priest-penitent privilege (New York) · Go Syfert
← New York issues

priest-penitent privilege in New York

5 New York opinions name it 2 courts 1979–2025 1 in the last five years

The cases below were cited by New York courts in a sentence that names this issue. Sides come from how each citing opinion treated the case (Syfertize flag on that citation), so a case can appear on both: that is where the law is contested. A red or yellow chip is the case's own overall treatment.

Followed or applied (3)

CaseFollowedCited
S.E. v. Diocese of Brooklyngreen
nyappdiv · 2025 · cited in 1 New York opinions naming this issue, 2025–2025
2 sentences

2025Moreover, certain portions of the personnel files were not subject to redaction pursuant to CPLR 4504, the physician-patient privilege, and CPLR 4507, the client-psychologist privilege ( see Maida v Diocese of Brooklyn , _____ AD3d _____, 2025 NY Slip Op 06314 ; S.E. v Diocese of Brooklyn , 240 AD3d at 743).

2025Additionally, the Supreme Court properly determined that certain portions of the personnel files were not subject to redaction pursuant to CPLR 4505, the priest-penitent privilege, as the Diocese failed to establish that such documents were related to a communication that Failla "made in confidence and for the purpose of obtaining spiritual guidance" ( S.E. v Diocese of Brooklyn , 240 AD3d at 743 [internal quotation marks omitted]; see People v Carmona , 82 NY2d 603, 609 ).

11
People v. Carmonagreen
ny · 1993 · cited in 1 New York opinions naming this issue, 2025–2025
1 sentence

2025Additionally, the Supreme Court properly determined that certain portions of the personnel files were not subject to redaction pursuant to CPLR 4505, the priest-penitent privilege, as the Diocese failed to establish that such documents were related to a communication that Failla "made in confidence and for the purpose of obtaining spiritual guidance" ( S.E. v Diocese of Brooklyn , 240 AD3d at 743 [internal quotation marks omitted]; see People v Carmona , 82 NY2d 603, 609 ).

11
Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints v. Superior Courtgreen
arizctapp · 1988 · cited in 1 New York opinions naming this issue, 1992–1992
1 sentence

1992However, by voluntarily repeating the substance of his admissions to the priest, an act clearly inconsistent with any desire to maintain a priest-penitent privilege, the defendant effectively waived that privilege (see, People v O’Connor, 85 AD2d 92 ; People v Fentress, 103 Misc 2d 179 ; see also, Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints v Superior Ct., 159 Ariz 24, 764 P2d 759 ; Perry v Arkansas, 280 Ark 36 , 655 SW2d 380 ; Kansas v Andrews, 187 Kan 458, 357 P2d 739 , cert denied 368 US 868 ; see generally, Richardson, Evidence § 418 [Prince 10th ed]; cf., People v Brown, 82 Misc 2d 115 ).

11

Distinguished, questioned or overruled (0)

CaseNegativeCited
No negative-treatment citations attached to this issue in New York. Read the followed side critically anyway.

Also cited on this issue (15)

CaseCitedYears
People v. O'Connor green
nyappdiv · 1982
2 sentences

1993He acted contrary to the very essence of the privilege by discussing the subject matter of the purportedly confidential communication with third persons (see, 8 Wigmore, Evidence § 2285 [McNaughton rev 1961]; Richardson, Evidence §§ 418, 425 [Prince 10th ed]; and see, e.g., People v Figueroa, 173 AD2d 156, 159 ; Matter of Rivera v Coughlin, 133 AD2d 694, 695 ; People v O’Connor, 85 AD2d 92, 97 ; People v Fentress, 103 Mise 2d 179, 191-196).

1992However, by voluntarily repeating the substance of his admissions to the priest, an act clearly inconsistent with any desire to maintain a priest-penitent privilege, the defendant effectively waived that privilege (see, People v O’Connor, 85 AD2d 92 ; People v Fentress, 103 Misc 2d 179 ; see also, Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints v Superior Ct., 159 Ariz 24, 764 P2d 759 ; Perry v Arkansas, 280 Ark 36 , 655 SW2d 380 ; Kansas v Andrews, 187 Kan 458, 357 P2d 739 , cert denied 368 US 868 ; see generally, Richardson, Evidence § 418 [Prince 10th ed]; cf., People v Brown, 82 Misc 2d 115 ).

21992–1993
People v. Fentress green
nycountyct · 1980
2 sentences

1993He acted contrary to the very essence of the privilege by discussing the subject matter of the purportedly confidential communication with third persons ( see , 8 Wigmore, Evidence § 2285 [McNaughton rev 1961]; Richardson, Evidence §§ 418, 425 [Prince 10th ed]; and see, e.g. , People v Figueroa , 173 AD2d 156, 159 ; Matter of Rivera v Coughlin , 133 AD2d 694, 695 ; People v O'Connor , 85 AD2d 92, 97 ; People v Fentress , 103 Misc 2d 179, 191-196 ).

1992However, by voluntarily repeating the substance of his admissions to the priest, an act clearly inconsistent with any desire to maintain a priest-penitent privilege, the defendant effectively waived that privilege (see, People v O’Connor, 85 AD2d 92 ; People v Fentress, 103 Misc 2d 179 ; see also, Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints v Superior Ct., 159 Ariz 24, 764 P2d 759 ; Perry v Arkansas, 280 Ark 36 , 655 SW2d 380 ; Kansas v Andrews, 187 Kan 458, 357 P2d 739 , cert denied 368 US 868 ; see generally, Richardson, Evidence § 418 [Prince 10th ed]; cf., People v Brown, 82 Misc 2d 115 ).

21992–1993
Maida v. Diocese of Brooklyn neutral
nyappdiv · 2025
1 sentence

2025Moreover, certain portions of the personnel files were not subject to redaction pursuant to CPLR 4504, the physician-patient privilege, and CPLR 4507, the client-psychologist privilege ( see Maida v Diocese of Brooklyn , _____ AD3d _____, 2025 NY Slip Op 06314 ; S.E. v Diocese of Brooklyn , 240 AD3d at 743).

12025–2025
Matter of N.Y. City Council v. Goldwater green
ny · 1940
2 sentences

1993Waiver of the priest-penitent privilege may be express, "upon the trial or examination by the person confessing" ( Matter of City Council v Goldwater , 284 N.Y. 296, 300 ; see also , Richardson, Evidence § 425, at 419 [Prince 10th ed] [commenting on former Civ Prac Act §§ 351, 354]) or by implication, upon the "voluntary public or private disclosure before trial of the privileged communication" (Richardson, Evidence § 418, at 413 [Prince 10th ed]).

1993Waiver of the priest-penitent privilege may be express, "upon the trial or examination by the person confessing” (Matter of City Council v Goldwater, 284 NY 296, 300 ; see also, Richardson, Evidence § 425, at 419 [Prince 10th ed] [commenting on former Civ Prac Act §§ 351, 354]) or by implication, upon the "voluntary public or private disclosure before trial of the privileged communication” (Richardson, Evidence § 418, at 413 [Prince 10th ed]).

11993–1993
Simmons v. United States green
scotus · 1968
2 sentences

1993Moreover, this case is unlike Simmons v United States ( 390 US 377, 394 ), where the Supreme Court held that "when a defendant testifies in support of a motion to suppress evidence on Fourth Amendment grounds, his testimony may not thereafter be admitted against him at trial on the issue of guilt unless he makes no objection." There, the Supreme Court was concerned with two constitutional rights, the right to be free from unreasonable searches and seizures and the right not to incriminate oneself.

1993Moreover, this case is unlike Simmons v United States ( 390 US 377, 394 ), where the Supreme Court held that "when a defendant testifies in support of a motion to suppress evidence on Fourth Amendment grounds, his testimony may not thereafter be admitted against him at trial on the issue of guilt unless he makes no objection.” There, the Supreme Court was concerned with two constitutional rights, the right to be free from unreasonable searches and seizures and the right not to incriminate oneself.

11993–1993
Rivera v. Coughlin neutral
nyappdiv · 1987
2 sentences

1993He acted contrary to the very essence of the privilege by discussing the subject matter of the purportedly confidential communication with third persons ( see , 8 Wigmore, Evidence § 2285 [McNaughton rev 1961]; Richardson, Evidence §§ 418, 425 [Prince 10th ed]; and see, e.g. , People v Figueroa , 173 AD2d 156, 159 ; Matter of Rivera v Coughlin , 133 AD2d 694, 695 ; People v O'Connor , 85 AD2d 92, 97 ; People v Fentress , 103 Misc 2d 179, 191-196 ).

1993He acted contrary to the very essence of the privilege by discussing the subject matter of the purportedly confidential communication with third persons (see, 8 Wigmore, Evidence § 2285 [McNaughton rev 1961]; Richardson, Evidence §§ 418, 425 [Prince 10th ed]; and see, e.g., People v Figueroa, 173 AD2d 156, 159 ; Matter of Rivera v Coughlin, 133 AD2d 694, 695 ; People v O’Connor, 85 AD2d 92, 97 ; People v Fentress, 103 Mise 2d 179, 191-196).

11993–1993
People v. Figueroa green
nyappdiv · 1991
2 sentences

1993He acted contrary to the very essence of the privilege by discussing the subject matter of the purportedly confidential communication with third persons ( see , 8 Wigmore, Evidence § 2285 [McNaughton rev 1961]; Richardson, Evidence §§ 418, 425 [Prince 10th ed]; and see, e.g. , People v Figueroa , 173 AD2d 156, 159 ; Matter of Rivera v Coughlin , 133 AD2d 694, 695 ; People v O'Connor , 85 AD2d 92, 97 ; People v Fentress , 103 Misc 2d 179, 191-196 ).

1993He acted contrary to the very essence of the privilege by discussing the subject matter of the purportedly confidential communication with third persons (see, 8 Wigmore, Evidence § 2285 [McNaughton rev 1961]; Richardson, Evidence §§ 418, 425 [Prince 10th ed]; and see, e.g., People v Figueroa, 173 AD2d 156, 159 ; Matter of Rivera v Coughlin, 133 AD2d 694, 695 ; People v O’Connor, 85 AD2d 92, 97 ; People v Fentress, 103 Mise 2d 179, 191-196).

11993–1993
People v. Brown green
nysupct · 1974
1 sentence

1992However, by voluntarily repeating the substance of his admissions to the priest, an act clearly inconsistent with any desire to maintain a priest-penitent privilege, the defendant effectively waived that privilege (see, People v O’Connor, 85 AD2d 92 ; People v Fentress, 103 Misc 2d 179 ; see also, Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints v Superior Ct., 159 Ariz 24, 764 P2d 759 ; Perry v Arkansas, 280 Ark 36 , 655 SW2d 380 ; Kansas v Andrews, 187 Kan 458, 357 P2d 739 , cert denied 368 US 868 ; see generally, Richardson, Evidence § 418 [Prince 10th ed]; cf., People v Brown, 82 Misc 2d 115 ).

11992–1992
People v. Samuels green
ny · 1980
1 sentence

1992Moreover, this waiver was effective even though Detective Torres would subsequently be precluded, on the strength of People v Samuels (supra), from testifying as to the substance of the confession.

11992–1992
State v. Andrews green
kan · 1960
1 sentence

1992However, by voluntarily repeating the substance of his admissions to the priest, an act clearly inconsistent with any desire to maintain a priest-penitent privilege, the defendant effectively waived that privilege (see, People v O’Connor, 85 AD2d 92 ; People v Fentress, 103 Misc 2d 179 ; see also, Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints v Superior Ct., 159 Ariz 24, 764 P2d 759 ; Perry v Arkansas, 280 Ark 36 , 655 SW2d 380 ; Kansas v Andrews, 187 Kan 458, 357 P2d 739 , cert denied 368 US 868 ; see generally, Richardson, Evidence § 418 [Prince 10th ed]; cf., People v Brown, 82 Misc 2d 115 ).

11992–1992
Perry v. State green
ark · 1983
2 sentences

1992However, by voluntarily repeating the substance of his admissions to the priest, an act clearly inconsistent with any desire to maintain a priest-penitent privilege, the defendant effectively waived that privilege (see, People v O’Connor, 85 AD2d 92 ; People v Fentress, 103 Misc 2d 179 ; see also, Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints v Superior Ct., 159 Ariz 24, 764 P2d 759 ; Perry v Arkansas, 280 Ark 36 , 655 SW2d 380 ; Kansas v Andrews, 187 Kan 458, 357 P2d 739 , cert denied 368 US 868 ; see generally, Richardson, Evidence § 418 [Prince 10th ed]; cf., People v Brown, 82 Misc 2d 115 ).

1992However, by voluntarily repeating the substance of his admissions to the priest, an act clearly inconsistent with any desire to maintain a priest-penitent privilege, the defendant effectively waived that privilege (see, People v O’Connor, 85 AD2d 92 ; People v Fentress, 103 Misc 2d 179 ; see also, Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints v Superior Ct., 159 Ariz 24, 764 P2d 759 ; Perry v Arkansas, 280 Ark 36 , 655 SW2d 380 ; Kansas v Andrews, 187 Kan 458, 357 P2d 739 , cert denied 368 US 868 ; see generally, Richardson, Evidence § 418 [Prince 10th ed]; cf., People v Brown, 82 Misc 2d 115 ).

11992–1992
Andrews v. Kansas neutral
scotus · 1961
1 sentence

1992However, by voluntarily repeating the substance of his admissions to the priest, an act clearly inconsistent with any desire to maintain a priest-penitent privilege, the defendant effectively waived that privilege (see, People v O’Connor, 85 AD2d 92 ; People v Fentress, 103 Misc 2d 179 ; see also, Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints v Superior Ct., 159 Ariz 24, 764 P2d 759 ; Perry v Arkansas, 280 Ark 36 , 655 SW2d 380 ; Kansas v Andrews, 187 Kan 458, 357 P2d 739 , cert denied 368 US 868 ; see generally, Richardson, Evidence § 418 [Prince 10th ed]; cf., People v Brown, 82 Misc 2d 115 ).

11992–1992
Miranda v. Arizona green
scotus · 1966
1 sentence

1984Defendant’s second argument is that his right to counsel and right against self incrimination were violated when Sergeant Richard Morganstern was allowed to testify at trial concerning a statement made by defendant to Captain Aldrich Johnson in Morganstern’s presence (Rhode Island v Innis, 446 US 291 ; Miranda v Arizona, 384 US 436 ).

11984–1984
Rhode Island v. Innis green
scotus · 1980
1 sentence

1984Defendant’s second argument is that his right to counsel and right against self incrimination were violated when Sergeant Richard Morganstern was allowed to testify at trial concerning a statement made by defendant to Captain Aldrich Johnson in Morganstern’s presence (Rhode Island v Innis, 446 US 291 ; Miranda v Arizona, 384 US 436 ).

11984–1984
Branzburg v. Hayes green
scotus · 1972
2 sentences

1979(Cf. Branzburg v Hayes, 408 US 665 , supra.) Absent a showing that the conversations sought to be disclosed are embraced by the priest-penitent privilege, appellant, even though a clergyman, is, like all citizens, obligated to respond to those questions relevant to the Grand Jury’s investigation.

1979(Cf. Branzburg v Hayes, 408 US 665 , supra.) Absent a showing that the conversations sought to be disclosed are embraced by the priest-penitent privilege, appellant, even though a clergyman, is, like all citizens, obligated to respond to those questions relevant to the Grand Jury’s investigation.

11979–1979

Where else courts name it

NJ 7 (1971–2020) CA 6 (1982–2015) NY 5 (1979–2025) MS 3 (2001–2005) MA 3 (1994–2015) UT 2 (1994–2014) AL 2 (2006–2006) IA 2 (2014–2018)

Opinions by the citing court's state. A doctrine retained in one state and abandoned in another shows up here as a year span that stalls.

← Caselaw search · G Cite Topics · Brief Check