section 3 proviso clause (Idaho) · Go Syfert
← Idaho issues

section 3 proviso clause in Idaho

6 Idaho opinions name it 1 courts 1896–2015 0 in the last five years

The cases below were cited by Idaho courts in a sentence that names this issue. Sides come from how each citing opinion treated the case (Syfertize flag on that citation), so a case can appear on both: that is where the law is contested. A red or yellow chip is the case's own overall treatment.

Followed or applied (2)

CaseFollowedCited
City of Boise v. Fraziergreen
idaho · 2006 · cited in 3 Idaho opinions naming this issue, 2010–2015
2 sentences

2015This bright-line rule provides that “in order for an expenditure to qualify as ‘necessary’ under the proviso clause of Article VIII, § 3 there must exist a necessity for making the expenditure at or during such year.” Id. (emphasis original) (quoting Frazier, 143 Idaho at 4 , 137 P.3d at 391 ).

2015This bright-line rule provides that “in order for an expenditure to qualify as ‘necessary’ under the proviso clause of Article VIII, § 3 there must exist a necessity for making the expenditure at or during such year.” Id. (emphasis original) (quoting Frazier, 143 Idaho at 4 , 137 P.3d at 391 ).

13
City of Idaho Falls v. Fuhrimangreen
idaho · 2010 · cited in 2 Idaho opinions naming this issue, 2015–2015
2 sentences

2015This bright-line rule provides that “in order for an expenditure to qualify as ‘necessary’ under the proviso clause of Article VIII, § 3 there must exist a necessity for making the expenditure at or during such year.” Fuhriman, 149 Idaho at 578 , 237 P.3d at 1204 (emphasis original) (quoting Frazier, 143 Idaho at 4 , 137 P.3d at 391 ).

2015This bright-line rule provides that “in order for an expenditure to qualify as ‘necessary’ under the proviso clause of Article VIII, § 3 there must exist a necessity for making the expenditure at or during such year.” Fuhriman, 149 Idaho at 578 , 237 P.3d at 1204 (emphasis original) (quoting Frazier, 143 Idaho at 4 , 137 P.3d at 391 ).

12

Distinguished, questioned or overruled (0)

CaseNegativeCited
No negative-treatment citations attached to this issue in Idaho. Read the followed side critically anyway.

Also cited on this issue (4)

CaseCitedYears
Bannock County v. Bunting red
idaho · 1894
2 sentences

1983In County of Ada v. Bullen Bridge Co., 5 Idaho 79 , 47 P. 818 (1896), the court stated, “If it is claimed that this expenditure comes within the proviso of section 3, article 8, of the constitution, we answer that a construction of that proviso, as well as of the entire section, was given by this court in Bannock Co. v. Bunting, 4 Idaho 156 , 37 Pac. 277 , and we would suggest that an improvement involving an expenditure of nearly $40,000, where the revenue of the county for the year was only about $70,000, would not readily be classed as an ‘ordinary and necessary expense.’ It would be diffic

1983In County of Ada v. Bullen Bridge Co., 5 Idaho 79 , 47 P. 818 (1896), the court stated, “If it is claimed that this expenditure comes within the proviso of section 3, article 8, of the constitution, we answer that a construction of that proviso, as well as of the entire section, was given by this court in Bannock Co. v. Bunting, 4 Idaho 156 , 37 Pac. 277 , and we would suggest that an improvement involving an expenditure of nearly $40,000, where the revenue of the county for the year was only about $70,000, would not readily be classed as an ‘ordinary and necessary expense.’ It would be diffic

21896–1983
County of Ada v. Bullen Bridge Co. neutral
idaho · 1896
2 sentences

1983In County of Ada v. Bullen Bridge Co., 5 Idaho 79 , 47 P. 818 (1896), the court stated, “If it is claimed that this expenditure comes within the proviso of section 3, article 8, of the constitution, we answer that a construction of that proviso, as well as of the entire section, was given by this court in Bannock Co. v. Bunting, 4 Idaho 156 , 37 Pac. 277 , and we would suggest that an improvement involving an expenditure of nearly $40,000, where the revenue of the county for the year was only about $70,000, would not readily be classed as an ‘ordinary and necessary expense.’ It would be diffic

1983In County of Ada v. Bullen Bridge Co., 5 Idaho 79 , 47 P. 818 (1896), the court stated, “If it is claimed that this expenditure comes within the proviso of section 3, article 8, of the constitution, we answer that a construction of that proviso, as well as of the entire section, was given by this court in Bannock Co. v. Bunting, 4 Idaho 156 , 37 Pac. 277 , and we would suggest that an improvement involving an expenditure of nearly $40,000, where the revenue of the county for the year was only about $70,000, would not readily be classed as an ‘ordinary and necessary expense.’ It would be diffic

11983–1983
Ball v. Bannock County neutral
idaho · 1897
2 sentences

1983If these provisions of law are to be ignored or defeated upon flimsy technicalities, it is difficult to see what protection the people will have.” Id. at 90, 47 P. at 823 . 19 See also, Ball v. Bannock Co., 5 Idaho 602 , 51 P. 454 (1897).

1983If these provisions of law are to be ignored or defeated upon flimsy technicalities, it is difficult to see what protection the people will have.” Id. at 90, 47 P. at 823 . 19 See also, Ball v. Bannock Co., 5 Idaho 602 , 51 P. 454 (1897).

11983–1983
Potter v. Furnish green
mont · 1912
2 sentences

1934A court is never justified, it has been well said, in passing upon a question not necessary to a decision of the matter before it, and will particularly “avoid the consideration of constitutional questions except when forced on them in forms of procedure permitting due argument and deliberation.” (Bishop on the Written Laws, see. 35, p. 33; Potter v. Furnish, 46 Mont. 391 , 128 Pac. 542 .) And consequently, we do not deem it necessary to discuss the contentions made by both counsel amici curiae and appellants bearing on that question, or the cases cited in support of the contentions. *358 Turn

1934A court is never justified, it has been well said, in passing upon a question not necessary to a decision of the matter before it, and will particularly “avoid the consideration of constitutional questions except when forced on them in forms of procedure permitting due argument and deliberation.” (Bishop on the Written Laws, see. 35, p. 33; Potter v. Furnish, 46 Mont. 391 , 128 Pac. 542 .) And consequently, we do not deem it necessary to discuss the contentions made by both counsel amici curiae and appellants bearing on that question, or the cases cited in support of the contentions. *358 Turn

11934–1934

Statutes the citing opinions construe

ID § Idaho Code § 7-1301 (3)

Counted by distinct opinions that both name this issue and are annotated to the section; sections every opinion cites regardless of issue are not filtered here, so read the counts against the total above.

Where else courts name it

ID 6 (1896–2015) IL 4 (1911–1977) IN 2 (1894–1941) MO 2 (1938–1972)

Opinions by the citing court's state. A doctrine retained in one state and abandoned in another shows up here as a year span that stalls.

← Caselaw search · G Cite Topics · Brief Check