give instruction (Utah) · Go Syfert
← Utah issues

give instruction in Utah

5 Utah opinions name it 2 courts 1905–2026 1 in the last five years

The cases below were cited by Utah courts in a sentence that names this issue. Sides come from how each citing opinion treated the case (Syfertize flag on that citation), so a case can appear on both: that is where the law is contested. A red or yellow chip is the case's own overall treatment.

Followed or applied (1)

CaseFollowedCited
Newbury v. Vogelgreen
colo · 1963 · cited in 1 Utah opinions naming this issue, 1999–1999
2 sentences

1999Although Robinson presented evidence that most of his injuries were attributable to the 1995 accident, he failed to present evidence that causation and damages could not be apportioned between the 1995 accident and the 1991 accident. ¶32 The majority relies on Tingey v. Christensen, 987 P.2d 588 (Utah 1999), which in turn relied on Newbury v. Vogel, 151 Colo. 520 , 379 P.2d 811, 813 (1963) (en banc), and its progeny.

1999Although Robinson presented evidence that most of his injuries were attributable to the 1995 accident, he failed to present evidence that causation and damages could not be apportioned between the 1995 accident and the 1991 accident. ¶32 The majority relies on Tingey v. Christensen, 987 P.2d 588 (Utah 1999), which in turn relied on Newbury v. Vogel, 151 Colo. 520 , 379 P.2d 811, 813 (1963) (en banc), and its progeny.

11

Distinguished, questioned or overruled (0)

CaseNegativeCited
No negative-treatment citations attached to this issue in Utah. Read the followed side critically anyway.

Also cited on this issue (8)

CaseCitedYears
cluster 10860139 green
·
1 sentence

2026And for similar reasons, we agree with the State that, even if Counsel had succeeded in persuading the court to give a defense-of-others instruction in this case, there is no reasonable likelihood of a different outcome. 20230748-CA 14 2026 UT App 78 State v. Cartwright the others, Counsel could have reasonably opted not to lodge an objection anyway.

12026–2026
Tingey v. Christensen green
utah · 1999
2 sentences

1999Although Robinson presented evidence that most of his injuries were attributable to the 1995 accident, he failed to present evidence that causation and damages could not be apportioned between the 1995 accident and the 1991 accident. ¶32 The majority relies on Tingey v. Christensen, 987 P.2d 588 (Utah 1999), which in turn relied on Newbury v. Vogel, 151 Colo. 520 , 379 P.2d 811, 813 (1963) (en banc), and its progeny.

1999Although Robinson presented evidence that most of his injuries were attributable to the 1995 accident, he failed to present evidence that causation and damages could not be apportioned between the 1995 accident and the 1991 accident. ¶ 32 The majority relies on Tingey v. Christensen, 987 P.2d 588 (Utah 1999), which in turn relied on Newbury v. Vogel, 151 Colo. 520 , 379 P.2d 811, 813 (1963) (en banc), and its progeny.

11999–1999
Rodríguez v. Industrial Commission green
prsupreme · 1942
1 sentence

1939Much of the language contained in the instruction is found in a statement of an admonitory character in the case of State v. Hilberg, 22 Utah 27 , 61 P. 215 .

11939–1939
State v. Hilberg green
utah · 1900
1 sentence

1939Much of the language contained in the instruction is found in a statement of an admonitory character in the case of State v. Hilberg, 22 Utah 27 , 61 P. 215 .

11939–1939
State v. Judd neutral
utah · 1929
2 sentences

1932The instruction requested was identical with that which we held in State v. Judd, 74 Utah 398 , 279 P. 953 , to be mere argument and objectionable.

1932The instruction requested was identical with that which we held in State v. Judd, 74 Utah 398 , 279 P. 953 , to be mere argument and objectionable.

11932–1932
State v. Robinson neutral
wash · 1895
2 sentences

1905State v. Robinson, 12 Wash. 491 , 41 Pac. 884 ; State v. Williams, 13 Wash. 335 , 43 Pac. 15 ; State v. Cushing, 17 Wash. 544 , 50 Pac. 512 .

1905State v. Robinson, 12 Wash. 491 , 41 Pac. 884 ; State v. Williams, 13 Wash. 335 , 43 Pac. 15 ; State v. Cushing, 17 Wash. 544 , 50 Pac. 512 .

11905–1905
State v. Williams green
wash · 1895
2 sentences

1905State v. Robinson, 12 Wash. 491 , 41 Pac. 884 ; State v. Williams, 13 Wash. 335 , 43 Pac. 15 ; State v. Cushing, 17 Wash. 544 , 50 Pac. 512 .

1905State v. Robinson, 12 Wash. 491 , 41 Pac. 884 ; State v. Williams, 13 Wash. 335 , 43 Pac. 15 ; State v. Cushing, 17 Wash. 544 , 50 Pac. 512 .

11905–1905
State v. Cushing green
wash · 1897
2 sentences

1905State v. Robinson, 12 Wash. 491 , 41 Pac. 884 ; State v. Williams, 13 Wash. 335 , 43 Pac. 15 ; State v. Cushing, 17 Wash. 544 , 50 Pac. 512 .

1905State v. Robinson, 12 Wash. 491 , 41 Pac. 884 ; State v. Williams, 13 Wash. 335 , 43 Pac. 15 ; State v. Cushing, 17 Wash. 544 , 50 Pac. 512 .

11905–1905

Where else courts name it

CA 86 (1892–2026) MO 55 (1886–2017) IL 35 (1873–2023) KS 24 (1882–2022) WA 24 (1900–2023) IN 24 (1856–2005) OK 24 (1894–1997) KY 23 (1914–1987) NC 22 (1887–2014) NE 20 (1893–2019) AR 20 (1906–1983) TX 18 (1899–2019) FL 17 (1898–1999) MI 16 (1924–2018) NY 16 (1904–2024) NJ 15 (1975–2022) GA 11 (1893–2022) OR 11 (1874–2026) CO 11 (1909–2021) IA 11 (1877–2016) MS 11 (1913–2014) VA 10 (1901–2012) OH 10 (1936–2017) WY 9 (1937–2016) AZ 9 (1956–2021) PA 8 (1947–2015) NM 8 (1938–1998) ID 8 (1911–2020) WV 8 (1896–2015) WI 7 (1883–1995) CT 7 (2007–2021) MT 6 (1900–1923) ME 6 (1995–2023) TN 5 (1960–2017) UT 5 (1905–2026) MD 5 (1946–2016) AL 5 (1963–1994) SD 4 (1894–1985) HI 4 (1918–2024) MN 4 (1921–2015) DC 3 (1988–1999) SC 2 (1907–1992)

Opinions by the citing court's state. A doctrine retained in one state and abandoned in another shows up here as a year span that stalls.

← Caselaw search · G Cite Topics · Brief Check