United States v. Awkard
Expert testimony regarding the efficacy of hypnosis is improper unless the witness's ability to recall is first challenged by the adversary.
In a prison murder trial, the government called a medical expert to testify before the witness regarding the reliability of hypnosis and the witness's specific memory refreshment. The defendants objected, arguing the testimony improperly bolstered credibility without prior attack. The court holds that while hypnotically refreshed evidence is admissible, expert testimony on the efficacy of hypnosis is improper unless the witness's ability to recall is first challenged by the adversary. Furthermore, expert opinion on a specific witness's credibility is inadmissible under Federal Rule of Evidence 608(a), which limits such testimony to character for truthfulness. The court finds the trial judge erred by failing to exercise discretion and allowing the expert to opine on the witness's specific recall. However, the error is not prejudicial because other evidence sufficiently supported the convictions.
At page 671Limiting opinion testimony on witness credibility23 citing cases“under the federal rules, opinion testimony on credibility is limited to character; all other opinions on credibility are for the jurors themselves to form.”
- United States v. Ute Jarlik Bell, 585 F. App'x 552 (9th Cir. 2014).unpublishedWe reverse nonconstitutional errors in admitting evidence “if it is more probable than not that the erroneous admission of the evidence materially affected the jurors’ verdict.” United States v. Awkard, 597 F.2d 667, 671 (9th Cir.1979).
- United States v. Charles J. SANCHEZ, Jr., 176 F.3d 1214 (9th Cir. 1999).publishedWe noted that “[t]his court has already held that opinion evidence regarding a witness’ credibility is inadmissible.” Id. (citing United States v. Awkard, 597 F.2d 667, 671 (9th Cir.1979) and United States v. Binder, 769 F.2d 595, 602 (9th…
- State v. Raymond, 540 N.W.2d 407 (S.D. 1995).publishedFurthermore, the Ninth Circuit has held that opinion testimony on credibility is limited to character and “all other opinions on credibility are for the juror themselves to form.” United States v. Awkard, 597 F.2d 667, 671 (9th Cir.1979).
- United States v. Jose Arambula-Ruiz, 987 F.2d 599 (9th Cir. 1993).publishedThis court reverses for nonconstitutional errors in admitting evidence “ ‘only if it is more probable than not that the erroneous admission of the evidence materially affected the jurors' verdict.’ ” United States v. Bettencourt, 614 F.2d…
- State v. Johnson, 810 P.2d 1138 (Idaho Ct. App. 1991).publishedSee also United States v. Samara, 643 F.2d 701 (10th Cir.) cert. denied, 454 U.S. 829 , 102 S.Ct. 122 , 70 L.Ed.2d 104 (1981), reh. denied, 454 U.S. 1094 , 102 S.Ct. 662 , 70 L.Ed.2d 633 (1981); United States v. Awkard, 597 F.2d 667, 671 (…
- State v. Hoyt, 806 P.2d 204 (Utah Ct. App. 1991).publishedUnited States v. Awkard, 597 F.2d 667, 671 (9th Cir.), cert. denied, 444 U.S. 885 , 100 S.Ct. 179 , 62 L.Ed.2d 116 (1979).
- State v. Rimmasch, 775 P.2d 388 (Utah 1989).publishedSee, e.g., United States v. Azure, 801 F.2d 336, 341 (8th Cir.1986) (construing Federal Rule of Evidence 608(a), which is the model for Utah’s rule); United States v. Awkard, 597 F.2d 667, 671 (9th Cir.), cert. denied, 444 U.S. 885 , 100 S…
- United States v. Diane Candoli, 870 F.2d 496 (9th Cir. 1989).publishedEvid. 608(a); United States v. Awkard, 597 F.2d 667, 671 (9th Cir.) (under the Federal Rules, opinion testimony on credibility is limited to character for truthfulness), cert. denied, 444 U.S. 885 , 100 S.Ct. 179 , 62 L.Ed.2d 116 (1979).
- United States v. Gordon Wayne Roy, 843 F.2d 305 (8th Cir. 1988).publishedSee Delaware v. Van Arsdall, 475 U.S. 673 , 106 S.Ct. 1431, 1438 , 89 L.Ed.2d 674 (1986); United States v. Awkard, 597 F.2d 667, 671-72 (9th Cir.), cert. denied, 444 U.S. 885 , 100 S.Ct. 179 , 62 L.Ed.2d 116 (1979) (improper expert opinion…
- United States v. Ronald Cecil, United States of Am. v. Patrick Haddix, United States of Am. v. Odus Hayes, 836 F.2d 1431 (4th Cir. 1988).published Again, in United States v. Awkard, 597 F.2d 667, 671 (9th Cir.1979), cert. denied, 444 U.S. 885 and 969, 100 S.Ct. 179 and 460, 62 L.Ed.2d 116 and 383, the court reiterated its decision in Barnard, supra, adding: Under the Federal Rules, o…
Show 13 more citing cases
- United States v. Cox, 23 M.J. 808 (N.M.C.M.R. 1986).publishedDuring the subsequent cross, redirect, and recross examinations, however, the pertinent portions of which have been set forth above, the testimony elicited from the witness went well beyond any permissible avenues of examination and invade…
- United States v. Terry Lee Rhodes, 713 F.2d 463 (9th Cir. 1983).publishedA conviction will be reversed as a result of a nonconstitutional error only if it is “more probable than not” that the error “materially affected the verdict.” United States v. Valle-Valdez, 554 F.2d 911, 916 (9th Cir.1977); Hamling v. Uni…
- United States v. James ("Jake") Rohrer, United States of Am. v. John Bump, 708 F.2d 429 (9th Cir. 1983).publishedFed.R.Crim.P. 52(a); United States v. Mehrmanesh, 689 F.2d 822, 832 (9th Cir.1982); United States v. Awkard, 597 F.2d 667, 671 (9th Cir.1979), cert. denied, 444 U.S. 885 , 100 S.Ct. 179 , 62 L.Ed.2d 116 (1979); United States v. Valle-Valde…
- United States v. David G. Bettencourt, 614 F.2d 214 (9th Cir. 1980).publishedThis circuit’s standard for reviewing non-constitutional errors in admitting evidence is that “these errors are reversible only if it is more probable than not that the erroneous admission of the evidence materially affected the jurors’ ve…
- United States v. Jack Alan Geston, United States of Am. v. Jack Alan Geston, 299 F.3d 1130 (9th Cir. 2002).published(recognizing that credibility determinations are for the jury)
- United States v. Gabriel SANCHEZ-LIMA, 161 F.3d 545 (9th Cir. 1998).publishedSee United States v. Awkard, 597 F.2d 667, 671 (9th Cir.1979).
- United States v. Williams, 26 M.J. 487 (C.M.A. 1988).published See United States v. Awkard, 597 F.2d 667, 671 (9th Cir.), cert. denied, 444 U.S. 885 , 100 S.Ct. 179 , 62 L.Ed.2d 116 (1979).
- United States v. Guinn Dutton Hodges, 770 F.2d 1475 (9th Cir. 1985).published See United States v. Awkard, 597 F.2d 667, 671 (9th Cir.), cert. denied, 444 U.S. 885 , 100 S.Ct. 179 , 62 L.Ed.2d 116 and 444 U.S. 969 , 100 S.Ct. 460 , 62 L.Ed.2d 383 (1979); United States v. Barnard, 490 F.2d 907, 912 (9th Cir.1973), ce…
- United States v. Mark Kevin Binder, 769 F.2d 595 (9th Cir. 1985).published Accord United States v. Awkard, 597 F.2d 667 , 671 (9th Cir.), cert. denied, 444 U.S. 885 , 100 S.Ct. 179 , 62 L.Ed.2d 116 (1979).
- United States v. Anthony Damian Azure, 801 F.2d 336 (8th Cir. 1986).published
- Commonwealth v. Seese, 517 A.2d 920 (Pa. 1986).published
- Mason v. Texaco, Inc., 741 F. Supp. 1472 (D. Kan. 1990).published
- United States v. Woodall, 23 F. App'x 765 (9th Cir. 2001).unpublished
At page 669Hypnosis affecting evidence credibility but not admissibility16 citing casesholding “[t]he fact of hypnosis, if disclosed to the jury, may affect the credibility of evidence, but not its admissibility
- State Of Washington v. Randy L. Donaldson, No. 55942-1 (Wash. Ct. App. Oct. 24, 2023).unpublished(The fact of hypnosis, if disclosed to the jury, may affect the credibility of evidence, but not its admissibility.)
- United States v. D.W.B., 74 M.J. 630 (N.M.C.C.A. 2015).published Awkard, 597 F.2d at 669, n. 2 (emphasis added) (citation omitted).
- United States v. Burris, 74 M.J. 630 (N.M.C.C.A. 2015).published If the trial court overrules the objection and permits the subject to testify, the adverse party may, if it wishes, expose the details of the hypnosis to the jury. 17 Awkard, 597 F.2d at 669, n.2 (emphasis added) (citation omitted).
- William Harold Mancuso v. Ana M. Olivarez, 292 F.3d 939 (9th Cir. 2002).published(holding “[t]he fact of hypnosis, if disclosed to the jury, may affect the credibility of evidence, but not its admissibility)
- Burral v. State, 724 A.2d 65 (Md. 1999).published See also Armstrong v. Young, 34 F.3d 421, 429-30 (7th Cir.1994), reh’g denied en banc; Boykin v. Leapley, 28 F.3d 788, 793 (8th Cir.1994); White v. Ieyoub, 25 F.3d 245, 247 (5th Cir.1994); Beachum v. Tansy, 903 F.2d 1321, 1326 (10th Cir.),…
- Kevin Coe v. Larry Kincheloe, 5 F.3d 535 (9th Cir. 1993).publishedHypnosis "may affect the credibility of evidence but not its admissibility." United States v. Awkard, 597 F.2d 667, 669 (9th Cir.), cert. denied, 444 U.S. 885 (1979). 3 The Superior Court was painstaking in its review of the testimony of t…
- United States v. Verl Hadley, 918 F.2d 848 (9th Cir. 1990).publishedSolomon, 753 F.2d at 1525 , quoting United States v. Awkard, 597 F.2d 667, 669 (9th Cir.), cert. denied, 444 U.S. 885 , 969, 100 S.Ct. 179 , 460, 62 L.Ed.2d 116, 383 (1979).
- United States v. Walter D. Brodie, United States of Am. v. Nancy A. Brodie, 858 F.2d 492 (9th Cir. 1988).publishedSolomon, 753 F.2d at 1525 ; United States v. Awkard, 597 F.2d 667, 669 (9th Cir.), cert. denied, 444 U.S. 885 , 100 S.Ct. 179 , 62 L.Ed.2d 116 (1979).
- United States v. Charles Langford, 802 F.2d 1176 (9th Cir. 1986).published See United States v. Solomon, 753 F.2d 1522, 1525 (9th Cir.1985) (quoting United States v. Awkard, 597 F.2d 667, 669 (9th Cir.), cert. denied, 444 U.S. 885 , 100 S.Ct. 179 , 62 L.Ed.2d 116 and 444 U.S. 969 , 100 S.Ct. 460 , 62 L.Ed.2d 383…
- United States v. Louella G. Solomon, United States of Am. v. John Elias Wesley, 753 F.2d 1522 (9th Cir. 1985).publishedUnited States v. Awkard, 597 F.2d 667, 669 (9th Cir.), cert. denied, 444 U.S. 885 , 969, 100 S.Ct. 179 , 460, 62 L.Ed.2d 116, 383 (1979).
Show 6 more citing cases
- State v. Seager, 341 N.W.2d 420 (Iowa 1983).publishedUnited States v. Awkard, 597 F.2d 667, 669 (9th Cir.), cert denied, 444 U.S. 885 , 100 S.Ct. 179 , 62 L.Ed.2d 116 (1979); United States v. Adams, 581 F.2d 193, 198 (9th Cir.), cert. denied, 439 U.S. 1006 , 99 S.Ct. 621 , 58 L.Ed.2d 683 (19…
- State v. Collins, 464 A.2d 1028 (Md. 1983).published Cases in the first category holding that the fact a witness has been hypnotized goes to weight and credibility and not to admissibility include: United States v. Awkard, 597 F.2d 667, 669 (9th Cir.1979), cert. denied, 444 U.S. 885 and 444…
- State v. Hurd, 414 A.2d 291 (N.J. Super. Ct. App. Div. 1980).publishedThus, in the case of United States v. Awkard, 597 F. 2d 667, 669 (9 Cir.1979), the court noted that "pretrial hypnosis of witnesses is permitted in this circuit in both criminal and civil cases." The court noted that the use of hypnosis af…
- William Harold Mancuso v. Ana M. Olivarez, 282 F.3d 728 (9th Cir. 2002).published(holding “[t]he fact of hypnosis, if disclosed to the jury, may affect the credibility of evidence, but not its admissibility)
- United States v. Walter Harvey, United States of Am. v. Raphael Clark, 756 F.2d 636 (8th Cir. 1985).published See United States v. Awkard, 597 F.2d 667, 669 (9th Cir.), cert. denied, 444 U.S. 885 , 100 S.Ct. 179 , 62 L.Ed.2d 116 (1979).
- United States v. George Michael Gwaltney, 790 F.2d 1378 (9th Cir. 1986).published
At page 670Limiting trial judge discretion in admitting expert testimony3 citing casesreversing where trial court erroneously concluded admission of expert testimony was required under appellate precedent
- United States v. Timothy Alexander, 76 F.3d 388 (9th Cir. 1996).unpublishedSee, e.g., United States v. Binder, 769 F.2d 595, 601-02 (9th Cir.1985); United States v. Awkard, 597 F.2d 667, 670-71 (9th Cir.), cert. denied, 444 U.S. 885 (1979).
- United States v. Sharon Ann Rahm, 993 F.2d 1405 (9th Cir. 1993).published (reversing where trial court erroneously concluded admission of expert testimony was required under appellate precedent)
- State v. Centeno-Sarabia, No. 1 CA-CR 11-0803 (Ariz. Ct. App. Dec. 11, 2014).unpublished(witness’s ability to recall was relevant to credibility but “had nothing to do with his character)
At page 668cited at this page1 citing case
- Fred F. Thomas v. Joe C. Martinez, 2 F.3d 1158 (9th Cir. 1993).unpublishedSee id.; cf. United States v. Awkard, 597 F.2d 667, 668 (9th Cir.) (testimony of witnesses who have undergone hypnosis is admissible in the Ninth Circuit), cert. denied, 444 U.S. 885 (1979).
At page 667“the fact of hypnosis, if disclosed to the jury, may affect the credibility of evidence, but not its admissibility”0 citing cases
Other citing cases
- David Watkins Harker v. State of Maryland, 800 F.2d 437 (4th Cir. 1986).published
- United States v. Cameron, 21 M.J. 59 (C.M.A. 1985).published
- Vivian Sprynczynatyk v. Gen. Motors Corp., 771 F.2d 1112 (8th Cir. 1985).published
- United States v. Wagner, 20 M.J. 758 (A.F.C.M.R. 1985).published
- United States v. Harrington, 18 M.J. 797 (A.C.M.R. 1984).published
- Bundy v. State, 455 So. 2d 330 (Fla. 1984).published
- Vester v. State, 684 S.W.2d 715 (Tex. App.—Amarillo 1984).published
- State v. Brown, 337 N.W.2d 138 (N.D. 1983).published
- United States v. Charles, 561 F. Supp. 694 (S.D. Tex. 1983).published
- State v. Culpepper, 434 So. 2d 76 (La. Ct. App. 1982).published
Show 2 more citing cases
- Pearson v. State, 441 N.E.2d 468 (Ind. 1982).published
- State v. Mena, 624 P.2d 1274 (Ariz. 1981).published
v.
George L. AWKARD, Appellant UNITED STATES of America v. John Wright WILLIAMS, Appellant UNITED STATES of America v. Clarence HINNANT, Jr., Appellant UNITED STATES of America v. Paul Milton LANEY, Appellant UNITED STATES of America v. Richard Lafayette THOMPSON
Five defendants, convicted of a prison murder, appeal. They assert, among other assignments, that the court erred in permitting a government witness to testify about events recalled only after hypnosis, and in permitting the medical expert who hypnotized the witness to testify in a manner prejudicial to the defendants.
The government witness, Hackney, was one of several inmates who had stabbed Lewis, a fellow prisoner, in the prison’s group activities center. After being granted immunity, Hackney began to recall the names of other prisoners he said were in on the stabbing. Aided by hypnosis, Hackney remembered still others who he claimed participated in the crime.
At trial, the government called Dr. William Kroger, the expert who had hypnotized and interrogated Hackney. Kroger was qualified as an internationally respect¿cTauthority on medical hypnosis, and he explained the techniques used in hypnosis. The prosecution then had the doctor express his opinions about the reliability of hypnotic stimulation in enhancing the memory of past events, and about whether Hackney in particular had had his memory accurately refreshed. At the government’s request, this expert testimony was brought in “out of order”, before Hackney testified, and hence before Hackney’s credibility had been called into question.
Defendants object, first, to the use of hypnosis to refresh Hackney’s recollection. This objection is without merit. The use of hypnotically adduced evidence has gained acceptance in many jurisdictions.[1] Pretrial hypnosis of witnesses is permitted in this^afCuTt'Tn both criminal and civil cases. The fact of hypnosis, if disclosed to the jury, may affect the credibility of evidence, but not its admissibility. United States v. Adams, 581 F.2d 193, 198-99 (9th Cir. 1978); Kline v. Ford Motor Co., 523 F.2d 1067, 1069-70 (9th Cir. 1975). There was, no error in admitting Hackney’s hypnotically .refreshed recollections.
More troublesome is the testimony of the prosecution’s hypnosis expert, Dr. Kroger. Defendants object that the court erred in refusing to exercise discretion regarding that testimony, and that the testimony improperly buttressed Hackney’s credibility.
In jurisdictions in which the admissibility’ of hypnotically refreshed evidence’Ts’stfll an open question, a foundation concerning the reliability of hypnosis is no doubt necessary. See, e. g., Harding v. State, 5 Md.App. 230, 246 A.2d 302 (1968), cert. denied, 395 U.S. 949, 89 S.Ct. 2030, 23 L.Ed.2d 468 (1969). But admissibility of such evidence has not been an issue in the federal hurts of this circuit since Wyller v. Fairchild Hiller Corp., 503 F.2d 506, 509-10 (9th Cir. 1974), Because there is no issue about the admission of hypnotically refreshed evidence,, there is no need for a foundation concerning the nature and effects of hypnosis.[2]
It was therefore unnecessary for Kroger to testify in advance of Hackney about the technique of hypnosis. The government urges, nevertheless, that there was no error in allowing Kroger to take the stand. The government asserts that the use of expert testimony is within the discretion of the trial court. This general proposition is correct. “The general test regarding the admissibility of expert testimony is whether the jury can receive ‘appreciable help’ from such testimony. The balancing of the probative value of the tendered expert testimony evidence against its prejudi[*670]eial effect is committed to the ‘broad discretion’ of the trial judge * * United States v. Amaral, 488 F.2d 1148, 1152 (9th Cir. 1973) (citations omitted); see Fed.R. Evid. 702. Generally, the order of proof at trial is also a matter of discretion for the trial judge. United States v. Peterson, 549 F.2d 654, 657 (9th Cir. 1977).
In this instance, however, the dis■ict judge did not exercise discretion. In the face of the defendants’ objection that there was no need for Kroger to testify on the use or reliability of hypnosis, the court let the testimony come in without weighing the possibility of prejudice in having a nationally recognized expert testify as an oath-helper in support of Hackney. The trial judge read our decisions in Kline v. Ford Motor Co., supra, and Wyller v. Fair-child Hiller Corp., supra, as requiring the expert testimony to establish admissibility. As discussed above, this is not the rule.[3] The district court’s failure to exercise its discretion in admitting the expert testimony about hypnosis was therefore erroneous.
Moreover, several important considerations limit the discretion of the trial judge when the expert testimony concerns only the ability of a witness to recall details of past experience. In analogous areas, the Federal Rules of Evidence carefully restrict the bolstering of a witness’s testimony when the credibility of that witness has not been attacked. For example, prior consistent statements by a witness may not be introduced until an adverse party has charged the witness with recent fabrication or improper influence or motive. See Fed. R.Evid. 801(d)(1), and Advisory Committee note (C) thereto. Evidence of truthful character may be introduced only in the forms of opinion or reputation evidence, and only when the character of the witness for truthfulness has been attacked. See Fed.R.Evid. 608(a).
Similar considerations must govern the exercise of the trial judge’s discretion here. Unless an adverse party attacks the witness’s ability to recall by bringing out or exploring the fact of hypnosis, the use of expert testimony to support the efficacy of hypnosis is improper. The party calling a witness should not be permitted to inquire in any way into the witness’s ability to recall, or methods of pretrial memory refreshment, until such questions have been raised by the adversary.
In this case, before the introduction of Kroger’s testimony, defense counsel indicated that they preferred not to cross-examine Hackney about his hypnosis, given its current acceptance in the courts and Kroger’s credentials. If defendants strategically chose not to challenge the use of hypnosis, there was no purpose consistent with the Federal Rules in having the jury hear his testimony. Therefore, it was error to allow Kroger to take the stand at the time, and to testify in the manner described.
Even had the defense challenged Hackney on cross-examination because of his hypnosis, portions of Kroger’s testimony would have been inadmissible. In addition to testifying that he had hypnotized Hackney, and that hypnosis generally helps subjects to remember past events, the doctor stated his opinion that Hackney’s memory had been accurately refreshed by hypnosis. While Kroger’s testimony on the general nature and usual effects of hypnosis would have been proper had Hackney been challenged, Kroger’s opinion of its effects on Hackney would still have been inadmissible, under Fed.R.Evid. 608(a). That rule strictly limits opinion evidence on witness credibility -to “character for truthfulness or untruthfulness”; Hackney’s ability to recall the stabbing, while relevant to credibility, had nothing to do with his character. Thus,[*671] even if hypnosis of the witness had been raised as a ground for discrediting his testimony, Kroger should have been permitted to testify only about the general nature and usual effects of hypnosis, and the details of his hypnosis of Hackney.
“Credibility * * * is for the jury — the jury is the lie detector in the courtroom.” United States v. Barnard, 490 F.2d 907, 912 (9th Cir. 1973), cert. denied, 416 U.S. 959, 94 S.Ct. 1976, 40 L.Ed.2d 310 (1974). In Barnard, a case decided before the effective date of the Federal Rules, we upheld the district judge’s exclusion of expert psychiatric testimony that a defendant-witness was a sociopath who would lie if it was to his advantage to do so. We held that such evidence should be received only in unusual cases. Expert medical evidence on the effect of hypnosis on a particular witness’s ability to recall is inadmissible for the same reasons as those invoked in Barnard. Under the Federal Rules, opinion testimony on credibility is limited to character; all other opinions on credibility are for the jurors themselves to form.
Therefore, it was error to bring in the expert in this case, and to have him give an opinion on Hackney’s ability to recall the stabbing. It was also error to have Hackney testify on direct examination that he had been hypnotized. But these errors are reversible only if it is more probable than not that the erroneous admission of the evidence materially affected the jurors’ verdict against any of the five defendants. United States v. Valle-Valdez, 554 F.2d 911, 914-16 (9th Cir. 1977).[4]
Defendant Hinnant was the one most affected by Hackney’s posthypnosis testimony. Before hypnosis, Hackney had placed defendants Awkard, Williams, and Laney at the scene of the crime. Only after hypnosis, however, did Hackney recall Hinnant at the scene. (Hackney did not place Thompson at the scene at all.) The jury heard that it was hypnosis that enabled the witness to remember Hinnant’s involvement in the stabbing. It also heard that both before and after hypnosis, Hackney remembered seeing Awkard, Williams, and Laney at the stabbing.
But Hackney’s inculpation of Hinnant was only cumulative to more damaging testimony against Hinnant offered by another inmate, Alex. Hackney, aided by hypnosis and testifying under immunity, only recalled Hinnant leaning up against the wall of the group activities center while Lewis was stabbed. Alex, who also witnessed the murder, testified without either hypnosis or immunity that Hinnant participated in the stabbing by holding the struggling victim while another defendant stabbed him. Unlike Hackney, Alex also stated that Hinnant was holding a knife. And a fellow inmate testified that five months after the murder of Lewis, in a conversation about that crime, Hinnant said, “the nigger knew I was there”.
Even without Hackney’s testimony, there was also ample evidence to support the finding of guilt against the other four defendants. Alex testified that Laney, Thompson, and Awkard were at the scene of the murder. Another inmate testified that he saw Laney, wearing bloodstained clothes and with a knife in his hands, immediately after the stabbing. This witness also testified that Laney admitted holding the victim while Awkard stabbed him. A * third witness testified that Thompson had asked him for a knife shortly before the stabbing; a fourth, that Thompson later threatened “to take care of Pato [an inmate] like we did that dude in GAC [the group activities center], and I’ll take care of him in GAC style.”
Witnesses other than Hackney testified that Awkard was seen with Williams and Laney before and after the stabbing, and seen leaving the area of the murder with blood on him; that Awkard later admitted before other inmates that he had stabbed Lewis; that Awkard had said before the murder that “he was going to make an example” of the victim; and that Awkard actively recruited participants. Alex testified that Williams was stabbing the strug[*672]gling victim while Hinnant held him. These and other items of evidence make it more probable than not that the jury would have convicted these five men even if the trial court had allowed the defense to keep Kroger off the stand, and prevent Hackney from mentioning hypnosis. The error in admitting this testimony was not prejudicial.
Defendants have briefed and argued other assignments of error. Our study of the record and transcript convinces us that there was no reversible error in the proceedings below.
Affirmed.
See Note, Refreshing the Memory of a Witness Through Hypnosis, 5 U.C.L.A.—Ala.L. Rev. 266 (1976).
We have suggested procedures to be followed 1 during hypnosis to ensure that posthypnosis | statements are truly the subject’s own recollec-1 tions. United. Jitates. v. Adams, 581 F.2d at 1 198-99 and n.12. Objections to the subject , testimony on the ground that such procedures were not followed should be heard by the district judge before trial, or out of the presence of the jury on voir dire of the witness. If the trial court'overrules the objection and permits the® subject to testify, the adverse party may, if it] wishes, expose the details of the hypnosis to' the jury.
In Wyller, the hypnotist did testify, but only (after the fact of hypnosis had been attacked on ) cross-examination. As explained below, this is j crucially different from the situation here. In ¡j Kline, the hypnotist testified, not before the j jury, but in a hearing before the court. The ' court refused to admit the hypnotically recalled evidence because a sufficient foundation on the validity of hypnosis had not been laid. We reversed, noting that the fact of hypnosis did not affect admissibility. Any insufficiency of | the expert’s foundation was irrelevant to the ¡propriety of the witness’s testimony.
Defendants do not argue that the error here was of constitutional dimension.