California Codes homeSearch California
Cal. CodesLabor CodeDivision 2. Employment Regulation and SupervisionPart 3.5. Agricultural Labor RelationsChapter 6. Prevention of Unfair Labor Practices and Judicial Review and Enforcement

Cal. Labor Code § 1160.3 (2026)

Edition and currency
leginfo export of Sept. 26, 2026 (applied Oct. 1, 2026). The text is the edition Syfert holds; for a past event, check the version in force on that date.
Other sources
CURRENTleginfo export of Sept. 26, 2026 (applied Oct. 1, 2026) cited 1978–2023 34citing cases
At a glance

Courts have cited this section in 34 opinions since 1978, 2 of them in the last five years.

The testimony taken by such member, agent, or agency, or the board in such hearing shall be reduced to writing and filed with the board. Thereafter, in its discretion, the board, upon notice, may take further testimony or hear argument. If, upon the preponderance of the testimony taken, the board shall be of the opinion that any person named in the complaint has engaged in or is engaging in any such unfair labor practice, the board shall state its findings of fact and shall issue and cause to be served on such person an order requiring such person to cease and desist from such unfair labor practice, to take affirmative action, including reinstatement of employees with or without backpay, and making employees whole, when the board deems such relief appropriate, for the loss of pay resulting from the employer’s refusal to bargain, and to provide such other relief as will effectuate the policies of this part. Where an order directs reinstatement of an employee, backpay may be required of the employer or labor organization, as the case may be, responsible for the discrimination suffered by the employee. Such order may further require such person to make reports from time to time showing the extent to which it has complied with the order. If, upon the preponderance of the testimony taken, the board shall be of the opinion that the person named in the complaint has not engaged in or is not engaging in any unfair labor practice, the board shall state its findings of fact and shall issue an order dismissing the complaint. No order of the board shall require the reinstatement of any individual as an employee who has been suspended or discharged, or the payment to the employee of any backpay, if such individual was suspended or discharged for cause. In case the evidence is presented before a member of the board, or before an administrative law officer thereof, such member, or such administrative law officer, as the case may be, shall issue and cause to be served on the parties to the proceedings a proposed report, together with a recommended order, which shall be filed with the board, and, if no exceptions are filed within 20 days after service thereof upon such parties, or within such further period as the board may authorize, such recommended order shall become the order of the board and become effective as therein prescribed. If exceptions have been filed and the board issues an order finding that the person named in the complaint has engaged in or is engaging in any unfair labor practice and directing payment of a monetary remedy, the board shall order further proceedings to determine the specific amount of the monetary remedy or, if the monetary remedy is continuing to accrue, the amount accrued as of the date of the board’s order. In these cases, the board’s order does not become final for purposes of Section 1160.8 until the board has issued its determination of the specific amount of the monetary remedy.

Until the record in a case shall have been filed in a court, as provided in this chapter, the board may, at any time upon reasonable notice and in such manner as it shall deem proper, modify or set aside, in whole or in part, any finding or order made or issued by it.

The 20 cases that cite Cal. Labor Code § 1160.3 most heavily, weighted by court and treatment. RelevanceNewestTreatment
1
GREENMartori Bros. Distributors v. James-Massengale, 781 F.2d 1349 (9th Cir. 1986).
cites § 1160.3 6×cited by 114 cases
Where it cites § 1160.3
“The Employers also sought a declaration that California Labor Code § 1160.3, to the extent that it permits the ALRB to award the fringe benefit component of a “make-whole” order, is preempted by the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA), Pub.”
The case’s holding
State laws calculating damages for unfair labor practices by referencing fringe benefits do not relate to or regulate employee benefit plans under ERISA.
Later courts cite it for
“congress was not concerned, when it enacted erisa, with the multitude of problems surrounding employers who refused to bargain in good faith.” · 2 citing courts
cites § 1160.3 6×cited by 111 cases
Where it cites § 1160.3
“” The second issue requires us to examine the circumstances in which Labor Code section 1160.”
The case’s holding
An administrative board abuses its discretion by applying a blanket rule requiring make-whole relief whenever an employer refuses to bargain to obtain judicial review of an election certification.
Later courts cite it for
“eviscerated important alra policy and fundamentally misconstrued the nature of and legislative purpose behind such relief.” · 3 citing courts
cites § 1160.3 4×cited by 54 cases
Where it cites § 1160.3
“The essence of Dal Porto , drawn from Labor Code section 1160.3 and fortified by federal precedent under the National Labor Relations Act, on which California law is modeled ( Dal Porto, supra, 191 Cal.”
The case’s holding
An administrative mandamus action is a special proceeding that carries only issue-preclusive effect rather than claim-preclusive effect.
4
GREENAndrews v. Agric. Labor Relations Bd., 28 Cal. 3d 781 (1981).
cites § 1160.3 2×cited by 83 cases
Where it cites § 1160.3
“Indeed, the appearance of bias standard may be particularly untenable in certain administrative settings.”
The case’s holding
Disqualification of an administrative officer requires allegations of concrete facts demonstrating bias or prejudice, as mere perceptions of bias or erroneous rulings do not constitute grounds for removal.
Later courts cite it for
“numerous and continuous rulings against a litigant, even when erroneous, form no ground for a charge of bias or prejudice” · 5 citing courts
5
GREENJasmine Vineyards, Inc. v. Agric. Labor Relations Bd., 113 Cal. App. 3d 968 (Ct. App. 1980).
cites § 1160.3 4×cited by 18 cases
Where it cites § 1160.3
“) Although we might not agree wholeheartedly with the foregoing reasoning of the Board, we nonetheless conclude that it is grounded on policy considerations which are properly addressed to the Board and to the Legislature and not to the courts.”
6
GREENSandrini Bros. v. Agric. Labor Relations Bd., 156 Cal. App. 3d 878 (Ct. App. 1984).
cites § 1160.3 6×cited by 8 cases
Where it cites § 1160.3
“When it enacted the ALRA, the Legislature inserted language in Labor Code section 1160.”
cites § 1160.3 8×cited by 3 cases
Where it cites § 1160.3
“) Labor Code section 1160.3 provides in pertinent part that, if the Board finds an unfair labor practice, it "shall issue and cause to be served .”
8
GREENBabbitt Eng'g & Mach., Inc. v. Agric. Labor Relations Bd., 152 Cal. App. 3d 310 (Ct. App. 1984).
cites § 1160.3 6×cited by 4 cases
Where it cites § 1160.3
“2d 171, 173 ; Lab. Code, § 1160.3.) II. THE CALIFORNIA LAW The California Supreme Court in San Clemente Ranch, Ltd.”
cites § 1160.3 2×cited by 21 cases
Where it cites § 1160.3
“3 authorizes the board to impose the make-whole remedy when an employer refuses to bargain in order to obtain judicial review of the board's action dismissing a challenge to an election certification. Here we are asked to determine (1) whether the summary dismissal of some of…”
The case’s holding
An employer's refusal to bargain constitutes an unfair labor practice subject to make-whole relief unless the employer litigated in good faith that the union was not freely selected.
Later courts cite it for
“a decree issue enforcing the board's order in full.” · 1 citing court
10
GREENAbatti Farms, Inc. v. Agric. Labor Relations Bd., 107 Cal. App. 3d 317 (Ct. App. 1980).
cites § 1160.3 2×cited by 20 cases
Where it cites § 1160.3
“405-8) "On the other hand, another fact finder seeing and hearing the same witness may conclude that he is just too good a testifier, that he is an expert actor, and that he is also a liar.”
The case’s holding
Under the Board's special expertise, courts defer to its weighing of circumstantial evidence of discriminatory motive and its judgment whether employer statements are coercive in the labor election context.
Later courts cite it for
“because of its particular sensitivity to the effects of speech in the labor . . . context.” · 1 citing court
11
cites § 1160.3 1×cited by 9 cases
Where it cites § 1160.3
“The Board then ordered Tri-Fanucchi to pay make-whole relief under Labor Code section 1160.”
12
GREENTermo Co. v. Luther, 169 Cal. App. 4th 394 (Ct. App. 2008).
cites § 1160.3 1×cited by 17 cases
Where it cites § 1160.3
“*413 Finally, we note that Labor Code section 1160.3 requires that the ALRB make its decision based upon the preponderance of the testimony taken.”
13
GREENDuffy v. State Pers. Bd., 232 Cal. App. 3d 1 (Ct. App. 1991).
cites § 1160.3 2×cited by 11 cases
Where it cites § 1160.3
“206 ] [holding employers and labor organizations are not similarly situated in a review of the applicability of Lab. Code § 1160.”
Later courts cite it for
“the ... government has an obligation to, and through prison chaplaincies does, afford rea 874 sonable opportunities to inmates to exercise the religious freedom guaranteed by the first and fourteenth amendments.” · 1 citing court
14
GREENGeorge Arakelian Farms, Inc. v. Agric. Labor Relations Bd., 111 Cal. App. 3d 258 (Ct. App. 1980).
cites § 1160.3 2×cited by 11 cases
Where it cites § 1160.3
“(Lab. Code, § 1160.3.) "The responsibility for decision thus placed on the Board is wholly inconsistent with the notion that it has power to reverse an examiner's findings only when they are `clearly *281 erroneous.”
15
GREENM. B. Zaninovich, Inc. v. Agric. Labor Relations Bd., 114 Cal. App. 3d 665 (Ct. App. 1981).
cites § 1160.3 4×cited by 4 cases
Where it cites § 1160.3
“Labor Code section 1160.3 authorizes the board after it finds an unfair labor practice to have occurred, to issue a cease and desist order and to order the guilty party to take affirmative action "when the board deems such relief appropriate, .”
16
YELLOWDyna-Med, Inc. v. Fair Emp. & Hous. Comm'n, 43 Cal. 3d 1379 (1987).
cites § 1160.3 2×cited by 1,016 cases
Flagged on editorial review. Superseded by statute on another issue: 3 citing opinions limit it to another issue. As recognized in Escondido Union School District v. Casa Sueños De Oro, Inc.
Where it cites § 1160.3
“[10] Seeking to alleviate concern that a "flood of agencies" would arrogate to themselves similar authority, Commission states that only four other agencies have been granted comparable statutory authority to order actions that will effectuate the purposes of the acts they…”
The case’s holding
The meaning of a word is determined by its context within a clause through the canon of noscitur a sociis (explaining that a word's meaning is shaped by its surrounding clause).
Later courts cite it for
“statutes or statutory sections relating to the same subject must be harmonized, both internally and with each other, to the extent possible.” · 41 citing courts
17
GREENJ. R. Norton Co. v. Agric. Labor Relations Bd., 192 Cal. App. 3d 874 (Ct. App. 1987).
cites § 1160.3 2×cited by 10 cases
Where it cites § 1160.3
“3 which reads in relevant part: "If, upon the preponderance of the testimony taken, the board shall be of the opinion that any person named in the complaint has engaged in or is engaging in any such unfair labor practice, the board shall state its findings of fact and shall…”
18
GREENJackson & Perkins Co. v. Agric. Labor Relations Bd., 77 Cal. App. 3d 830 (Ct. App. 1978).
cites § 1160.3 2×cited by 10 cases
Where it cites § 1160.3
“1 The Legislature expressly gave the Board authority to reconsider its orders. Labor Code section 1160.”
19
GREENBertuccio v. Agric. Labor Relations Bd., 202 Cal. App. 3d 1369 (Ct. App. 1988).
cites § 1160.3 2×cited by 9 cases
Where it cites § 1160.3
“55, proper? (3) Must the makewhole order in any event be remanded to the Board for further proceedings under new procedural rules stated in Dal Porto //? The ALRA’s provision for “making employees whole, when the board deems such relief appropriate, for the loss of pay resulting…”
Later courts cite it for
“it is 'compensatory in that it reimburses employees for the losses they incur as a result of delays in the collective bargaining process.' at the same time 'it ... reduces the employer's financial incentive for refusing to bargain in order to avoid the expenses the employer would be required to pay if the employer had entered into a collective bargaining agreement.” · 2 citing courts
20
GREENButte View Farms v. Agric. Labor Relations Bd., 95 Cal. App. 3d 961 (Ct. App. 1979).
cites § 1160.3 1×cited by 24 cases
Where it cites § 1160.3
“In its exceptions to the supplemental decision of the administrative law officer, petitioner did not except to the revocation of the subpoena.”

Show all 34 citing cases (list view) →

The flag is Syfertize’s treatment of the citing case itself, not of the statute. “Where it cites” is the passage in the opinion; the holding is a summary of the whole case and may concern another point. Annotations are extracted automatically from the opinions in the Syfert caselaw corpus.

Citing cases by year
197820002023

One bar per year. Tallest: 4 cases in 1987. These are opinions in the Syfert collection, which holds more of some courts’ recent opinions than their older ones, so a rise can reflect what the collection holds and not more litigation.

By court
Cal. Ct. App.25Cal.79th Cir.2
By subsection

Courts have not cited this section by subsection, so its cases are not split up here. The Leading cases tab lists the cases that cite it most heavily.

Show all 34 citing cases (list view) →

Enactment and amendments

Syfert holds no separate history line for this section. Where this code prints a source or history note, it appears with the text, usually at the end.

Versions

Edition shown: leginfo export of Sept. 26, 2026 (applied Oct. 1, 2026). Syfert holds no earlier or later version of this section.

California Codes Home  |  Search California  |  Search cases for this section  |  syfert.com