Hawaii Revised Statutes homeSearch Hawaii
Haw. Rev. Stat.Haw. Rev. Stat.Chapter 91

Haw. Rev. Stat. § 91-12 (2025)

  Decisions and orders

Edition and currency
laws through the 2025 session: the 2026 session is not included. The text is the edition Syfert holds; for a past event, check the version in force on that date.
Other sources
CURRENTlaws through the 2025 session: the 2026 session is not included cited 1972–2026 43citing cases
At a glance

Courts have cited this section in 43 opinions since 1972, 10 of them in the last five years.

     §91-12  Decisions and orders.  Every decision and order adverse to a party to the proceeding, rendered by an agency in a contested case, shall be in writing or stated in the record and shall be accompanied by separate findings of fact and conclusions of law.  If any party to the proceeding has filed proposed findings of fact, the agency shall incorporate in its decision a ruling upon each proposed finding so presented.  The agency shall notify the parties to the proceeding by delivering or mailing a certified copy of the decision and order and accompanying findings and conclusions within a reasonable time to each party or to the party's attorney of record. [L 1961, c 103, §12; Supp, §6C-12; HRS §91-12; am L 1980, c 232, §4; gen ch 1985]

 

Case Notes

 

  Order of agency must conform to decision as reflected in agency minutes.  52 H. 221, 473 P.2d 573.

  Although each proposed finding by a party must be ruled upon, a separate ruling on each proposed finding is not indispensable and the agency may incorporate its findings and rulings in its decision.  54 H. 134, 504 P.2d 1214; 4 H. App. 633, 675 P.2d 784.

  Section applies to decision of criminal injuries compensation commission.  54 H. 294, 506 P.2d 444.

  Agency must make its findings reasonably clear.  54 H. 663, 513 P.2d 1376.

  A separate ruling on each proposed finding is not necessary.  57 H. 535, 560 P.2d 1292.

  Findings merely summarizing testimony of witness do not constitute findings of basic fact.  57 H. 535, 560 P.2d 1292.

  Sufficiency of particularity of ruling on proposed findings.  57 H. 535, 560 P.2d 1292.

  Agency's findings of ultimate facts must be supported by findings of basic facts which must be supported by the evidence in the record.  60 H. 625, 594 P.2d 612.

  Does not limit board's power to order union to implement staffing of essential positions.  66 H. 461, 667 P.2d 783.

  Where commissioner followed all relevant administrative requirements in issuing cease and desist order, holding hearings, responding to exceptions, and scheduling oral arguments, and there was no indication that nine-month period  between oral argument and the final order was caused by an unjustified agency decision to postpone resolution of the matter, commissioner's action in issuing final order nine months after oral argument was not "characterized by an abuse of discretion or a clearly unwarranted exercise of discretion" or "made upon unlawful procedure".  112 H. 90, 144 P.3d 1.

  Labor and industrial relations appeals board should generally state whether or not it has applied presumption that claim is for a covered work injury.  But failure to do so in instant case did not prejudice appellant's substantial rights.  1 H. App. 77, 613 P.2d 927.

  Does not require notices of tax assessment be accompanied by findings of fact and conclusions of law.  6 H. App. 260, 718 P.2d 1122.

  Labor department's decision vacated where decision did not comply with this section's requirement that decision be accompanied by separate findings of fact and conclusions of law as decision did not decide whether employee's stated reasons for quitting constituted good cause for terminating employment.  81 H. 84 (App.), 912 P.2d 581.

  Cited:  9 H. App. 240, 833 P.2d 93.

 

 

The 20 cases that cite Haw. Rev. Stat. § 91-12 most heavily, weighted by court and treatment. RelevanceNewestTreatment
1
GREENTrivectra v. Ushijima, 144 P.3d 1 (Haw. 2006).
cites § 91-12 24×cited by 41 cases
Where it cites § 91-12
“contained therein violated the Appellants' statutory rights under HRS § 91-11 (1993); [2] (4) that the issuance of the final order sixteen months after the issuance of the original cease and desist order (CDO) and eleven months after the issuance of the hearings officer's…”
The case’s holding
An investment contract exists when purchasers provide value subject to enterprise risk with an expectation of profits derived from the efforts of others.
Later courts cite it for
“the delay was caused by an unjustified agency decision to postpone resolution of the matter or was so outside the bounds of the workings of a large and complex bureaucracy as to be deemed unreasonable per se.” · 1 citing court
cites § 91-12 12×cited by 120 cases
Where it cites § 91-12
“The only "other agency orders" referred to in HAPA are orders "rendered by an agency in a contested case" under HRS § 91-12. [4] Thus, reading HRS § 91-8 in pari materia with HRS § 91-12, declaratory rulings have the "same status" as contested case orders.”
The case’s holding
Orders disposing of petitions for declaratory rulings are appealable to the circuit court regardless of whether a hearing was required.
Later courts cite it for
“the right to appeal is purely statutory and exists only when jurisdiction is given by some constitutional or statutory provision.” · 8 citing courts
3
GREENIn re Kauai Elec. Div. of Citizens Utils. Co., 590 P.2d 524 (Haw. 1978).
cites § 91-12 16×cited by 51 cases
Where it cites § 91-12
“It lacks specific findings of fact and conclusions of law as required by HRS § 91-12; II. Whether order number 4084 is void because the ultimate conclusions reached by the Commission are unsupported by reliable, probative and substantial evidence; III.”
The case’s holding
A public utility commission must make specific findings of fact and conclusions of law to support an order for an interim rate increase.
Later courts cite it for
“in regard to the setting of rates, hrs 269-16 requires that all rates and charges must be 'just and reasonable.” · 2 citing courts
cites § 91-12 8×cited by 17 cases
Where it cites § 91-12
“Every decision and order adverse to a party to the proceeding, rendered by an agency in a contested case, shall be in writing or stated in the record and shall be accompanied by separate findings of fact and conclusions of law.”
5
GREENIn re Hawaiian Tel. Co., 513 P.2d 1376 (Haw. 1973).
cites § 91-12 36×cited by 13 cases
Where it cites § 91-12
“HRS § 91-12 provides: § 91-12 Decisions and orders.”
6
GREENOutdoor Circle v. Harold K.L. Castle Trust Est., 675 P.2d 784 (Haw. App. 1983).
cites § 91-12 10×cited by 44 cases
Where it cites § 91-12
“ts from presenting arguments on all issues in violation of HRS § 91-9(a) and (c) (1976) and HRS § 91-10(3) (1976); (3) it rejected certain of appellants’proposed findings without a quorum of the commissioners being present in violation of HRS § 92-15 (1976); and (4) it failed to…”
The case’s holding
An agency decision that reasonably incorporates specific findings of fact implies the rejection of all other proposed findings.
Later courts cite it for
“by choosing those, it impliedly rejected all others,” · 2 citing courts
7
GREENLanai Co. v. Land Use Com'n, 97 P.3d 372 (Haw. 2004).
cites § 91-12 4×cited by 64 cases
Where it cites § 91-12
“38 The LUC, in the 1991 Order, acknowledged that it had “heard and examined” the proposed findings and conclusions and thereby issued its findings, conclusions and decision and order accordingly.”
The case’s holding
An appellate court is not obligated to sift through a voluminous record to verify an appellant's inadequately documented contentions.
Later courts cite it for
“this court is not obligated to sift through the voluminous record to verify an appellant's inadequately documented contentions.” · 13 citing courts
8
GREENSurvivors of Timothy Freitas v. PAC. CONTRACTORS, 613 P.2d 927 (Haw. App. 1980).
cites § 91-12 5×cited by 21 cases
Where it cites § 91-12
“Appellants contend that the Board’s rejection of six of Employer’s proposed findings of fact was “clearly contrary” to section 91-12, Hawaii Revised Statutes, because the Board did not specifically indicate why the proposed findings were *83 rejected.”
The case’s holding
Although an agency must respond to each proposed finding, a separate ruling on each proposed finding is not indispensable, provided its findings and rulings are reasonably clear.
Later courts cite it for
“a separate ruling on each proposed finding” · 2 citing courts
9
GREENRife v. Akiba, 912 P.2d 581 (Haw. App. 1996).
cites § 91-12 10×cited by 6 cases
Where it cites § 91-12
“We vacate and remand pursuant to HRS § 91-14(g)(l) because the Department failed to satisfy HRS § 91-12 (1993). THE APPLICABLE LAW Hawaii’s Employment Security Law states in HRS § 383-30 (1993) various disqualifications for benefits.”
10
GREENMitchell v. BWK Jt. Venture, 560 P.2d 1292 (Haw. 1977).
cites § 91-12 6×cited by 12 cases
Where it cites § 91-12
“Appellants contend that the wholesale rejection of their proposed findings by the board is contrary to HRS § 91-12, which requires a ruling on each proposed finding, as follows: Decisions and orders.”
The case’s holding
An administrative board need not rule on every proposed finding if its decision provides reasonably clear findings of fact.
Later courts cite it for
“because they are, in whole or in part, contrary to the facts or the law or because they are immaterial.” · 2 citing courts
11
GREENAsato v. Procurement Policy Bd., 322 P.3d 228 (Haw. 2014).
cites § 91-12 4×cited by 11 cases
Where it cites § 91-12
“Also, by the same token, the term “[a]ny interested person” does not by its plain language require that an individual have met the injury in fact test.”
The case’s holding
Parties to a contract must be made parties to a lawsuit in which the validity of that contract is challenged.
Later courts cite it for
“generally, the parties to a contract must be made parties to a suit in which the contract is challenged.” · 2 citing courts
12
cites § 91-12 8×cited by 4 cases
Vacated by E & J Lounge Operating Co. v. Liquor Commission of Honolulu (2008): the Hawaii Supreme Court's own opinion in this case.
Where it cites § 91-12
“HRS § 91-12. Additionally, if the officials who are to render the final decision have not heard and examined all the evidence submitted, which commonly occurs when the officials are volunteer members of a state or county board or commission, no final decision can be made until a…”
The case’s holding
Liquor license application hearings are governed by specific statutory public hearing requirements rather than general contested case procedures.
Later courts cite it for
“are not trial-like in nature, but are more akin to the public hearings that legislative committees conduct to receive public input on proposed bills or the public hearings that state and county agencies conduct as part of the process for adopting, amending, or repealing rules.” · 1 citing court
cites § 91-12 4×cited by 22 cases
Where it cites § 91-12
“Utilizing these sections, the UPW argues it was not afforded adequate notice and the opportunity to litigate the specifics of the special orders as evidenced by the fact that there were no specific findings of fact or conclusions of law incorporated in Decision 119 concerning…”
The case’s holding
A public employment relations board may set requirements to avoid imminent danger to public health or safety during a strike, and civil contempt fines survive settlement of the strike.
14
GREENSudbeck v. Dale Elec., Inc., 519 N.W.2d 63 (S.D. 1994).
cites § 91-12 4×cited by 17 cases
Where it cites § 91-12
“HRS § 91-12 provided that if any party has filed proposed findings of fact, "the agency shall incorporate in its decision a ruling upon each proposed finding so presented.”
15
GREENApplication of Charley's Tour & Transp., Inc., 522 P.2d 1272 (Haw. 1974).
cites § 91-12 6×cited by 22 cases
Where it cites § 91-12
“First they contend that because not all of the commissioners who voted to approve appellee's application heard and examined all of the evidence presented, the Commission violated the requirements of HRS § 91-11 [1] by not sending a proposed decision to the appellants.”
The case’s holding
Procedural errors not specifically stated in an application for reconsideration cannot be raised on appeal, and substantial evidence supports public necessity and financial fitness findings.
16
GREENApplication of Hawaii Elec. Light Co., Inc., 594 P.2d 612 (Haw. 1979).
cites § 91-12 2×cited by 63 cases
Where it cites § 91-12
“While we have said that the courts have great respect for the findings made by specialized agencies, those findings are subject to judicial review.”
The case’s holding
Administrative agency decisions are accorded a presumption of validity to ensure reasoned decision making and enable effective judicial review.
Later courts cite it for
“to assure reasoned decision making by the agency and enable judicial review of agency decisions.” · 4 citing courts
17
GREENDavenport v. City & Cnty. of Honolulu, 60 P.3d 882 (Haw. 2002).
cites § 91-12 4×cited by 7 cases
Where it cites § 91-12
“The ICA cited HRS § 91-12 (1993), which provides that the Board must make findings and rulings that are reasonably clear, and the court should not be left to speculate as to the findings of an administrative agency.”
Later courts cite it for
“is social legislation that is to be interpreted broadly.” · 3 citing courts
18
GREENPrice v. Zoning Bd. of App. of Honolulu, 883 P.2d 629 (Haw. 1994).
cites § 91-12 2×cited by 55 cases
Where it cites § 91-12
“HRS § 91-12 (1985). The purpose of the statutory requirement that the agency set forth separate FOFs and COLs is to “assure reasoned decision making by the agency and to enable judicial review of agency decisions.”
The case’s holding
Mixed questions of law and fact are reviewed under the clearly erroneous standard because the conclusion depends upon the facts and circumstances of the particular case.
Later courts cite it for
“a col that presents mixed questions of fact and law is reviewed under the clearly erroneous standard because the conclusion is dependent upon the facts and circumstances of the particular case.” · 12 citing courts
19
GREEN'O Haleakalâ v. Bd. of Land & Nat. Resources, 382 P.3d 195 (Haw. 2016).
cites § 91-12 2×cited by 8 cases
Where it cites § 91-12
“And like a trial order, an agency order in a contested case must be supported by "reliable, probative, and substantial evidence.”
The case’s holding
A proposed land use in a conservation district must not cause substantial adverse impact to existing natural resources within the surrounding area, community, or region.
Later courts cite it for
“existing natural resources within the surrounding area, community, or region.” · 3 citing courts
20
GREENDavenport v. City & Cnty. of Honolulu, 59 P.3d 932 (Haw. App. 2001).
cites § 91-12 3×cited by 9 cases
Where it cites § 91-12
“HRS § 91-12 (1993) provides, in relevant part, that ‘‘[ejvery decision and order adverse to a party to the proceeding, rendered by an agency in a contested case, shall be in writing or stated in the record and shall be accompanied by separate findings of fact and conclusions of…”
The case’s holding
Psychological injuries resulting from non-disciplinary personnel actions are compensable under workers' compensation statutes.
Later courts cite it for
“a contributing factor to the build up of perceived stress over the years has been davenport's dogged persistence in pursuing these promotion and grievance issues without compromise.” · 1 citing court

Show all 43 citing cases (list view) →

The flag is Syfertize’s treatment of the citing case itself, not of the statute. “Where it cites” is the passage in the opinion; the holding is a summary of the whole case and may concern another point. Annotations are extracted automatically from the opinions in the Syfert caselaw corpus.

Citing cases by year
197219992026

One bar per year. Tallest: 3 cases in 2023. 2026 is a partial year. These are opinions in the Syfert collection, which holds more of some courts’ recent opinions than their older ones, so a rise can reflect what the collection holds and not more litigation.

By court
Haw.23Haw. App.18D. Haw.1S.D.1
By subsection

Courts have not cited this section by subsection, so its cases are not split up here. The Leading cases tab lists the cases that cite it most heavily.

Show all 43 citing cases (list view) →

Enactment and amendments

Syfert holds no separate history line for this section. Where this code prints a source or history note, it appears with the text, usually at the end.

Versions

Edition shown: laws through the 2025 session: the 2026 session is not included. Syfert holds no earlier or later version of this section.

Hawaii Revised Statutes Home  |  Search Hawaii  |  Search cases for this section  |  syfert.com