Utah Code homeSearch Utah
Utah CodeTitle 59, Chapter 1 — General Taxation Policies; part 59-1-6 — Judicial Review

Utah Code § 59-1-610 (2026)

Standard of review of appellate court

Edition and currency
laws through the 2026 General Session (checked Sept. 2026). The text is the edition Syfert holds; for a past event, check the version in force on that date.
Other sources
CURRENTlaws through the 2026 General Session (checked Sept. 2026) cited 1993–2025 78citing cases
At a glance

Courts have cited this section in 78 opinions since 1993, 4 of them in the last five years. The most litigated part is subsection (1)(b) (18 cases).

When reviewing formal adjudicative proceedings commenced before the commission, the Court of Appeals or Supreme Court shall:
grant the commission deference concerning its written findings of fact, applying a substantial evidence standard on review; and
grant the commission no deference concerning its conclusions of law, applying a correction of error standard, unless there is an explicit grant of discretion contained in a statute at issue before the appellate court.
This section supercedes Section 63G-4-403 pertaining to judicial review of formal adjudicative proceedings.

Amended by Chapter 382, 2008 General Session

The 20 cases that cite Utah Code § 59-1-610 most heavily, weighted by court and treatment. RelevanceNewestTreatment
cites § 59-1-610 24×subsections: (2) 4× (1)(b) 2×cited by 23 cases
Where it cites § 59-1-610
“See Utah Code Ann. § 59-1-610 (1)(a) (1996). In other words, the court of appeals must uphold those findings of fact that are supported by substantial evidence, or "that quantum and quality of relevant evidence which is adequate to convince a reasonable mind to support a…”
The case’s holding
A stipulation of fact is binding on the parties and the tribunal absent a timely motion showing justifiable cause; unambiguous stipulated facts cannot be contradicted by extrinsic evidence.
2
GREENAlta Pac. Assocs., Ltd. v. Utah State Tax Comm'n, 931 P.2d 103 (Utah 1997).
cites § 59-1-610 21×subsections: (1)(b) 3×cited by 22 cases
Where it cites § 59-1-610
“Sevier County argues that the fee simple rule is not a rule of law, but an appraisal guideline, and the application of such guidelines is an issue of fact. Therefore, the county argues, this court must afford deference to the Commission's determination and apply "a substantial…”
cites § 59-1-610 18×subsections: (1) 4×cited by 28 cases
Where it cites § 59-1-610
“Prior to the passage of that statute, review was in this court only and the standard of review, governed by section 59-1-610, was more restrictive. See Utah Code Ann.”
The case’s holding
Amendments to a procedural statute that clarify procedure apply retroactively to pending matters, because such statutes control the mode and form of enforcing substantive rights.
Later courts cite it for
“controls the mode and form of procedure for enforcing the underlying substantive rights” · 3 citing courts
4
GREEN49th Street Galleria v. Tax Comm'n, 860 P.2d 996 (Utah Ct. App. 1993).
cites § 59-1-610 16×subsections: (2)cited by 29 cases
Where it cites § 59-1-610
“8 STANDARD OF REVIEW Our analysis of tax cases is guided by the standards of review announced in Utah Code Ann. § 59-1-610 (Supp.1993). OSI Indus.”
The case’s holding
Fees charged for specific activities or equipment within an entertainment venue are not admission fees where no charge is levied for the right to enter the premises.
Later courts cite it for
“section 59-12-103 does not contain language which would even arguably constitute an explicit grant of discretion to the tax commission....” · 1 citing court
cites § 59-1-610 15×subsections: (1) 2× (2)cited by 19 cases
Later courts cite it for
“we grant the commission no deference concerning its conclusions of law, applying a correction-of-error standard, unless there is an explicit grant of discretion contained in a statute at issue before the appellate court.” · 1 citing court
6
GREENABCO Enter. v. Utah State Tax Comm'n, 2009 UT 36, 211 P.3d 382.
cites § 59-1-610 5×subsections: (1)(b)cited by 41 cases
Where it cites § 59-1-610
“" Utah Code Ann. § 59-1-610 (1)(a) (2008). We review the Commission's conclusions of law for correctness, granting no deference where the statute at issue, as here, gives no explicit grant of discretion to the Commission.”
The case’s holding
A statute taxing lessees of exempt property at the same rate as fee simple owners does not violate equal protection or constitutional uniformity requirements.
7
GREENUtah State Tax Comm'n v. Stevenson, 2006 UT 84, 150 P.3d 521.
cites § 59-1-610 8×subsections: (1)(a) 2×cited by 11 cases
Where it cites § 59-1-610
“3d 1232 , and a correctness standard to the ALJ's conclusions of law, see Utah Code Ann. § 59-1-610 (1)(b) (2004); Stevenson, 2005 UT App 179, ¶ 10 , 112 P.”
Later courts cite it for
“look to other interpretive tools.” · 2 citing courts
8
GREENHarper Investments, Inc. v. Auditing Div., 868 P.2d 813 (Utah 1994).
cites § 59-1-610 8×cited by 18 cases
Where it cites § 59-1-610
“"We grant the Commission no deference concerning its conclusions of law, applying a correction-of-error standard, unless there is an explicit grant of discretion contained in a statute at issue before the appellate court.”
The case’s holding
A petition for judicial review is timely if filed within thirty days after the agency's final order is issued or deemed issued, and sales tax cannot rest on accounting entries contradicting actual ownership.
Later courts cite it for
“within 30 days after the date that the order constituting the final agency action is issued or is considered to have been issued under subsection 63-46b-13(3)(b).” · 1 citing court
9
GREENBeaver Cnty. v. Utah State Tax Comm'n, 919 P.2d 547 (Utah 1996).
cites § 59-1-610 12×subsections: (1)(b) 2×cited by 9 cases
Where it cites § 59-1-610
“" Utah Code Ann. § 59-1-610 (1)(b). The proceeding from which the Counties appeal was a formal adjudicative proceeding.”
Later courts cite it for
“a designation is mandatory, and therefore jurisdictional, if it is of the essence of the thing to be done.” · 2 citing courts
cites § 59-1-610 6×cited by 29 cases
Where it cites § 59-1-610
“2d at 19 ; see also Utah Code Ann. § 59-1-610 (1); Utah Admin.”
Later courts cite it for
“we review the court of appeals' decision for correctness and give its conclusions of law no deference.” · 3 citing courts
11
GREENT-Mobile USA, Inc. v. Utah State Tax Comm'n, 2011 UT 28, 254 P.3d 752.
cites § 59-1-610 4×subsections: (1) 3× (1)(a)cited by 25 cases
Where it cites § 59-1-610
“§§ 59-1-610(1), 683G-4-408(1), (4). In this case, T-Mobile chose the first avenue.”
The case’s holding
Accounting goodwill is intangible property that is not separately taxable because its income is already subject to taxation.
Later courts cite it for
“restricted to include things of the same kind, class, character, or nature as those specifically enumerated.” · 2 citing courts
12
GREENBeaver Cnty. v. Utah State Tax Comm'n, 916 P.2d 344 (Utah 1996).
cites § 59-1-610 6×cited by 25 cases
Where it cites § 59-1-610
“” Utah Code Ann. § 59-1-610 (l)(b). The proceeding from which the Counties appeal was a formal adjudicative proceeding.”
The case’s holding
A party challenging a Tax Commission finding must marshal all supporting evidence and show that, despite it, the findings lack substantial evidence; Commission findings are reviewed for substantial evidence.
Later courts cite it for
“marshal all of the evidence supporting the findings and show that despite the supporting facts and in light of the conflicting evidence, the findings are not supported by substantial evidence.” · 5 citing courts
cites § 59-1-610 2×subsections: (1)(b) 2×cited by 104 cases
Where it cites § 59-1-610
“2d 581, 588-89 (Utah 1991) (superseded by Utah Code section 59-1-610(1)(b) for the specific instance of administrative deci sions by the Utah State Tax Commission as stated in 49th St.”
The case’s holding
An employee seeking permanent total disability compensation bears the burden of proving all statutory elements, including the ability to perform essential job functions and the availability of other work.
Later courts cite it for
“an administrative law decision meets the substantial evidence test when a reasonable mind might accept as adequate the evidence supporting the decision.” · 11 citing courts
cites § 59-1-610 8×subsections: (1)(b) 4×cited by 14 cases
Summary
No passage or summary on file for this case yet.
15
GREENIvory Homes, Ltd. v. Utah State Tax Comm'n, 2011 UT 54, 266 P.3d 751.
cites § 59-1-610 3×subsections: (1)(a) 2× (1)(b)cited by 33 cases
Where it cites § 59-1-610
“Because the relevant statutory language has not changed, we cite to the current version of the statute. .”
The case’s holding
A taxpayer is entitled to a sales tax refund only if the tax commission erroneously receives, collects, or computes the tax.
Later courts cite it for
“a decision is supported by substantial evidence if there is a quantum and quality of relevant evidence that is adequate to convince a reasonable mind to support a conclusion.” · 4 citing courts
16
GREENMt. Olympus Waters, Inc. v. Utah State Tax Comm'n, 877 P.2d 1271 (Utah Ct. App. 1994).
cites § 59-1-610 13×cited by 5 cases
Where it cites § 59-1-610
“Utah Code Ann. § 59-1-610 (Supp.1993). 3 Mount Olympus challenges the Commission’s interpretation of the statutory container exemption.”
17
GREENLPI Servs. &/or Travelers Indem. Co. v. McGee, 2009 UT 41, 215 P.3d 135.
cites § 59-1-610 2×cited by 57 cases
Where it cites § 59-1-610
“2d 581, 587 (Utah 1991) (superseded by Utah Code Ann. § 59-1-610 (1)(b) with regard to administrative decisions made by the Utah State Tax Commission as stated in 49th St.”
The case’s holding
A broad and generalized statutory term indicates legislative intent to delegate the interpretation of that term to the responsible agency.
Later courts cite it for
“when the plain meaning of the statute can be discerned from its language, no other interpretive tools are needed.” · 8 citing courts
cites § 59-1-610 4×cited by 14 cases
Where it cites § 59-1-610
“3d 706 ; see also Utah Code Ann. §§ 59-1-610 (1)(b), 59-2-217 (2004).”
Later courts cite it for
“in a system where a statute of limitations controls a potential plaintiff's ability to file a cause of action, the discovery rule balances the equitable interests of the potential plaintiff and defendant where the potential plaintiff has discovered new facts forming the basis for the cause of action.” · 2 citing courts
cites § 59-1-610 6×cited by 15 cases
Where it cites § 59-1-610
“Utah Code Ann. § 59-1-610 . ANALYSIS Software Maintenance Agreements Tangible personal property is taxable pursuant to Utah Code Ann.”
20
GREENYeargin, Inc. v. Tax Comm'n, 1999 UT App 94, 977 P.2d 527.
cites § 59-1-610 10×cited by 5 cases
Where it cites § 59-1-610
“4 Utah Code Ann. § 59-1-610 (1996). ¶ 11 Our resolution of this issue disposes of Yeargin’s other arguments on appeal.”

Show all 78 citing cases (list view) →

The flag is Syfertize’s treatment of the citing case itself, not of the statute. “Where it cites” is the passage in the opinion; the holding is a summary of the whole case and may concern another point. Annotations are extracted automatically from the opinions in the Syfert caselaw corpus.

Citing cases by year
199320092025

One bar per year. Tallest: 8 cases in 1997. These are opinions in the Syfert collection, which holds more of some courts’ recent opinions than their older ones, so a rise can reflect what the collection holds and not more litigation.

By court
Utah47Utah Ct. App.31
By subsection
(1)7 cases
T-Mobile USA, Inc. v. Utah State Tax Comm'n, 2011 UT 28, 254 P.3d 752.“§§ 59-1-610(1), 683G-4-408(1), (4). In this case, T-Mobile chose the first avenue.”
Evans & Sutherland Comput. Corp. v. Utah State Tax Comm'n, 953 P.2d 435 (Utah 1997).“Prior to the passage of that statute, review was in this court only and the standard of review, governed by section 59-1-610, was more restrictive. See Utah Code Ann.”
Benjamin v. Utah State Tax Comm'n, 2011 UT 14, 250 P.3d 39.
Showing the top 5 of 7. More in the list view →
(1)(a)6 cases
Ivory Homes, Ltd. v. Utah State Tax Comm'n, 2011 UT 54, 266 P.3d 751.“Because the relevant statutory language has not changed, we cite to the current version of the statute. .”
Utah State Tax Comm'n v. Stevenson, 2006 UT 84, 150 P.3d 521.“3d 1232 , and a correctness standard to the ALJ's conclusions of law, see Utah Code Ann. § 59-1-610 (1)(b) (2004); Stevenson, 2005 UT App 179, ¶ 10 , 112 P.”
Wal-Mart v. Tax Comm'n, 2025 UT App 28.
Showing the top 5 of 6. More in the list view →
(1)(b)18 cases
Martinez v. Media-Paymaster Plus/Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints, 2007 UT 42, 164 P.3d 384.“2d 581, 588-89 (Utah 1991) (superseded by Utah Code section 59-1-610(1)(b) for the specific instance of administrative deci sions by the Utah State Tax Commission as stated in 49th St.”
Yeargin, Inc. v. Auditing Div. of Utah State Tax Comm'n, 2001 UT 11, 20 P.3d 287.“See Utah Code Ann. § 59-1-610 (1)(a) (1996). In other words, the court of appeals must uphold those findings of fact that are supported by substantial evidence, or "that quantum and quality of relevant evidence which is adequate to convince a reasonable mind to support a…”
Murray v. Utah Labor Comm'n, 2013 UT 38, 308 P.3d 461.
Alta Pac. Assocs., Ltd. v. Utah State Tax Comm'n, 931 P.2d 103 (Utah 1997).“Sevier County argues that the fee simple rule is not a rule of law, but an appraisal guideline, and the application of such guidelines is an issue of fact. Therefore, the county argues, this court must afford deference to the Commission's determination and apply "a substantial…”
Showing the top 5 of 18. More in the list view →
(2)4 cases
49th Street Galleria v. Tax Comm'n, 860 P.2d 996 (Utah Ct. App. 1993).“8 STANDARD OF REVIEW Our analysis of tax cases is guided by the standards of review announced in Utah Code Ann. § 59-1-610 (Supp.1993). OSI Indus.”
Brent Brown Dealerships v. Tax Comm'n, 2006 UT App 261, 139 P.3d 296.

Show all 78 citing cases (list view) →

Enactment and amendments

Syfert holds no separate history line for this section. Where this code prints a source or history note, it appears with the text, usually at the end.

Versions

Edition shown: laws through the 2026 General Session (checked Sept. 2026). Syfert holds no earlier or later version of this section.

Utah Code Home  |  Search Utah  |  Search cases for this section  |  syfert.com