green
Positive treatment
Issue: tier II hearingNY ↗
Issue: tier III hearingNY ↗
Issue: inmate ruleNY ↗
Issue: III hearingNY ↗
30.0 score
Treatment trajectory · 1997 → 2026 · click a year to view as-of
1997
2011
2026
Top citers, strongest first. 38 distinct citers.
How cited ↗
discussed
Cited as authority (rule)
Matter of Asencio v. Martuscello
(2×)
The determination found after a tier III hearing that petitioner had violated various incarcerated individual rules. [*1] It is hereby ORDERED that said proceeding is unanimously dismissed without costs as moot ( see Matter of Free v Coombe , 234 AD2d 996, 996 [4th Dept 1996]).
discussed
Cited as authority (rule)
Matter of Barry v. Martuscello
Because petitioner has obtained the relief that he could be granted in this proceeding, the proceeding is dismissed as moot ( see Matter of Smith v Annucci , 173 AD3d 1685 , 1685 [4th Dept 2019]; Matter of Free v Coombe , 234 AD2d 996, 996 [4th Dept 1996]).
examined
Cited as authority (rule)
Matter of Encarnacion v. Martuscello
(3×)
Because petitioner has obtained the relief that he could be granted in this proceeding, the proceeding is dismissed as moot ( see Matter of Smith v Annucci , 173 AD3d 1685, 1685 [4th Dept 2019]; Matter of Free v Coombe , 234 AD2d 996, 996 [4th Dept 1996]).
cited
Cited as authority (rule)
Matter of MacDonald v. Martuscello
It is hereby ORDERED that said proceeding is unanimously dismissed without costs as moot ( see Matter of Free v Coombe , 234 AD2d 996, 996 [4th Dept 1996]).
cited
Cited as authority (rule)
Matter of Shevlin v. Annucci
It is hereby ORDERED that said proceeding is unanimously dismissed without costs as moot ( see Matter of Free v Coombe , 234 AD2d 996, 996 [4th Dept 1996]).
cited
Cited as authority (rule)
Matter of Dublino v. Eckert
It is hereby ORDERED that said proceeding is unanimously dismissed without costs as moot ( see Matter of Free v Coombe , 234 AD2d 996, 996 [4th Dept 1996]).
cited
Cited as authority (rule)
Matter of Roots v. Annucci
It is hereby ORDERED that said proceeding is unanimously dismissed without costs as moot ( see Matter of Free v Coombe , 234 AD2d 996, 996 [4th Dept 1996]).
cited
Cited as authority (rule)
Matter of Williams v. Annucci
It is hereby ORDERED that said proceeding is unanimously dismissed without costs as moot ( see Matter of Free v Coombe , 234 AD2d 996, 996 [4th Dept 1996]).
cited
Cited as authority (rule)
Matter of Kennedy v. Monetgari
It is hereby ORDERED that said proceeding is unanimously dismissed without costs as moot ( see Matter of Free v Coombe , 234 AD2d 996, 996 [4th Dept 1996]).
cited
Cited as authority (rule)
Matter of Coston v. Thompson
It is hereby ORDERED that said proceeding is unanimously dismissed without costs as moot ( see Matter of Free v Coombe , 234 AD2d 996, 996 [4th Dept 1996]).
cited
Cited as authority (rule)
Matter of Shelton v. Annucci
It is hereby ORDERED that said proceeding is unanimously dismissed without costs as moot ( see Matter of Free v Coombe , 234 AD2d 996, 996 [4th Dept 1996]).
cited
Cited as authority (rule)
Matter of Tolliver v. Annucci
It is hereby ORDERED that said proceeding is unanimously dismissed without costs as moot ( see Matter of Free v Coombe , 234 AD2d 996, 996 [4th Dept 1996]).
cited
Cited as authority (rule)
Matter of You v. Annucci
It is hereby ORDERED that said proceeding is unanimously dismissed without costs as moot ( see Matter of Free v Coombe , 234 AD2d 996, 996 [4th Dept 1996]).
cited
Cited as authority (rule)
Matter of Carter v. Fischer
It is hereby ORDERED that said proceeding is unanimously dismissed without costs as moot ( see Matter of Free v Coombe , 234 AD2d 996, 996 [4th Dept 1996]).
cited
Cited as authority (rule)
Matter of Terrence v. Annucci
It is hereby ORDERED that said proceeding is unanimously dismissed without costs as moot ( see Matter of Free v Coombe , 234 AD2d 996, 996 [4th Dept 1996]).
cited
Cited as authority (rule)
Matter of Green v. Annucci
It is hereby ORDERED that said proceeding is unanimously dismissed without costs as moot ( see Matter of Free v Coombe , 234 AD2d 996, 996 [4th Dept 1996]) Entered: October 2, 2020 Mark W.
cited
Cited as authority (rule)
Matter of Alexander v. Annucci
It is hereby ORDERED that said proceeding is unanimously dismissed without costs as moot ( see Matter of Free v Coombe , 234 AD2d 996, 996 [4th Dept 1996]).
cited
Cited as authority (rule)
Matter of Plaza v. Annucci
It is hereby ORDERED that said proceeding is unanimously dismissed without costs as moot ( see Matter of Free v Coombe , 234 AD2d 996, 996 [4th Dept 1996]).
cited
Cited as authority (rule)
Matter of Burke v. Annucci
It is hereby ORDERED that said proceeding is unanimously dismissed without costs as moot ( see Matter of Free v Coombe , 234 AD2d 996, 996 [4th Dept 1996]).
cited
Cited as authority (rule)
Matter of Bailey v. Annucci
It is hereby ORDERED that said proceeding is unanimously dismissed without costs as moot ( see Matter of Free v Coombe , 234 AD2d 996, 996 [4th Dept 1996]).
cited
Cited as authority (rule)
Matter of Coggins v. Annucci
It is hereby ORDERED that said proceeding is unanimously dismissed without costs as moot ( see Matter of Free v Coombe , 234 AD2d 996, 996 [4th Dept 1996]).
cited
Cited as authority (rule)
Matter of Bush v. Annucci
It is hereby ORDERED that said proceeding is unanimously dismissed without costs as moot ( see Matter of Free v Coombe , 234 AD2d 996, 996 [4th Dept 1996]).
cited
Cited as authority (rule)
Matter of Coggins v. Annucci
It is hereby ORDERED that said proceeding is unanimously dismissed without costs as moot ( see Matter of Free v Coombe , 234 AD2d 996, 996 [4th Dept 1996]).
discussed
Cited as authority (rule)
Matter of Smith v. Annucci
Because petitioner has obtained the relief that he could be granted in this proceeding, the proceeding is dismissed as moot ( see Matter of Davis v Annucci , 169 AD3d 1352 , 1352 [4th Dept 2019]; Matter of Free v Coombe , 234 AD2d 996, 996 [4th Dept 1996]).
cited
Cited as authority (rule)
Matter of Davis v. Annucci
It is hereby ORDERED that said proceeding is unanimously dismissed without costs as moot ( see Matter of Free v Coombe , 234 AD2d 996, 996 [4th Dept 1996]).
cited
Cited as authority (rule)
Matter of Burgess v. Annucci
It is hereby ORDERED that said proceeding is unanimously dismissed without costs as moot ( see Matter of Free v Coombe , 234 AD2d 996, 996 [4th Dept 1996]).
cited
Cited as authority (rule)
Matter of Fewell v. Eckert
It is hereby ORDERED that said proceeding is unanimously dismissed without costs as moot ( see Matter of Free v Coombe , 234 AD2d 996, 996 [4th Dept 1996]) Entered: December 21, 2018 Mark W.
cited
Cited as authority (rule)
Matter of Richards v. Annucci
It is hereby ORDERED that said proceeding is unanimously dismissed without costs as moot ( see Matter of Free v Coombe , 234 AD2d 996, 996 [4th Dept 1996]).
cited
Cited as authority (rule)
Matter of Gourdine v. Annucci
It is hereby ORDERED that said proceeding is unanimously dismissed without costs as moot ( see Matter of Free v Coombe , 234 AD2d 996, 996 [4th Dept 1996]).
cited
Cited as authority (rule)
Matter of McLeod v. Eckert
It is hereby ORDERED that said proceeding is unanimously dismissed without costs as moot ( see Matter of Free v Coombe , 234 AD2d 996, 996 [4th Dept 1996]).
cited
Cited as authority (rule)
Matter of McGowan v. Doldo
It is hereby ORDERED that said proceeding is unanimously dismissed without costs as moot ( see Matter of Free v Coombe , 234 AD2d 996, 996 [4th Dept 1996]).
cited
Cited as authority (rule)
Matter of Stanley v. Annucci
It is hereby ORDERED that said proceeding is unanimously dismissed without costs as moot ( see Matter of Free v Coombe , 234 AD2d 996, 996 [4th Dept 1996]).
cited
Cited as authority (rule)
Matter of Collins v. Annucci
It is hereby ORDERED that said proceeding is unanimously dismissed without costs as moot ( see Matter of Free v Coombe , 234 AD2d 996, 996 [4th Dept 1996]).
cited
Cited as authority (rule)
Matter of Fountain v. Annucci
It is hereby ORDERED that said petition is unanimously dismissed without costs as moot ( see Matter of Free v Coombe , 234 AD2d 996, 996 [4th Dept 1996]).
cited
Cited as authority (rule)
Farrington v. Annucci
Because petitioner has obtained the relief he sought in the petition, this appeal is dismissed as moot (see Matter of Free v Coombe, 234 AD2d 996, 996 [1996]).
cited
Cited as authority (rule)
Farrington v. Annucci
Because petitioner has obtained the relief he sought in the petition, this appeal is dismissed as moot (see Matter of Free v Coombe, 234 AD2d 996, 996 [1996]).
discussed
Cited as authority (rule)
Bennefield v. Annucci
We agree with respondent that the petition must be dismissed as moot to the extent that it concerns the expunged disciplinary determination (see Matter of Silva v Walker, 245 AD2d 1115, 1115 [1997]; Matter of Free v Coombe, 234 AD2d 996, 996 [1996]).
discussed
Cited as authority (rule)
Bennefield v. Annucci
We agree with respondent that the petition must be dismissed as moot to the extent that it concerns the expunged disciplinary determination (see Matter of Silva v Walker, 245 AD2d 1115, 1115 [1997]; Matter of Free v Coombe, 234 AD2d 996, 996 [1996]).
Retrieving the full opinion text from the archive…
In the Matter of Timothy Free
v.
Philip Coombe, Jr., as Acting Commissioner of New York State Department of Correctional Services
v.
Philip Coombe, Jr., as Acting Commissioner of New York State Department of Correctional Services
Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York.
Dec 30, 1996.
Cited by 280 opinions | Published
—Proceeding unanimously dismissed without costs. Memorandum: Petitioner commenced this proceeding seeking to annul a determination that he violated certain inmate disciplinary rules. After Supreme Court transferred the proceeding to this Court pursuant to CPLR 7804 (g), respondent issued an administrative order reversing the determination and directing that all references to the disciplinary proceeding be expunged. Because petitioner has obtained the relief he seeks in this proceeding, the proceeding is dismissed as moot. (CPLR art 78 Proceeding Transferred by Order of Supreme Court, Oneida County, Murad, J.) Present—Denman, P. J., Green, Fallon, Doerr and Balio, JJ.