Nevada Bd. of Osteopathic Med. v. Graham
A medical board's license revocation is invalid if the agency fails to provide the licensee with statutory due process rights, including notice and the right to counsel, during the final decision-making process.
A state medical board revoked a physician's license for gross malpractice after a hearing where the physician was present with counsel. Subsequently, the board met without the physician or his counsel to consider new complaints and examination results before voting to revoke the license. The physician appealed, arguing he was denied statutory rights to notice, representation, and the opportunity to call witnesses. The court applies the rule that administrative agencies must afford due process, including the right to be heard and represented, before imposing severe sanctions. The court holds that the board's failure to provide these fundamental rights during the final decision-making process rendered the revocation invalid. The court affirms the lower court's invalidation of the license revocation but reverses the award of attorney's fees due to lack of statutory authority.
At page 175Denial of due process rights in professional licensing hearings1 citing case“The court concluded that because Graham was deprived of his fundamental rights of due process of law, the Board’s ruling was invalid.”
- Zenor v. State, Dep't of Transp., 134 Nev. 109 (2018).published Bd. of Osteopathic Med. v. Graham, 98 Nev. 174, 175, 643 P.2d 1222, 1223 (1982)).
v.
Frank Graham, D.O.
[*175] OPINION
Per Curiam:The Nevada Board of Osteopathic Medicine issued a formal complaint against Frank Graham alleging unprofessional conduct and gross malpractice. The Board conducted a hearing on the complaint on July 17, 1979. Graham was present with counsel. At the conclusion of the hearing it was agreed that two physicians would examine Graham relative to his medical competency. This was done. The Board met on August 9, 1979 to consider the results of the examination. The Board further considered newspaper reports concerning Graham and two additional complaints that had been filed against Graham since the July meeting. Neither Graham nor his counsel was present. At the conclusion of the meeting, the Board voted to' revoke Graham’s license for gross malpractice.
Graham appealed the Board’s ruling to the district court. The court below found, among other things, that at the August 1979 hearing Graham had been denied his statutory rights to notice of the hearing (NRS 233B. 121(1)); to be represented by counsel (NRS 233B.121(3)); the right to call and examine witnesses (NRS 233B. 123(4)). The court concluded that because Graham was deprived of his fundamental rights of due process of law, the Board’s ruling was invalid. We agree.
The district court also awarded Graham $1,500.00 attorney’s fees. This was improper. The settled rule is that attorney’s fees may not be awarded in the absence of a statute, rule or contract granting them. State ex rel. List v. Courtesy Motors, 95 Nev. 103, 590 P.2d 163 (1979). NRS 18.010 only applies to actions[*176] for money damages. International Industries v. United Mortgage Co., 96 Nev. 150, 157, 606 P.2d 163, 167 (1980). There is no statutory authority for the award of the fees.
We affirm the judgment below except as to the award of the attorney’s fees, which we reverse.
Gunderson, C. J., and Manoukian, Springer, and Mow-bray, JJ., and Zenoff, Sr. J.,[1] concur.