case without rule (New York) · Go Syfert
← New York issues

case without rule in New York

5 New York opinions name it 3 courts 1895–1912 0 in the last five years

The cases below were cited by New York courts in a sentence that names this issue. Sides come from how each citing opinion treated the case (Syfertize flag on that citation), so a case can appear on both: that is where the law is contested. A red or yellow chip is the case's own overall treatment.

Followed or applied (0)

CaseFollowedCited
No positive-treatment citations attached to this issue in New York.

Distinguished, questioned or overruled (0)

CaseNegativeCited
No negative-treatment citations attached to this issue in New York. Read the followed side critically anyway.

Also cited on this issue (9)

CaseCitedYears
O'Brien v. . Home Benefit Society green
ny · 1889
2 sentences

1898In that case, as in this, the deceased was able to read and write; but it was held that that fact did not take the case without the rule laid down in O’Brien v. Society, 117 N. Y. 310 , 22 N. E. 954 , that: “Where the Insured gives true answers to the questions put to him as the basis of insurance, and an authorized agent of the insurance company inserts in the application false answers, the company, and not the insured, is responsible for their falsity, and their falsity is no defense to an action upon the policy.” In the Peters Case, Mr. Justice Bartlett said: “In those cases, it is true, th

1898In that case, as in this, the deceased was able to read and write; but it was held that that fact did not take the case without the rule laid down in O’Brien v. Society, 117 N. Y. 310 , 22 N. E. 954 , that: “Where the Insured gives true answers to the questions put to him as the basis of insurance, and an authorized agent of the insurance company inserts in the application false answers, the company, and not the insured, is responsible for their falsity, and their falsity is no defense to an action upon the policy.” In the Peters Case, Mr. Justice Bartlett said: “In those cases, it is true, th

21898–1898
Sonnentheil v. Christian Moerlein Brewing Co. green
scotus · 1899
1 sentence

1912Co., 119 id. 540; Sonnentheil v. Moerlein Brewing Co., 172 U. S. 401 .) But direct interest, such as would have disqualified the witness at common law, is not necessary to take the case without the exception.

11912–1912
Peters v. United States Industrial Insurance neutral
nyappdiv · 1896
1 sentence

1898Co. ( 10 App. Div. 533 ; affirmed by the Court of Appeals, 154 N. Y. 758 , on the opinion of this court)." In that case as in this the deceased was able to read and write ; but it was held that that fact did not take the case without the rule laid down in O' Brien v. Home Benefit Society ( 117 N. Y. 310 ), that “where the insured gives .true answers to the questions put to him as the basis of insurance, and an authorized agent of the insurance company inserts in the application false answers, the company and not the insured is responsible for their falsity, and that their falsity is no defense

11898–1898
Keats v. Hugo green
mass · 1874
1 sentence

1898N. C. 435 ; Doyle v. Lord, 64 N. Y. 432 ; Myers v. Gemmel, 10 Barb. 537 ; Palmer v. Wetmore, 2 Sandf. 316 ; Keats v. Hugo, 115 Mass. 204 .) Eor does the fact that the windows are in a party wall take this case without the rule.

11898–1898
Doyle v. . Lord green
ny · 1876
1 sentence

1898N. C. 435 ; Doyle v. Lord, 64 N. Y. 432 ; Myers v. Gemmel, 10 Barb. 537 ; Palmer v. Wetmore, 2 Sandf. 316 ; Keats v. Hugo, 115 Mass. 204 .) Eor does the fact that the windows are in a party wall take this case without the rule.

11898–1898
Peters v. . United States Industrial Insurance Company neutral
ny · 1897
1 sentence

1898Co. ( 10 App. Div. 533 ; affirmed by the Court of Appeals, 154 N. Y. 758 , on the opinion of this court)." In that case as in this the deceased was able to read and write ; but it was held that that fact did not take the case without the rule laid down in O' Brien v. Home Benefit Society ( 117 N. Y. 310 ), that “where the insured gives .true answers to the questions put to him as the basis of insurance, and an authorized agent of the insurance company inserts in the application false answers, the company and not the insured is responsible for their falsity, and that their falsity is no defense

11898–1898
Myers v. Gemmel neutral
nysupct · 1851
1 sentence

1898N. C. 435 ; Doyle v. Lord, 64 N. Y. 432 ; Myers v. Gemmel, 10 Barb. 537 ; Palmer v. Wetmore, 2 Sandf. 316 ; Keats v. Hugo, 115 Mass. 204 .) Eor does the fact that the windows are in a party wall take this case without the rule.

11898–1898
Palmer v. Wetmore green
nysuperctnyc · 1849
1 sentence

1898N. C. 435 ; Doyle v. Lord, 64 N. Y. 432 ; Myers v. Gemmel, 10 Barb. 537 ; Palmer v. Wetmore, 2 Sandf. 316 ; Keats v. Hugo, 115 Mass. 204 .) Eor does the fact that the windows are in a party wall take this case without the rule.

11898–1898
Helmer v. Shoemaker neutral
nysupct · 1839
1 sentence

1895Dig. 23 ; Jackson v. Robins, 16 Johns. 538 ; Helmer v. Shoemaker, 22 Wend. 137 ), the adjudication is, nevertheless, inapplicable to the present case, for here we have every element of a limitation repugnant to a devise in fee, with none of the peculiar characteristics which the courts have sometimes found to bring a case without the rule declaring the subsequent limitation void.

11895–1895

Where else courts name it

TX 10 (1929–2024) AL 10 (1870–1996) CA 9 (1932–2011) SC 6 (1903–2018) MI 5 (1896–2018) NY 5 (1895–1912) WA 4 (1932–2024) MO 4 (1936–1993) IN 4 (1910–2020) VT 3 (1984–2015) UT 3 (2007–2013) TN 3 (1929–2024) GA 3 (1930–1983) NM 3 (1996–2021) PA 3 (1930–2015) KS 2 (1911–1986) FL 2 (1983–1990) MT 2 (1956–2025) OH 2 (2016–2022) IL 2 (1906–1966) MA 2 (1922–1925) OK 2 (1992–2013)

Opinions by the citing court's state. A doctrine retained in one state and abandoned in another shows up here as a year span that stalls.

← Caselaw search · G Cite Topics · Brief Check