Idaho Code homeSearch Idaho

Idaho Code § 72-732 (2026)

Disposition of appeal — Jurisdiction of Supreme Court. 

Edition and currency
text as last checked Oct. 2026 (this copy records no edition or section history). The text is the edition Syfert holds; for a past event, check the version in force on that date.
Other sources
CURRENTtext as last checked Oct. 2026 (this copy records no edition or section history) cited 1972–2026 177citing cases
At a glance

Courts have cited this section in 177 opinions since 1972, 7 of them in the last five years. The most litigated part is subsection (1) (45 cases).

Disposition of appeal — Jurisdiction of Supreme Court. 

Upon hearing the court may affirm or set aside such order or award, or may set it aside only upon any of the following grounds:

(1)  The commission’s findings of fact are not based on any substantial competent evidence;
(2)  The commission has acted without jurisdiction or in excess of its powers;
(3)  The findings of fact, order or award were procured by fraud;
(4)  The findings of fact do not as a matter of law support the order or award.
The 20 cases that cite Idaho Code § 72-732 most heavily, weighted by court and treatment. RelevanceNewestTreatment
1
GREENShriner v. Rausch, 108 P.3d 375 (Idaho 2005).
cites § 72-732 12×cited by 18 cases
Where it cites § 72-732
“Standard of Review The standard of review to be applied by this Court in reviewing an appeal from a decision of the Industrial Commission is set forth in Idaho Code § 72-732 . I.C. § 72-732 provides that: Upon hearing the court may affirm or set aside such order or award, or may…”
The case’s holding
A sole proprietor independent contractor is not eligible for worker’s compensation benefits from the entity that contracted him (basis).
Later courts cite it for
“coverage under idaho's workers' compensation laws depends on the existence of an employer-employee relationship,” · 2 citing courts
2
GREENGraham v. Larry Donohoe Logging, 654 P.2d 1377 (Idaho 1982).
cites § 72-732 12×subsections: (1) 8×cited by 29 cases
Where it cites § 72-732
“I.C. § 72-732. We are not concerned with whether this *1379 Court would have reached the same conclusion, but rather, with whether the findings by the Commission are supported by substantial, competent evidence.”
The case’s holding
Appellate review of Industrial Commission findings is limited to determining whether those findings are supported by substantial, competent evidence.
Later courts cite it for
“does not entail a de novo determination of fact.” · 1 citing court
3
GREENJenkins v. Agri-Lines Corp., 602 P.2d 47 (Idaho 1979).
cites § 72-732 12×cited by 24 cases
Where it cites § 72-732
“(e) His unemployment is not due to the fact that he left his employment voluntarily without good cause, or that he was discharged for misconduct in connection with his employment. This court's review in unemployment cases on appeal from the Industrial Commission is limited to…”
The case’s holding
Failing to properly notify an employer of an intended absence, in disregard of expected standards of conduct, can constitute misconduct disqualifying a discharged employee from unemployment benefits.
4
GREENOlvera v. Del's Auto Body, 795 P.2d 862 (Idaho 1990).
cites § 72-732 12×cited by 22 cases
Where it cites § 72-732
“Olvera testified before the Commission that he was never advised that he was an independent contractor and that no worker's compensation benefits would be available.”
The case’s holding
Under Idaho's right-to-control test, a worker may be found an independent contractor where payment, tax treatment, equipment, and staffing show the employer did not control the time, manner, and method of work.
5
GREENNeufeld v. Browning Ferris Indus., 712 P.2d 600 (Idaho 1985).
cites § 72-732 8×subsections: (1) 4×cited by 35 cases
Where it cites § 72-732
“Before reviewing the evidence that the commission relied on in reaching its decision, we note the limited scope of our review.”
The case’s holding
A workers' compensation claimant must prove a probable connection between the injury and an unexpected mishap in the course of employment to establish a compensable accident.
6
GREENHorner v. Ponderosa Pine Logging, 695 P.2d 1250 (Idaho 1985).
cites § 72-732 8×cited by 23 cases
Where it cites § 72-732
“5, § 9; I.C. § 72-732. That determination is raised by claimant's second issue and is found in Part II of this opinion.”
Later courts cite it for
“in idaho, as in most states, there is a presumption of regularity in the performance of official duties by public officers.” · 4 citing courts
7
GREENCombs v. Kelly Logging, 769 P.2d 572 (Idaho 1989).
cites § 72-732 8×subsections: (1) 4×cited by 22 cases
Where it cites § 72-732
“5 § 9; I.C. § 72-732. However, we are not bound by conclusions of law drawn by the Commission; an order of the Commission must be set aside where the law is misapplied to the evidence.”
The case’s holding
An injured worker need not move from home to find suitable work, so the reasonable geographic area for assessing permanent disability is measured from the worker's home.
Later courts cite it for
“it is well established, even without legislative statutory direction, that a worker who sustains an industrial accident is not required to move from his or her home to find suitable work in order to be eligible for worker's compensation.” · 1 citing court
8
GREENBint v. Creative Forest Prods., 697 P.2d 818 (Idaho 1985).
cites § 72-732 8×subsections: (1) 4×cited by 21 cases
Where it cites § 72-732
“Rather, the real concern lies in the fact that an occupational *824 disease which disabled two workmen in less than sixty working days each was determined to be "non-acute" and therefore non-compensable under I.C. § 72-439. If the result in this case is wrong, the wrongness…”
Later courts cite it for
“under the 'rational basis test,' a classification will withstand an equal protection challenge if there is any conceivable state of facts which will support it.” · 2 citing courts
9
GREENRoberts v. Kit Mfg. Co., 866 P.2d 969 (Idaho 1993).
cites § 72-732 8×subsections: (1) 4×cited by 20 cases
Where it cites § 72-732
“V, § 9 and Idaho Code § 72-732 , the decisions made by the referees and the Commission are of critical importance to injured employees and their families.”
The case’s holding
A workers' compensation claimant must prove a probable, not merely possible, causal link between the injury and employment; a qualified medical opinion may be discounted.
10
GREENMortimer v. Riviera Apts., 840 P.2d 383 (Idaho 1992).
cites § 72-732 8×cited by 19 cases
Where it cites § 72-732
“(One might query: Who does the attorney for the Riviera Apartments represent, if not the owners thereof? And if the Riviera Apartments do not exist as an independent legal entity, how does it have standing to pursue or resist an appellate proceeding?) Idaho Code § 72-732 (4)…”
The case’s holding
An interlocutory commission order that leaves unresolved issues in a case is not a final appealable order.
Later courts cite it for
“contravene our policy of avoiding piecemeal litigation.” · 3 citing courts
11
GREENDallas Clark v. Shari's Mgmt. Corp, 314 P.3d 631 (Idaho 2013).
cites § 72-732 4×cited by 26 cases
Where it cites § 72-732
“I.C. § 72-732; Neihart v. Universal Joint Auto Parts, Inc.”
The case’s holding
A workers' compensation claim fails if the claimant's testimony lacks substantive credibility due to material inconsistencies regarding the occurrence of an industrial accident.
Later courts cite it for
“i.c. 12-121, does not apply to this appeal because worker's compensation cases are not civil actions.” · 2 citing courts
12
GREENStevens-McAtee v. Potlatch Corp., 179 P.3d 288 (Idaho 2008).
cites § 72-732 4×cited by 25 cases
Where it cites § 72-732
“I.C. § 72-732; Neihart v. Universal Joint Auto Parts, Inc.”
The case’s holding
An injury resulting from the vibrations and jostling of heavy machinery during normal work duties constitutes a compensable accident under workers' compensation law.
Later courts cite it for
“credibility of witnesses and evidence is a matter within the province of the commission.” · 3 citing courts
13
GREENBaldner v. Bennett's, Inc., 649 P.2d 1214 (Idaho 1982).
cites § 72-732 4×cited by 58 cases
Where it cites § 72-732
“I.C. § 72-732. Defendants-respondents finally assert that the Commission erred in its determination of Baldner's total annual pre-injury wages by including therein those earnings from part-time employment, i.”
The case’s holding
Appellate courts will not consider or review issues that were not raised in the lower court.
Later courts cite it for
“ijssues not raised below and presented for the first time on appeal will not be considered or reviewed.” · 1 citing court
14
YELLOWPaulson v. Idaho Forest Indus., Inc., 591 P.2d 143 (Idaho 1979).
cites § 72-732 4×subsections: (1) 4×cited by 54 cases
Overruled by Jones v. Emmett Manor on other grounds: 3 citing opinions limit it to other grounds.
Where it cites § 72-732
“2d 775 (1975); I.C. § 72-732(1). I The commission's finding that Paulson's work related injuries caused his hysterical neurosis is supported by substantial competent evidence.”
The case’s holding
Medical testimony sufficiently establishes causation if it plainly and unequivocally conveys a conviction that events are causally related without requiring a specific verbal formula.
Later courts cite it for
“no special verbal formula is necessary when, as here, a doctor's testimony plainly and unequivocally conveys his conviction that events are causally related.” · 1 citing court
15
GREENHarris v. Elec. Wholesale, 105 P.3d 267 (Idaho 2004).
cites § 72-732 4×cited by 20 cases
The case’s holding
An employer's expectation is not objectively reasonable for misconduct purposes unless the employer specifically communicates that personal conduct will trigger discharge for violating insurability policies.
Later courts cite it for
“must be sustained regardless of whether this court may have reached a different conclusion.” · 3 citing courts
16
GREENFunes v. Aardema Dairy, 244 P.3d 151 (Idaho 2010).
cites § 72-732 4×cited by 19 cases
Where it cites § 72-732
“Idaho Code § 72-732 provides that this Court may only overturn a decision of the Industrial Commission where: (1) The commission’s findings of fact are not based on any substantial competent evidence; (2) The commission has acted without jurisdiction or in excess of its powers;…”
Later courts cite it for
“bear responsibility for the legal arguments advanced on its behalf.” · 1 citing court
17
GREENGordon v. West, 645 P.2d 334 (Idaho 1982).
cites § 72-732 4×cited by 41 cases
Where it cites § 72-732
“The crucial issue on appeal in this case is whether there was substantial competent evidence to sustain the commission's finding that after December 24, 1977, claimant's permanent disability caused by the 1977 accident did not exceed his permanent impairment rating of 15% of the…”
The case’s holding
A claimant must establish a prima facie case of odd lot status by proving the unavailability of suitable work in any occupation rather than just the inability to perform previous duties.
Later courts cite it for
“to prove the unavailability of suitable work in attempting to establish his alleged total disability,” · 3 citing courts
18
GREENMcNulty v. Sinclair Oil Corp., 272 P.3d 554 (Idaho 2012).
cites § 72-732 4×cited by 15 cases
Where it cites § 72-732
“This Court may affirm an order or award made by the Commission, “or may set it aside only upon the following grounds: (1) the commission’s findings of fact are not based on any substantial competent evidence; (2) the commission has acted without jurisdiction or in excess of its…”
The case’s holding
A fact is material if it is relevant to the determination of a claimant's right to benefits, regardless of whether the fact affects the final outcome.
Later courts cite it for
“a claimant shall not be entitled to benefits for a period of fifty-two (52) weeks if it is determined that she has willfully made a false statement or willfully failed to report a material fact in order to obtain benefits.” · 2 citing courts
19
GREENLangley v. State, Indus. Special Indem. Fund, 890 P.2d 732 (Idaho 1995).
cites § 72-732 4×subsections: (1) 2×cited by 34 cases
Where it cites § 72-732
“ANALYSIS When reviewing Industrial Commission decisions on appeal, this Court reviews questions of fact only to determine if there is substantial and competent evidence to support the findings of the Commission, but exercises free review over questions of law.”
The case’s holding
A claimant fails to prove a compensable industrial accident or state fund liability without medical evidence linking the injury to a specific mishap and proof that preexisting impairments hindered employment.
20
GREENJimmy Christy Jr v. Grasmick Produce, 395 P.3d 819 (Idaho 2017).
cites § 72-732 4×cited by 6 cases
Where it cites § 72-732
“3d 750, 753 (2011) (citing I.C. § 72-732). The Court exercises free review over questions of law.”
Later courts cite it for
“this court has explained that the term willful as used in section 72-1366(12) does not mean that someone has acted maliciously or with what the law calls an 'evil mind.” · 2 citing courts

Show all 177 citing cases (list view) →

The flag is Syfertize’s treatment of the citing case itself, not of the statute. “Where it cites” is the passage in the opinion; the holding is a summary of the whole case and may concern another point. Annotations are extracted automatically from the opinions in the Syfert caselaw corpus.

Citing cases by year
197219992026

One bar per year. Tallest: 9 cases in 1985. 2026 is a partial year. These are opinions in the Syfert collection, which holds more of some courts’ recent opinions than their older ones, so a rise can reflect what the collection holds and not more litigation.

By subsection
(1)45 cases
Graham v. Larry Donohoe Logging, 654 P.2d 1377 (Idaho 1982).“I.C. § 72-732. We are not concerned with whether this *1379 Court would have reached the same conclusion, but rather, with whether the findings by the Commission are supported by substantial, competent evidence.”
Paulson v. Idaho Forest Indus., Inc., 591 P.2d 143 (Idaho 1979).“2d 775 (1975); I.C. § 72-732(1). I The commission's finding that Paulson's work related injuries caused his hysterical neurosis is supported by substantial competent evidence.”
Neufeld v. Browning Ferris Indus., 712 P.2d 600 (Idaho 1985).“Before reviewing the evidence that the commission relied on in reaching its decision, we note the limited scope of our review.”
Sykes v. C. P. Clare & Co., 605 P.2d 939 (Idaho 1980).
Lopez v. Amalgamated Sugar Co., 691 P.2d 1205 (Idaho 1984).
Showing the top 5 of 45. More in the list view →
(2)4 cases
Curtis v. M.H. King Co., 128 P.3d 920 (Idaho 2005).
Kessler ex rel. Kessler v. Payette Cnty., 934 P.2d 28 (Idaho 1997).
Coronado v. City of Boise, No. 51722 (Idaho Nov. 14, 2025).
Coronado v. City of Boise, No. 51722 (Idaho Nov. 24, 2025).
(4)13 cases
O'Loughlin v. Circle a Constr., 739 P.2d 347 (Idaho 1987).
Aguilar v. State, 436 P.3d 1242 (Idaho 2019).
Hope v. Indus. Special Indem. Fund, 338 P.3d 546 (Idaho 2014).
Dinius v. Loving Care & More, Inc., 990 P.2d 738 (Idaho 1999).
Ford v. Bonner Cnty. Sch. Dist., 612 P.2d 557 (Idaho 1980).
Showing the top 5 of 13. More in the list view →

Show all 177 citing cases (list view) →

Enactment and amendments

Syfert holds no separate history line for this section. Where this code prints a source or history note, it appears with the text, usually at the end.

Versions

Edition shown: text as last checked Oct. 2026 (this copy records no edition or section history). Syfert holds no earlier or later version of this section.

Idaho Code Home  |  Search Idaho  |  Search cases for this section  |  syfert.com