cites § 196 7×cited by 158 cases
- Where it cites § 196
- “” With regard to the battery cause of action, the trial court stated: “The test for determining whether a homicide was justifiable under Penal Code section 196 is whether the circumstances ‘reasonably created a fear of death or serious bodily harm to the officer or to another.”
- The case’s holding
- A state law battery claim is the counterpart to a federal excessive force claim and requires proof that the officer's use of force was unreasonable.
- Later courts cite it for
- “the elements of civil battery are: (1) defendant intentionally performed an act that resulted in a harmful or offensive contact with the plaintiff's person; (2) plaintiff did not consent to the contact; and (3) the harmful or offensive contact caused injury, damage, loss or harm to plaintiff.” · 17 citing courts
cites § 196 2×cited by 4,187 cases
- Where it cites § 196
- “§ 41-510 (1977); Cal. Penal Code Ann. § 196 (West 1970); Conn.”
- The case’s holding
- Deadly force is a seizure subject to Fourth Amendment reasonableness and is constitutionally permissible only if the officer has probable cause to believe the suspect poses a threat of harm.
- Later courts cite it for
- “where the officer has probable cause to believe that the suspect poses a threat of serious physical harm, either to the officer or to others, it is not constitutionally unreasonable to prevent escape by using deadly force.” · 344 citing courts
cites § 196 2×cited by 164 cases
- Where it cites § 196
- “) [18] In light of our analysis and conclusion, we do not address defendants' claims that they owed no duty of care regarding their preshooting conduct and that they are immune under Penal Code section 196.”
- The case’s holding
- An issue is actually litigated for collateral estoppel purposes if it was properly raised, submitted for determination, and determined in a prior proceeding.
- Later courts cite it for
- “for purposes of collateral estoppel, an issue was actually litigated in a prior proceeding if it was properly raised, submitted for determination, and determined in that proceeding.” · 25 citing courts
cites § 196 2×cited by 298 cases
- Where it cites § 196
- “) [3] It is evident that the mental state required for the crime of murder of the first degree does not entail intent to kill.”
- The case’s holding
- A conviction for conspiracy to commit murder requires proof of the intent to kill and cannot be sustained on a theory of implied malice.
- Later courts cite it for
- “a conviction of conspiracy to commit murder requires a finding of intent to kill” · 19 citing courts
cites § 196 3×cited by 65 cases
- Where it cites § 196
- “) The trial court entered judgment for the defendants on the ground that the officer’s use of deadly force was justifiable under the provision applicable to homicides committed by police officers, Penal Code section 196, the analogue of Penal Code section 197 applicable to…”
- The case’s holding
- A homicide that is justifiable under the penal code is a privileged act that precludes civil liability in a wrongful death action.
- Later courts cite it for
- “which is simply the statutorily created right of an heir to recover for damages resulting from a tor-tious act which results in the decedent's death,” · 2 citing courts
cites § 196 3×cited by 56 cases
- Where it cites § 196
- “7 Under Penal Code section 196, a police officer who kills someone has committed a justifiable homicide if the homicide was “necessarily committed in overcoming actual resistance to the execution of some legal process, or in the discharge of any other legal duty” or when…”
- Holding on this section
- A homicide is justifiable under Penal Code section 196 if the circumstances reasonably create a fear of death or serious bodily harm to an officer or another person.
- Later courts cite it for
- “the test for determining whether a homicide was justifiable under penal code section 196 is whether the circumstances 'reasonably created a fear of death or serious bodily harm to the officer or to another.” · 3 citing courts
cites § 196 2×cited by 59 cases
- Where it cites § 196
- “Code, § 835a as to lawful use of force by police officers.) The jury was, however, instructed on justifiable homicide as defined in section 196 and, by its verdict, necessarily rejected that defense.”
- The case’s holding
- An officer's lack of due care can give rise to negligence liability for the intentional shooting death of a suspect.
- Later courts cite it for
- “an officer's lack of due care can give rise to negligence liability for the intentional shooting death of a suspect.” · 9 citing courts
cites § 196 1×cited by 29 cases
- Where it cites § 196
- “Under this theory of immunity, they assert an officer may “‘press forward and make the arrest, using all the force [reasonably] necessary to accomplish that purpose.’” See Hernandez v. City of Pomona, 207 P.”
- The case’s holding
- Under California negligence law, an officer's pre-shooting tactical decisions can render his conduct unreasonable under the totality of the circumstances, even if the shooting itself would be reasonable in isolation.
- Later courts cite it for
- “under california law, the officer's pre-shooting decisions can render his behavior unreasonable under the totality of the circumstances, even if his use of deadly force at the moment of shooting might be reasonable in isolation.” · 2 citing courts
cites § 196 2×cited by 14 cases
- Where it cites § 196
- “” Cal. Pen. Code § 196 . “There can be no civil liability under California law as the result of a justifiable homicide.”
- Later courts cite it for
- “failure of a party to address a claim in an opposition to a motion for summary judgment may constitute a waiver of that claim.” · 5 citing courts
cites § 196 3×cited by 5 cases
- Where it cites § 196
- “Second, Defendants argue that they are protected under California Penal Code § 196. “Under Penal Code section 196, a police officer who kills someone has committed a justifiable homicide if the homicide was necessarily committed in overcoming actual resistance to the execution…”
cites § 196 1×cited by 54 cases
- Where it cites § 196
- “Pamphlet 1976); Cal.Penal Code § 196 (West 1970); Colo.Rev.”
- The case’s holding
- State statutes are unconstitutional if they permit deadly force against a fleeing felon who has used no violence and poses no immediate threat to others.
- Later courts cite it for
- “force which the actor uses with the purpose of causing or which he knows to create a substantial risk of causing death or serious bodily harm” · 2 citing courts
cites § 196 1×cited by 30 cases
- Where it cites § 196
- “) 6 Penal Code section 196, subdivision 3, provides: “Homicide is justifiable when committed by public officers and those acting by their command in their aid and assistance, either— “3.”
- The case’s holding
- A municipality may adopt firearms use policies more restrictive than state penal code provisions because state law does not preempt the field of local police regulation.
- Later courts cite it for
- “the purpose of the regulation is to provide training and guidance to the officer so that he will not get into a situation where a plaintiff could claim that he used excessive force.” · 1 citing court
cites § 196 6×cited by 31 cases
Flagged on editorial review. Superseded: 1 citing opinion says superseded.
- Where it cites § 196
- “, Pen. Code, § 196 [justifiable homicide by police officers]; Murphy v.”
- The case’s holding
- A police department manual provision restricting firearm use constitutes a regulation of a public entity that triggers a statutory presumption of negligence when violated.
- Later courts cite it for
- “traditionally has been regarded as an 'agency' of the city and is obviously 'public.” · 2 citing courts
cites § 196 1×cited by 12 cases
- Where it cites § 196
- “26 ] [peace officer may use deadly force against a felony suspect only if the felony is a “forcible and atrocious one,” which threatens death or great bodily harm, or there are other circumstances which reasonably create a fear of death or serious bodily harm to the officer or…”
cites § 196 2×cited by 1 case
- Where it cites § 196
- “8 and California Penal Code section 196 give him immunity from liability; and (2) the failure to establish a violation of the Fourth Amendment likewise establishes his lack of liability for these claims.”
cites § 196 1×cited by 12 cases
- Where it cites § 196
- “§ 41-2238 (1964) California: Cal.Penal Code §§ 196, 197 (West 1969) Colorado: Colo.”
cites § 196 2×cited by 63 cases
Disapproved by People v. Morgan on another ground: 1 citing opinion limits it to another ground, 1 adds another limit ("to the extent inconsistent"), and 1 says disapproved outright.
- Where it cites § 196
- “4th at page 349 & footnote 8 (defenses of official justification under Pen. Code, § 196 and official immunity under Gov.”
- The case’s holding
- A trial court errs by failing to instruct on a lesser included offense when the jury's conviction of a different lesser offense demonstrates a readiness to scrutinize the evidence.
- Later courts cite it for
- “in assessing prejudice, 'it does not matter that the jury chose to convict the defendant of the greater offense over acquittal or that the defendant was convicted of the greater offense on sufficient evidence.' to hold otherwise would undermine the very purpose of the sua sponte rule.” · 3 citing courts
cites § 196 2×cited by 196 cases
Reversed by City and County of San Francisco v. Sheehan (2015): the U.S. Supreme Court's own opinion in this case.
- Where it cites § 196
- “6; Cal. Penal Code §§ 196 , 836.5, 835a, 847(b).”
- The case’s holding
- Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act applies to arrests and exigent circumstances inform the reasonableness analysis under the ADA just as they do under the Fourth Amendment.
- Later courts cite it for
- “ratification . . . generally requires more than acquiescence.” · 10 citing courts
cites § 196 1×cited by 3 cases
- Where it cites § 196
- “1), and the use of lethal force for the prevention of a crime, or to effect an arrest, is also limited to cases of felonies and is not permissible in eases of misdemeanors (Pen. Code, § 196, subd. 3; Pen. Code, § 197, subd.”
cites § 196 4×cited by 0 casesunknown
- Where it cites § 196
- “City of Los Angeles et al analysis. Id. Penal Code section 196, defining justified homicide by a peace officer, Agdeppa contends, confirms that “aside from the tactical consideration under the negligence claim .”
Show all 32 citing cases (list view) →
The flag is Syfertize’s treatment of the citing case itself, not of the statute. “Where it cites” is the passage in the opinion; the holding is a summary of the whole case and may concern another point. Annotations are extracted automatically from the opinions in the Syfert caselaw corpus.