Hartley v. CSX Transp., Inc., 187 F.3d 422 (4th Cir. 1999)
The party alleging fraudulent joinder bears a heavy burden to show that the plaintiff cannot establish a claim even after resolving all issues of law and fact in their favor.
A plaintiff sued a railroad and two state government entities in state court after a train collision. The railroad removed the case to federal court, arguing the government defendants were fraudulently joined to defeat diversity jurisdiction. The district court denied remand, holding state law barred the claims against the government entities. The Fourth Circuit reversed, applying the rule that the party alleging fraudulent joinder bears a heavy burden to show the plaintiff cannot establish a claim even after resolving all issues in the plaintiff's favor. Because the application of the public duty rule presented a novel legal question and factual uncertainties remained, the court found a glimmer of hope for recovery, ending the jurisdictional inquiry and requiring remand to state court.
At page 424Demonstrating fraudulent joinder to remove a case97 citing cases“this standard is even more favorable to the plaintiff than the standard for ruling on a motion to dismiss under fed.r.civ.p. 12(b)(6).”
- Giannetti v. Batth, No. 8:22-cv-00506 (D. Md. Sept. 29, 2022).(The party alleging fraudulent joinder bears a heavy burden—it must show that the plaintiff cannot establish a claim even after resolving all issues of law and fact in the plaintiff’s favor.)
- Crider v. Pilgrim's Pride Corp., No. 5:20-cv-02279 (D.S.C. Jan. 22, 2021). (There need be only a slight possibility of a right to relief. Once the court identifies this glimmer of hope for the plaintiff, the jurisdictional inquiry ends.)
- Montanaro v. State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins., 29 F. Supp. 3d 662 (D.S.C. 2014).published Dist., 519 F.Supp.2d at 614 ; see also Hartley, 187 F.3d at 425 (“[A] jurisdictional inquiry is not the appropriate stage of litigation to resolve these various uncertain questions of law and fact.”).
- Beaufort Cnty. Sch. Dist. v. United Nat. Ins. Co., 519 F. Supp. 2d 609 (D.S.C. 2007).published See Hartley, 187 F.3d at 425 ("[A] jurisdictional inquiry is not the appropriate stage of litigation to resolve these various uncertain questions of law and fact.").
- Beaufort Cnty. Sch. Dist. v. United Nat'l Ins., 519 F. Supp. 2d 609 (D.S.C. 2007).published See Hartley, 187 F.3d at 425 (“[A] jurisdictional inquiry is not the appropriate stage of litigation to resolve these various uncertain questions of law and fact.”).
- Delmarva Sash & Door Co. of Maryland v. Andersen Windows, Inc., 218 F. Supp. 2d 729 (D. Md. 2002).published That does not, however, license the court to engage in extensive fact finding or “delv[e] too far into the merits in deciding a jurisdictional question.” Hartley, 187 F.3d at 425 (“The district court should not have made its own determinat…
- Christensen v. Phillip Morris, Inc., 198 F. Supp. 2d 713 (D. Md. 2002).published That does not, however, license the court to engage in extensive fact finding or “delv[e] too far into the merits in deciding a jurisdictional question.” Hartley, 187 F.3d at 425 (“The district court should not have made its own determinat…
- Wells' Dairy, Inc. v. Am. Indus. Refrigeration, Inc., 157 F. Supp. 2d 1018 (N.D. Iowa 2001).published(The party alleging fraudulent joinder bears a heavy burden — it must show that the plaintiff cannot establish a claim even after resolving all issues of law and fact in the plaintiff’s favor. [Citation omitted.] This s…)
- Jeremy Skidmore v. Michael Schinke, 171 F.4th 319 (4th Cir. 2026).published Hartley, 187 F.3d at 424.
- Campbell v. Navy Fed. Credit Union, No. 2:25-cv-03100 (D.S.C. Aug. 27, 2025).The party alleging fraudulent joinder bears a heavy burden—it must show that the plaintiff “cannot establish a claim even after resolving all issues of law and fact in the plaintiff’s favor.” Hartley, 187 F.3d at 422, 425.
Show 87 more citing cases
- Fayette Cnty. Solid Waste Auth. v. ERP Env't Fund, Inc., No. 2:25-cv-00023 (S.D. W. Va. July 3, 2025).“This standard is even more favorable to 2 the plaintiff than the standard for ruling on a motion to dismiss under [Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure] 12(b)(6).” Hartley, 187 F.3d at 424.
- Love v. Costco Wholesale Corp., No. 2:25-cv-01292 (D.S.C. June 13, 2025).The party alleging fraudulent joinder bears a heavy burden—it must show that the plaintiff “cannot establish a claim even after resolving all issues of law and fact in the plaintiff’s favor.” Hartley, 187 F.3d at 422, 425.
- Huffman v. Plusnick, No. 4:23-cv-00687 (D.S.C. Feb. 11, 2025). Indeed, the Fourth Circuit emphasized, regarding the second showing, that “there need be only a slight possibility of a right to relief” and, “[o]nce the court identifies this glimmer of hope for the plaintiff, the jurisdictional inquiry e…
- Haynes v. Rocky Mount Cycles, Inc., 730 F. Supp. 3d 206 (E.D.N.C. 2024).published Hartley, 187 F.3d at 426; see Johnson v. Am.
- Royal Plus, Inc. v. Child.'s Hosp. of Baltimore City, Inc., No. 1:23-cv-02395 (D. Md. Oct. 24, 2023). “The party alleging fraudulent joinder bears a heavy burden—it must show that the plaintiff cannot establish a claim even after resolving all issues of law and fact in the plaintiff's favor.” Jd. (quoting Hartley, 187 F.3d at 424).
- Vitello v. Ramsden, No. 5:23-cv-00196 (E.D.N.C. Sept. 27, 2023). “The party alleging fraudulent joinder bears a heavy burden—it must show that the plaintiff cannot establish a claim even after resolving all issues of law and fact in the plaintiff’s favor.” Id. at 424.
- Sproul v. Atkinson, No. 3:23-cv-00075 (W.D.N.C. May 2, 2023). Hartley, 187 F.3d at 424.
- Holland v. U-Haul Int'l, Inc., No. 8:22-cv-02473 (D. Md. Mar. 29, 2023). Id. at 426.
- Asbury v. Pocahontas Coal Co., No. 2:23-cv-00005 (S.D. W. Va. Mar. 14, 2023). P. 12(b)(6).” Hartley, 187 F.3d at 424.
- Edmonds v. Wal-Mart Stores East, LP, No. 3:22-cv-00496 (E.D. Va. Mar. 9, 2023). Furthermore, the United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit has explained that “a jurisdictional inquiry is not the appropriate stage of litigation to resolve . . .various uncertain questions of law and fact.” Hartley, 187 F.3d…
- Quast v. English Riding Supply, Inc., No. 4:22-cv-00077 (E.D.N.C. Dec. 12, 2022). “The party alleging fraudulent joinder bears a heavy burden—it must show that the plaintiff cannot establish a claim even after resolving all issues of law and fact in the plaintiff’s favor”
- Brown, Jr. v. CMH Mfg., Inc., No. 3:22-cv-01293 (D.S.C. Aug. 9, 2022). P. 12(b)(6).” Id. (quoting Hartley, 187 F.3d at 424 (internal quotation marks omitted).
- Pipe & Boiler Insulation, Inc. v. Cont'l Ins. Co., No. 3:21-cv-03033 (D.S.C. Apr. 19, 2022). P. 12(b)(6).” Id. (quoting Hartley, 187 F.3d at 424 (internal quotation marks omitted).
- Fleshman-Massey v. First-Citizens Bank & Trust Co., No. 5:21-cv-00443 (S.D. W. Va. Oct. 12, 2021).Id. at 465. “[T]his standard is even more favorable to the plaintiff than the standard for ruling on a motion to dismiss under Fed.R.Civ.P. 12(b)(6).” Id. (quoting Hartley, 187 F.3d at 424).
- Bright-Jamison v. Haq, No. 9:21-cv-02246 (D.S.C. Sept. 13, 2021).The plaintiff need not establish that he will ultimately succeed on his claims; “[t]here need be only a slight possibility of a right to relief.” Id. at 426.
- Durham Wood Fired Pizza Co. v. Cincinnati Ins. Co., No. 1:20-cv-00856 (M.D.N.C. Aug. 27, 2021). Hartley, 187 F.3d at 426.
- Rawl v. Dick's Sporting Goods Inc, No. 2:20-cv-03955 (D.S.C. June 10, 2021). P. 12(b)(6).” Hartley, 187 F.3d at 424 (citation omitted).
- Johnson v. S. Indus. Constructors, No. 5:21-cv-00165 (D.S.C. May 25, 2021). “The party alleging fraudulent joinder bears a heavy burden—it must show that the plaintiff cannot establish a claim even after resolving all issues of law and fact in the plaintiff's favor”
- Gregg v. Thompson, No. 2:21-cv-00623 (D.S.C. Mar. 19, 2021). “To show fraudulent joinder, the removing party must demonstrate either (1) outright fraud in the plaintiff's pleading of jurisdictional facts or (2) that there is no possibility that the plaintiff would be able to estab…”
- John Walker v. Philip Morris USA Inc., 443 F. App'x 946 (6th Cir. 2011).unpublished
- Patricia J. Mayes v. Stanley Rapoport Judith Rapoport David Key, 198 F.3d 457 (4th Cir. 1999).published
- Herbert McFadden v. Fed. Nat'l Mortg. Ass'n, 525 F. App'x 223 (4th Cir. 2013).unpublished
- Baltimore Cnty. MD v. Cigna Healthcare, 238 F. App'x 914 (4th Cir. 2007).unpublished
- Hartman v. Caraco Pharm. Labs., Ltd., 789 F. Supp. 2d 701 (S.D. W. Va. 2011).published
- Grubbs v. Westfield Ins., 430 F. Supp. 2d 563 (N.D. W. Va. 2006).published
- Murphy v. Jefferson Pilot Commc'ns Co., 657 F. Supp. 2d 683 (D.S.C. 2008).published
- Wise v. Travelers Indem. Co., 192 F. Supp. 2d 506 (N.D. W. Va. 2002).published
- Newman v. Motorola, Inc., 125 F. Supp. 2d 717 (D. Md. 2000).published
- Ashworth v. Albers Med., Inc., 395 F. Supp. 2d 395 (S.D. W. Va. 2005).published
- Crawford v. C. Richard Dobson Builders, Inc., 597 F. Supp. 2d 605 (D.S.C. 2009).published
- Carter v. Hitachi Koki U.S.A Ltd., 445 F. Supp. 2d 597 (E.D. Va. 2006).published
- McWilliams v. Monarch Rubber Co., 70 F. Supp. 2d 663 (S.D. W. Va. 1999).published
- Briano v. Conseco Life Ins., 126 F. Supp. 2d 1293 (C.D. Cal. 2000).published
- Benjamin v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc., 413 F. Supp. 2d 652 (D.S.C. 2006).published
- Allen ex rel. Allen v. C. Richard Dobson Builders, Inc., 595 F. Supp. 2d 654 (D.S.C. 2009).published
- Burns v. Friedli, 241 F. Supp. 2d 519 (D. Md. 2003).published
- Coots v. Allstate Life Ins., 313 F. Supp. 2d 539 (D. Md. 2004).published
- Robert Johnson v. Am. Towers, LLC, 781 F.3d 693 (4th Cir. 2015).published
- Mayes v. Rapoport, No. 98-2695 (4th Cir. Dec. 2, 1999).published
- Williams ex rel. Est. of Williams v. Preiss-Wal Pat III, LLC, 17 F. Supp. 3d 528 (D.S.C. 2014).published
- Dotson v. Elite Oil Field Servs., Inc., 91 F. Supp. 3d 865 (N.D. W. Va. 2015).published
- Allard v. Laroya, 163 F. Supp. 3d 309 (E.D. Va. 2016).published
- Cardoza v. Med. Device Bus. Servs., Inc., 389 F. Supp. 3d 399 (W.D. Va. 2019).published
- McCoy v. Norfolk S. Ry. Co., 858 F. Supp. 2d 639 (S.D. W. Va. 2012).published
- Feldman's Med. Ctr. Pharmacy, Inc. v. CareFirst, Inc., 959 F. Supp. 2d 783 (D. Md. 2013).published
- Harrell v. Caliber Home Loans, Inc., 995 F. Supp. 2d 548 (E.D. Va. 2014).published
- Allen v. RBC Capital Markets, LLC, No. 8:18-cv-03971 (D. Md. Aug. 8, 2019).
- The Est. of Mary Sue Welsh v. Michaels Stores, Inc., No. 1:19-cv-00988 (D. Md. Oct. 9, 2019).
- Fish v. Cincinnati Ins. Co., 451 F. Supp. 3d 430 (D. Md. 2020).published
- Johnson v. Team Washington, Inc., No. 8:21-cv-01693 (D. Md. Oct. 7, 2021).
- Waymer v. Columbia Ins. Co., No. 2:19-cv-00260 (D.S.C. Aug. 7, 2019).
- Whitney v. Fedex Freight Inc, No. 3:19-cv-01118 (D.S.C. Feb. 27, 2020).
- Antoine v. Holcim (U.S.), Inc., No. 5:20-cv-01156 (D.S.C. May 7, 2020).
- Finch v. Sentry Cas. Co., No. 3:19-cv-01827 (D.S.C. June 4, 2020).
- Phillips v. Liberty Mut. Ins. Co., No. 0:19-cv-03433 (D.S.C. June 15, 2020).
- Johnson v. Pinnacle Mining Co., No. 5:17-cv-03536 (S.D. W. Va. Oct. 13, 2017).
- Lyles v. FTL Ltd., Inc., No. 2:17-cv-01974 (S.D. W. Va. Feb. 7, 2018).
- Owen v. Saxon Asset Sec. 2006-1 Mortg. Asset Backed Notes, No. 2:17-cv-04396 (S.D. W. Va. Apr. 5, 2018).
- Banks v. Nationwide Prop. & Cas. Ins. Co., No. 2:18-cv-00259 (S.D. W. Va. July 13, 2018).
- Rowe v. Peoples Bancorp, Inc., No. 3:18-cv-01186 (S.D. W. Va. Dec. 19, 2018).
- Puffinberger v. 3M Co., No. 2:20-cv-00122 (S.D. W. Va. Feb. 13, 2020).
- Boggs v. 3M Co., No. 2:20-cv-00121, 2020 WL 762859 (S.D. W. Va. Feb. 14, 2020).
- Louie, No. 1:25-cv-03649 (D. Md. Apr. 2, 2026).
- Oxendine v. Merck & Co., 236 F. Supp. 2d 517 (D. Md. 2002).published
- Hill v. John Alden Life Ins., 556 F. Supp. 2d 571 (S.D. W. Va. 2008).published
- Willard v. United Parcel Serv., 413 F. Supp. 2d 593 (M.D.N.C. 2006).published
- Hill, Peterson, Carper, Bee & Deitzler, P.L.L.C. v. XL Specialty Ins., 261 F. Supp. 2d 546 (S.D. W. Va. 2003).published
- Capparelli v. AmeriFirst Home Improvement Fin. Co., 535 F. Supp. 2d 554 (E.D.N.C. 2008).published
- Skevofilax ex rel. Skevofilax v. Aventis Pasteur, Inc., 304 F. Supp. 2d 691 (D. Md. 2003).published
- Grennell v. W. S. Life Ins., 298 F. Supp. 2d 390 (S.D. W. Va. 2004).published
- Julie Hughes v. Wells Fargo Bank, N.A., 617 F. App'x 261 (4th Cir. 2015).unpublished
- Toney v. Lasalle Bank Nat'l Ass'n, 36 F. Supp. 3d 657 (D.S.C. 2014).published
- Trs. of Hackberry Baptist Church v. Womack, 62 F. Supp. 3d 523 (W.D. Va. 2014).published
- Bowman v. Top Gun of Virginia, Inc., No. 8:21-cv-02207 (D. Md. Dec. 8, 2021).
- Sharpe v. FCFS NC, Inc., No. 1:19-cv-00985 (M.D.N.C. July 16, 2020).
- Queen v. Waffle House Inc, No. 6:22-cv-04193 (D.S.C. June 18, 2024).
- Priselac v. Chemours Co., No. 7:20-cv-00190 (E.D.N.C. Mar. 28, 2022).
- Santana v. Brookfield Props. Retail, Inc., No. 4:23-cv-00210 (E.D.N.C. Apr. 8, 2024).
- Elliot v. Orchid Island Plantation Apts. Assocs., LLC, No. 6:24-cv-00836 (D.S.C. July 12, 2024).
- Whitman v. Ruby Tuesday, Inc., No. 1:17-cv-00058 (N.D. W. Va. Aug. 8, 2017).
- Goss v. Marion Cnty. Coal Co., No. 1:17-cv-00084 (N.D. W. Va. Aug. 10, 2017).
- Carter v. Marion Cnty. Coal Co., No. 1:17-cv-00081 (N.D. W. Va. Aug. 10, 2017).
- Kellaway v. Marion Cnty. Coal Co., No. 1:17-cv-00085 (N.D. W. Va. Aug. 10, 2017).
- Glaspell v. Marion Cnty. Coal Co., No. 1:17-cv-00083 (N.D. W. Va. Aug. 10, 2017).
- Chapman v. Marion Cnty. Coal Co., No. 1:17-cv-00082 (N.D. W. Va. Aug. 10, 2017).
- Gasper v. Swick & Sons Maint. Specialists, Inc, No. 1:20-cv-00212 (N.D. W. Va. Apr. 28, 2021).
- Llarenas v. Jacobs Tech., Inc., No. 4:24-cv-00061 (E.D. Va. Nov. 7, 2024).
At page 426Determining possibility of right to relief for remand46 citing cases“there need be only a slight possibility of a right to relief. once the court identifies this glimmer of hope for the plaintiff, the jurisdictional inquiry ends.”
- Montanaro v. State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins., 29 F. Supp. 3d 662 (D.S.C. 2014).published Dist., 519 F.Supp.2d at 614 ; see also Hartley, 187 F.3d at 425 (“[A] jurisdictional inquiry is not the appropriate stage of litigation to resolve these various uncertain questions of law and fact.”).
- Tackett v. 3M Co., No. 7:22-cv-00063 (E.D. Ky. Mar. 28, 2023).“once the court identifies this glimmer of hope for the plaintiff, the jurisdictional inquiry ends.”
- Bowen v. 3M Co., No. 7:22-cv-00013 (E.D. Ky. Mar. 28, 2023).“once the court identifies this glimmer of hope for the plaintiff, the jurisdictional inquiry ends.”
- Anderson v. 3M Co., No. 7:22-cv-00068 (E.D. Ky. Mar. 28, 2023).“once the court identifies this glimmer of hope for the plaintiff, the jurisdictional inquiry ends.”
- Hatfield v. 3M Co., No. 7:22-cv-00062 (E.D. Ky. Mar. 28, 2023).“once the court identifies this glimmer of hope for the plaintiff, the jurisdictional inquiry ends.”
- Daniels v. 3M Co., No. 7:22-cv-00069 (E.D. Ky. Mar. 28, 2023).“once the court identifies this glimmer of hope for the plaintiff, the jurisdictional inquiry ends.”
- Castle v. 3M Co., 664 F. Supp. 3d 770 (E.D. Ky. 2023).published“once the court identifies this glimmer of hope for the plaintiff, the jurisdictional inquiry ends.”
- Banks v. 3M Co., No. 7:21-cv-00083 (E.D. Ky. Sept. 27, 2022).“once the court identifies this glimmer of hope for the plaintiff, the jurisdictional inquiry ends.”
- Adams v. 3M Co., No. 7:21-cv-00082 (E.D. Ky. Sept. 27, 2022).“once the court identifies this glimmer of hope for the plaintiff, the jurisdictional inquiry ends.”
- Combs v. 3M Co., No. 7:21-cv-00084 (E.D. Ky. Sept. 27, 2022).“once the court identifies this glimmer of hope for the plaintiff, the jurisdictional inquiry ends.”
Show 36 more citing cases
- Hamilton v. 3M Co., No. 7:21-cv-00087 (E.D. Ky. Sept. 27, 2022).“once the court identifies this glimmer of hope for the plaintiff, the jurisdictional inquiry ends.”
- Mounts v. 3M Co., No. 7:21-cv-00086 (E.D. Ky. Sept. 27, 2022).“once the court identifies this glimmer of hope for the plaintiff, the jurisdictional inquiry ends.”
- Yates v. 3M Co., No. 7:21-cv-00085 (E.D. Ky. Sept. 27, 2022).“once the court identifies this glimmer of hope for the plaintiff, the jurisdictional inquiry ends.”
- Lee v. State Farm Fire & Cas. Co., No. 3:21-cv-00608 (W.D.N.C. May 17, 2022).“there need be only a slight possibility of a right to relief. once the court identifies this glimmer of hope for the plaintiff, the jurisdictional inquiry ends.”
- Morris v. Walmart Stores East, L.P., No. 6:20-cv-00150 (E.D. Ky. Jan. 20, 2021).“once the court identifies this glimmer of hope for the plaintiff, the jurisdictional inquiry ends.”
- Clark v. Lowe's Home Centers, LLC, No. 6:19-cv-00114, 2019 WL 5092941 (E.D. Ky. Oct. 11, 2019).“once the court identifies this glimmer of hope for the plaintiff, the jurisdictional inquiry ends.”
- Huffman v. Plusnick, No. 4:23-cv-00687 (D.S.C. Feb. 11, 2025). Indeed, the Fourth Circuit emphasized, regarding the second showing, that “there need be only a slight possibility of a right to relief” and, “[o]nce the court identifies this glimmer of hope for the plaintiff, the jurisdictional inquiry e…
- Alexander v. Walmart Inc, No. 8:24-cv-01410 (D. Md. Oct. 25, 2024).(slight possibility of a right to relief” is sufficient to obtain remand to state court)
- Haynes v. Rocky Mount Cycles, Inc., 730 F. Supp. 3d 206 (E.D.N.C. 2024).published Hartley, 187 F.3d at 426; see Johnson v. Am.
- Vitello v. Ramsden, No. 5:23-cv-00196 (E.D.N.C. Sept. 27, 2023). “The party alleging fraudulent joinder bears a heavy burden—it must show that the plaintiff cannot establish a claim even after resolving all issues of law and fact in the plaintiff’s favor.” Id. at 424.
- Holland v. U-Haul Int'l, Inc., No. 8:22-cv-02473 (D. Md. Mar. 29, 2023). Id. at 426.
- Edmonds v. Wal-Mart Stores East, LP, No. 3:22-cv-00496 (E.D. Va. Mar. 9, 2023). Furthermore, the United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit has explained that “a jurisdictional inquiry is not the appropriate stage of litigation to resolve . . .various uncertain questions of law and fact.” Hartley, 187 F.3d…
- Quast v. English Riding Supply, Inc., No. 4:22-cv-00077 (E.D.N.C. Dec. 12, 2022). “The party alleging fraudulent joinder bears a heavy burden—it must show that the plaintiff cannot establish a claim even after resolving all issues of law and fact in the plaintiff’s favor.” Hartley, 187 F.3d at 424.
- Brown, Jr. v. CMH Mfg., Inc., No. 3:22-cv-01293 (D.S.C. Aug. 9, 2022). P. 12(b)(6).” Id. (quoting Hartley, 187 F.3d at 424 (internal quotation marks omitted).
- Cooper v. 7-Eleven, Inc., No. 2:21-cv-00553 (S.D. W. Va. July 22, 2022). While Cooper may only have a “a slight possibility of a right to relief” on her negligence claim against Lanham, that slight possibility, or “glimmer of hope,” is all that is required for this court’s jurisdictional inquiry to end.6 See Ha…
- Pipe & Boiler Insulation, Inc. v. Cont'l Ins. Co., No. 3:21-cv-03033 (D.S.C. Apr. 19, 2022). P. 12(b)(6).” Id. (quoting Hartley, 187 F.3d at 424 (internal quotation marks omitted).
- Kisner v. Medtronic Inc, No. 2:21-cv-01767, 2021 WL 4690979 (D.S.C. Oct. 7, 2021).Once the court identifies this glimmer of hope for the plaintiff, the jurisdictional inquiry ends.” Id. at 426 (citation omitted).
- Bright-Jamison v. Haq, No. 9:21-cv-02246 (D.S.C. Sept. 13, 2021).The plaintiff need not establish that he will ultimately succeed on his claims; “[t]here need be only a slight possibility of a right to relief.” Id. at 426.
- Durham Wood Fired Pizza Co. v. Cincinnati Ins. Co., No. 1:20-cv-00856 (M.D.N.C. Aug. 27, 2021). Hartley, 187 F.3d at 426.
- Rawl v. Dick's Sporting Goods Inc, No. 2:20-cv-03955 (D.S.C. June 10, 2021). P. 12(b)(6).” Hartley, 187 F.3d at 424 (citation omitted).
- Gregg v. Thompson, No. 2:21-cv-00623 (D.S.C. Mar. 19, 2021). “To show fraudulent joinder, the removing party must demonstrate either (1) outright fraud in the plaintiff's pleading of jurisdictional facts or (2) that there is no possibility that the plaintiff would be able to establish a cause of act…
- Patricia J. Mayes v. Stanley Rapoport Judith Rapoport David Key, 198 F.3d 457 (4th Cir. 1999).published
- Burns v. Friedli, 241 F. Supp. 2d 519 (D. Md. 2003).published
- Mayes v. Rapoport, No. 98-2695 (4th Cir. Dec. 2, 1999).published
- Finch v. Sentry Cas. Co., No. 3:19-cv-01827 (D.S.C. June 4, 2020).
- Lyles v. FTL Ltd., Inc., No. 2:17-cv-01974 (S.D. W. Va. Feb. 7, 2018).
- Banks v. Nationwide Prop. & Cas. Ins. Co., No. 2:18-cv-00259 (S.D. W. Va. July 13, 2018).
- West Virginia ex rel. McGraw v. Minnesota Mining & Mfg. Co., 354 F. Supp. 2d 660 (S.D. W. Va. 2005).published
- Hien Pham v. Bank of New York, 856 F. Supp. 2d 804 (E.D. Va. 2012).published
- Dawn Flores v. Ethicon, Inc., 563 F. App'x 266 (4th Cir. 2014).unpublished
- Joyce Barlow v. Colgate Palmolive Co., 750 F.3d 437 (4th Cir. 2014).published
- Donaldson v. Walmart Stores Inc, No. 6:20-cv-01565 (D.S.C. Aug. 4, 2020).
- McDowell v. Allstate Veh. & Prop. Ins. Co., No. 2:19-cv-00746 (S.D. W. Va. Dec. 11, 2019).
- Toney v. Lasalle Bank Nat'l Ass'n, 36 F. Supp. 3d 657 (D.S.C. 2014).published
- Sharpe v. FCFS NC, Inc., No. 1:19-cv-00985 (M.D.N.C. July 16, 2020).
- Whitman v. Ruby Tuesday, Inc., No. 1:17-cv-00058 (N.D. W. Va. Aug. 8, 2017).
At page 425Resolving doubts about jurisdiction in favor of state court45 citing cases[A] jurisdictional inquiry is not the appropriate stage of litigation to resolve these various uncertain questions of law and fact.
- Montanaro v. State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins., 29 F. Supp. 3d 662 (D.S.C. 2014).published ([A] jurisdictional inquiry is not the appropriate stage of litigation to resolve these various uncertain questions of law and fact.)
- Beaufort Cnty. Sch. Dist. v. United Nat. Ins. Co., 519 F. Supp. 2d 609 (D.S.C. 2007).published ([A] jurisdictional inquiry is not the appropriate stage of litigation to resolve these various uncertain questions of law and fact.)
- Beaufort Cnty. Sch. Dist. v. United Nat'l Ins., 519 F. Supp. 2d 609 (D.S.C. 2007).published ([A] jurisdictional inquiry is not the appropriate stage of litigation to resolve these various uncertain questions of law and fact.)
- Delmarva Sash & Door Co. of Maryland v. Andersen Windows, Inc., 218 F. Supp. 2d 729 (D. Md. 2002).published “the district court should not have made its own determination concerning the novel application of the public duty rule to hartley's claims.”
- Christensen v. Phillip Morris, Inc., 198 F. Supp. 2d 713 (D. Md. 2002).published “the district court should not have made its own determination concerning the novel application of the public duty rule to hartley's claims.”
- Cross v. Clemons, No. 5:21-cv-00743 (W.D. Okla. Dec. 6, 2021).“because all legal uncertainties are to be resolved in the plaintiff's favor in determining whether fraudulent joinder exists, a truly 'novel' issue . . . cannot be the basis for finding fraudulent joinder.”
- Reavis v. McCabe Trotter & Beverly PC, No. 2:21-cv-02089 (D.S.C. Oct. 5, 2021).“courts should 'resolve all doubts about the propriety of removal in favor of retained state court jurisdiction.”
- Bennett v. Keystone Cremation All., LLC, No. 2:18-cv-01280 (S.D. W. Va. Oct. 11, 2018).“jurisdictional rules direct judicial traffic. they function to steer litigation to the proper forum with a minimum of preliminary fuss.”
- Huffman v. Plusnick, No. 4:23-cv-00687 (D.S.C. Feb. 11, 2025). Indeed, the Fourth Circuit emphasized, regarding the second showing, that “there need be only a slight possibility of a right to relief” and, “[o]nce the court identifies this glimmer of hope for the plaintiff, the jurisdictional inquiry e…
- Holland v. U-Haul Int'l, Inc., No. 8:22-cv-02473 (D. Md. Mar. 29, 2023). Id. at 426.
Show 35 more citing cases
- Asbury v. Pocahontas Coal Co., No. 2:23-cv-00005 (S.D. W. Va. Mar. 14, 2023). P. 12(b)(6).” Hartley, 187 F.3d at 424.
- Edmonds v. Wal-Mart Stores East, LP, No. 3:22-cv-00496 (E.D. Va. Mar. 9, 2023). “a jurisdictional inquiry is not the appropriate stage of litigation to resolve . . .various uncertain questions of law and fact”
- Quast v. English Riding Supply, Inc., No. 4:22-cv-00077 (E.D.N.C. Dec. 12, 2022). “The party alleging fraudulent joinder bears a heavy burden—it must show that the plaintiff cannot establish a claim even after resolving all issues of law and fact in the plaintiff’s favor.” Hartley, 187 F.3d at 424.
- Durham Wood Fired Pizza Co. v. Cincinnati Ins. Co., No. 1:20-cv-00856 (M.D.N.C. Aug. 27, 2021). Hartley, 187 F.3d at 426.
- Hartman v. Caraco Pharm. Labs., Ltd., 789 F. Supp. 2d 701 (S.D. W. Va. 2011).published
- Grubbs v. Westfield Ins., 430 F. Supp. 2d 563 (N.D. W. Va. 2006).published
- Murphy v. Jefferson Pilot Commc'ns Co., 657 F. Supp. 2d 683 (D.S.C. 2008).published
- Crawford v. C. Richard Dobson Builders, Inc., 597 F. Supp. 2d 605 (D.S.C. 2009).published
- Carter v. Hitachi Koki U.S.A Ltd., 445 F. Supp. 2d 597 (E.D. Va. 2006).published
- Benjamin v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc., 413 F. Supp. 2d 652 (D.S.C. 2006).published
- Allen ex rel. Allen v. C. Richard Dobson Builders, Inc., 595 F. Supp. 2d 654 (D.S.C. 2009).published
- McCoy v. Norfolk S. Ry. Co., 858 F. Supp. 2d 639 (S.D. W. Va. 2012).published
- Feldman's Med. Ctr. Pharmacy, Inc. v. CareFirst, Inc., 959 F. Supp. 2d 783 (D. Md. 2013).published
- Whitney v. Fedex Freight Inc, No. 3:19-cv-01118 (D.S.C. Feb. 27, 2020).
- Johnson v. Pinnacle Mining Co., No. 5:17-cv-03536 (S.D. W. Va. Oct. 13, 2017).
- Lyles v. FTL Ltd., Inc., No. 2:17-cv-01974 (S.D. W. Va. Feb. 7, 2018).
- Banks v. Nationwide Prop. & Cas. Ins. Co., No. 2:18-cv-00259 (S.D. W. Va. July 13, 2018).
- Rowe v. Peoples Bancorp, Inc., No. 3:18-cv-01186 (S.D. W. Va. Dec. 19, 2018).
- Puffinberger v. 3M Co., No. 2:20-cv-00122 (S.D. W. Va. Feb. 13, 2020).
- Boggs v. 3M Co., No. 2:20-cv-00121, 2020 WL 762859 (S.D. W. Va. Feb. 14, 2020).
- Stephens v. Kaiser Found. Health Plan of Mid-Atl. States, Inc., 807 F. Supp. 2d 375 (D. Md. 2011).published
- McCaulley v. Purdue Pharma, L.P., 172 F. Supp. 2d 803 (W.D. Va. 2001).published
- West Virginia ex rel. McGraw v. Minnesota Mining & Mfg. Co., 354 F. Supp. 2d 660 (S.D. W. Va. 2005).published
- Miller v. BAS Technical Emp. Placement Co., 153 F. Supp. 2d 835 (S.D. W. Va. 2001).published
- Adams v. Ins. Co. of North Am., 426 F. Supp. 2d 356 (S.D. W. Va. 2006).published
- Ryan Env't, Inc. v. Hess Oil Co., 718 F. Supp. 2d 719 (N.D. W. Va. 2010).published
- Burns v. W. S. Life Ins., 298 F. Supp. 2d 401 (S.D. W. Va. 2004).published
- Powell v. Bank of Am., N.A., 842 F. Supp. 2d 966 (S.D. W. Va. 2012).published
- Hien Pham v. Bank of New York, 856 F. Supp. 2d 804 (E.D. Va. 2012).published
- Adkins v. Consolidation Coal Co., 856 F. Supp. 2d 817 (S.D. W. Va. 2012).published
- Santos Arita v. Stericycle, Inc., No. 1:20-cv-00355 (D. Md. Nov. 12, 2020).
- Pettit v. State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co., No. 2:18-cv-00472 (S.D. W. Va. Oct. 10, 2018).
- Poston, No. 9:25-cv-03268 (D.S.C. Oct. 27, 2025).
- Toney v. Lasalle Bank Nat'l Ass'n, 36 F. Supp. 3d 657 (D.S.C. 2014).published
- Whitman v. Ruby Tuesday, Inc., No. 1:17-cv-00058 (N.D. W. Va. Aug. 8, 2017).
Once the court identifies this glimmer of hope for the plaintiff, the jurisdictional inquiry ends.
- Tackett v. 3M Co., No. 7:22-cv-00063 (E.D. Ky. Mar. 28, 2023).(Once the court identifies this glimmer of hope for the plaintiff, the jurisdictional inquiry ends.)
- Bowen v. 3M Co., No. 7:22-cv-00013 (E.D. Ky. Mar. 28, 2023).(Once the court identifies this glimmer of hope for the plaintiff, the jurisdictional inquiry ends.)
- Anderson v. 3M Co., No. 7:22-cv-00068 (E.D. Ky. Mar. 28, 2023).(Once the court identifies this glimmer of hope for the plaintiff, the jurisdictional inquiry ends.)
- Hatfield v. 3M Co., No. 7:22-cv-00062 (E.D. Ky. Mar. 28, 2023).(Once the court identifies this glimmer of hope for the plaintiff, the jurisdictional inquiry ends.)
- Daniels v. 3M Co., No. 7:22-cv-00069 (E.D. Ky. Mar. 28, 2023).(Once the court identifies this glimmer of hope for the plaintiff, the jurisdictional inquiry ends.)
- Castle v. 3M Co., 664 F. Supp. 3d 770 (E.D. Ky. 2023).published(Once the court identifies this glimmer of hope for the plaintiff, the jurisdictional inquiry ends.)
- Banks v. 3M Co., No. 7:21-cv-00083 (E.D. Ky. Sept. 27, 2022).(Once the court identifies this glimmer of hope for the plaintiff, the jurisdictional inquiry ends.)
- Adams v. 3M Co., No. 7:21-cv-00082 (E.D. Ky. Sept. 27, 2022).(Once the court identifies this glimmer of hope for the plaintiff, the jurisdictional inquiry ends.)
- Combs v. 3M Co., No. 7:21-cv-00084 (E.D. Ky. Sept. 27, 2022).(Once the court identifies this glimmer of hope for the plaintiff, the jurisdictional inquiry ends.)
- Hamilton v. 3M Co., No. 7:21-cv-00087 (E.D. Ky. Sept. 27, 2022).(Once the court identifies this glimmer of hope for the plaintiff, the jurisdictional inquiry ends.)
Show 5 more citing cases
- Mounts v. 3M Co., No. 7:21-cv-00086 (E.D. Ky. Sept. 27, 2022).(Once the court identifies this glimmer of hope for the plaintiff, the jurisdictional inquiry ends.)
- Yates v. 3M Co., No. 7:21-cv-00085 (E.D. Ky. Sept. 27, 2022).(Once the court identifies this glimmer of hope for the plaintiff, the jurisdictional inquiry ends.)
- Lee v. State Farm Fire & Cas. Co., No. 3:21-cv-00608 (W.D.N.C. May 17, 2022).([T]here need be only a slight possibility of a right to relief. Once the court identifies this glimmer of hope for the plaintiff, the jurisdictional inquiry ends.)
- Morris v. Walmart Stores East, L.P., No. 6:20-cv-00150 (E.D. Ky. Jan. 20, 2021).(Once the court identifies this glimmer of hope for the plaintiff, the jurisdictional inquiry ends.)
- Clark v. Lowe's Home Centers, LLC, No. 6:19-cv-00114, 2019 WL 5092941 (E.D. Ky. Oct. 11, 2019).(Once the court identifies this glimmer of hope for the plaintiff, the jurisdictional inquiry ends.)
At page 422Reviewing fraudulent joinder doctrine in diversity cases11 citing cases“cannot establish a claim even after resolving all issues of law and fact in the plaintiff’s favor”
- Campbell v. Navy Fed. Credit Union, No. 2:25-cv-03100 (D.S.C. Aug. 27, 2025).“cannot establish a claim even after resolving all issues of law and fact in the plaintiff’s favor”
- Love v. Costco Wholesale Corp., No. 2:25-cv-01292 (D.S.C. June 13, 2025).“cannot establish a claim even after resolving all issues of law and fact in the plaintiff’s favor”
- 17th Street Assocs., LLP v. Markel Int'l Ins., 373 F. Supp. 2d 584 (E.D. Va. 2005).published
- Jeffries v. CU Recovery, Inc., No. 5:17-cv-00124 (N.D. W. Va. Nov. 13, 2017).
- Nathaniel Realty, LLC v. State Farm Fire & Cas. Co., No. 5:18-cv-00110 (N.D. W. Va. Aug. 27, 2018).
- Upper Ohio Valley Italian Heritage Festival, Inc. v. Burlington Ins. Co., No. 5:18-cv-00120, 2018 WL 5284207 (N.D. W. Va. Oct. 24, 2018).
- Schmitt v. Goff, No. 5:18-cv-00105 (N.D. W. Va. Dec. 12, 2018).
- Burns v. State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co., No. 5:19-cv-00031 (N.D. W. Va. June 25, 2019).
- Dynes v. Erie Ins. Prop. & Cas. Co., No. 5:19-cv-00214 (N.D. W. Va. Aug. 16, 2019).
- Hamilton v. Lexington Ins. Co., No. 5:19-cv-00241 (N.D. W. Va. Sept. 17, 2019).
v.
CSX TRANSPORTATION, INCORPORATED South Carolina Department of Transportation Town of Allendale, South Carolina, Defendants-Appellees Lidy J. Hartley v. CSX Transportation, Incorporated South Carolina Department of Transportation Town of Allendale, South Carolina
Reversed and remanded by published opinion. Chief Judge WILKINSON wrote the opinion, in which Judge NIEMEYER and Judge KING joined.
OPINION
WILKINSON, Chief Judge:A South Carolina citizen filed a tort action in South Carolina state court against a Virginia railroad corporation and two South Carolina government entities. The railroad removed the case to federal court on diversity grounds, claiming that the government defendants were fraudulently joined. The district court denied plaintiffs motion to remand the case to state court. Because there is at least some possibility that plaintiff will recover against the government defendants, we reverse.
I.
Lidy J. Hartley is a South Carolina citizen whose automobile collided with a train at an Allendale, South Carolina railroad crossing in July 1997. She filed suit in the Allendale County Court of Common Pleas against CSX Transportation, Inc. (CSX), the South Carolina Department of Trans[*424]portation (SCDOT), and the Town of Allendale, South Carolina (Town). Hartley alleged, among other things, that the SCDOT was negligent in maintaining an unsafe crossing, in failing to inspect the crossing adequately, and in failing to maintain proper markings on the roadway near the crossing. She also alleged that the Town was negligent in maintaining its property and in failing to warn the public of the obstructed view at the crossing.
CSX removed the case to the United States District Court for tl~e District of South Carolina on the basis of diversity of citizenship. With the government defendants joined, there is incomplete diversity between plaintiff and defendants, and federal jurisdiction will not attach. On the other hand, if the government defendants are dismissed, then diversity jurisdiction will lie. CSX contended thatthe SCDOT and the Town were sham defendants that Hartley had named solely for the purpose of defeating diversity.
Hartley filed a motion to remand the case to state court on the ground that the district court lacked subject matter jurisdiction. The district court denied the motion, holding that South Carolina's public duty rule precluded Hartley's claims against the SCDOT and the Town. Hartley then filed this interlocutory appeal.
II.
CSX argues that diversity jurisdiction exists because the SCDOT and the Town are not proper defendants in this action. The district court agreed, holding that the government defendants were fraudulently joined because they could not be liable as a matter of law under the public duty rule. That rule provides that "public officials are generally not liable to individuals for their negligence in discharging public duties because the duty is owed to the public at large rather than to anyone individually." Wells v. City of Lynchburg, 331 S.C. 296, 501 S.E.2d 746, 751-52 (1998).
We disagree with the district court. To show fraudulent joinder, the removing party must demonstrate either "outright fraud in the plaintiff's pleading of jurisdictional facts" or that "there is no possibility that the plaintiff would be able to establish a cause of action against the in-state defendant in stat~ court." Marshall v. Manville Sales Corp., 6 F.3d 229, 232 (4th Cir.1993) (internal quotation marks omitted): CSX does not allege any bad faith in pleading, so the only inquiry is whether Hartley has any possibility of recovery.
The party alleging fraudulent joinder bears a heavy burden-it must show that the plaintiff cannot establish a claim even after resolving all issues of law and fact in the plaintiffs favor. Id. at 232-33. This standard is even more favorable to the plaintiff than the standard for ruling on a motion to dismiss under Fed.R.Civ.P. 12(b)(6). See, e.g., Batoff v. State Farm Ins. Co., 977 F.2d 848, 852 (3d Cir.1992) (inquiry into validity of complaint is more searching under Rule 12(b)(6) than when party claims fraudulent joinder).
CSX cannot meet this burden. The public duty rule does not preclude all possibility of recovery here. South Carolina law prescribes a six-part test for determining whether the public duty rule applies. Wells, 501 S.E.2d at 752. This test requires the court to ascertain the purposes of the statute; whether the statute imposes a duty on a specific public officer; the class protected by the statute; the membership of the plaintiff in that class; the public officer's state of mind concerning the likelihood of harm to members of the class if he fails in his duty; and the nature of the officer's authority. Id.
No South Carolina case has squarely held that the public duty rule forecloses Hartley's claims. Further, it is unclear whether a state court would apply the rule to her claims because the six-part test requires a judgment call at every turn. The presence or absence of each element often depends on several variables and[*425] may require factual investigation. See, e.g., Bellamy v. Brown, 305 S.C. 291, 408 S.E.2d 219, 221 (1991) (public duty rule inquiry requires “applying this test to the facts of [the] case” (emphasis added)); Jensen v. Anderson County Dep’t of Soc. Servs., 304 S.C. 195, 403 S.E.2d 615, 617-19 (1991) (endorsing lower court’s findings that, inter alia, considered report received by social worker and social worker’s personal observations in determining foreseeability of harm). These judgment calls may go either way. Thus, we cannot say with certainty that a South Carolina state court would find Hartley’s claims barred by the rule.
In fact, the district court’s own characterization of this case indicates its uncertainty as to the possibility of recovery. The district court described its application of the public duty rule in these circumstances as “a novel issue” and noted that “other courts may have a differing opinion of this matter.” Because all legal uncertainties are to be resolved in the plaintiffs favor in determining whether fraudulent joinder exists, a truly “novel” issue such as this cannot be the basis for finding fraudulent joinder. The very fact that courts may differ in their resolutions of this issue shows there is a possibility of recovery.
Further, courts should “resolve all doubts about the propriety of removal in favor of retained state court jurisdiction.” Marshall, 6 F.3d at 232. The district court in this case was sufficiently doubtful about the propriety of removal that it certified this interlocutory appeal. The district court instead should have resolved its doubts in favor of remanding the case to state court.
CSX contends that even if the application of the public duty rule presents an arguable question, Hartley still cannot hope to recover against the public defendants in court. We cannot say, however, that Hartley has no chance of establishing the facts necessary to support her tort claims. For example, she claims that the SCDOT was required by its own manual to place pavement markings in advance of the railroad crossing and that the absence of such markings was a proximate cause of her injuries. CSX contests these points and we are unable to resolve them with the snap of a finger at this stage of the litigation. Indeed, these are questions of fact that are ordinarily left to the state court jury.
In all events, a jurisdictional inquiry is not the appropriate stage of litigation to resolve these various uncertain questions of law and fact. Allowing joinder of the public defendants is proper in this case because courts should minimize threshold litigation over jurisdiction. See Navarro Sav. Ass’n v. Lee, 446 U.S. 458, 464 n. 13, 100 S.Ct. 1779, 64 L.Ed.2d 425 (1980) (“Jurisdiction should be as self-regulated as breathing; ... litigation over whether the case is in the right court is essentially a waste of time and resources.” (internal quotation marks omitted)). Jurisdictional rules direct judicial traffic. They function to steer litigation to the proper forum with a minimum of preliminary fuss. The best way to advance this objective is to accept the parties joined on the face of the complaint unless joinder is clearly improper. To permit extensive litigation of the merits of a case while determining jurisdiction thwarts the purpose of jurisdictional rules.
The district court erred by delving too far into the merits in deciding a jurisdictional question. The district court should not have made its own determination concerning the novel application of the public duty rule to Hartley’s claims. It also incorrectly placed the burden on Hartley to show that her claims may succeed rather than requiring CSX to negate all possibility of recovery. The issues that the district court attempted to resolve are properly left to the state court for later stages of litigation.
III.
We cannot predict with certainty how a state court and state jury would resolve[*426] the legal issues and weigh the factual evidence in this case. Hartley’s claims may not succeed ultimately, but ultimate success is not required to defeat removal. Marshall, 6 F.3d at 233. Rather, there need be only a slight possibility of a right to relief. Id. Once the court identifies this glimmer of hope for the plaintiff, the jurisdictional inquiry ends.
We therefore reverse and remand with directions to remand this case to state court.
REVERSED AND REMANDED.