Idaho Code homeSearch Idaho

Idaho Code § 72-719 (2026)

Modification of awards and agreements — Grounds — Time within which made. 

Edition and currency
text as last checked Oct. 2026 (this copy records no edition or section history). The text is the edition Syfert holds; for a past event, check the version in force on that date.
Other sources
CURRENTtext as last checked Oct. 2026 (this copy records no edition or section history) cited 1975–2019 44citing cases
At a glance

Courts have cited this section in 44 opinions since 1975. The most litigated part is subsection (3) (15 cases).

Modification of awards and agreements — Grounds — Time within which made. 

(1) On application made by a party in interest filed with the commission at any time within five (5) years of the date of the accident causing the injury or date of first manifestation of an occupational disease, on the ground of a change in conditions, the commission may, but not oftener than once in six (6) months, review any order, agreement or award upon any of the following grounds:

(a)  Change in the nature or extent of the employee’s injury or disablement; or
(b)  Fraud.
(2)  The commission on such review may make an award ending, diminishing or increasing the compensation previously agreed upon or awarded, subject to the maximum and minimum provided in this law, and shall make its findings of fact, rulings of law and order or award, file the same in the office of the commission, and immediately send a copy thereof to the parties.
(3)  The commission, on its own motion at any time within five (5) years of the date of the accident causing the injury or date of first manifestation of an occupational disease, may review a case in order to correct a manifest injustice.
(4)  This section shall not apply to a commutation of payments under section 72-404.
The 20 cases that cite Idaho Code § 72-719 most heavily, weighted by court and treatment. RelevanceNewestTreatment
1
GREENSines v. Appel, 644 P.2d 331 (Idaho 1982).
cites § 72-719 66×subsections: (3) 34× (1)(a) 4×cited by 37 cases
Where it cites § 72-719
“The primary issue presented by appellant is that the Commission erred in refusing to grant a modification of the previous award as sought in his application for a hearing.”
The case’s holding
An industrial commission has the authority to review a prior workmen’s compensation award if the circumstances demonstrate that the award was manifestly unjust.
Later courts cite it for
“the term 'manifest injustice' as a ground for reopening and review of an order must be construed broadly.” · 1 citing court
2
GREENFrank v. Bunker Hill Co., 124 P.3d 1002 (Idaho 2005).
cites § 72-719 39×subsections: (1) 6×cited by 16 cases
Where it cites § 72-719
“On June 4,1991, Bunker Hill responded to the application for hearing, asserting that Frank’s claim for additional disability benefits was barred by the statute of limitations in Idaho Code § 72-719 . The parties stipulated to present the following issues for determination: (1)…”
Later courts cite it for
“(1) the other party's arguments are not well grounded in fact, warranted by existing law, or made in good faith, and (2) the claims were brought for an improper purpose, such as unnecessary delay or increase in the costs of litigation.” · 2 citing courts
3
GREENFowler v. City of Rexburg, 773 P.2d 269 (Idaho 1989).
cites § 72-719 66×subsections: (1) 8×cited by 11 cases
Where it cites § 72-719
“For the following reasons, we reject Fowler's contentions and affirm the decision of the Industrial Commission.”
Later courts cite it for
“income benefits payable under the workmen's compensation law, with the exception of retraining benefits, i.c. 72-450, are based upon disability, either temporary or permanent, but not merely impairment.” · 4 citing courts
4
GREENWoodvine v. Triangle Dairy, Inc., 682 P.2d 1263 (Idaho 1984).
cites § 72-719 28×cited by 41 cases
Where it cites § 72-719
“§ 72-706(2), or alternatively, to reopen and modify the third compensation agreement pursuant to I.C. § 72-719. Claimant alleged that he was in fact 100% disabled according to the "odd lot" doctrine.”
The case’s holding
A commission decision is final and conclusive only as to the matters actually adjudicated therein.
Later courts cite it for
“when the legislature changes the language of a statute, it is presumed that they intended to change the application or meaning of that statute.” · 3 citing courts
5
GREENBanzhaf v. Carnation Co., 662 P.2d 1144 (Idaho 1983).
cites § 72-719 36×subsections: (3) 20×cited by 13 cases
Where it cites § 72-719
“It is well recognized that a compensation agreement approved by the Industrial Commission is equivalent to an award under the Idaho Workmen's Compensation laws.”
Later courts cite it for
“by our holding today we are making it known that claimants, and in some instances, employers and their sureties, are not precluded from making the same motion, ...” · 1 citing court
6
GREENKindred v. Amalgamated Sugar Co., 756 P.2d 401 (Idaho 1988).
cites § 72-719 24×cited by 25 cases
Where it cites § 72-719
“Primarily, there are two issues in this appeal: (1) Whether a claimant can only seek modifications of his worker's compensation award pursuant to I.C. § 72-719, as provided on the face of the compensation agreement; (2) Whether the Industrial Commission inappropriately applied…”
The case’s holding
A compensation agreement operates as res judicata only regarding the specific matters it decided and does not bar claims for benefits not addressed in the agreement.
Later courts cite it for
“tjhese retraining benefits were not awarded pursuant to the compensation agreement filed in september, 1976.” · 1 citing court
7
GREENFrank v. Bunker Hill Co., 792 P.2d 815 (Idaho 1990).
cites § 72-719 54×subsections: (3) 8× (1)(a) 6×cited by 5 cases
Where it cites § 72-719
“I.C. § 72-719 provides: Modification of awards and agreements — Grounds — Time within which made.”
Later courts cite it for
“date of first manifestation of an occupational disease” · 1 citing court
8
GREENIverson v. Gordon Farming Co., 650 P.2d 669 (Idaho 1982).
cites § 72-719 36×subsections: (3) 36×cited by 9 cases
Where it cites § 72-719
“Following this dismissal, Iverson, through new counsel, filed a motion to reopen the case before the Industrial Commission on March 27, 1978, under I.C. § 72-719(3) [1] claiming that the case required reopening in order to correct a manifest injustice.”
9
GREENWalters v. Blincoe's Magic Valley Packing Co., 787 P.2d 225 (Idaho 1990).
cites § 72-719 42×cited by 4 cases
Where it cites § 72-719
“Blincoe's Magic Valley Packing Company (the employer) and General Insurance Company of America (the employer's surety) contend that *226 I.C. § 72-719 governs the case and that the application was filed too late.”
Later courts cite it for
“if compensation is discontinued more than five (5) years from the date of the accident causing the injury.” · 2 citing courts
10
GREENSund v. Gambrel, 896 P.2d 329 (Idaho 1995).
cites § 72-719 12×cited by 11 cases
Where it cites § 72-719
“Such “final and conclusive” awards cannot be modified for any reason unless modification is sought under I.C. § 72-719 within five years of the date of the accident causing the injury.”
Later courts cite it for
“no authority to award attorney fees against an unsuccessful worker's compensation claimant.” · 2 citing courts
11
GREENReynolds v. Browning Ferris Indus., 751 P.2d 113 (Idaho 1988).
cites § 72-719 8×cited by 19 cases
Where it cites § 72-719
“Also, Reynolds had filed with the Commission on July 22, 1983, an Application for Hearing pursuant to I.C. § 72-719, in order to obtain benefits as the result of a change of condition.”
The case’s holding
The commission must retain jurisdiction or issue an award accounting for both present and probable future disability when a claimant has a progressive impairment.
Later courts cite it for
“whenever the commission explicitly retains jurisdiction over a matter, that act by its very nature infers that there is neither a final determination of the case nor a final permanent award to the employee.” · 3 citing courts
12
GREENWelch v. Del Monte Corp., 915 P.2d 1371 (Idaho 1996).
cites § 72-719 10×subsections: (3) 8×cited by 12 cases
Where it cites § 72-719
“Section 72-719. Modification of awards and agreements — Grounds—Time within which made.”
Later courts cite it for
“an administrative agency is a creature of statute, limited to the power and authority granted it by the legislature....” · 3 citing courts
13
GREENCharles Hartgrave v. City of Twin Falls & SIF, 413 P.3d 747 (Idaho 2018).
cites § 72-719 4×subsections: (3) 4×cited by 10 cases
Where it cites § 72-719
“Hartgrave moved the Commission to reopen the record under Idaho Code section 72-719(3) to correct manifest injustice, contending new evidence would show that he will likely need yet another right TKA.”
14
GREENEdwards v. Harold L. Harris Constr., 856 P.2d 96 (Idaho 1993).
cites § 72-719 16×cited by 5 cases
Where it cites § 72-719
“We decline the invitation to address whether I.C. § 72-719 permits the Commission to increase a prior award, because the claimant did not preserve the issue for appeal.”
15
GREENGordon v. West, 645 P.2d 334 (Idaho 1982).
cites § 72-719 4×subsections: (3) 4×cited by 41 cases
Where it cites § 72-719
“2d 331 (1982) (holding that it is within the power of the Industrial Commission under I.C. § 72-719(3) to review a previous workmen's compensation award in a case in which the circumstances demonstrate that the award was manifestly unjust).”
The case’s holding
A claimant must establish a prima facie case of odd lot status by proving the unavailability of suitable work in any occupation rather than just the inability to perform previous duties.
Later courts cite it for
“to prove the unavailability of suitable work in attempting to establish his alleged total disability,” · 3 citing courts
16
GREENHorton v. Garrett Freightlines, Inc., 772 P.2d 119 (Idaho 1989).
cites § 72-719 4×cited by 29 cases
Where it cites § 72-719
“Reynolds in turn sought an upward modification of his benefits on grounds of change of condition, I.C. § 72-719, but then moved the Commission to hold in abeyance any determination of a permanent disability rating.”
The case’s holding
An employer is liable only for the additional disability resulting from an industrial injury and not for disability caused by pre-existing conditions that were not aggravated by the injury.
Later courts cite it for
“in cases of permanent disability less than total, if the degree or duration of disability resulting from an industrial injury or occupational disease is increased or prolonged because of a preexisting physical impairment, the employer shall be liable only for the additional disability from the industrial injury or occupational disease.” · 1 citing court
17
GREENPage v. McCain Foods, Inc., 179 P.3d 265 (Idaho 2008).
cites § 72-719 4×subsections: (3) 4×cited by 12 cases
Where it cites § 72-719
“Hicks after missing her November 26, 2001, appointment with Dr. Petersen, and furthermore, that Page has since followed up with Dr.”
The case’s holding
When the Commission apportions permanent disability to exclude preexisting conditions, it must explain its rationale in sufficient detail to permit appellate review for substantial and competent evidence.
Later courts cite it for
“there is a presumption that the commission by its experience is able to judge the causative factors in a particular case, and the commission is 'allowed a degree of latitude in making an apportionment.” · 2 citing courts
18
GREENWalker v. Hensley Trucking, 691 P.2d 1187 (Idaho 1984).
cites § 72-719 4×cited by 25 cases
Where it cites § 72-719
“" Notwithstanding that the industrial case was closed, other than for re-opening on change of condition within five years pursuant to I.C. § 72-719, Argonaut filed a petition with the Industrial Commission asking that the Commission declare Argonaut's subrogation interest in…”
Later courts cite it for
“a well-settled rule of construction is that the words of a statute must be given their plain, usual and ordinary meaning in the absence of any ambiguity.” · 1 citing court
19
GREENUrry v. Walker & Fox Masonry Contractors, 769 P.2d 1122 (Idaho 1989).
cites § 72-719 4×cited by 21 cases
Where it cites § 72-719
“This, he claims, is a "manifest injustice" warranting modification of the agreement under I.C. § 72-719. We will consider in a moment whether the Commission made a correct evaluation of impairment resulting from *1125 the 1984 accident.”
The case’s holding
Pain relating to functional loss is a medical factor that must be considered when determining impairment rather than being treated merely as a nonmedical factor in determining disability.
Later courts cite it for
“if a decision, taken as a whole, appears to reflect a misapprehension of law, the proper appellate response is to vacate the decision and to remand the case for reconsideration in light of the proper legal framework.” · 4 citing courts
20
GREENMatthews v. Dep't of Corr., 827 P.2d 693 (Idaho 1992).
cites § 72-719 8×cited by 6 cases
Where it cites § 72-719
“I.C. § 72-719. Also challenged is the Commission’s denial of Matthews’ request for further medical benefits.”

Show all 44 citing cases (list view) →

The flag is Syfertize’s treatment of the citing case itself, not of the statute. “Where it cites” is the passage in the opinion; the holding is a summary of the whole case and may concern another point. Annotations are extracted automatically from the opinions in the Syfert caselaw corpus.

Citing cases by year
197519972019

One bar per year. Tallest: 6 cases in 1989. These are opinions in the Syfert collection, which holds more of some courts’ recent opinions than their older ones, so a rise can reflect what the collection holds and not more litigation.

By subsection
(1)3 cases
Frank v. Bunker Hill Co., 124 P.3d 1002 (Idaho 2005).“On June 4,1991, Bunker Hill responded to the application for hearing, asserting that Frank’s claim for additional disability benefits was barred by the statute of limitations in Idaho Code § 72-719 . The parties stipulated to present the following issues for determination: (1)…”
Fowler v. City of Rexburg, 773 P.2d 269 (Idaho 1989).“For the following reasons, we reject Fowler's contentions and affirm the decision of the Industrial Commission.”
Davis v. Hammack Mgmt., Inc., 391 P.3d 1261 (Idaho 2017).
(1)(a)7 cases
Sines v. Appel, 644 P.2d 331 (Idaho 1982).“The primary issue presented by appellant is that the Commission erred in refusing to grant a modification of the previous award as sought in his application for a hearing.”
Frank v. Bunker Hill Co., 792 P.2d 815 (Idaho 1990).“I.C. § 72-719 provides: Modification of awards and agreements — Grounds — Time within which made.”
Lampe v. Zamzow's, Inc., 626 P.2d 782 (Idaho 1981).
Ayala v. Robert J. Meyers Farms, Inc., 445 P.3d 164 (Idaho 2019).
Magee v. Thompson Creek Mining Co., 268 P.3d 464 (Idaho 2012).
Showing the top 5 of 7. More in the list view →
(1)(b)1 case
Brannon v. Pike, 737 P.2d 459 (Idaho 1987).
(3)15 cases
Sines v. Appel, 644 P.2d 331 (Idaho 1982).
Iverson v. Gordon Farming Co., 650 P.2d 669 (Idaho 1982).“Following this dismissal, Iverson, through new counsel, filed a motion to reopen the case before the Industrial Commission on March 27, 1978, under I.C. § 72-719(3) [1] claiming that the case required reopening in order to correct a manifest injustice.”
Banzhaf v. Carnation Co., 662 P.2d 1144 (Idaho 1983).“It is well recognized that a compensation agreement approved by the Industrial Commission is equivalent to an award under the Idaho Workmen's Compensation laws.”
Charles Hartgrave v. City of Twin Falls & SIF, 413 P.3d 747 (Idaho 2018).“Hartgrave moved the Commission to reopen the record under Idaho Code section 72-719(3) to correct manifest injustice, contending new evidence would show that he will likely need yet another right TKA.”
Welch v. Del Monte Corp., 915 P.2d 1371 (Idaho 1996).“Section 72-719. Modification of awards and agreements — Grounds—Time within which made.”
Showing the top 5 of 15. More in the list view →

Show all 44 citing cases (list view) →

Enactment and amendments

Syfert holds no separate history line for this section. Where this code prints a source or history note, it appears with the text, usually at the end.

Versions

Edition shown: text as last checked Oct. 2026 (this copy records no edition or section history). Syfert holds no earlier or later version of this section.

Idaho Code Home  |  Search Idaho  |  Search cases for this section  |  syfert.com