C.F.R. homeSearch C.F.R.
C.F.R.Title 47Chapter I—Federal Communications CommissionSubchapter B—Common Carrier ServicesPart 51—InterconnectionSubpart D—Additional Obligations of Incumbent Local Exchange Carriers

47 C.F.R. § 51.317 (2026)

Standards for requiring the unbundling of network elements

Edition and currency
eCFR text as of Sept. 29, 2026. The text is the edition Syfert holds; for a past event, check the version in force on that date.
Other sources
CURRENTeCFR text as of Sept. 29, 2026 cited 1997–2010 17citing cases
At a glance

Courts have cited this section in 17 opinions since 1997. The most litigated part is subsection (b)(2) (2 cases).

(a) Proprietary network elements. A network element shall be considered to be proprietary if an incumbent LEC can demonstrate that it has invested resources to develop proprietary information or functionalities that are protected by patent, copyright or trade secret law. The Commission shall undertake the following analysis to determine whether a proprietary network element should be made available for purposes of section 251(c)(3) of the Act:

(1) Determine whether access to the proprietary network element is “necessary.” A network element is “necessary” if, taking into consideration the availability of alternative elements outside the incumbent LEC's network, including self-provisioning by a requesting telecommunications carrier or acquiring an alternative from a third-party supplier, lack of access to the network element precludes a requesting telecommunications carrier from providing the services that it seeks to offer. If access is “necessary,” the Commission may require the unbundling of such proprietary network element.

(2) In the event that such access is not “necessary,” the Commission may require unbundling if it is determined that:

(i) The incumbent LEC has implemented only a minor modification to the network element in order to qualify for proprietary treatment;

(ii) The information or functionality that is proprietary in nature does not differentiate the incumbent LEC's services from the requesting telecommunications carrier's services; or

(iii) Lack of access to such element would jeopardize the goals of the Act.

(b) Non-proprietary network elements. The Commission shall determine whether a non-proprietary network element should be made available for purposes of section 251(c)(3) of the Act by analyzing, at a minimum, whether lack of access to a non-proprietary network element “impairs” a requesting carrier's ability to provide the service it seeks to offer. A requesting carrier's ability to provide service is “impaired” if, taking into consideration the availability of alternative elements outside the incumbent LEC's network, including elements self-provisioned by the requesting carrier or acquired as an alternative from a third-party supplier, lack of access to that element poses a barrier or barriers to entry, including operational and economic barriers, that are likely to make entry into a market by a reasonably efficient competitor uneconomic.

[70 FR 8952, Feb. 24, 2005]
The 17 cases that cite 47 C.F.R. § 51.317 most heavily, weighted by court and treatment. RelevanceNewestTreatment
1
GREENMCI Telecomm. Corp. v. GTE Nw., Inc., 41 F. Supp. 2d 1157 (D. Or. 1999).
cites § 51.317 2×cited by 28 cases
Where it cites § 51.317
“319 (“Rule 319”) and, by implication, 47 C.F.R. § 51.317 as well. AT & T, — U.S.”
The case’s holding
Substantive regulations stayed before taking effect and later vacated cannot be applied retroactively to an agreement approved while those regulations were not in force.
Later courts cite it for
“perceived a crucial distinction between applying a new interpretation of a law that admittedly was in effect during the relevant time period, versus applying a substantive regulation that never was in effect to begin with.” · 3 citing courts
2
REDUnited States Telecom Ass'n v. Fed. Commc'ns Comm'n, 290 F.3d 415 (D.C. Cir. 2002).
cites § 51.317 4×cited by 20 cases
Reversed by National Cable & Telecommunications Assn. v. Brand X Internet Services (2005): the U.S. Supreme Court's own opinion in this case.
Where it cites § 51.317
“” Local Competition Order, 15 FCC Rcd at 3725, ¶ 51 (emphasis added); 47 C.F.R. § 51.317 (b)(1). In weighing the availability of alternative network elements, the Commission noted that it would examine five factors — cost, effect on timeliness of entry, quality, ubiquity, and…”
Later courts cite it for
“if parties who have not shared the risks are able to come in as equal partners on the successes, and avoid payment for the losers, the incentive to invest plainly declines.” · 2 citing courts
3
GREENIowa Utils. Bd. v. Fed. Commc'ns Comm'n, 120 F.3d 753 (8th Cir. 1997).
cites § 51.317 3×cited by 139 cases
Where it cites § 51.317
“, ¶ 281 ; 47 C.F.R. § 51.317 . Although we just upheld the Commission’s definition of the term “technically feasible,” we reject the Commission’s use of this term to determine what elements must be unbundled.”
cites § 51.317 1×cited by 59 cases
Reversed in part by the U.S. Supreme Court in this case: Verizon Communications Inc. v. Federal Communications Commission (2002).
Where it cites § 51.317
“The petitioners also request that the court vacate 47 C.F.R. § 51.317 , regarding the identification of additional unbundled network elements, and that the court reaffirm its previous decision vacating the superior-quality rules and the additional combination of network elements…”
The case’s holding
Wholesale rates for network elements must be based on the actual cost of providing existing facilities rather than the cost of a hypothetical efficient network.
Later courts cite it for
“based on the cost ... of providing the interconnection or network element,” · 2 citing courts
5
cites § 51.317 5×cited by 11 cases
Where it cites § 51.317
“§§ 251 (d) (3) and 253; 47 C.F.R. § 51.317 (2001). *18 Like the Connecticut reform scheme, the 1996 federal act contains a provision to enable new market entrants to gain access to an incumbent carrier’s facilities in order to offer competition in local telephone service.”
6
GREENPac. Bell Tel. Co. v. California Pub. Utils. Comm'n, 621 F.3d 836 (9th Cir. 2010).
cites § 51.317 1×cited by 14 cases
Where it cites § 51.317
“” 47 C.F.R. § 51.317 (b). 10 . Under the Hobbs Act, this court lacks jurisdiction to rule on a collateral attack of an FCC order.”
7
GREENMCI v. Bell Atl., 36 F. Supp. 2d 419 (D.D.C. 1999).
cites § 51.317 2×cited by 8 cases
Where it cites § 51.317
“See 47 C.F.R. § 51.317 (1997). 1. Dark Fiber In the proceeding below, the Arbitrator held that BA-DC is not obligated to supply MCI with access to its “dark fiber” on an unbundled basis.”
Later courts cite it for
“a market entrant must demonstrate something more than a minor decrease in quality or rise in costs” · 2 citing courts
8
GREENMCI Telecomm. Corp. v. Michigan Bell Tel. Co., 79 F. Supp. 2d 768 (E.D. Mich. 1999).
cites § 51.317 1×cited by 23 cases
Where it cites § 51.317
“47 C.F.R. § 51.317 . Here, the Arbitration Panel concluded that Ameritech must provide MCI access to its dark fiber, holding as follows: Under FCC Order ¶ 281, there is a presumption in favor of unbundling if it is technically feasible.”
Later courts cite it for
“a court can uphold the state commission's decision only on the grounds set forth in the decision.” · 2 citing courts
9
REDAt & T Commc'ns of the Sw., Inc. v. Sw. Bell Tel. Co., 86 F. Supp. 2d 932 (W.D. Mo. 1999).
cites § 51.317 1×cited by 10 cases
Reversed by Southwestern Bell Telephone Company v. Missouri Public Service Commission Sheila A. Lumpe M. Dianne Drainer, Vice-Chair Harold Crumpton, Commissioner Robert Schemenauer, Commissioner Connie Murray, Commissioner, All t…
Where it cites § 51.317
“47 C.F.R. § 51.317 (b). 16 In this way, § 51.”
10
GREENPac. Bell Tel. Co. v. California Pub. Utils. Comm'n, 597 F.3d 958 (9th Cir. 2010).
cites § 51.317 1×cited by 3 cases
Where it cites § 51.317
“” 47 C.F.R. § 51.317 (b). 10 . Under the Hobbs Act, this court lacks jurisdiction to rule on a collateral attack of an FCC order.”
11
GREENUS West Commc'ns, Inc. v. Jennings, 304 F.3d 950 (9th Cir. 2002).
cites § 51.317 1×cited by 5 cases
Where it cites § 51.317
“707, holding that setting specific prices intrudes on the states’ right to set the actual rates pursuant to § 252(c)(2) and that the FCC was estopped from arguing otherwise; (4) vacated 47 C.F.R. § 51.317 (establishing standards under which an ILEC must unbundle or make…”
Later courts cite it for
“properly promulgated fcc regulations currently in effect must be presumed valid” · 4 citing courts
12
cites § 51.317 1×cited by 2 cases
Where it cites § 51.317
“319 (“Rule 319”) and, by implication, 47 C.F.R. § 51.317 as well. AT & T, 119 S.”
cites § 51.317 2×subsections: (b)(2) 2×cited by 2 cases
Where it cites § 51.317
“See 47 C.F.R. 51.317(b)(2) (1997). MCI wants to lease Bell Atlantic’s dark fiber, splice in its own electronics, and then deploy its own network technology and design.”
14
GREENAt&t Commc'ns of Virginia, Inc., & MCI Telecomm. Corp., a Delaware Corp. McImetro Access Transmission Servs. of Virginia, Inc., a Virginia Corp. v. Bell Atl.-Virginia, Inc. Hullihen Williams Moore, in His Off. Capacity as Comm'r of the Commonwealth of Virginia State Corp. Comm'n I. Clinton Miller, in His Off. Capacity as Comm'r of the Commonwealth of Virginia State Corp. Comm'n Theodore v. Morrison, Jr., in His Off. Capacity as Comm'r of the Commonwealth of Virginia State Corp. Comm'n State Corp. Comm'n, Commonwealth of Virginia, & Richard Cullen, Attorney Gen. of Virginia, Intervenor-Defendant, & Fed. Commc'ns Comm'n, Party in Interest. MCI Telecomm. Corp., a Delaware Corp. McImetro Access Transmission Servs. of Virginia, Inc., a Virginia Corp., & At&t Commc'ns of Virginia, Inc., Intervenor-Plaintiff v. Bell Atl.-Virginia, Inc. Hullihen Williams Moore, in His Off. Capacity as Comm'r of the Commonwealth of Virginia State Corp. Comm'n I. Clinton Miller, in His Off. Capacity as Comm'r of the Commonwealth of Virginia State Corp. Comm'n Theodore v. Morrison, Jr., in His Off. Capacity as Comm'r of the Commonwealth of Virginia State Corp. Comm'n State Corp. Comm'n, Commonwealth of Virginia, & Richard Cullen, Attorney Gen. of Virginia, Intervenor-Defendant, & Fed. Commc'ns Comm'n, Party in Interest. MCI Telecomm. Corp., a Delaware Corp. McImetro Access Transmission Servs. of Virginia, Inc., a Virginia Corp. At&t Commc'ns of Virginia, Inc. v. Bell Atl.-Virginia, Inc., & Hullihen Williams Moore, in His Off. Capacity as Comm'r of the Commonwealth of Virginia State Corp. Comm'n I. Clinton Miller, in His Off. Capacity as Comm'r of the Commonwealth of Virginia State Corp. Comm'n Theodore v. Morrison, Jr., in His Off. Capacity as Comm'r of the Commonwealth of Virginia State Corp. Comm'n State Corp. Comm'n, Commonwealth of Virginia, & Richard Cullen, Attorney Gen. of Virginia, Intervenor-Defendant, & Fed. Commc'ns Comm'n, Party in Interest, 197 F.3d 663 (4th Cir. 1999).
cites § 51.317 2×subsections: (b)(2) 2×cited by 0 cases
Where it cites § 51.317
“See 47 C.F.R. 51.317(b)(2) (1997). MCI wants to lease Bell Atlantic's dark fiber, splice in its own electronics, and then deploy its own network technology and design.”
15
NO FLAGPac. Bell Tel. Co. v. Cpuc, No. 08-15568 (9th Cir. Mar. 4, 2010).
cites § 51.317 1×cited by 0 cases
Where it cites § 51.317
“Peevey, native elements outside the incumbent LEC’s network, including elements self-provisioned by the requesting carrier or acquired as an alternative from a third-party supplier, lack of access to that element poses a barrier or barriers to entry, including operational and…”
16
NEUTRALVerizon, N.E. v. NH PUC, 2006 DNH 094 (D.N.H. 2006).
cites § 51.317 1×cited by 0 cases
Where it cites § 51.317
“§ 251 (d)(2); 47 C.F.R. § 51.317 . Section 252 of the Act sets forth the processes through which CLECs can connect to an ILEC's network through interconnection agreements.”
17
REDIowa Utils. Bd. v. FCC, No. 96-3321 (8th Cir. July 18, 2000).
cites § 51.317 1×cited by 0 cases
Where it cites § 51.317
“The petitioners also request that the court vacate 47 C.F.R. § 51.317 , regarding the identification of additional unbundled network elements, and that the court reaffirm its previous decision vacating the superior-quality rules and the additional combination of network elements…”

The flag is Syfertize’s treatment of the citing case itself, not of the statute. “Where it cites” is the passage in the opinion; the holding is a summary of the whole case and may concern another point. Annotations are extracted automatically from the opinions in the Syfert caselaw corpus.

Citing cases by year
199720032010

One bar per year. Tallest: 7 cases in 1999. These are opinions in the Syfert collection, which holds more of some courts’ recent opinions than their older ones, so a rise can reflect what the collection holds and not more litigation.

By court
9th Cir.48th Cir.34th Cir.2D. Or.2D.C. Cir.1Conn.1D.D.C.1E.D. Mich.1

The 8 courts with the most citing cases, of 10 courts in all.

By subsection
(b)(2)2 cases
At&T Commc'ns of Virginia, Inc. v. Bell Atl.-Virginia, Inc., 197 F.3d 663 (4th Cir. 1999).“See 47 C.F.R. 51.317(b)(2) (1997). MCI wants to lease Bell Atlantic’s dark fiber, splice in its own electronics, and then deploy its own network technology and design.”
At&t Commc'ns of Virginia, Inc., & MCI Telecomm. Corp., a Delaware Corp. McImetro Access Transmission Servs. of Virginia, Inc., a Virginia Corp. v. Bell Atl.-Virginia, Inc. Hullihen Williams Moore, in His Off. Capacity as Comm'r of the Commonwealth of Virginia State Corp. Comm'n I. Clinton Miller, in His Off. Capacity as Comm'r of the Commonwealth of Virginia State Corp. Comm'n Theodore v. Morrison, Jr., in His Off. Capacity as Comm'r of the Commonwealth of Virginia State Corp. Comm'n State Corp. Comm'n, Commonwealth of Virginia, & Richard Cullen, Attorney Gen. of Virginia, Intervenor-Defendant, & Fed. Commc'ns Comm'n, Party in Interest. MCI Telecomm. Corp., a Delaware Corp. McImetro Access Transmission Servs. of Virginia, Inc., a Virginia Corp., & At&t Commc'ns of Virginia, Inc., Intervenor-Plaintiff v. Bell Atl.-Virginia, Inc. Hullihen Williams Moore, in His Off. Capacity as Comm'r of the Commonwealth of Virginia State Corp. Comm'n I. Clinton Miller, in His Off. Capacity as Comm'r of the Commonwealth of Virginia State Corp. Comm'n Theodore v. Morrison, Jr., in His Off. Capacity as Comm'r of the Commonwealth of Virginia State Corp. Comm'n State Corp. Comm'n, Commonwealth of Virginia, & Richard Cullen, Attorney Gen. of Virginia, Intervenor-Defendant, & Fed. Commc'ns Comm'n, Party in Interest. MCI Telecomm. Corp., a Delaware Corp. McImetro Access Transmission Servs. of Virginia, Inc., a Virginia Corp. At&t Commc'ns of Virginia, Inc. v. Bell Atl.-Virginia, Inc., & Hullihen Williams Moore, in His Off. Capacity as Comm'r of the Commonwealth of Virginia State Corp. Comm'n I. Clinton Miller, in His Off. Capacity as Comm'r of the Commonwealth of Virginia State Corp. Comm'n Theodore v. Morrison, Jr., in His Off. Capacity as Comm'r of the Commonwealth of Virginia State Corp. Comm'n State Corp. Comm'n, Commonwealth of Virginia, & Richard Cullen, Attorney Gen. of Virginia, Intervenor-Defendant, & Fed. Commc'ns Comm'n, Party in Interest, 197 F.3d 663 (4th Cir. 1999).“See 47 C.F.R. 51.317(b)(2) (1997). MCI wants to lease Bell Atlantic's dark fiber, splice in its own electronics, and then deploy its own network technology and design.”
Enactment and amendments

Syfert holds no separate history line for this section. Where this code prints a source or history note, it appears with the text, usually at the end.

Versions

Edition shown: eCFR text as of Sept. 29, 2026. Syfert holds no earlier or later version of this section.

C.F.R. Home  |  Search C.F.R.  |  Search cases for this section  |  syfert.com