DaimlerChrysler Vans v. Freightliner, 2004 DNH 010 (D.N.H. 2004)
No citing cases on record.
v.
Freightliner
DaimlerChrysler Vans v . Freightliner CV-03-304-B 01/08/04
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF NEW HAMPSHIRE
DaimlerChrysler Vans LLC v. Civil N o . 03-304-B Opinion N o . 2004 DNH 010 Freightliner of New Hampshire, Inc.
MEMORANDUM AND ORDER
DaimlerChrysler Vans (“DC Vans”) seeks a preliminary injunction compelling Freightliner of New Hampshire, Inc. (“Freightliner”) to arbitrate a dispute that is currently pending before the New Hampshire Motor Vehicle Industry Board. I deny DC Vans’ request for an injunction because federal law protects Freightliner from having to abide by the arbitration clauses in its dealer contracts.
I.
A. The Dealer Agreements
On October 3 1 , 2001, and November 1 4 , 2001, DC Vans entered into agreements authorizing Freightliner to sell “Sprinter” utility vans from dealerships in Londonderry and Lebanon, New Hampshire (the “Dealer Agreements”). The Dealer Agreements contain clauses that obligate the parties to arbitrate “all controversies, disputes, or claims . . . arising from or relating to [the agreements] . . . .” (Alosa Aff. Ex. 12 Art. 18(3).)
B. The Target Agreements
The Dealer Agreements require the parties to attempt to reach “Target Agreements” for each year that the Dealer Agreements are in effect. One of the items that the parties must attempt to agree on in each Target Agreement is a “Sales Volume Objective” for the upcoming year. If the parties are unable to agree on a Sales Volume Objective, the Dealer Agreements describe a process by which DC Vans is authorized to establish the objective unilaterally. Freightliner’s performances of its sales responsibility will be evaluated in part based on its achievement of the Sales Volume Objective. Additionally, DC Vans uses the Sales Volume Objective in determining Freightliner’s eligibility for certain bonuses.
DC Vans sent Freightliner proposed Target Agreements for the Londonderry and Lebanon dealerships in March 2003. Freightliner’s president, Joseph Alosa, signed both agreements on March 2 7 , 2003 but did not immediately return them to DC Vans. Instead, he signed identical copies on April 7 , 2003 and sent DC Vans the newly signed agreements. The Londonderry Target Agreement specifies a purchase target of 60 vans and a minimum retail sales target of 52 vans. The Derry Target Agreement specifies a purchase target of 7 vans and a retail sales target of 4 vans.
C. The Current Litigation
DC Vans sent Freightliner a notice on July 1 9 , 2002 stating that: (1) it planned to introduce a new Dodge-branded Sprinter van in 2006; (2) the new van would be sold exclusively through Dodge dealers; and (3) until the new van was released, Sprinter vans would be sold by both Freightliner and Dodge dealers.
On February 2 5 , 2003, Freightliner filed an administrative protest with the New Hampshire Motor Vehicle Industry Board challenging the changes that DC Vans proposed to make in its Sprinter van distribution program. DC Vans responded on March 2 8 , 2003 with a demand that Freightliner submit its dispute to arbitration. DC Vans commenced the present action after Freightliner refused to arbitrate.
II. [1]
DC Vans argues that the arbitration clauses in the Dealer Agreements require Freightliner to arbitrate the current dispute because the dispute “aris[es] from or relat[es] to” the Dealer Agreements. Freightliner responds by claiming that the arbitration clauses are unenforceable under 15 U.S.C. § 1226(a)(2). Section 1226(a)(2) bars a party to a motor vehicle franchise contract from enforcing an arbitration clause in the contract unless all parties to the contract consent to arbitration. The law applies, however, only to arbitration agreements that are “entered into, amended, altered, modified, renewed, or extended after November 2 , 2002.” 15 U.S.C. § 1226(b). Because the Dealer Agreements were executed prior to November 2 , 2002, Freightliner’s argument has merit only if the 2003 Target Agreements “amended, altered or modified” the Dealer Agreements.
DC Vans offers two arguments to support its contention that the Target Agreements are inconsequential. First, it asserts that the agreements merely implement the Dealer Agreements.[2] I disagree. The Target Agreements establish sales objectives for both dealerships. These objectives were not fixed by the Dealer Agreements but instead were proposed by DC Vans and agreed to by Freightliner. The sales objectives are significant to both parties because they will be used to determine Freightliner’s eligibility for bonuses. The Target Agreements thus make changes to the Dealer Agreements that are sufficiently consequential to qualify as amendments to the Dealer Agreements.
DC Vans’ second argument is that the Target Agreements are irrelevant because they did not become effective until after it made its demand for arbitration on March 2 8 , 2003. Because DC Vans has failed to develop this argument, I decline to discuss it in detail. Instead, I merely note that § 1226(a)(2) applies to agreements that are amended at any point after November 2 , 2002. The law does not exempt amendments that occur after a demand for arbitration is made. Accordingly, I need not resolve the parties’ dispute as to whether the Target Agreements became effective in March, when they were first signed, or in April, when duplicate copies were signed and delivered to DC Vans.
III.
For the reasons set forth in this Memorandum and Order, I determine that DC Vans is not likely to succeed on the merits of its request for arbitration. Accordingly, it is not entitled to a preliminary injunction. See SEC v . Fife, 311 F.3d 1 (1st Cir. 2002) (likelihood of success is a prerequisite to the issuance of a preliminary injunction). DC Vans’ motion for preliminary injunction (doc. n o . 4 ) is denied. I propose to grant summary judgment to Freightliner unless, on or before January 3 0 , 2004, DC Vans is able to demonstrate that facts material to the resolution of this case remain in genuine dispute.
SO ORDERED.
Paul Barbadoro Chief Judge
January 8 , 2004 cc: Gregory A . Holmes, Esq.
Mary E . Tenn, Esq.
Richard V . Wiebusch, Esq.