the claimant, or those acting on the claimant's or the commonwealth's behalf. At a jury trial, the court shall consider these same factors as part of the exercise of its discretion when determining the admissibility and weight of evidence, and the court shall instruct the jury that it may consider the same factors when it weighs the evidence presented at trial. No evidence proffered by any party shall be excluded on grounds that it was seized or obtained in violation of the Fourth, Fifth or Sixth amendments to the Constitution of the United States, or in violation of Articles 12 or 14 of Part the First of the Constitution of Massachusetts.

(G) A claimant shall be entitled to preliminary relief under section subsection (E) of section 5 upon an initial showing that there is a substantial likelihood of success on the merits of the case.

The 20 cases that cite Mass. Gen. Laws ch. 258D, § 1 most heavily, weighted by court and treatment. RelevanceNewestTreatment
1
GREENIrwin v. Commonwealth, 992 N.E.2d 275 (Mass. 2013).
cites § 1 17×cited by 23 cases
Where it cites § 1
“1 We consider also whether a conviction that was overturned because the Commonwealth introduced evidence of the plaintiff’s prearrest silence as purportedly establishing consciousness of guilt was overturned “on grounds which tend to establish” his innocence, such that he is…”
The case’s holding
Compensation under the erroneous convictions statute requires a conviction to be overturned on grounds resting upon facts and circumstances probative of the proposition that the claimant did not commit the crime.
Later courts cite it for
“rather, 'grounds which tend to establish' a plaintiff's innocence require that a conviction be overturned 'on grounds resting upon facts and circumstances probative of the proposition that the claimant did not commit the crime.” · 3 citing courts
2
GREENDrumgold v. Commonwealth, 937 N.E.2d 450 (Mass. 2010).
cites § 1 22×cited by 14 cases
Where it cites § 1
“" G. L. c. 258D, § 1 (B) (ii). A judge in the Superior Court denied the Commonwealth's motion.”
The case’s holding
Eligibility for erroneous conviction relief exists if the grounds for a new trial rest on facts and circumstances probative of the defendant's innocence.
Later courts cite it for
“the fact finder was forestalled from making a fully informed decision as to the defendant's guilt or innocence” · 2 citing courts
3
GREENGuzman v. Commonwealth, 937 N.E.2d 441 (Mass. 2010).
cites § 1 8×cited by 20 cases
Where it cites § 1
“Relevant here are certain subsections of G. L. c. 258D, § 1. General Laws c. 258D, § 1 (A), authorizes certain claims to be brought against the Commonwealth, thereby waiving the Commonwealth’s sovereign immunity as to such claims.”
The case’s holding
Whether grounds for relief tend to establish innocence is a question of law when the grounds are not in dispute under the Massachusetts Erroneous Convictions Law.
Later courts cite it for
“where the grounds for relief are not in dispute, the question whether they 'tend to establish' that the plaintiff did not commit the crime is primarily a question of law.” · 2 citing courts
4
REDGuzman v. Commonwealth, 907 N.E.2d 1140 (Mass. App. Ct. 2009).
cites § 1 6×subsections: (B) 3× (A)cited by 11 cases
Reversed by Guzman v. Commonwealth (2010): the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court's own opinion in this case.
Where it cites § 1
“G. L. c. 258D, §§ 1, 5, & 7. 3 Relevant here are certain subsections of G.”
Later courts cite it for
“grounds resting upon facts and circumstances probative of the proposition that the claimant did not commit the crime.” · 5 citing courts
5
GREENRenaud v. Commonwealth, 28 N.E.3d 478 (Mass. 2015).
cites § 1 5×cited by 12 cases
Where it cites § 1
“We transferred the case here on our own initiative to determine whether, under G. L. c. 258D, § 1 (B), the reversal of Renaud’s convictions due to insufficient evidence amounts to “grounds which tend to establish” his innocence, thus rendering him eligible to obtain relief under…”
Later courts cite it for
“the eligibility requirement is 'separate and distinct from the merits of the claim of relief that a claimant must establish at trial,' namely that he or she did not commit the charged offense.” · 2 citing courts
6
GREENDrumgold v. Callahan, 707 F.3d 28 (1st Cir. 2013).
cites § 1 2×cited by 63 cases
Where it cites § 1
“2d at 452 ; see Mass. Gen. Laws ch. 258D, § 1. As the SJC's decision made clear, the combination of the various grounds offered in the new trial motion, and particularly the allegations regarding Alexander, were very serious.”
The case’s holding
Law enforcement officers have an affirmative duty to disclose material exculpatory evidence known only to them to prosecutors.
Later courts cite it for
“law enforcement officers have a correlative duty to turn over to the prosecutor any material evidence that is favorable to a defendant.” · 7 citing courts
7
GREENLimone v. United States, 579 F.3d 79 (1st Cir. 2009).
cites § 1 1×cited by 162 cases
Where it cites § 1
“§§ 1495 , 2513(e) (limiting government’s liability for wrongful incarceration of federal prisoners to $50,000 per year, or to $100,000 per year in capital cases); Mass. Gen. Laws ch. 258D, §§ 1, 5 (capping state’s liability at $500,000 per incident).”
The case’s holding
The discretionary function exception does not immunize the government from liability for conduct that violates federal statutes or the Constitution.
Later courts cite it for
“it is elementary that the discretionary function exception does not immunize the government from liability for actions proscribed by federal statute or regulation. . . . nor does it shield conduct that transgresses the constitution.” · 7 citing courts
8
GREENSantana v. Commonwealth, 90 Mass. App. Ct. 372 (Mass. App. Ct. 2016).
cites § 1 12×subsections: (B)(ii) 8× (C)(vi) 3×cited by 1 case
Where it cites § 1
“…out of or reasonably connected to the facts supporting the indictment or complaint, or any lesser included felony.” G. L. c. 258D, § 1 (C)(vi).”
9
GREENCommonwealth v. Martin, 63 N.E.3d 1107 (Mass. 2016).
cites § 1 1×cited by 13 cases
Where it cites § 1
“Contrast G. L. c. 258D, § 1 (B) (ii) (eligible defendants include “those who have been granted judicial relief by a state court of competent jurisdiction”).”
10
GREENPaul Kamienski v. State of New Jersey, 169 A.3d 493 (N.J. Super. Ct. App. Div. 2017).
cites § 1 1×subsections: (C)(vi)cited by 12 cases
Where it cites § 1
“Other states have required the claimant to provide proof of innocence of "any other felony arising out of or reasonably connected to the facts supporting the indictment or complaint, or any lesser included felony," Mass. Gen. Laws ch. 258D, § 1(C)(vi) (2017); "another criminal…”
Later courts cite it for
“an expert's opinion on a question of law is neither appropriate nor probative.” · 2 citing courts
11
GREENSantana v. Commonwealth, 88 Mass. App. Ct. 553 (Mass. App. Ct. 2015).
cites § 1 3×subsections: (B)(ii) 3×cited by 5 cases
Later courts cite it for
“rejected a categorical approach,” · 1 citing court
12
GREENState of Iowa v. David R. Desimone, 839 N.W.2d 660 (Iowa 2013).
cites § 1 1×subsections: (B)(ii)cited by 24 cases
Where it cites § 1
“2013); Mass. Gen. Laws Ann. ch. 258D, § 1(B)(ii) (West Supp.”
Later courts cite it for
“statutes must be read in their entirety.” · 4 citing courts
13
GREENRiley v. Commonwealth, 971 N.E.2d 843 (Mass. App. Ct. 2012).
cites § 1 2×subsections: (B) (F)cited by 5 cases
Where it cites § 1
“In order to pass the initial bar of G. L. c. 258D, § 1(B), “the relief granted must be on grounds tending to do more than merely assist the defendant’s chances of acquittal.”
Later courts cite it for
“a plaintiff must first show that the grounds for judicial relief were probative of his innocence.” · 2 citing courts
14
GREENSeres v. Lerner, 102 P.3d 91 (Nev. 2004).
cites § 1 1×cited by 2 cases
Where it cites § 1
“1939, proposed Mass. Gen. Laws ch. 258D, § 1 (2001)). 44 Id.”
The case’s holding
A Son of Sam statute is a content-based restriction on speech that must pass strict scrutiny and is unconstitutional if it is overinclusive.
Later courts cite it for
“because the 'son of sam' law is a content-based restriction on speech, the statute must pass a strict scrutiny level of review, in line with relevant case authority.” · 1 citing court
15
NEUTRALPeterson v. Commonwealth, 85 N.E.3d 965 (Mass. 2017).
cites § 1 11×cited by 0 cases
Where it cites § 1
“1 We transferred the case here on our own motion to determine whether, under G. L. c. 258D, § 1 (B) (ii), Peterson is eligible to pursue a claim for compensation.”
16
NO FLAGRoberto Cruz v. Commonwealth, 243 N.E.3d 430 (Mass. 2024).
cites § 1 11×cited by 0 cases
Where it cites § 1
“For the reasons discussed below, we conclude that misdemeanor charges do not fall within the scope of the eligibility requirement set forth in G. L. c. 258D, § 1 (C) (vi). Accordingly, we affirm the Superior Court's denial of the Commonwealth's motion for summary judgment and…”
17
GREENCruz v. Commonwealth, 102 Mass. App. Ct. 685 (Mass. App. Ct. 2023).
cites § 1 10×cited by 0 cases
Where it cites § 1
“See G. L. c. 258D, § 1 (B) (ii). Because the facts adduced at Cruz's criminal trial supported a conviction of assault and battery, a crime for which Cruz was 2 indicted but that the Commonwealth voluntarily dismissed before the case went to the jury, we conclude that Cruz is not…”
18
NO FLAGKenneth James Otey v. Commonwealth of Massachusetts., No. 22-P-0599 (Mass. App. Ct. Mar. 14, 2024).
cites § 1 2×cited by 0 casesunpublished
Where it cites § 1
“G. L. c. 258D, § 1 (B) (ii). His conviction was vacated and dismissed for reasons unrelated to the merits of the indictments.”
19
NO FLAGDaniel Knight v. Attorney Gen.., No. 22-P-0765 (Mass. App. Ct. Apr. 10, 2024).
cites § 1 1×cited by 0 casesunpublished
Where it cites § 1
“" G. L. c. 258D § 1 (B). We disagree with the plaintiff's contention that the global remedy provided by the Supreme Judicial Court's opinion in Committee for Pub.”
20
NO FLAGGuy Israel Greene v. State of Minnesota, No. A15-351 (Minn. Ct. App. Oct. 19, 2015).
cites § 1 1×subsections: (B)(ii)cited by 0 casesunpublished
Where it cites § 1
“Mass. Gen. Laws ch. 258D, § 1(B)(ii) (2014).”

The flag is Syfertize’s treatment of the citing case itself, not of the statute. “Where it cites” is the passage in the opinion; the holding is a summary of the whole case and may concern another point. Annotations are extracted automatically from the opinions in the Syfert caselaw corpus.

Citing cases by year
200420142024

One bar per year. Tallest: 3 cases in 2013. These are opinions in the Syfert collection, which holds more of some courts’ recent opinions than their older ones, so a rise can reflect what the collection holds and not more litigation.

By court
Mass.7Mass. App. Ct.71st Cir.2Iowa1Minn. Ct. App.1Nev.1N.J. Super. Ct. App. Div.1
By subsection
(A)1 case
Guzman v. Commonwealth, 907 N.E.2d 1140 (Mass. App. Ct. 2009).“G. L. c. 258D, §§ 1, 5, & 7. 3 Relevant here are certain subsections of G.”
(B)2 cases
Guzman v. Commonwealth, 907 N.E.2d 1140 (Mass. App. Ct. 2009).
Riley v. Commonwealth, 971 N.E.2d 843 (Mass. App. Ct. 2012).“In order to pass the initial bar of G. L. c. 258D, § 1(B), “the relief granted must be on grounds tending to do more than merely assist the defendant’s chances of acquittal.”
(B)(ii)4 cases
Santana v. Commonwealth, 90 Mass. App. Ct. 372 (Mass. App. Ct. 2016).“…out of or reasonably connected to the facts supporting the indictment or complaint, or any lesser included felony.” G. L. c. 258D, § 1 (C)(vi).”
Santana v. Commonwealth, 88 Mass. App. Ct. 553 (Mass. App. Ct. 2015).
State of Iowa v. David R. Desimone, 839 N.W.2d 660 (Iowa 2013).“2013); Mass. Gen. Laws Ann. ch. 258D, § 1(B)(ii) (West Supp.”
Guy Israel Greene v. State of Minnesota, No. A15-351 (Minn. Ct. App. Oct. 19, 2015).“Mass. Gen. Laws ch. 258D, § 1(B)(ii) (2014).”
(C)(vi)2 cases
Paul Kamienski v. State of New Jersey, 169 A.3d 493 (N.J. Super. Ct. App. Div. 2017).“Other states have required the claimant to provide proof of innocence of "any other felony arising out of or reasonably connected to the facts supporting the indictment or complaint, or any lesser included felony," Mass. Gen. Laws ch. 258D, § 1(C)(vi) (2017); "another criminal…”
Santana v. Commonwealth, 90 Mass. App. Ct. 372 (Mass. App. Ct. 2016).
(F)1 case
Riley v. Commonwealth, 971 N.E.2d 843 (Mass. App. Ct. 2012).
Enactment and amendments

Syfert holds no separate history line for this section. Where this code prints a source or history note, it appears with the text, usually at the end.

Versions

Edition shown: text as last checked Sept. 2026 (this copy records no edition or section history). Syfert holds no earlier or later version of this section.

Massachusetts General Laws Home  |  Search Massachusetts  |  Search cases for this section  |  syfert.com