perfect defense (Illinois) · Go Syfert
← Illinois issues

perfect defense in Illinois

8 Illinois opinions name it 3 courts 1877–1946 0 in the last five years

The cases below were cited by Illinois courts in a sentence that names this issue. Sides come from how each citing opinion treated the case (Syfertize flag on that citation), so a case can appear on both: that is where the law is contested. A red or yellow chip is the case's own overall treatment.

Followed or applied (0)

CaseFollowedCited
No positive-treatment citations attached to this issue in Illinois.

Distinguished, questioned or overruled (0)

CaseNegativeCited
No negative-treatment citations attached to this issue in Illinois. Read the followed side critically anyway.

Also cited on this issue (11)

CaseCitedYears
Volmut v. Bern neutral
ill · 1931
1 sentence

1946(Stein v. McKinney, 313 Ill. 84 ; Hagen v. Anderson, 317 Ill. 173 ; Volmut v. Bern, 346 Ill. 619 .) There is therefore a lack of mutuality in obligation, which requires a denial of a decree of specific performance.

11946–1946
Hagen v. Anderson green
ill · 1925
1 sentence

1946(Stein v. McKinney, 313 Ill. 84 ; Hagen v. Anderson, 317 Ill. 173 ; Volmut v. Bern, 346 Ill. 619 .) There is therefore a lack of mutuality in obligation, which requires a denial of a decree of specific performance.

11946–1946
Stein v. McKinney green
ill · 1924
1 sentence

1946(Stein v. McKinney, 313 Ill. 84 ; Hagen v. Anderson, 317 Ill. 173 ; Volmut v. Bern, 346 Ill. 619 .) There is therefore a lack of mutuality in obligation, which requires a denial of a decree of specific performance.

11946–1946
Roland v. Fischer neutral
· 1863
1 sentence

1936(Roland v. Fletcher, 30 Ill. 224 .) In the instant case none of these presumptions are present.

11936–1936
Monroe v. Becker neutral
· 1918
1 sentence

1935Monroe v. Becker, 283 Ill. 42 .

11935–1935
Great Western Railroad v. Bacon neutral
· 1863
1 sentence

1914(Great Western Railroad Co. v. Bacon, 30 Ill. 347 ; Germania Fire Ins.

11914–1914
Piper v. Connelly green
ill · 1884
1 sentence

1904Piper v. Connelly, 108 Ill. 646 .

11904–1904
Windett v. Hurlbut green
ill · 1885
1 sentence

1896Where a party knowingly and voluntarily signs a deed, although he do so in violation of his duty and of the laws, or be induced thereto by the fraudulent contrivances of others, yet if it be such, upon its face, as will convey title, it can only be impeached and set aside, and parol evidence be received for that purpose, in a court of equity.” Windett v. Hurlbut, 115 Ill. 403 ; Johnson v. Wilson, 33 Ill.

11896–1896
Johnson v. Wilson neutral
illappct · 1889
1 sentence

1896Where a party knowingly and voluntarily signs a deed, although he do so in violation of his duty and of the laws, or be induced thereto by the fraudulent contrivances of others, yet if it be such, upon its face, as will convey title, it can only be impeached and set aside, and parol evidence be received for that purpose, in a court of equity.” Windett v. Hurlbut, 115 Ill. 403 ; Johnson v. Wilson, 33 Ill.

11896–1896
People ex rel. Rice v. Board of Trade neutral
ill · 1875
1 sentence

1878Rice v. The Board of Trade of Chicago, 80 Ill. 134 , as authority, then it is clear that the petition for a mandamus in this case cannot be sustained and that the answer to it presents a perfect defense.

11878–1878
Illinois Central Railroad v. Read green
· 1865
1 sentence

1877But, on the assumption he was a passenger on the car, riding on a free ticket containing the usual conditions, as this did, then the case is like that of Illinois Central Railroad Co. v. Read, 37 Ill. 484 , where it was held, such a pass or ticket is a perfect immunity to the company for such unavoidable accidents as will happen to the best managed railroad trains; not, however, shielding them from liability for gross negligence, or any degree of negligence having the character of recklessness.

11877–1877

Where else courts name it

NY 45 (1808–2013) CA 34 (1861–2026) OR 23 (1928–2026) TX 13 (1883–2015) AL 12 (1847–1963) GA 11 (1915–2025) MI 11 (1886–2017) MD 10 (1975–2026) MN 9 (1926–2015) MO 9 (1889–1957) IL 8 (1877–1946) WI 8 (1885–2022) AZ 7 (1950–2009) PA 7 (1958–2017) MA 6 (1854–2002) SC 5 (1926–2019) MS 5 (1910–2012) FL 4 (1936–2018) CT 4 (1899–2005) KS 4 (1877–2019) IA 3 (1911–1930) VA 3 (1825–1927) LA 3 (1937–1984) WA 2 (1901–2015) WY 2 (1905–1931) WV 2 (1915–1980) NE 2 (1908–1929) DC 2 (2003–2008) MT 2 (1890–1897) KY 2 (1920–1933)

Opinions by the citing court's state. A doctrine retained in one state and abandoned in another shows up here as a year span that stalls.

← Caselaw search · G Cite Topics · Brief Check