Kuperman v. Wrenn, 2010 DNH 153 (D.N.H. 2010)
No citing cases on record.
v.
Wrenn, et al.
Kuperman v . Wrenn, et a l . 08-CV-513-SM 08/27/10 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
DISTRICT OF NEW HAMPSHIRE
Albert R. Kuperman, Plaintiff v. Civil N o . 08-cv-513-SM Opinion N o . 2010 DNH 153 William R. Wrenn, Commissioner, New Hampshire Department of Corrections; Richard M. Gerry, Warden, New Hampshire State Prison; Michael A . Samson; and Steven E . Britton, Defendants
O R D E R
Albert Kuperman is an inmate at the New Hampshire State Prison (“NHSP”). He brought suit to challenge a prison regulation that prohibits an inmate from growing facial hair longer than 1/4 inch. See 42 U.S.C. § 1983. An orthodox Jew, Kuperman claims that the regulation violates his rights under: (1) the free exercise clause of the First Amendment to the United States Constitution; (2) the equal protection clause of the Fourteenth Amendment; and (3) the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act (“RLUIPA”), 42 U.S.C. § 2000cc et seq.[1] Before the court is defendants’ motion for summary Meuser, 564 F.3d at 515 (citing Rochester Ford Sales, Inc. v . Ford Motor Co., 287 F.3d 3 2 , 38 (1st Cir. 2002)).
Defendants say the regulation limiting the length of beards (allowed only under special circumstances) to 1/4 inch, promotes hygiene, safety, and security. (See Boyajian Aff. (document n o . 2 7 - 2 ) , ¶¶ 5-6.) That length allows correctional officers to identify inmates easily, prevents inmates from hiding contraband and weapons in beards, and minimizes the risk that an escaped inmate could quickly change his appearance after an escape. (See id. ¶ 5.) A grooming policy that allowed full beards, on the other hand, would strain prison resources and/or relations between inmates and staff by requiring the issuance of multiple identification cards and by requiring more frequent inmate searches. (See id. ¶ 6.) Moreover, such a policy would provide escaped inmates with a fast and simple way to dramatically alter their appearances. (See id.)
Discussion
Defendants move for summary judgment on all three of Kuperman’s claims, supporting their motion with affidavits from Captain Charles Boyajian, unit manager of the SHU and the Close Custody Unit at the NHSP in Concord, and Lieutenant Paul Cascio, Lieutenant of Security for the SPU and the RTU at the NHSP in Concord. Kuperman has produced only a single exhibit, a one-page newsletter titled “Inmate Communications Committee,” that includes a brief discussion of the NHSP shaving policy.
such rights in a prison than it would allow elsewhere.” Beard, 548 U.S. at 528 (citation omitted). Specifically, “restrictive prison regulations are permissible if they are reasonably related to legitimate penological interests and are not an exaggerated response to such objectives.” Id. (quoting Turner, 482 U.S. at 87) (internal quotation marks omitted).
Turner . . . sets forth four factors relevant in determining the reasonableness of the regulation at issue. First, is there a valid, rational connection between the prison regulation and the legitimate governmental interest put forward to justify it? Second, are there alternative means of exercising the right that remain open to prison inmates? Third, what impact will accommodation of the asserted constitutional right have on guards and other inmates, and on the allocation of prison resources generally? And, fourth, are ready alternatives for furthering the governmental interest available?
Beard, 548 U.S. at 529 (citations and punctuation omitted).
prison authorities.” Beard, 548 U.S. at 530. “Unless a prisoner can point to sufficient evidence regarding such issues of judgment to allow him to prevail on the merits, he cannot prevail at the summary judgment stage.” Id.
B . Fourteenth Amendment Claim
In his Report and Recommendation, the Magistrate Judge construed Kuperman’s complaint to be claiming that the Warden discriminated against him on account of both his religion and his classification status, in violation of the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. Specifically, he claims that he was not allowed to grow a beard longer than 1/4 inch while in a medium security unit, but inmates confined in high-security units were allowed to grow beards of any length. Defendants have countered with evidence, undisputed by Kuperman, that inmates in some high-security units, who are not allowed to possess razors, are shaved by barbers once a week or once every two weeks. Kuperman has offered no evidence tending to show that any inmate is permitted to grow a full untrimmed beard, or anything more than a two-week growth of facial hair. See Meuser, 564 F.3d at 515 (“Once the moving party avers an absence of evidence to support the non-moving party’s case, the non-moving party must offer definite, competent evidence to rebut the motion . . .”) (internal quotation marks and citation omitted). Moreover, defendants have offered a rational basis for allowing some inmates to go a week or two between shaves – the danger associated with allowing them to possess razors, and the resource limitations dictating time intervals between shaves by a barber. Defendants are entitled to judgment as a matter of law on Kuperman’s Equal Protection claim.
C . RLUIPA Claim
Kuperman also claims that enforcement of 7.17(IV)(D) violates his rights under RLUIPA. Defendants counter that the beard-length restriction is a lawful imposition on Kuperman’s religious freedom, and is the least restrictive means of furthering the state’s compelling interest in maintaining prison safety and security.
burden is the least restrictive means of achieving that compelling interest. Id.
Spratt v . R.I. Dep’t of Corr., 482 F.3d 3 3 , 38 (1st Cir. 2007). Regarding the third and fourth elements, “in passing RLUIPA, Congress stated that [courts] should continue to give ‘due deference to the experience and expertise of prison and jail administrators’ in determining prison policy.” Id. at 38-39 (quoting Cutter v . Wilkinson, 544 U.S. 709, 717 (2005)). “However . . . inadequately formulated prison regulations and policies grounded on mere speculation, exaggerated fears, or post-hoc rationalizations will not suffice to meet the act’s requirements.” Spratt, 482 F.3d at 39 (citation and internal quotation marks omitted).
To meet their burden under the third element of Kuperman’s RLUIPA claim, defendants must identify a compelling governmental interest and must also establish that the beard-length restriction furthers that interest. See Spratt, 482 F.3d at 39 (“merely stating a compelling interest does not fully satisfy [the defendant prison’s] burden on this element of RLUIPA; [the defendant] must also establish that prison security is furthered by barring [the plaintiff prisoner] from engaging in any preaching at any time”). Defendants have identified prison security as a compelling governmental interest, and so it i s . See id. at 39 (citing Cutter, 544 U.S. at 725 n.13). They have also produced testimonial evidence from a senior NHSP correctional officer to the effect that a restriction on the length of inmate facial hair directly furthers institutional security in three ways: (1) by making it easier for correctional officers to identify inmates; (2) by depriving inmates of a means to conceal weapons or contraband; and (3) by depriving inmates of a way to quickly change their appearances.
substantial deference. See Spratt, 482 F.3d at 38-39. While Boyajian’s affidavit may be somewhat thin, it is not nearly as deficient as the affidavit the court of appeals found wanting in Spratt. See id. at 39-40. Kuperman, on the other hand, has produced no evidence to counter Boyajian’s affidavit and, as a consequence, has failed to establish a trialworthy issue of material fact regarding the third element of his RLUIPA claim. See Meuser, 564 F.3d at 515.
generously, but such modest degrees of difference are best left to the judgment of prison administrators. That is particularly so here, where the issue is not well-developed. Plaintiff has not suggested, and the court cannot envision, plausible and pragmatic lesser alternative means of meeting the prison’s legitimate security concerns than a reasonable beard-length rule.