Chad Robert Shaffer v. Commonwealth of Virginia
v.
Commonwealth of Virginia
Present: Judges Benton, Elder and Bumgardner
Argued at Salem, Virginia
CHAD ROBERT SHAFFER
MEMORANDUM OPINION [*] BY v. Record No. 0735-01-3 JUDGE LARRY G. ELDER DECEMBER 4, 2001 COMMONWEALTH OF VIRGINIA
FROM THE CIRCUIT COURT OF FRANKLIN COUNTY
William N. Alexander, II, Judge
Melissa W. Friedman (Anthony F. Anderson, on brief), for appellant.
Jennifer R. Franklin, Assistant Attorney General (Randolph A. Beales, Attorney General, on brief), for appellee.
Chad Robert Shaffer (appellant) appeals from his bench trial conviction for attempted carnal knowledge in violation of Code §§ 18.2-26 and 18.2-63. 1 On appeal, he contends the evidence was insufficient to support his conviction or, in the alternative, that his conviction for attempted carnal knowledge simultaneously with his conviction for object sexual penetration in violation of fellatio, anallingus, anal intercourse, [or] animate [or] inanimate object sexual penetration." He also did not contend that evidence of the completed crime of animate object sexual penetration could not be used to support his conviction for the attempted carnal knowledge offense. Finally, he did not contend that use of evidence of the same act of object sexual penetration to support both convictions would constitute double jeopardy.
Nor does the ends of justice exception require us to consider these issues on appeal. To invoke the ends of justice exception, the record must "affirmatively show[] that a miscarriage of justice has occurred, not . . . merely . . . that a miscarriage [of justice] might have occurred." Mounce v. Commonwealth, 4 Va. App. 433, 436, 357 S.E.2d 742, 744 (1987). To satisfy this burden, an appellant must show "more than that the Commonwealth failed to prove an element of the offense . . . . [T]he appellant must demonstrate that he or she was convicted for conduct that was not a criminal offense[,] or the record must affirmatively prove that an element of the offense did not occur." Redman, 25 Va. App. at 221-22, 487 S.E.2d at 272-73.
In this case, although appellant moved to strike, he failed to specifically assert that the evidence was insufficient to prove a particular element of the offense, i.e., an intent to engage in "sexual intercourse, cunnilingus, fellatio, anallingus, anal intercourse, [or] animate [or] inanimate object sexual penetration." Even assuming the evidence of the completed act of object sexual penetration would not support the conviction for attempted carnal knowledge, the evidence does not disprove that appellant acted with some other proscribed intent. For example, the evidence did not prove appellant did not act with an intent to engage in "sexual intercourse, cunnilingus, fellatio, anallingus, anal intercourse, [or] . . . inanimate object sexual penetration." It also did not prove appellant did not act with an intent to commit an additional act of animate object sexual penetration beyond the completed act which supported his separate conviction for object penetration in violation of Code § 18.2-67.2. Thus, the evidence does not prove that an element of the offense did not occur, and the ends of justice exception does not apply. [2]
For these reasons, we hold that appellant failed to preserve his claims of error for appeal and that the ends of justice exception to Rule 5A:18 does not support our consideration of the claimed errors. Therefore, we affirm the challenged conviction.
Affirmed.