merits of each claim (New York) · Go Syfert
← New York issues

merits of each claim in New York

6 New York opinions name it 3 courts 1973–2017 0 in the last five years

The cases below were cited by New York courts in a sentence that names this issue. Sides come from how each citing opinion treated the case (Syfertize flag on that citation), so a case can appear on both: that is where the law is contested. A red or yellow chip is the case's own overall treatment.

Followed or applied (1)

CaseFollowedCited
City of Oneida v. Chassingreen
nyappdiv · 1996 · cited in 2 New York opinions naming this issue, 2017–2017
2 sentences

2017Here, Supreme Court heard oral argument as to the merits of claimant’s claims, considered the arguments and submitted proof and addressed the merits of each claim in its decision (compare Matter of City of Oneida v Chassin, 229 AD2d 855, 857 [1996]).

2017Here, Supreme Court heard oral argument as to the merits of claimant’s claims, considered the arguments and submitted proof and addressed the merits of each claim in its decision (compare Matter of City of Oneida v Chassin, 229 AD2d 855, 857 [1996]).

22

Distinguished, questioned or overruled (0)

CaseNegativeCited
No negative-treatment citations attached to this issue in New York. Read the followed side critically anyway.

Also cited on this issue (8)

CaseCitedYears
Society Milion Athena, Inc. v. National Bank of Greece green
ny · 1939
2 sentences

1978(Society Milion Athena v. National Bank of Greece, 281 N. Y. 282, 292 ; Young v. Shuart, 67 Misc 2d 689, 691 ; Summers v. Wyman, 64 Misc 2d 67, 70 , affd. 36 A D 2d 795.) Each aggrieved person is entitled to determine for himself the appropriate remedy that he will seek if he so desires and, as Judge Fuld noted in Gaynor v. Rockefeller (15 N Y 2d 120, 129-130), an alleged class action against the State charging discriminatory practices, 'each individual claim might be subject to defenses not available against others; and, in general, determination of the merits of each claim would turn on the

1974(Society Milion Athena v. National Bank of Greece, 281 N. Y. 282, 292 ; Young v. Shuart, 67 Misc 2d 689, 691 ; Summers v. Wyman, 64 Misc 2d 67, 70 , affd. 36 A D 2d 795.) Each aggrieved person is entitled to determine for himself the appropriate remedy that he will seek if he so desires and, as Judge Fuld noted in Gaynor v. Rockefeller (15 N Y 2d 120, 129-130), an alleged class action against the State charging discriminatory practices, ‘ ‘ each individual claim might be subject to defenses not available against others; and, in general, determination of the merits of each claim would turn on t

31973–1978
Summers v. Wyman neutral
nysupct · 1970
2 sentences

1978(Society Milion Athena v. National Bank of Greece, 281 N. Y. 282, 292 ; Young v. Shuart, 67 Misc 2d 689, 691 ; Summers v. Wyman, 64 Misc 2d 67, 70 , affd. 36 A D 2d 795.) Each aggrieved person is entitled to determine for himself the appropriate remedy that he will seek if he so desires and, as Judge Fuld noted in Gaynor v. Rockefeller (15 N Y 2d 120, 129-130), an alleged class action against the State charging discriminatory practices, 'each individual claim might be subject to defenses not available against others; and, in general, determination of the merits of each claim would turn on the

1974(Society Milion Athena v. National Bank of Greece, 281 N. Y. 282, 292 ; Young v. Shuart, 67 Misc 2d 689, 691 ; Summers v. Wyman, 64 Misc 2d 67, 70 , affd. 36 A D 2d 795.) Each aggrieved person is entitled to determine for himself the appropriate remedy that he will seek if he so desires and, as Judge Fuld noted in Gaynor v. Rockefeller (15 N Y 2d 120, 129-130), an alleged class action against the State charging discriminatory practices, ‘ ‘ each individual claim might be subject to defenses not available against others; and, in general, determination of the merits of each claim would turn on t

21974–1978
Young v. Shuart green
nysupct · 1971
2 sentences

1978(Society Milion Athena v. National Bank of Greece, 281 N. Y. 282, 292 ; Young v. Shuart, 67 Misc 2d 689, 691 ; Summers v. Wyman, 64 Misc 2d 67, 70 , affd. 36 A D 2d 795.) Each aggrieved person is entitled to determine for himself the appropriate remedy that he will seek if he so desires and, as Judge Fuld noted in Gaynor v. Rockefeller (15 N Y 2d 120, 129-130), an alleged class action against the State charging discriminatory practices, 'each individual claim might be subject to defenses not available against others; and, in general, determination of the merits of each claim would turn on the

1974(Society Milion Athena v. National Bank of Greece, 281 N. Y. 282, 292 ; Young v. Shuart, 67 Misc 2d 689, 691 ; Summers v. Wyman, 64 Misc 2d 67, 70 , affd. 36 A D 2d 795.) Each aggrieved person is entitled to determine for himself the appropriate remedy that he will seek if he so desires and, as Judge Fuld noted in Gaynor v. Rockefeller (15 N Y 2d 120, 129-130), an alleged class action against the State charging discriminatory practices, ‘ ‘ each individual claim might be subject to defenses not available against others; and, in general, determination of the merits of each claim would turn on t

21974–1978
Dennis v. Long Island Lighting Co. green
nysupct · 1974
1 sentence

1978(Society Milion Athena v. National Bank of Greece, 281 N. Y. 282, 292 ; Young v. Shuart, 67 Misc 2d 689, 691 ; Summers v. Wyman, 64 Misc 2d 67, 70 , affd. 36 A D 2d 795.) Each aggrieved person is entitled to determine for himself the appropriate remedy that he will seek if he so desires and, as Judge Fuld noted in Gaynor v. Rockefeller (15 N Y 2d 120, 129-130), an alleged class action against the State charging discriminatory practices, 'each individual claim might be subject to defenses not available against others; and, in general, determination of the merits of each claim would turn on the

11978–1978
Gaynor v. Rockefeller green
ny · 1965
1 sentence

1975Each aggrieved person is entitled to determine for himself the appropriate remedy that he will seek if he so desires and, as Judge Fuld noted in Gaynor v Rockefeller ( 15 NY2d 120, 129-30 ), in an alleged class action against the State charging discriminatory practices, "each individual claim might be subject to defenses not available against others; and, in general, determination of the merits of each claim would turn on the particular facts and circumstances involved.” Such a situation prevails in the case at bar, as the wrongs asserted are individual to the different persons involved, diffe

11975–1975
Brenner v. Title Guarantee & Trust Co. green
ny · 1937
1 sentence

1973(Society Milion Athena v. National Bank of Greece, 281 N. Y. 282, 292 ; see, also, Coolidge v. Kaskel, 16 N Y 2d 559; Brenner v. Title Guar, & Trust Co., 276 N. Y. 230 ; see, also, Onofrio v. Playboy Club of N. Y., 15 N Y 2d 740; Gaynor v. Rockefeller, 15 N Y 2d 120, 129-130.) In those eases, unlike the one before us, determination of the merits of each claim must, perforce, turn on the particular facts and circumstances involved; alternatively, the class , action was held not to lie because a choice of remedies was available and each member “'[was] free to determine for himself the remedy for

11973–1973
Gilligan v. Tishman Realty & Construction Co. green
nyappdiv · 1953
1 sentence

1973(Gaynor v. Rockefeller, 15 N Y 2d 120, 129, supra.) tions to tenants that the plan had been approved, or was about to be, in a calculated effort to induce them to buy as the time for acceptance of the plan, with its favorable inducements, was about to expire. “ Obviously, the most obsessing fear of a tenant confronted with a co-operative proposal, and the most paralyzing weapon in the arsenal of the promoter,” observed the court in the quite similar Gilligan case ( 283 App. Div. 157, 162 , affd. 306 N. Y. 974 , supra), “is the possibility that 80% of the tenants [the percentage there required]

11973–1973
Gilligan v. Tishman Realty & Construction Co. green
ny · 1954
1 sentence

1973(Gaynor v. Rockefeller, 15 N Y 2d 120, 129, supra.) tions to tenants that the plan had been approved, or was about to be, in a calculated effort to induce them to buy as the time for acceptance of the plan, with its favorable inducements, was about to expire. “ Obviously, the most obsessing fear of a tenant confronted with a co-operative proposal, and the most paralyzing weapon in the arsenal of the promoter,” observed the court in the quite similar Gilligan case ( 283 App. Div. 157, 162 , affd. 306 N. Y. 974 , supra), “is the possibility that 80% of the tenants [the percentage there required]

11973–1973

Where else courts name it

TX 523 (1991–2025) NY 6 (1973–2017) IL 5 (1976–2019) CA 4 (2012–2026) FL 3 (2006–2016) AL 2 (2003–2012) IA 2 (2019–2019) CT 2 (1985–1997) MO 2 (2019–2021)

Opinions by the citing court's state. A doctrine retained in one state and abandoned in another shows up here as a year span that stalls.

← Caselaw search · G Cite Topics · Brief Check