| #2 |
red |
California v. Cabazon Band of Mission Indians, 480 U.S. 202 (1987)
A state may only enforce its laws on an Indian reservation under Public Law 280 if the laws are criminal in nature rather than civil and regulatory.
Two Indian Tribes operate bingo and card games on their reservations, which are subject to state gambling regulations and local ordinances. The State seeks to enforce these laws, arguing they are criminal in nature under Public Law 280. The Court determines whether state laws are prohibitory or regulatory by assessing whether the conduct violates the state's public policy. Because the state permits various forms of gambling, the Court concludes the laws are regulatory rather than prohibitory. Consequently, Public Law 280 does not grant the state authority to enforce these civil regulatory laws on the reservations, as tribal sovereignty is subordinate only to the federal government.
|
co-cited 14× |
| #3 |
green |
White Mountain Apache Tribe v. Bracker, 448 U.S. 136 (1980)
Federal preemption of state authority is inferred when a federal regulatory scheme is comprehensive and pervasive.
A non-Indian logging company operating solely on a reservation is subject to state motor carrier license and fuel use taxes. The court must determine if these state taxes are pre-empted by federal law or infringe upon tribal self-government. Applying a particularized inquiry into state, federal, and tribal interests, the court finds that the federal regulatory scheme governing tribal timber is so pervasive and comprehensive that it leaves no room for additional state burdens. Because the taxes would undermine federal objectives and diminish tribal revenues, the state taxes are pre-empted by federal law.
|
co-cited 13× |
| #4 |
green |
Cotton Petroleum Corp. v. New Mexico, 490 U.S. 163 (1989)
The Commerce Clause and Indian Commerce Clause have distinct applications regarding state taxation authority over tribal lands (interpreting statutory ambiguity in favor of tribal independence).
A non-Indian oil and gas lessee challenged the validity of state severance taxes imposed on production within an Indian reservation, arguing that the taxes were pre-empted by federal law and created an unconstitutional multiple tax burden. The court applies a flexible pre-emption analysis, considering the state, federal, and tribal interests involved. Because the state provided substantial services and the taxes did not impose an undue economic burden on the tribe, the court finds no implied congressional pre-emption. Furthermore, the court holds that tribes are not states under the Commerce Clause, meaning tribal taxes do not require apportionment of state taxes. The state taxes are upheld.
|
co-cited 13× |
| #5 |
green |
Washington v. Confederated Tribes of the Colville Indian Reservation, 447 U.S. 134 (1980)
A state may tax transactions occurring on tribal lands involving nonmembers if the products are obtained off-reservation and the state implements reasonable recordkeeping to prevent fraud.
A state seeks to enforce cigarette and sales taxes on transactions occurring on tribal reservations involving nonmembers. The Tribes argue that these state taxes are pre-empted by tribal ordinances and infringe upon tribal self-government. The Court holds that the power to tax transactions occurring on trust lands and significantly involving a tribe or its members is a fundamental attribute of sovereignty that tribes retain unless divested by federal law or necessary implication of their dependent status. The Court further determines that the state may validly impose recordkeeping requirements for exempt sales to prevent fraud and may seize unstamped cigarettes en route to reservations to enforce collection obligations.
|
co-cited 12× |
| #6 |
green |
New Mexico v. Mescalero Apache Tribe, 462 U.S. 324 (1983)
Tribal hunting regulations prevail over conflicting state laws when a particularized inquiry demonstrates a preference for tribal self-government and federal interests.
A State seeks to apply its hunting and fishing regulations to nonmembers on a reservation, even though the Tribe has established a comprehensive management scheme for wildlife resources with federal assistance. The Court considers whether state jurisdiction is pre-empted by federal law. Applying a particularized inquiry into the nature of competing interests, the Court holds that state jurisdiction is pre-empted if it interferes with or is incompatible with federal and tribal interests reflected in federal law, unless state interests are sufficient to justify the assertion of authority. Because the State's regulations would disrupt the federal and tribal management scheme and undermine tribal self-sufficiency, the State's authority is pre-empted.
|
co-cited 10× |
| #8 |
green |
Ramah Navajo Sch. Bd., Inc. v. Bureau of Revenue of NM, 458 U.S. 832 (1982)
A state cannot impose a gross receipts tax on payments received by a non-Indian contractor for services performed on reservation land for a tribal entity.
A tribal school board contracted with a non-Indian construction company to build a school on reservation land using federal funds. The state imposed a gross receipts tax on the construction project, which the contractor paid and the board subsequently reimbursed. The question is whether federal law pre-empts this state tax. Because federal regulation of the construction and financing of Indian educational institutions is comprehensive and pervasive, and federal policy encourages Indian self-sufficiency in education, the state tax is pre-empted. The tax imposes an undue burden on the federal scheme by depleting funds intended for Indian educational opportunities.
|
co-cited 8× |
| #10 |
green |
Martin v. Georgia Dep't of Pub. Saf., 357 S.E.2d 569 (Ga. 1987)
A self-insurance program covering employees waives the sovereign immunity of a state department despite statutory language to the contrary (adopting Justice Clarke's special concurrence in Robinson).
A state trooper’s high-speed chase results in a fatal crash, leading to a tort suit against the Department of Public Safety and its employees. The court addresses whether the 1983 Constitution’s waiver of sovereign immunity applies when the state maintains liability insurance. The court holds that the constitutional provision waives sovereign and official immunity to the extent that liability insurance coverage exists for the specific claims. Because the department’s insurance fund covers negligence in the performance of official duties, the immunity defenses are waived. The court reverses summary judgment for the department and the trooper on state tort claims, but affirms summary judgment for the commissioner on negligence and federal civil rights claims due to insufficient evidence of deliberate indifference.
|
co-cited 8× |
| #11 |
green |
Moe v. Confederated Salish & Kootenai Tribes of the Flathead Reservation, 425 U.S. 463 (1976)
Federal courts have jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 1362 to enjoin state taxes that conflict with federal law, as the statutory bar in § 1341 does not apply to tribes.
A tribe and its members challenged the constitutionality of state cigarette taxes and personal property taxes applied to reservation residents. The state argued that federal courts were barred from enjoining state tax collection under 28 U.S.C. § 1341. The court holds that 28 U.S.C. § 1362 provides original jurisdiction for civil actions brought by recognized Indian tribes arising under federal law, and because the United States could have brought similar actions to protect tribal interests, the statutory bar in § 1341 does not apply. The court finds the taxes conflict with federal statutes and treaties, and that requiring tribal retailers to collect taxes from non-Indian purchasers is a permissible minimal burden.
|
co-cited 6× |
| #12 |
green |
Mescalero Apache Tribe v. Jones, 411 U.S. 145 (1973)
Indians traveling beyond reservation boundaries are subject to non-discriminatory state laws and taxation otherwise applicable to all citizens of the state (absent express federal law to the contrary).
A tribe operating a ski resort on land leased from the United States Forest Service outside its reservation boundaries challenges the state's imposition of gross receipts and use taxes. The Court holds that, absent express federal law to the contrary, Indians operating beyond reservation boundaries are subject to nondiscriminatory state laws. While the Indian Reorganization Act provides tax immunity for certain lands and rights held in trust, this statutory exemption does not extend to income derived from those rights. However, because the use tax applied to permanent improvements on the exempt land, the immunity for the land itself extends to the use tax on those improvements.
|
co-cited 5× |