Idaho Code homeSearch Idaho

Idaho Code § 40-208 (2026)

Judicial review. 

Edition and currency
text as last checked Oct. 2026 (this copy records no edition or section history). The text is the edition Syfert holds; for a past event, check the version in force on that date.
Other sources
CURRENTtext as last checked Oct. 2026 (this copy records no edition or section history) ACTIVE · 5 IN 5Y cited 1998–2025 16citing cases
At a glance

Courts have cited this section in 16 opinions since 1998, 5 of them in the last five years. The most litigated part is subsection (7) (12 cases).

Judicial review. 

(1) Any resident or property holder within the county or highway district system, including the state of Idaho or any of its subdivisions or any agency of the federal government, who is aggrieved by a final decision of a board of county or highway district commissioners in an abandonment and vacation or validation proceeding is entitled to judicial review under the provisions of this section.

(2)  Proceedings for review are instituted by filing a petition in the district court of the county in which the commissioners have jurisdiction over the highway or public right-of-way within twenty-eight (28) days after the filing of the final decision of the commissioners or, if a rehearing is requested, within twenty-eight (28) days after the decision thereon.
(3)  The filing of the petition does not itself stay enforcement of the commissioners’ decision. The reviewing court may order a stay upon appropriate terms.
(4)  Within thirty (30) days after the service of the petition, or within further time allowed by the court, the commissioners shall transmit to the reviewing court the original or a certified copy of the entire record of the proceeding under review. By stipulation of all parties to the review proceedings, the record may be shortened. A party unreasonably refusing to stipulate to limit the record may be ordered by the court to pay for additional costs. The court may require subsequent corrections to the record and may also require or permit additions to the record.
(5)  The parties may present additional evidence to the court, upon a showing to the court that such evidence is material to the issues presented to the court. In such case, the court may order that the additional information be presented to the commissioners upon conditions determined by the court. The commissioners may modify their findings and decisions by reason of the additional information and shall file that information and any modifications, new findings, or decisions with the reviewing court.
(6)  Either party to a proceeding may request in writing that a judge who resides outside the county where the subject road or property is located be appointed to hear the case, and, upon such written request, such a judge shall be appointed for the case. The review shall be conducted by the court without a jury. The court shall consider the record before the board of county or highway district commissioners and shall defer to the board of county or highway district commissioners on matters in which such board has appropriately exercised its discretion with respect to the evaluation of the public interest. As to the determination of highway or public right-of-way creation, width and abandonment, the court may accept new evidence and testimony supplemental to the record provided by the county or highway district, and the court shall consider those issues anew. In cases of alleged irregularities in procedure before the commissioners, not shown in the record, proof thereon may be taken in the court. The court, upon request, shall hear oral argument and receive written briefs.
(7)  Any person other than a board of county or highway district commissioners seeking a determination of the legal status or the width of a highway or public right-of-way shall first petition for the initiation of validation or abandonment proceedings, or both, as provided for in sections 40-203(1)(b) and 40-203A(1), Idaho Code. If the commissioners having jurisdiction over the highway system do not initiate a proceeding in response to such a petition within thirty (30) days, the person may seek a determination by quiet title or other available judicial means. When the legal status or width of a highway or public right-of-way is disputed and where a board of county or highway district commissioners wishes to determine the legal status or width of a highway or public right-of-way, the commissioners shall initiate validation or abandonment proceedings, or both, as provided for in sections 40-203 and 40-203A, Idaho Code, rather than initiating an action for quiet title. If proceedings pursuant to the provisions of section 40-203 or 40-203A, Idaho Code, are initiated, those proceedings and any appeal or remand therefrom shall provide the exclusive basis for determining the status and width of the highway, and no court shall have jurisdiction to determine the status or width of said highway except by way of judicial review provided for in this section. Provided that nothing in this subsection shall preclude determination of the legal status or width of a public road in the course of an eminent domain proceeding, as provided for in chapter 7, title 7, Idaho Code.
The 16 cases that cite Idaho Code § 40-208 most heavily, weighted by court and treatment. RelevanceNewestTreatment
1
GREENMunden v. Bannock Cnty., 504 P.3d 354 (Idaho 2022).
cites § 40-208 65×subsections: (7) 63×cited by 10 cases
Where it cites § 40-208
“7 The Defendant’s Counterclaim for a Declaratory Judgment regarding the status of Garden Creek Road is dismissed without prejudice pending a determination of the legal nature of Garden Creek Road pursuant to Idaho Code § 40-208 (7). The Amended Judgment dated August 20, 2019,…”
2
GREENNemeth v. Shoshone Cnty., 453 P.3d 844 (Idaho 2019).
cites § 40-208 26×subsections: (7) 26×cited by 7 cases
Where it cites § 40-208
“” I.C § 40-208(7) (emphasis added). In the case at bar, it was only the County’s refusal to initiate a validation proceeding that resulted in the 10 Nemeths utilizing the second method by bringing their claim to the district court pursuant to sections 40-204A and 40-208(7) of…”
Later courts cite it for
“we cannot find that the respondent acted without a foundation in fact or law in defending on appeal the judgment they won below.” · 3 citing courts
3
GREENCobbley v. City of Challis, 139 P.3d 732 (Idaho 2006).
cites § 40-208 20×subsections: (2) 2× (4) 2× (5) 2×cited by 21 cases
Where it cites § 40-208
“Idaho Code § 40-208 provides for judicial review of a county board of commissioners’ road validation decision.”
Later courts cite it for
“judicial review of an administrative decision is wholly statutory; there is no right of judicial review absent the statutory grant.” · 5 citing courts
4
GREENGalli v. Idaho Cnty., 191 P.3d 233 (Idaho 2008).
cites § 40-208 24×subsections: (7) 20× (7)(e) 4×cited by 15 cases
Where it cites § 40-208
“The district court ultimately reversed the Board's decision under I.C. § 40-208(7), holding that the Board's findings were not supported by substantial and competent evidence and that the decision affected a substantial right of the Gallis.”
The case’s holding
Establishing a public right-of-way under R.S. 2477 on land removed from the public domain requires proof of regular public use for five years under the Revised Statutes of 1887.
5
GREENFloyd v. Bd. of Commissioners, 953 P.2d 984 (Idaho 1998).
cites § 40-208 34×subsections: (7) 4× (5) 2× (6) 2×cited by 12 cases
Where it cites § 40-208
“The court further ruled that recently enacted Idaho Code § 40-208 , which limits the scope of judicial review of a decision by a board of county commissioners or highway district commissioners, would adversely affect the substantive rights of the Landowners if applied…”
6
GREENFloyd v. Bd. of Com'rs Bonneville Cnty., 52 P.3d 863 (Idaho 2002).
cites § 40-208 14×subsections: (6) 2× (7) 2× (7)(a) 2×cited by 21 cases
Where it cites § 40-208
“The Court vacated the decision of the district court and remanded the case for review pursuant to I.C. § 40-208. Id. *722 Pursuant to an order of the district court granting the parties’ joint motion to be allowed to present additional evidence, the district court remanded the…”
The case’s holding
Due process is satisfied by disregarding a biased commissioner's vote rather than nullifying a decision if the remaining members constitute a quorum.
Later courts cite it for
“be applied against the state in matters affecting its governmental or sovereign functions.” · 2 citing courts
cites § 40-208 14×subsections: (6) 4× (7) 4×cited by 11 cases
Where it cites § 40-208
“The court also may not substitute its judgment for that of the Commissioners as to the weight of the information on questions of fact.”
The case’s holding
A county may not place a road on its official highway system map without evidence it was properly created as a public highway; map inclusion alone does not make a road public.
Later courts cite it for
“if a road is not properly created as a public highway, its inclusion on an official county highway system map does not make it so, nor does it impose any requirement on a property owner to vacate what has never been established as a public roadway.” · 2 citing courts
cites § 40-208 13×subsections: (7) 7×cited by 10 cases
Where it cites § 40-208
“§ 40-202 is contained in the section of the Code relating to general provisions for the establishment and maintenance of the state and county highway system, including procedures required for abandonment, vacation or validation of highways,” the statutory standard of review…”
9
GREENSopatyk v. Lemhi Cnty., 264 P.3d 916 (Idaho 2011).
cites § 40-208 8×subsections: (7) 4× (7)(f) 2×cited by 11 cases
Where it cites § 40-208
“Idaho Code section 40-208 governs judicial review of validation proceedings.”
The case’s holding
Whether a road on federal land became public under R.S. 2477 is governed by state law, and the court reviews the public-interest finding for clear error.
Later courts cite it for
“state law governs the manner in which a road on federal property becomes public under r.s. 2477.” · 2 citing courts
10
GREENGalvin v. Canyon High. Dist. No. 4, 6 P.3d 826 (Idaho 2000).
cites § 40-208 4×subsections: (7) 2×cited by 13 cases
Where it cites § 40-208
“We address the following issues on appeal: 1) whether the district court erred by denying the Galvins’ motion to augment the agency record, and 2) whether the Board’s findings of fact are sufficient to support a validation under I.”
Later courts cite it for
“validate an existing highway or public right-of-way about which there is some kind of doubt,” · 3 citing courts
11
GREENMunden v. Bannock Cnty., No. 47978 (Idaho Dec. 15, 2021).
cites § 40-208 59×subsections: (7) 57×cited by 0 cases
Where it cites § 40-208
“7 The Defendant’s Counterclaim for a Declaratory Judgment regarding the status of Garden Creek Road is dismissed without prejudice pending a determination of the legal nature of Garden Creek Road pursuant to Idaho Code § 40-208 (7). The Amended Judgment dated August 20, 2019,…”
12
NO FLAGPalmer v. ESHD, No. 47548 (Idaho Dec. 10, 2020).
cites § 40-208 13×subsections: (7) 9× (6) 4×cited by 0 cases
Where it cites § 40-208
“C. § 40-208(6) (italics added) (“The court shall consider the record before the board of county or highway district commissioners and shall defer to the board of county or highway district commissioners on matters in which such board has appropriately exercised its discretion…”
13
NEUTRALRichel Fam. Trust v. Worley Hwy Dist, 468 P.3d 775 (Idaho 2020).
cites § 40-208 18×subsections: (6) 6×cited by 0 cases
Where it cites § 40-208
“I.C. § 40-208. That statute provides, in relevant part: The review shall be conducted by the court without a jury.”
14
NO FLAGMunden v. Bannock Cnty., No. 4:24-cv-00211 (D. Idaho Apr. 24, 2025).
cites § 40-208 11×cited by 0 casesunknown
Where it cites § 40-208
“Plaintiffs did not appeal the decision in accordance with Idaho Code § 40-208 (2). 1 Idaho Code § 40-208 (7) requires a person seeking the determination of legal status of a highway or public right-of-way to first petition county commissioners for an initiation of validation or…”
15
NO FLAGMunden v. Stewart Title Guar. Co., No. 4:19-cv-00112 (D. Idaho July 31, 2023).
cites § 40-208 8×subsections: (7) 8×cited by 0 casesunknown
Where it cites § 40-208
“The court “concluded that the Mundens were obliged to comply with Idaho Code section 40-208(7) and bring a petition before the Bannock County Commissioners before they could bring suit in Idaho district court.”
16
GREENHill v. Blaine Cnty., 173 Idaho 856 (Idaho 2024).
cites § 40-208 2×cited by 0 cases
Where it cites § 40-208
“C. § 40-208. While our decision today affirms the district court’s decision concerning the Board’s interpretation of the Validation Decision, our holding is premised on the facts of this specific case.”
Later courts cite it for
“greenhorn, who intervened on the side of the county, is not 'adverse' to the county and therefore cannot be awarded attorney fees pursuant to idaho code section 12-117.” · 2 citing courts

The flag is Syfertize’s treatment of the citing case itself, not of the statute. “Where it cites” is the passage in the opinion; the holding is a summary of the whole case and may concern another point. Annotations are extracted automatically from the opinions in the Syfert caselaw corpus.

Citing cases by year
199820112025

One bar per year. Tallest: 2 cases in 2020. These are opinions in the Syfert collection, which holds more of some courts’ recent opinions than their older ones, so a rise can reflect what the collection holds and not more litigation.

By court
Idaho14D. Idaho2
By subsection
(2)1 case
Cobbley v. City of Challis, 139 P.3d 732 (Idaho 2006).“Idaho Code § 40-208 provides for judicial review of a county board of commissioners’ road validation decision.”
(4)1 case
Cobbley v. City of Challis, 139 P.3d 732 (Idaho 2006).
(5)2 cases
Cobbley v. City of Challis, 139 P.3d 732 (Idaho 2006).
Floyd v. Bd. of Commissioners, 953 P.2d 984 (Idaho 1998).“The court further ruled that recently enacted Idaho Code § 40-208 , which limits the scope of judicial review of a decision by a board of county commissioners or highway district commissioners, would adversely affect the substantive rights of the Landowners if applied…”
(6)5 cases
Homestead Farms, Inc. v. Bd. of Commissioners of Teton Cnty., 119 P.3d 630 (Idaho 2005).“The court also may not substitute its judgment for that of the Commissioners as to the weight of the information on questions of fact.”
Floyd v. Bd. of Com'rs Bonneville Cnty., 52 P.3d 863 (Idaho 2002).“The Court vacated the decision of the district court and remanded the case for review pursuant to I.C. § 40-208. Id. *722 Pursuant to an order of the district court granting the parties’ joint motion to be allowed to present additional evidence, the district court remanded the…”
Floyd v. Bd. of Commissioners, 953 P.2d 984 (Idaho 1998).
Richel Fam. Trust v. Worley Hwy Dist, 468 P.3d 775 (Idaho 2020).“I.C. § 40-208. That statute provides, in relevant part: The review shall be conducted by the court without a jury.”
Palmer v. ESHD, No. 47548 (Idaho Dec. 10, 2020).“C. § 40-208(6) (italics added) (“The court shall consider the record before the board of county or highway district commissioners and shall defer to the board of county or highway district commissioners on matters in which such board has appropriately exercised its discretion…”
(7)12 cases
Munden v. Bannock Cnty., 504 P.3d 354 (Idaho 2022).“7 The Defendant’s Counterclaim for a Declaratory Judgment regarding the status of Garden Creek Road is dismissed without prejudice pending a determination of the legal nature of Garden Creek Road pursuant to Idaho Code § 40-208 (7). The Amended Judgment dated August 20, 2019,…”
Nemeth v. Shoshone Cnty., 453 P.3d 844 (Idaho 2019).“” I.C § 40-208(7) (emphasis added). In the case at bar, it was only the County’s refusal to initiate a validation proceeding that resulted in the 10 Nemeths utilizing the second method by bringing their claim to the district court pursuant to sections 40-204A and 40-208(7) of…”
Galli v. Idaho Cnty., 191 P.3d 233 (Idaho 2008).“The district court ultimately reversed the Board's decision under I.C. § 40-208(7), holding that the Board's findings were not supported by substantial and competent evidence and that the decision affected a substantial right of the Gallis.”
Flying \A\" Ranch v. Cnty. Commissioners of Fremont Cnty.", 342 P.3d 649 (Idaho 2015).“§ 40-202 is contained in the section of the Code relating to general provisions for the establishment and maintenance of the state and county highway system, including procedures required for abandonment, vacation or validation of highways,” the statutory standard of review…”
Sopatyk v. Lemhi Cnty., 264 P.3d 916 (Idaho 2011).“Idaho Code section 40-208 governs judicial review of validation proceedings.”
Showing the top 5 of 12. More in the list view →
(7)(a)1 case
Floyd v. Bd. of Com'rs Bonneville Cnty., 52 P.3d 863 (Idaho 2002).
(7)(e)1 case
Galli v. Idaho Cnty., 191 P.3d 233 (Idaho 2008).
(7)(f)1 case
Sopatyk v. Lemhi Cnty., 264 P.3d 916 (Idaho 2011).
Enactment and amendments

Syfert holds no separate history line for this section. Where this code prints a source or history note, it appears with the text, usually at the end.

Versions

Edition shown: text as last checked Oct. 2026 (this copy records no edition or section history). Syfert holds no earlier or later version of this section.

Idaho Code Home  |  Search Idaho  |  Search cases for this section  |  syfert.com