No positions above the rank of patrol officer in the police department shall be filled by original appointment. Vacancies in positions above the rank of patrol officer in a police department shall be filled by promotion from among persons holding positions in a rank lower than the position to be filled. No position above the rank of patrol officer in a police department shall be filled by any person unless the person has first passed a competitive promotional examination. Promotion shall be by successive ranks insofar as practicable, and no person in a police department shall be promoted to a position in a higher rank who has not served at least twelve months in the next lower rank. A municipal civil service commission may require a period of service of longer than twelve months for promotion to the rank immediately above the rank of patrol officer.
No competitive promotional examination shall be held unless there are at least two persons eligible to compete. Whenever a municipal or civil service township civil service commission determines that there are less than two persons holding positions in the rank next lower than the position to be filled, who are eligible and willing to compete, the commission shall allow the persons holding positions in the then next lower rank who are eligible, to compete with the persons holding positions in the rank lower than the position to be filled.
An increase in the salary or other compensation of anyone holding a position in a police department, beyond that fixed for the rank in which that position is classified, shall be deemed a promotion, except as provided in section 124.491 of the Revised Code.
If a vacancy occurs in a position above the rank of patrol officer in a police department, and there is no eligible list for such rank, the municipal or civil service township civil service commission shall, within sixty days of that vacancy, hold a competitive promotional examination. After the examination has been held and an eligible list established, the commission shall forthwith certify to the appointing officer the name of the person on the list receiving the highest rating. Upon the certification, the appointing officer shall appoint the person so certified within thirty days from the date of the certification. If there is a list, the commission shall, when there is a vacancy, immediately certify the name of the person on the list having the highest rating, and the appointing authority shall appoint that person within thirty days from the date of the certification.
No credit for seniority, efficiency, or any other reason shall be added to an applicant's examination grade unless the applicant achieves at least the minimum passing grade on the examination without counting that extra credit.
The 20 cases that cite Ohio Rev. Code § 124.44 most heavily, weighted by court and treatment.RelevanceNewestTreatment
“44 to certify and promote the highest-rated person on the current eligibility list when a vacancy occurs. The respondents contend that the city’s home rule charter supersedes the statutory provisions, allowing the commission’s rules to apply and the commission to certify someone…”
The case’s holding
A municipal charter supersedes general state statutes only where the conflict is expressed by the clear and express terms of the charter rather than by mere inference.
Later courts cite it for
“although the constitution gives municipalities the authority to adopt home rule, local self-government, the exercise of those powers by the adoption of a charter should clearly and expressly state the areas where the municipality intends to supersede and override general state statutes.” · 4 citing courts
“Pursuant to R.C. 124.44, appellees Fostoria and the Fostoria Civil Service Commission conducted a competitive promotional examination for police chief.”
The case’s holding
In quo warranto, judgment may be rendered against the defendant's right to office even if relator fails to show his own entitlement to the office, as justice requires.
Later courts cite it for
“or only upon the right of the defendant, as justice requires.” · 1 citing court
“The main issue before this court is whether the Indian Hill Charter expressly conflicts with R.C. 124.44 regarding police promotions such that it supersedes R.”
The case’s holding
In matters of local self-government, a municipal charter provision that expressly conflicts with parallel state law prevails over the state law.
Later courts cite it for
“in matters of local self-government, if a portion of a municipal charter expressly conflicts with parallel state law, the charter provisions will prevail.” · 5 citing courts
“” In contrast to the foregoing charter provision, R.C. 124.44 specifies: “ * * * Whenever a vacancy occurs in the position above the rank of patrolman in a police department, and there is no eligible list for such rank, the municipal or * * * township civil service commission…”
The case’s holding
Prejudice cannot be inferred from a mere lapse of time to bar a claim under the doctrine of laches.
Later courts cite it for
“prejudice will not be inferred from a mere lapse of time.” · 2 citing courts
“The principal questions presented in this appeal are (1) whether the Cincinnati City Manager must affirmatively declare the existence of a vacancy in the rank of police captain before the civil service commission can hold a competitive promotional examination for eligible police…”
Later courts cite it for
“avoiding the traditional spoils system and providing a method of fair employee selection and promotion based upon merit and fitness.” · 2 citing courts
“The question before this court is the interrelationship between R.C. 124.44, 1 which provides the procedure for pro *160 motion of police patrolmen, and R.”
Later courts cite it for
“the procedure for promotion provided in r.c. 124.44 is mandatory upon the occurrence of a vacancy in a position above police patrolman, and the vacant position must be filled by appointment before it is abolished pursuant to r.c. 124.37, which presupposes the existence of an incumbent.” · 3 citing courts
“07-44, pursuant to R.C. 124.44, to generate such a list. The following were the top four finishers on this examination: Lieutenant Michael Neville, Lieutenant Teresa Theetge, Lieutenant Russell Neville, and Fink.”
“R.C. 124.44 provides that “[i]f there is a[n] [eligibility] list, the commission shall, where there is a vacancy, immediately certify the name of the person having the highest rating, and the appointing authority shall appoint such person within thirty days from the date of such…”
The case’s holding
Administrative proceedings lacking notice, hearing, and an opportunity to introduce evidence are not quasi-judicial, so an action in quo warranto lies.
Later courts cite it for
“proceedings of administrative officers and agencies are not quasi-judicial where there is no requirement for notice, hearing and the opportunity for the introduction of evidence.” · 3 citing courts
“In Morgan, supra, this court carefully distinguished both the legal and factual bases underlying Gibbons and concluded that Gibbons did not control those situations in which “the municipality actively violated state civil service laws by impermissibly delaying the competitive…”
The case’s holding
An appellate court remand must be premised on a determination that error occurred below and a ruling on that error.
Later courts cite it for
“must be premised on a determination that error occurred below and a ruling on that error.” · 1 citing court
“R.C. 124.44 states in part: “Whenever a vacancy occurs in the position above the rank of patrolman in a police department, * * * [and there is an eligibility] list * * * the [civil service] commission shall, where there is a vacancy, immediately certify the name of the person…”
Later courts cite it for
“many 'matters of local self-government' are, in fact, matters of detail and procedure that are out of place in a charter, which is comparable to a local constitution.” · 2 citing courts
“Here, on the other hand, the trial court and court of appeals agree that the municipality actively violated state civil service laws by impermissibly delaying the competitive examination beyond the time required by R.C. 124.44. In such a case, it would be wholly inequitable to…”
The case’s holding
A civil service employee is entitled to recover back pay and seniority if a promotion was delayed due to municipal actions taken in violation of civil service statutes.
Later courts cite it for
“where a civil service employee shows that a promotion to which he was entitled was delayed as the result of actions taken by a municipality in violation of r.c. 124.44, that employee is entitled to recover back pay and seniority for the period of the delay.” · 2 citing courts
“45, which pertains to promotional exams for firefighters, provided that examinees could protest the grading of their exams within five days, while R.C. 124.44, pertaining to police-officer promotional exams, had no corresponding provision *810 concerning an examinee’s ability to…”
“” Appellant contends that Civil Service Commission Rule VIII, Section 2 conflicts with R.C. 124.44 and, as such, is unlawful based upon the precedent established in Bardo v.”
“Hipp asserts that the oral component of the 1992 promotional examination was invalid under pertinent civil service statutes and that he therefore received the highest score and was entitled to promotion to lieutenant under R.C. 124.44. Hipp claims that he should have been…”
Later courts cite it for
“mandamus is an appropriate remedy in wrongful-denial-of-promotion cases.” · 2 citing courts
“Appellant claims that civil service commission rules that provide for appointments in a municipal police department do not supersede similar but conflicting provisions of R.C. 124.44, and that the court of appeals erred in refusing to issue a writ of mandamus based upon the…”
Later courts cite it for
“the authority to deviate from the statutory standard was not expressly set forth in the south euclid charter.” · 3 citing courts
“{¶ 5} R.C. 124.44 states in part: "Whenever a vacancy occurs in the position above the rank of patrolman in a police department, * * * [and there is an eligibility] list, the [civil service] commission shall, where there is a vacancy, immediately certify the name of the person…”
““Because the Lyndhurst Charter does not contain a clear and express exercise of home rule powers specifically authorizing the commission to adopt rules with regard to certification of names from promotion lists, neither the charter nor the commission’s rules supersede the…”
“44 provides that “[n]o position above the rank of patrolman in a police department shall be filled by any person unless he has first passed a competitive promotional examination” and “[ajfter such examination has been held and an eligible list established, the commission shall…”
The case’s holding
A promotional examination is not rendered non-competitive merely because one question was improper, absent misconduct, unfair advantage, or closed access, given the commission's broad discretion.
Later courts cite it for
“in the absence of a specific statutory definition, words used in a statute must be interpreted in their usual, normal, or customary meaning.” · 2 citing courts
The flag is Syfertize’s treatment of the citing case itself, not of the statute. “Where it cites” is the passage in the opinion; the holding is a summary of the whole case and may concern another point. Annotations are extracted automatically from the opinions in the Syfert caselaw corpus.
Citing cases by year
198120012022
One bar per year. Tallest: 5 cases in 1990. These are opinions in the Syfert collection, which holds more of some courts’ recent opinions than their older ones, so a rise can reflect what the collection holds and not more litigation.
By court
Ohio Ct. App.31Ohio23S.D. Ohio1
By subsection
Courts have not cited this section by subsection, so its cases are not split up here. The Leading cases tab lists the cases that cite it most heavily.
Sections that the same cases cite. The first number is counted among the 100 cases that cite § 124.44 most heavily: how many of them are also among the other section’s own 20 leading cases.