force presumption (Pennsylvania) · Go Syfert
← Pennsylvania issues

force presumption in Pennsylvania

20 Pennsylvania opinions name it 6 courts 1857–2023 1 in the last five years

The cases below were cited by Pennsylvania courts in a sentence that names this issue. Sides come from how each citing opinion treated the case (Syfertize flag on that citation), so a case can appear on both: that is where the law is contested. A red or yellow chip is the case's own overall treatment.

Followed or applied (7)

CaseFollowedCited
Johns v. Ciocigreen
pasuperct · 2004 · cited in 2 Pennsylvania opinions naming this issue, 2014–2023
2 sentences

2023Johns v. Cioci, 865 A.2d 931, 942-43 (Pa. Super. 2004) (some internal citations and quotation marks omitted); see also M.J.M., supra at 339 (“It is within the trial court’s purview as the finder of fact to determine which factors are most salient and critical in each particular case.”) (citation omitted).

2014In cases where the siblings have not been reared in the same household, the force of the doctrine is less compelling. -11 - J-S42044-14 Johns v. Cioci, 865 A.2d 931, 942-43 (Pa. Super. 2004) (some internal citations and quotation marks omitted); see also Nomland v. Nomland, 813 A.2d 850, 855-56 (Pa. Super. 2002) (explaining that the general preference to have siblings raised together must yield to the paramount principle that the best interests of the child is the determining factor in a custody case).

22
M.J.M. v. M.L.G.green
pasuperct · 2013 · cited in 1 Pennsylvania opinions naming this issue, 2023–2023
1 sentence

2023Johns v. Cioci, 865 A.2d 931, 942-43 (Pa. Super. 2004) (some internal citations and quotation marks omitted); see also M.J.M., supra at 339 (“It is within the trial court’s purview as the finder of fact to determine which factors are most salient and critical in each particular case.”) (citation omitted).

11
Nicholas, J. v. Hofmann, D.green
pasuperct · 2017 · cited in 1 Pennsylvania opinions naming this issue, 2017–2017
1 sentence

2017Because we have concluded that Hauser’s right of action on the mortgage is not time-barred, we turn to Force’s claim that there was no consideration for the mortgage obligation. -7- J-A11018-17 Pennsylvania’s Uniform Written Obligations Act (“UWOA”) “applies to notes and mortgages, just as it does to other contract documents.” Nicholas v. Hofmann, 158 A.3d 675, 690 (Pa.Super. 2017).

11
González-Droz v. González-Colóngreen
ca1 · 2011 · cited in 1 Pennsylvania opinions naming this issue, 2015–2015
1 sentence

2015Id. at 14 (citations, brackets, and most quotations omitted).

11
Nomland v. Nomlandgreen
pasuperct · 2002 · cited in 1 Pennsylvania opinions naming this issue, 2014–2014
1 sentence

2014In cases where the siblings have not been reared in the same household, the force of the doctrine is less compelling. -11 - J-S42044-14 Johns v. Cioci, 865 A.2d 931, 942-43 (Pa. Super. 2004) (some internal citations and quotation marks omitted); see also Nomland v. Nomland, 813 A.2d 850, 855-56 (Pa. Super. 2002) (explaining that the general preference to have siblings raised together must yield to the paramount principle that the best interests of the child is the determining factor in a custody case).

11
Selm v. Elliottgreen
pasuperct · 1992 · cited in 1 Pennsylvania opinions naming this issue, 1995–1995
2 sentences

1995In John M., supra, 524 Pa. at 306 , 571 A.2d 1380 , the Pennsylvania Supreme Court reaffirmed the force of this presumption, characterizing it as “one of the strongest presumptions known to law.” Id. at 312-13 , 571 A.2d at 1383 (citing Cairgle, supra, 366 Pa. 249 , 77 A.2d at 439 ); see also Selm v. Elliott, 411 Pa.Super. 602 , 602 A.2d 358 (1992).

1995In John M., supra, 524 Pa. at 306 , 571 A.2d 1380 , the Pennsylvania Supreme Court reaffirmed the force of this presumption, characterizing it as “one of the strongest presumptions known to law.” Id. at 312-13 , 571 A.2d at 1383 (citing Cairgle, supra, 366 Pa. 249 , 77 A.2d at 439 ); see also Selm v. Elliott, 411 Pa.Super. 602 , 602 A.2d 358 (1992).

11
Commonwealth v. Goinsgreen
pa · 1974 · cited in 1 Pennsylvania opinions naming this issue, 1984–1984
2 sentences

1984See Commonwealth v. Goins, 457 Pa. 594, 599-600 , 321 A.2d 913, 916 (1974) (in murder trial in which only issue was degree of defendant’s guilt, court impermissibly “expressed] its opinion as to the merit of the only defense offered” when it charged that jury must find defendant guilty of first degree murder if it convicted him at all).

1984See Commonwealth v. Goins, 457 Pa. 594, 599-600 , 321 A.2d 913, 916 (1974) (in murder trial in which only issue was degree of defendant’s guilt, court impermissibly “expressed] its opinion as to the merit of the only defense offered” when it charged that jury must find defendant guilty of first degree murder if it convicted him at all).

11

Distinguished, questioned or overruled (0)

CaseNegativeCited
No negative-treatment citations attached to this issue in Pennsylvania. Read the followed side critically anyway.

Also cited on this issue (20)

CaseCitedYears
Commonwealth v. Brown green
pa · 1984
2 sentences

2013Relying on Commonwealth v. Brown, 506 Pa. 169 , 484 A.2d 738 (1984), it posits that conduct or words that are threatening that cause a person to relinquish property meet the force requirement of the applicable robbery statute.

2013Relying on Commonwealth v. Brown, 506 Pa. 169 , 484 A.2d 738 (1984), it posits that conduct or words that are threatening that cause a person to relinquish property meet the force requirement of the applicable robbery statute.

21985–2013
Cairgle v. AMERICAN R. AND SS CORP. green
pa · 1951
2 sentences

1995In John M., supra, 524 Pa. at 306 , 571 A.2d 1380 , the Pennsylvania Supreme Court reaffirmed the force of this presumption, characterizing it as “one of the strongest presumptions known to law.” Id. at 312-13 , 571 A.2d at 1383 (citing Cairgle, supra, 366 Pa. 249 , 77 A.2d at 439 ); see also Selm v. Elliott, 411 Pa.Super. 602 , 602 A.2d 358 (1992).

1995In John M., supra, 524 Pa. at 306 , 571 A.2d 1380 , the Pennsylvania Supreme Court reaffirmed the force of this presumption, characterizing it as “one of the strongest presumptions known to law.” Id. at 312-13 , 571 A.2d at 1383 (citing Cairgle, supra, 366 Pa. 249 , 77 A.2d at 439 ); see also Selm v. Elliott, 411 Pa.Super. 602 , 602 A.2d 358 (1992).

21995–1997
John M. v. Paula T. green
pa · 1990
2 sentences

1997In John M., supra, our supreme court reaffirmed the force of this presumption, labeling it “one of the strongest presumptions known to law.” Id. at 312-13, 571 A.2d at 1383 (citing Cairgle v. American Radiator & S.S.

1995In John M., supra, 524 Pa. at 306 , 571 A.2d 1380 , the Pennsylvania Supreme Court reaffirmed the force of this presumption, characterizing it as “one of the strongest presumptions known to law.” Id. at 312-13 , 571 A.2d at 1383 (citing Cairgle, supra, 366 Pa. 249 , 77 A.2d at 439 ); see also Selm v. Elliott, 411 Pa.Super. 602 , 602 A.2d 358 (1992).

21995–1997
United States v. James Heller green
ca6 · 1978
2 sentences

1980That is what the Sixth Circuit did in United States v. Heller, supra , and this court, in Commonwealth v. Bready, supra , and Commonwealth v. Black, supra ; it would not be an unworthy result here, given the force of the factors previously discussed in part II of this opinion as favoring the conclusion that strict liability was not intended.

1980That is what the Sixth Circuit did in United States v. Heller, supra, and this court, in Commonwealth v. Bready, supra, and Commonwealth v. Black, supra; it would not be an unworthy result here, given the force of the factors previously discussed in part II of this opinion as favoring the conclusion that strict liability was not intended.

11980–1980
Bureau of Traffic Safety v. Byrd green
pacommwct · 1979
2 sentences

1980Code section 1517(b) states: “The Board shall formulate rules and regulations for adoption by the Department on physical and mental criteria including vision standards relating to the licensing of drivers under the provisions of this chapter [15].” See Com. v. Byrd, 41 Pa. Commonwealth Ct. 38, 44 , 399 A. 2d 425 (1979), affirming 39 Somerset 213 (1977), decided on other grounds, recognizing “the distinction in administrative law between the weight accorded an agency rule promulgated under a grant of legislative power by the legislature and the force of a rule promulgated under the interpretive

1980Code section 1517(b) states: “The Board shall formulate rules and regulations for adoption by the Department on physical and mental criteria including vision standards relating to the licensing of drivers under the provisions of this chapter [15].” See Com. v. Byrd, 41 Pa. Commonwealth Ct. 38, 44 , 399 A. 2d 425 (1979), affirming 39 Somerset 213 (1977), decided on other grounds, recognizing “the distinction in administrative law between the weight accorded an agency rule promulgated under a grant of legislative power by the legislature and the force of a rule promulgated under the interpretive

11980–1980
Commonwealth v. Bready green
pasuperct · 1971
2 sentences

1980That is what the Sixth Circuit did in United States v. Heller, supra , and this court, in Commonwealth v. Bready, supra , and Commonwealth v. Black, supra ; it would not be an unworthy result here, given the force of the factors previously discussed in part II of this opinion as favoring the conclusion that strict liability was not intended.

1980That is what the Sixth Circuit did in United States v. Heller, supra, and this court, in Commonwealth v. Bready, supra, and Commonwealth v. Black, supra; it would not be an unworthy result here, given the force of the factors previously discussed in part II of this opinion as favoring the conclusion that strict liability was not intended.

11980–1980
Lane v. Samuels green
pa · 1944
2 sentences

1980On the effect of the physician’s unavailability or lack of independent recollection, see Brown, Pennsylvania Evidence, Chapter VII, Part XIII E3, citing Lane v. Samuels, 350 Pa. 446 , 39 A. 2d 626 (1944); Freedman v. Mutual Life Ins.

1980On the effect of the physician’s unavailability or lack of independent recollection, see Brown, Pennsylvania Evidence, Chapter VII, Part XIII E3, citing Lane v. Samuels, 350 Pa. 446 , 39 A. 2d 626 (1944); Freedman v. Mutual Life Ins.

11980–1980
Traylor v. Allentown green
pa · 1954
1 sentence

1961The force of the rule of uniformity is shown in Traylor v. Allentown, supra, where the court said, pages 494 and 495: “Actually, there was no competent evidence whatsoever adduced at the hearing in the court below as to the fair market value of the property.

11961–1961
Hopkins v. Phillips neutral
pasuperct · 1921
1 sentence

1932The agreement of sale in Hopkins v. Phillips, supra, is closely similar to that in the instant case, the minor variations in the language employed being insufficient to destroy the force of the rule so far as it applies to the written contract.

11932–1932
Stover v. . People of the State of N.Y. green
ny · 1874
1 sentence

1921The force of the presumption of guilt is one of fact to be inferred by the jury, not of law, and the jury must pass on all the evidence including the reasonableness of the explanation of his possession by the accused: Stover v. People, 56 N. Y. 315 .

11921–1921
McNeely Co. v. Bank of North America green
pa · 1908
1 sentence

1917The force of the doctrine on which he relies is fully declared in our own cases of McNeely v. Bank of North America, 221 Pa. 588 , and Lesley v. Ewing, 248 Pa. 135 .

11917–1917
Lesley v. Ewing green
pa · 1915
1 sentence

1917The force of the doctrine on which he relies is fully declared in our own cases of McNeely v. Bank of North America, 221 Pa. 588 , and Lesley v. Ewing, 248 Pa. 135 .

11917–1917
Whitaker v. Brown neutral
pa · 1864
1 sentence

1911L. & P. 674, it is said: “The terms ‘reservation’ and ‘exception’ are often used interchangeably, and the technical meaning will give way to the manifest intent, even though the technical term to the contrary be used.” The point is discussed at considerable length in Whitaker v. Brown, 46 Pa. 197 , and in Kister v. Reeser, 98 Pa. 1 , where it is said that the terms “reservation” and “exception” “are often used in the same sense, the technical distinction being disregarded.” By reference to the deed, it appears that except for the purpose set forth in the clause of reservation, the right of the

11911–1911
Kister v. Reeser green
pa · 1881
1 sentence

1911L. & P. 674, it is said: “The terms ‘reservation’ and ‘exception’ are often used interchangeably, and the technical meaning will give way to the manifest intent, even though the technical term to the contrary be used.” The point is discussed at considerable length in Whitaker v. Brown, 46 Pa. 197 , and in Kister v. Reeser, 98 Pa. 1 , where it is said that the terms “reservation” and “exception” “are often used in the same sense, the technical distinction being disregarded.” By reference to the deed, it appears that except for the purpose set forth in the clause of reservation, the right of the

11911–1911
Comm'th v. Detwiller green
pa · 1890
1 sentence

1906In Commonwealth v. Detwiller, 131 Pa. 614 , Mr. Justice Williams in discussing the enabling statutes so far as they relate to aliens, said: “ Even as to real estate, the distinction as between a resident alien friend and a citizen has disappeared in Pennsylvania, and nearly every other state in the union.” The learned Justice referred to the act of 1807, wherein it is provided generally that alien friends resident within our state may purchase lands, tenements and hereditaments and have and hold the same in fee simple or any lesser estate, as fully to all intents and purposes as the natural bo

11906–1906
Fryer v. Rishell neutral
pa · 1877
1 sentence

1900The learned judge of the court below, in his opinion filed, cites the case of Fryer v. Rishell, 84 Pa. 521 .

11900–1900
Scott's Estate neutral
pa · 1892
1 sentence

1900Recognizing the force of this rule of property, the parties to the proceeding in Scott’s Estate, 147 Pa. 102 , in preparing the agreement of separation, caused the same to be duly acknowledged by both parties, in the manner required by law, and the question now presented for our determination, therefore, did not arise in that ease.

11900–1900
Wyman v. Leavitt green
me · 1880
1 sentence

1892In no case has it ever been held that mental anguish alone, unaccompanied by an injury to the person, afforded a ground of action.” In Wyman v. Leavitt, 71 Me. 227 , a contractor of a railroad was blasting rocks within the right of way of the road.

11892–1892
Cummings v. Cummings neutral
pa · 1839
1 sentence

1857R. 365; 3 Rawle 249 ; 5 W. & S. 357, 513 ; and he has been faithfully followed in many other eases: 8 Watts 366 ; 8 State R. 213; 9 Id. 262; 12 Id. 175; 14 Id. 201; 19 Id. 251, 366; 25 Id. 308; 26 Id. 372, 383.

11857–1857
Swires v. Parsons neutral
pa · 1843
1 sentence

1857R. 365; 3 Rawle 249 ; 5 W. & S. 357, 513 ; and he has been faithfully followed in many other eases: 8 Watts 366 ; 8 State R. 213; 9 Id. 262; 12 Id. 175; 14 Id. 201; 19 Id. 251, 366; 25 Id. 308; 26 Id. 372, 383.

11857–1857

Where else courts name it

TX 82 (1883–2025) CA 82 (1859–2026) NY 36 (1875–2024) PA 20 (1857–2023) MA 19 (1905–2026) IL 15 (1874–2014) OH 13 (1924–2026) FL 13 (1975–2012) WA 13 (1911–2021) KS 13 (1892–2023) AL 8 (1909–2010) WI 8 (1876–2025) IN 8 (1891–2020) OK 8 (1913–2023) MO 7 (1902–2012) GA 6 (1927–1972) MI 6 (1925–2016) CT 5 (1907–2017) AR 5 (1912–1948) NC 5 (1910–1976) IA 5 (1917–1988) NJ 5 (1891–2018) ME 5 (1935–1981) MD 5 (1964–2022) LA 5 (1967–2024) NE 5 (1904–2003) DC 4 (1987–2021) MT 4 (1928–2025) MN 4 (1905–1985) SC 4 (1880–1934) OR 4 (1913–2024) KY 4 (1923–1987) NV 4 (1867–2011) UT 3 (1947–2017) AZ 3 (1928–1983) TN 3 (1928–1971) VA 3 (1941–2025) CO 3 (1894–1962) VT 3 (1887–1933) NM 2 (1933–1957) WV 2 (1888–1903) ID 2 (1937–2021) SD 2 (1988–2006) MS 2 (1874–2021) ND 2 (1900–1970) WY 2 (1937–1989)

Opinions by the citing court's state. A doctrine retained in one state and abandoned in another shows up here as a year span that stalls.

← Caselaw search · G Cite Topics · Brief Check