| #1 |
green |
Miller v. Albright, 523 U.S. 420 (1998)
An equal protection claim fails when the challenged classifications consist of individuals who are not similarly situated.
A petitioner challenges the constitutionality of a statutory distinction in the Immigration and Nationality Act between children born out of wedlock to citizen mothers and those born to citizen fathers. The statute requires children of citizen fathers to obtain formal proof of paternity, such as legitimation or a court adjudication, before the child reaches age eighteen to acquire citizenship, whereas no such requirement exists for children of citizen mothers. The Court holds that this distinction does not violate the Fifth Amendment because the requirements are supported by valid governmental interests, including ensuring reliable proof of biological relationships and fostering ties between the child and the citizen parent. The statutory classification is not arbitrary or invidious.
|
co-cited 5× |
| #2 |
green |
Tuan Anh Nguyen v. Immigr. & Naturalization Serv., 533 U.S. 53 (2001)
A gender-based statutory distinction is constitutional if it serves important governmental objectives and the means employed are substantially related to achieving those objectives.
A petitioner challenges the constitutionality of a federal statute that imposes different requirements for the acquisition of citizenship by children born abroad and out of wedlock depending on whether the citizen parent is the mother or the father. The statute requires an unwed father to establish paternity through legitimation, a written acknowledgment under oath, or a court order, whereas no such affirmative steps are required of an unwed mother. Applying heightened scrutiny, the Court holds that the gender-based distinction is consistent with the equal protection guarantee of the Fifth Amendment because the classification serves important governmental objectives of verifying biological parentage and ensuring an opportunity for a meaningful relationship to develop between the parent and child.
|
co-cited 5× |
| #3 |
green |
United States v. Flores-Villar, 536 F.3d 990 (9th Cir. 2008)
Statutory residence requirements imposed only on citizen fathers, not mothers, for transmitting citizenship to a foreign-born out-of-wedlock child survive equal protection review.
A United States citizen father who had a child out of wedlock abroad with a non-citizen mother challenged statutes requiring him, after age fourteen, to have resided in the United States for five years before transmitting citizenship, a requirement not imposed on citizen mothers, as violating equal protection based on gender and age. The court considers whether these residence requirements survive constitutional scrutiny. It holds that the requirements survive under intermediate scrutiny, assumed arguendo, because they substantially further interests in avoiding statelessness and fostering a parent-child tie to this country, and they also survive rational basis review. The judgment of conviction is affirmed.
|
co-cited 5× |
| #4 |
green |
Iowa-Des Moines Nat'l Bank v. Bennett, 284 U.S. 239 (1932)
Taxpayers are entitled to a refund of excess taxes when discriminatory taxation violates the right to equal treatment by favoring competitors.
When county taxing officials wrongfully applied lower tax rates to competing domestic corporations by misclassifying their assets, the resulting systematic discrimination violated federal law and the Fourteenth Amendment. Although the state court held that the officials acted without authority and thus the discrimination was not an act of the state, the Supreme Court determines that acts performed by state officials under color of authority in the performance of their duties constitute state action. Because the right to equal treatment is violated when competitors are taxed at lower rates, the aggrieved taxpayers are entitled to a refund of the excess taxes exacted, rather than being required to wait for the state to increase the taxes of its competitors.
|
co-cited 4× |
| #5 |
green |
Rogers v. Bellei, 401 U.S. 815 (1971)
Congress may constitutionally impose residency requirements for the retention of citizenship acquired by descent through statutory enactment rather than the Fourteenth Amendment.
A person born abroad to a United States citizen parent and an alien parent is a citizen at birth under statutory provisions but must satisfy a continuous residence requirement in the United States to retain that citizenship. The plaintiff, born in Italy, failed to meet the residency requirements of the Immigration and Nationality Act and was notified of the loss of his citizenship. He challenged the constitutionality of the statutory revocation under the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments. The Court holds that because the plaintiff's citizenship was granted solely by statute and not by the Fourteenth Amendment, Congress may constitutionally impose reasonable residency conditions to address concerns regarding dual nationality.
|
co-cited 4× |
| #6 |
green |
Frontiero v. Richardson, 411 U.S. 677 (1973)
The Equal Protection Clause prohibits sex-based discrimination in the administration of military dependency benefits.
A female member of the uniformed services challenged federal statutes that allowed male members to claim their wives as dependents for housing and medical benefits without proof of dependency, while requiring servicewomen to prove their husbands relied on them for more than half of their support. The court addressed whether this sex-based distinction violated the Due Process Clause of the Fifth Amendment. Applying strict judicial scrutiny to sex-based classifications, the court determined that the statutes were unconstitutional because they relied on administrative convenience rather than a relationship to individual responsibility. The court held that such arbitrary distinctions violate the Constitution.
|
co-cited 4× |
| #7 |
green |
Weinberger v. Wiesenfeld, 420 U.S. 636 (1975)
A gender-based statutory classification that denies survivor benefits to widowers while providing them to widows violates the equal protection component of the Fifth Amendment.
A widower challenged a Social Security Act provision that provided survivor benefits to widows with dependent children but denied similar benefits to widowers. The government argued the distinction was designed to allow mothers to remain at home to care for children. The Court held that this gender-based classification violates the Due Process Clause of the Fifth Amendment. Because the statutory purpose was to provide children with the personal attention of a surviving parent, the sex of that parent is irrelevant. The Court rejected the idea that a benign, compensatory purpose justifies a classification based on overbroad and archaic generalizations about gender roles.
|
co-cited 4× |
| #8 |
green |
Fiallo ex rel. Rodriguez v. Bell, 430 U.S. 787 (1977)
Congress possesses broad power over immigration and naturalization to make classifications regarding preferential visa status that are subject to limited judicial review.
Appellants challenged the constitutionality of the Immigration and Nationality Act, which provides special immigration preference status to certain parents and children of United States citizens or residents but excludes the relationship between an illegitimate child and its natural father. The appellants alleged that the statutory definitions violated equal protection and due process rights by discriminating based on sex and legitimacy. The Court held that the statutory provisions are constitutional because Congress possesses exceptionally broad power over the admission of aliens. Under a standard of limited judicial review, the Court determined that the legislative distinctions are policy choices entrusted to the political branches and are subject only to narrow scrutiny.
|
co-cited 4× |
| #9 |
green |
Orr v. Orr, 440 U.S. 268 (1979)
State statutes authorizing courts to impose alimony obligations only on husbands violate equal protection by discriminating against men (unconstitutional alimony laws may not discriminate against men).
A husband challenged the constitutionality of Alabama alimony statutes that authorized courts to impose alimony obligations on husbands but not on wives. The husband asserted that these gender-based classifications violated the Equal Protection Clause. The court applies intermediate scrutiny, holding that gender classifications must serve important governmental objectives and be substantially related to the achievement of those objectives. Although the state asserted objectives of assisting needy spouses and compensating women for past discrimination, the court finds the gender-based distinction gratuitous because individualized hearings can achieve these goals without relying on sex as a proxy. The court holds the statutes unconstitutional.
|
co-cited 4× |
| #10 |
green |
Califano v. Westcott, 443 U.S. 76 (1979)
A federal statute violates the Due Process Clause if it uses gender-based classifications that are not substantially related to the achievement of important governmental objectives.
A federal statute providing Aid to Families with Dependent Children benefits only to families where the father is unemployed violates the Due Process Clause of the Fifth Amendment. Although the government argued the gender distinction was intended to reduce costs and deter paternal desertion, the classification was based on archaic sexual stereotypes regarding the roles of breadwinners. The court finds that the gender-based distinction is not substantially related to the achievement of important governmental objectives. Because the statute is underinclusive, the court orders the extension of benefits to families where the mother is unemployed, rather than nullifying the program, to ensure gender neutrality.
|
co-cited 4× |
| #11 |
green |
Wengler v. Druggists Mut. Ins., 446 U.S. 142 (1980)
Gender discrimination claims are subject to intermediate scrutiny requiring that the challenged law be substantially related to the achievement of important governmental objectives (applying intermediate scrutiny to a state workers' compensation statute).
A Missouri workers' compensation statute provides death benefits to a widow by conclusively presuming her dependency, but requires a widower to prove actual dependency or physical/mental incapacity to receive benefits. The appellant, a widower, challenged the statute under the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. The Court holds that gender-based classifications must serve important governmental objectives and the discriminatory means employed must be substantially related to the achievement of those objectives. The Court determines that the state's claim of administrative convenience fails to justify the gender-based distinction, as the burden rests on those defending the discrimination to justify the means used.
|
co-cited 4× |
| #12 |
green |
Heckler v. Mathews, 465 U.S. 728 (1984)
Gender-based classifications are constitutional if the government provides an exceedingly persuasive justification that is substantially related to achieving important governmental objectives such as protecting reasonable reliance interests.
A retired postal worker challenged a Social Security Act amendment that required nondependent husbands to offset spousal benefits by the amount of their government pensions, while exempting certain women from this requirement. The plaintiff alleged this gender-based classification violated the Due Process Clause of the Fifth Amendment. The Court held that the government must provide an exceedingly persuasive justification for gender-based classifications. It determined that protecting reasonable reliance interests of individuals who planned their retirements based on prior law constitutes a legitimate and important governmental objective. Because the statutory exception was substantially related to this objective, the gender-based classification is constitutional.
|
co-cited 4× |