ad hoc analysis in New York

7 New York opinions name it 2 courts 1920–2015 0 in the last five years

The cases below were cited by New York courts in a sentence that names this issue. Sides come from how each citing opinion treated the case (Syfertize flag on that citation), so a case can appear on both: that is where the law is contested. A red or yellow chip is the case's own overall treatment.

Followed or applied (3)

Case	Followed	Cited
People v. Morrisgreen ny · 1984 · cited in 2 New York opinions naming this issue, 1992–1993 2 sentences 1993Clearly, under these circumstances (plus others to be discussed infra), one cannot reasonably conclude that the prosecution exhibited less than due diligence in its investigation. 1 Given the People’s apparent due diligence in this case, Morris further instructs that the following circumstances should be considered in the ad hoc analysis to determine the reasonableness of the time period alleged in the indictment: (1) the length of the alleged time period in relation to the number of criminal acts alleged, (2) the passage of time between the alleged period of the crime and the defendant’s arre 1992Where time periods are alleged which are not so excessive on their face that they are unreasonable (see, People v Keindl, supra, at 419), an ad hoc analysis must be performed to determine whether the time periods alleged are sufficiently specific and hence, reasonable under the circumstances (see, People v Morris, supra).	1	2
Bard v. Jahnkegreen ny · 2006 · cited in 1 New York opinions naming this issue, 2015–2015 2 sentences 2015The prediction of the Bard dissenters that the decision had created "an archaic, rigid rule, contrary to fairness and common sense, that will probably be eroded by ad hoc exceptions" (Bard, 6 NY3d at 599 [R. 2015The prediction of the Bard dissenters that the decision had created “an archaic, rigid rule, contrary to fairness and common sense, that will probably be eroded by ad hoc exceptions” (Bard, 6 NY3d at 599 [R.S.	1	1
People v. Keindlgreen ny · 1986 · cited in 1 New York opinions naming this issue, 1992–1992 1 sentence 1992Where time periods are alleged which are not so excessive on their face that they are unreasonable (see, People v Keindl, supra, at 419), an ad hoc analysis must be performed to determine whether the time periods alleged are sufficiently specific and hence, reasonable under the circumstances (see, People v Morris, supra).	1	1

Distinguished, questioned or overruled (0)

Case	Negative	Cited
No negative-treatment citations attached to this issue in New York. Read the followed side critically anyway.

Also cited on this issue (6)

Case	Cited	Years
Bartolomeo v. Charles Bennett Contracting Co. green ny · 1927 2 sentences 1952Co., 245 N. Y. 66; Ramsey v. New York Central R. 1935This court, in Wyllie v. Palmer ( 137 N. Y. 248, 257 ), quoted with approval from Shearman and Redfield on The Law of Negligence as follows: “ He is to be deemed the master who has the supreme choice, control and direction of the servant, and whose will the servant represents, not merely in the ultimate result of his work but in all its details.” (Cf. Cannon v. Fargo, 222 N. Y. 321 ; McNamara v. Leipzig, 227 N. Y. 291 ; Bartolomeo v. Bennett Contracting Co., 245 N. Y. 66 .) The ad hoc principle has been applied in many cases by this court.	2	1935–1952
Cannon v. . Fargo green · 1918 2 sentences 1935This court, in Wyllie v. Palmer ( 137 N. Y. 248, 257 ), quoted with approval from Shearman and Redfield on The Law of Negligence as follows: “ He is to be deemed the master who has the supreme choice, control and direction of the servant, and whose will the servant represents, not merely in the ultimate result of his work but in all its details.” (Cf. Cannon v. Fargo, 222 N. Y. 321 ; McNamara v. Leipzig, 227 N. Y. 291 ; Bartolomeo v. Bennett Contracting Co., 245 N. Y. 66 .) The ad hoc principle has been applied in many cases by this court. 1920We have no such statute in this state and unless the employee hired out to another becomes his employee under the ad hoc doctrine (Cannon v. Fargo, 222 N. Y. 321 ) the Workmen’s Compensation Law only applies to the general employer.	2	1920–1935
Hodel v. Irving green scotus · 1987 2 sentences 1994Thus, in Hodel v Irving ( 481 US 704 ), Justice O'Connor characterized the Penn Cent. approach as a "framework for examining the question whether a regulation of property amounts to a taking requiring just compensation [which] is firmly established and has been regularly and recently reaffirmed" ( id. , at 713-714). 1994Thus, in Hodel v Irving ( 481 US 704 ), Justice O'Connor characterized the Penn Cent. approach as a "framework for examining the question whether a regulation of property amounts to a taking requiring just compensation [which] is firmly established and has been regularly and recently reaffirmed" ( id. , at 713-714).	1	1994–1994
People v. Beauchamp green ny · 1989 1 sentence 1992The law, as stated by our Court of Appeals, is that time allegations of nine months are too long (People v Beauchamp, supra) and that time allegations which are not so long as to render an indictment facially defective are subject to an ad hoc analysis to determine the reasonableness thereof (People v Morris, supra).	1	1992–1992
McNamara v. . Leipzig green ny · 1919 1 sentence 1935This court, in Wyllie v. Palmer ( 137 N. Y. 248, 257 ), quoted with approval from Shearman and Redfield on The Law of Negligence as follows: “ He is to be deemed the master who has the supreme choice, control and direction of the servant, and whose will the servant represents, not merely in the ultimate result of his work but in all its details.” (Cf. Cannon v. Fargo, 222 N. Y. 321 ; McNamara v. Leipzig, 227 N. Y. 291 ; Bartolomeo v. Bennett Contracting Co., 245 N. Y. 66 .) The ad hoc principle has been applied in many cases by this court.	1	1935–1935
Wyllie v. . Palmer green ny · 1893 1 sentence 1935This court, in Wyllie v. Palmer ( 137 N. Y. 248, 257 ), quoted with approval from Shearman and Redfield on The Law of Negligence as follows: “ He is to be deemed the master who has the supreme choice, control and direction of the servant, and whose will the servant represents, not merely in the ultimate result of his work but in all its details.” (Cf. Cannon v. Fargo, 222 N. Y. 321 ; McNamara v. Leipzig, 227 N. Y. 291 ; Bartolomeo v. Bennett Contracting Co., 245 N. Y. 66 .) The ad hoc principle has been applied in many cases by this court.	1	1935–1935

Where else courts name it

TX 25 (1994–2025) CA 9 (1989–2021) CO 8 (1980–2025) NY 7 (1920–2015) AR 6 (2009–2021) OH 5 (1998–2006) ID 5 (1983–2019) TN 4 (1975–2018) FL 4 (2014–2021) MI 4 (1980–2020) UT 3 (1994–2022) NM 3 (2014–2014) MN 3 (1986–2014) ME 3 (1975–2019) DC 2 (1976–2011) WA 2 (1973–2018) KY 2 (2013–2017) CT 2 (1979–1986) OR 2 (1986–1995) IA 2 (1992–2026) NC 2 (1997–2006)

Opinions by the citing court's state. A doctrine retained in one state and abandoned in another shows up here as a year span that stalls.

← Caselaw search · G Cite Topics · Brief Check