#1
green
In re Williams, 183 Cal. 11 (1920)
In habeas corpus, the prisoner bears the burden to prove a police court conviction was void for lack of complaint or trial; conflicting evidence does not meet it.
A prisoner held on a vagrancy conviction from a San Francisco police court petitioned for habeas corpus, alleging no complaint was filed, no trial occurred, and he was denied a chance to obtain witnesses. The court considers whether the record shows the court lacked jurisdiction or denied due process. Conflicting evidence shows a complaint was likely filed, and the presumption of official duty applies. The burden of proof rested on the prisoner, and the conflicting testimony did not establish the absence of a trial. The writ is discharged and the prisoner remanded.
co-cited 12×
#2
neutral
In re Horr, 177 Cal. 721 (1918)
Quick Summary
Generate summary
co-cited 9×
#3
green
In re Vitalie, 117 Cal. App. 553 (Ct. App. 1931)
Quick Summary
Generate summary
co-cited 6×
#4
neutral
In re Kaster, 52 Cal. App. 454 (Ct. App. 1921)
Quick Summary
Generate summary
co-cited 5×
#5
green
In re Application of Gutierrez, 46 Cal. App. 94 (Ct. App. 1920)
Quick Summary
Generate summary
co-cited 5×
#6
neutral
In re Stevenson, 187 Cal. 773 (1922)
Quick Summary
Generate summary
co-cited 5×
#7
green
In re Drew, 188 Cal. 717 (1922)
Habeas corpus review is limited to jurisdictional defects, and prior final adjudications on the validity of the underlying judgment are conclusive against the petitioner.
A petitioner seeks a writ of habeas corpus to challenge a contempt judgment for failing to appear for a supplementary examination in a different county. The court examines whether the underlying judgment is void due to the corporation's alleged nonexistence and whether the examination location and referee appointment were valid. The court applies the rule that habeas corpus review is limited to jurisdictional defects and that prior final adjudications on the validity of the underlying judgment are conclusive. Because the petitioner previously litigated and lost the argument regarding the corporation's existence, that issue is barred. The court further holds that the statute authorizing examinations in the debtor's county of residence permits the examination in San Francisco and that the referee's residency does not affect jurisdiction. The court denies the writ.
co-cited 5×
#8
green
Mooney v. Holohan, 294 U.S. 103 (1935)
Due process is violated when a state procures a conviction through the knowing use of perjured testimony and the deliberate suppression of impeachment evidence.
A prisoner seeks a writ of habeas corpus, alleging that his conviction for murder was obtained through the knowing use of perjured testimony and the deliberate suppression of impeachment evidence by prosecuting authorities. The State contends that the actions of a prosecutor do not, in themselves, constitute a denial of due process unless they deprive a defendant of notice or the opportunity to present evidence. The Court rejects this narrow view, holding that due process is violated when a State procures a conviction through a pretense of a trial involving the deliberate deception of the court and jury. However, because the petitioner has not yet invoked the state's available writ of habeas corpus, the Court declines to grant leave to file the petition at this time.
co-cited 4×
#9
green
In re Stambaugh, 117 Cal. App. 659 (Ct. App. 1931)
Quick Summary
Generate summary
co-cited 4×
#10
green
Ex parte Long, 114 Cal. 159 (1896)
Quick Summary
Generate summary
co-cited 4×
#11
green
Ex parte Williams, 121 Cal. 328 (1898)
A habeas corpus petition cannot substitute for a demurrer; a complaint is sufficient if its facts state an offense within the court's jurisdiction, however imperfectly pleaded.
Petitioner was convicted in a justice's court of a misdemeanor for obtaining food and lodging at a boarding house without paying, with intent to defraud, and sought habeas corpus, challenging the complaint's sufficiency and the statute's constitutionality. The court upheld the statute's validity. It held that a habeas proceeding cannot serve as a demurrer, so the complaint is tested by whether its facts state an offense, however imperfectly pleaded. Because the complaint alleged nonpayment with intent to defraud, it stated an offense under the first clause. The writ is denied.
co-cited 4×
#12
green
Harlan v. McGourin, 218 U.S. 442 (1910)
A writ of habeas corpus examines only the power and authority of the court to act rather than the correctness of its legal conclusions.
Petitioners convicted of peonage-related conspiracy seek habeas corpus relief, arguing the trial court lacked jurisdiction and the evidence was insufficient. The court holds that habeas corpus is limited to examining the power and authority of the court to act, not the correctness of its conclusions. It rejects the argument that the writ allows review of evidentiary sufficiency or procedural errors that do not render the judgment void. The court finds the trial court had legal authority to sit and that the petitioners failed to demonstrate a lack of jurisdiction. Consequently, the writ cannot be used to substitute for a writ of error or to re-examine the merits of the conviction.
co-cited 3×