Already have an account? Sign in instead.
You stay signed in for 30 days on this browser.
Continue with Google Continue with MicrosoftNo account yet? Create a free one.
We sent a six-digit code.
It expires in ten minutes, works once, and only in this browser. Five wrong tries void it. Send another code.
Your account is live and the Cloudflare checks are off for this browser.
13 Oregon opinions name it 3 courts 1984–2017 0 in the last five years
The cases below were cited by Oregon courts in a sentence that names this issue. Sides come from how each citing opinion treated the case (Syfertize flag on that citation), so a case can appear on both: that is where the law is contested. A red or yellow chip is the case's own overall treatment.
| Case | Followed | Cited |
|---|---|---|
State v. Robertsongreen2 sentences1993See State v. Robertson, 293 Or 402,408 , 649 P2d 569 (1982). 1993See State v. Robertson, 293 Or 402,408 , 649 P2d 569 (1982). | 5 | 5 |
In Re the Marriage of Crockergreen2 sentences2017See Crocker and Crocker, 332 Or 42, 54 , 22 P3d 759 (2001) (“The equal privileges and immunities clause scrutinizes benefits in the form of privileges and immunities given to a particular class [.] ”). 2017See Crocker and Crocker, 332 Or 42, 54 , 22 P3d 759 (2001) (“The equal privileges and immunities clause scrutinizes benefits in the form of privileges and immunities given to a particular class [.] ”). | 1 | 2 |
State v. Savagegreen2 sentences2001See State v. Savage, 96 Or 53, 59 , 184 P 567 (1920) (Article I, section 20, is ‘antithesis’ of Fourteenth Amendment’s equal protection clause). 2001See State v. Savage, 96 Or 53, 59 , 184 P 567 (1920) (Article I, section 20, is ‘antithesis’ of Fourteenth Amendment’s equal protection clause). | 1 | 1 |
| Case | Negative | Cited |
|---|---|---|
| No negative-treatment citations attached to this issue in Oregon. Read the followed side critically anyway. | ||
| Case | Cited | Years |
|---|---|---|
WITCHERS v. State of Oregon
green
2 sentences2015“To survive an equal privileges and immunities challenge under the rational basis test, the classification involved must bear some rational relationship to some legitimate end.” Withers v. State, 163 Or App 298, 309 , 987 P2d 1247 (1999). 2015“To survive an equal privileges and immunities challenge under the rational basis test, the classification involved must bear some rational relationship to some legitimate end.” Withers v. State, 163 Or App 298, 309 , 987 P2d 1247 (1999). | 1 | 2015–2015 |
Tony Duckett v. Salvador Godinez Brian McKay
green
1 sentence2013“In addition, the trial court violated the above constitutional rights when it ordered, on its own motion, and without appropriate objection from defense counsel, that the Defendant [sic] should be shackled and placed in additional restraint, i.e., leg irons, during the penalty phase in contravention of established law at the time of the penalty phase as expressed by Duckett v. Godinz/McKay, 67 F3d 734 (9th Cir 1995).” Rather, petitioner contends, trial counsel asserted that the state’s disparate treatment of petitioner and Susbauer in plea negotiations had violated the equal privileges and im | 1 | 2013–2013 |
Seto v. Tri-County Metropolitan Transportation District
green
2 sentences2002An equal privileges and immunities analysis in this context 7 entails a determination of: “(1) whether the legislature had authority to act; (2) whether one class of persons receives privileges that the other does not; and (3) whether the disparate treatment had a rational basis.” Crocker and Crocker, 332 Or 42, 54 , 22 P3d 759 (2001) (citing Seto v. Tri-County Metro Transportation Dist., 311 Or 456, 467 , 814 P2d 1060 (1991)). 2002An equal privileges and immunities analysis in this context 7 entails a determination of: “(1) whether the legislature had authority to act; (2) whether one class of persons receives privileges that the other does not; and (3) whether the disparate treatment had a rational basis.” Crocker and Crocker, 332 Or 42, 54 , 22 P3d 759 (2001) (citing Seto v. Tri-County Metro Transportation Dist., 311 Or 456, 467 , 814 P2d 1060 (1991)). | 1 | 2002–2002 |
State v. Buchholz
green
2 sentences2001It is undisputed that, for purposes of Article I, section 20, a “district attorney may not decide whether to plea bargain based on impermissible criteria, such as race or religion.” State v. Buchholz, 309 Or 442, 446 , 788 P2d 998 (1990). 2001It is undisputed that, for purposes of Article I, section 20, a “district attorney may not decide whether to plea bargain based on impermissible criteria, such as race or religion.” State v. Buchholz, 309 Or 442, 446 , 788 P2d 998 (1990). | 1 | 2001–2001 |
State v. Day
green
2 sentences1989Unless the challenged classification is based “on ‘immutable’ personal characteristics,” Hewitt v. SAIF, 294 Or 33, 45 , 653 P2d 970 (1982), it will be upheld so long as it “bears a rational relationship to some legitimate state interest.” State v. Day, 84 Or App 291, 294 , 733 P2d 937 , rev den 303 Or 535 (1987) (quoting Ritchie v. Board of Parole, 35 Or App 711 , *469 717, 583 P2d 1 (1978), adhered to as modified 37 Or App 385 , 587 P2d 1036 (1978)). 1989Unless the challenged classification is based “on ‘immutable’ personal characteristics,” Hewitt v. SAIF, 294 Or 33, 45 , 653 P2d 970 (1982), it will be upheld so long as it “bears a rational relationship to some legitimate state interest.” State v. Day, 84 Or App 291, 294 , 733 P2d 937 , rev den 303 Or 535 (1987) (quoting Ritchie v. Board of Parole, 35 Or App 711 , *469 717, 583 P2d 1 (1978), adhered to as modified 37 Or App 385 , 587 P2d 1036 (1978)). | 1 | 1989–1989 |
Hewitt v. State Accident Insurance Fund Corp.
green
2 sentences1989Unless the challenged classification is based “on ‘immutable’ personal characteristics,” Hewitt v. SAIF, 294 Or 33, 45 , 653 P2d 970 (1982), it will be upheld so long as it “bears a rational relationship to some legitimate state interest.” State v. Day, 84 Or App 291, 294 , 733 P2d 937 , rev den 303 Or 535 (1987) (quoting Ritchie v. Board of Parole, 35 Or App 711 , *469 717, 583 P2d 1 (1978), adhered to as modified 37 Or App 385 , 587 P2d 1036 (1978)). 1989Unless the challenged classification is based “on ‘immutable’ personal characteristics,” Hewitt v. SAIF, 294 Or 33, 45 , 653 P2d 970 (1982), it will be upheld so long as it “bears a rational relationship to some legitimate state interest.” State v. Day, 84 Or App 291, 294 , 733 P2d 937 , rev den 303 Or 535 (1987) (quoting Ritchie v. Board of Parole, 35 Or App 711 , *469 717, 583 P2d 1 (1978), adhered to as modified 37 Or App 385 , 587 P2d 1036 (1978)). | 1 | 1989–1989 |
Ritchie v. Board of Parole
neutral
2 sentences1989Unless the challenged classification is based “on ‘immutable’ personal characteristics,” Hewitt v. SAIF, 294 Or 33, 45 , 653 P2d 970 (1982), it will be upheld so long as it “bears a rational relationship to some legitimate state interest.” State v. Day, 84 Or App 291, 294 , 733 P2d 937 , rev den 303 Or 535 (1987) (quoting Ritchie v. Board of Parole, 35 Or App 711 , *469 717, 583 P2d 1 (1978), adhered to as modified 37 Or App 385 , 587 P2d 1036 (1978)). 1989Unless the challenged classification is based “on ‘immutable’ personal characteristics,” Hewitt v. SAIF, 294 Or 33, 45 , 653 P2d 970 (1982), it will be upheld so long as it “bears a rational relationship to some legitimate state interest.” State v. Day, 84 Or App 291, 294 , 733 P2d 937 , rev den 303 Or 535 (1987) (quoting Ritchie v. Board of Parole, 35 Or App 711 , *469 717, 583 P2d 1 (1978), adhered to as modified 37 Or App 385 , 587 P2d 1036 (1978)). | 1 | 1989–1989 |
Ritchie v. Board of Parole
neutral
2 sentences1989Unless the challenged classification is based “on ‘immutable’ personal characteristics,” Hewitt v. SAIF, 294 Or 33, 45 , 653 P2d 970 (1982), it will be upheld so long as it “bears a rational relationship to some legitimate state interest.” State v. Day, 84 Or App 291, 294 , 733 P2d 937 , rev den 303 Or 535 (1987) (quoting Ritchie v. Board of Parole, 35 Or App 711 , *469 717, 583 P2d 1 (1978), adhered to as modified 37 Or App 385 , 587 P2d 1036 (1978)). 1989Unless the challenged classification is based “on ‘immutable’ personal characteristics,” Hewitt v. SAIF, 294 Or 33, 45 , 653 P2d 970 (1982), it will be upheld so long as it “bears a rational relationship to some legitimate state interest.” State v. Day, 84 Or App 291, 294 , 733 P2d 937 , rev den 303 Or 535 (1987) (quoting Ritchie v. Board of Parole, 35 Or App 711 , *469 717, 583 P2d 1 (1978), adhered to as modified 37 Or App 385 , 587 P2d 1036 (1978)). | 1 | 1989–1989 |
Planned Parenthood Ass'n v. Department of Human Resources
green
2 sentences1984Planned Parenthood et al v. Department of Human Resources, 63 Or App 41 , 663 P2d 1247 (1983). 1984Planned Parenthood et al v. Department of Human Resources, 63 Or App 41 , 663 P2d 1247 (1983). | 1 | 1984–1984 |
Counted by distinct opinions that both name this issue and are annotated to the section; sections every opinion cites regardless of issue are not filtered here, so read the counts against the total above.
Opinions by the citing court's state. A doctrine retained in one state and abandoned in another shows up here as a year span that stalls.