did not commit error (Indiana) · Go Syfert
← Indiana issues

did not commit error in Indiana

10 Indiana opinions name it 2 courts 1917–2013 0 in the last five years

The cases below were cited by Indiana courts in a sentence that names this issue. Sides come from how each citing opinion treated the case (Syfertize flag on that citation), so a case can appear on both: that is where the law is contested. A red or yellow chip is the case's own overall treatment.

Followed or applied (1)

CaseFollowedCited
Gerrish v. Brewergreen
indctapp · 1979 · cited in 1 Indiana opinions naming this issue, 1981–1981
1 sentence

1981It may be noted that the court did so instruct as related to contributory negligence.” 10 Gerrish v. Brewer, supra at 1301.

11

Distinguished, questioned or overruled (0)

CaseNegativeCited
No negative-treatment citations attached to this issue in Indiana. Read the followed side critically anyway.

Also cited on this issue (13)

CaseCitedYears
Lewis v. Davis green
indctapp · 1980
2 sentences

2013We found the instruction “neutral in tone and the court did not commit error by giving it to the jury.” Id.

2013We found the instruction “neutral in tone and the court did not commit error by giving it to the jury.” Id.

22013–2013
Scott v. Kell green
indctapp · 1956
2 sentences

1968It was held in Scott v. Kell (1956), 127 Ind. App. 472, 483 , 134 N. E. 2d 828 , that the court did not commit error in re-entering substantially the same judgment pursuant to this rule.

1968It was held in Scott v. Kell (1956), 127 Ind. App. 472, 483 , 134 N. E. 2d 828 , that the court did not commit error in re-entering substantially the same judgment pursuant to this rule.

21965–1968
Aetna Casualty & Surety Co. v. Acme-Goodrich, Inc. green
indctapp · 1959
2 sentences

1973Harvey’s Indiana Practice, Vol. 3, p. 146, Rule 38(b) ; Aetna Casualty and Surety v. Acme-Goodrich (1959), 130 Ind. App. 432, 438 , 159 N.E.2d 310 .

1973Harvey’s Indiana Practice, Vol. 3, p. 146, Rule 38(b) ; Aetna Casualty and Surety v. Acme-Goodrich (1959), 130 Ind. App. 432, 438 , 159 N.E.2d 310 .

11973–1973
Gilchrist v. Gilchrist green
ind · 1947
2 sentences

1952Gelchrist v. Gelchrist (1947), 225 Ind. 367 , 75 N. E. 2d 417 .

1952Gelchrist v. Gelchrist (1947), 225 Ind. 367 , 75 N. E. 2d 417 .

11952–1952
Louisville & Northern Railway & Lighting Co. v. Beck neutral
ind · 1925
2 sentences

1940On authority of L. & N. Railway and Lighting Company v. Beck (1925), 196 Ind. 238 , 145 N. E. 886 , 147 N. E. 776 , we hold that the court did not commit error in sustaining objections to said questions.

1940On authority of L. & N. Railway and Lighting Company v. Beck (1925), 196 Ind. 238 , 145 N. E. 886 , 147 N. E. 776 , we hold that the court did not commit error in sustaining objections to said questions.

11940–1940
Sutherlin v. State neutral
ind · 1886
2 sentences

1917Sutherlin v. State (1886), 108 Ind. 389, 391 , 9 N. E. 298 ; Williams v. State (1908), 170 Ind. 630, 632 , 85 N. E. 113 ; Ludwig v. State (1908), 170 Ind. 648, 654 , 85 N. E. 345 ; Ray v. Baker (1905), 165 Ind. 74, 88 , 74 N. E. 619 ; City of Hammond v. Jahnke (1912), 178 Ind. 177 , 99 N. E. 39 ; Thain v. State (1914), 182 Ind. 345, 349 , 106 N. E. 690 . 6. 7.

1917Sutherlin v. State (1886), 108 Ind. 389, 391 , 9 N. E. 298 ; Williams v. State (1908), 170 Ind. 630, 632 , 85 N. E. 113 ; Ludwig v. State (1908), 170 Ind. 648, 654 , 85 N. E. 345 ; Ray v. Baker (1905), 165 Ind. 74, 88 , 74 N. E. 619 ; City of Hammond v. Jahnke (1912), 178 Ind. 177 , 99 N. E. 39 ; Thain v. State (1914), 182 Ind. 345, 349 , 106 N. E. 690 . 6. 7.

11917–1917
City of Huntington v. Mahan neutral
ind · 1895
2 sentences

1917City of Huntington v. Mahan (1895), 142 Ind. 695 , 42 N. E. 463 , 51 Am.

1917City of Huntington v. Mahan (1895), 142 Ind. 695 , 42 N. E. 463 , 51 Am.

11917–1917
Williams v. State neutral
ind · 1908
2 sentences

1917Sutherlin v. State (1886), 108 Ind. 389, 391 , 9 N. E. 298 ; Williams v. State (1908), 170 Ind. 630, 632 , 85 N. E. 113 ; Ludwig v. State (1908), 170 Ind. 648, 654 , 85 N. E. 345 ; Ray v. Baker (1905), 165 Ind. 74, 88 , 74 N. E. 619 ; City of Hammond v. Jahnke (1912), 178 Ind. 177 , 99 N. E. 39 ; Thain v. State (1914), 182 Ind. 345, 349 , 106 N. E. 690 . 6. 7.

1917Sutherlin v. State (1886), 108 Ind. 389, 391 , 9 N. E. 298 ; Williams v. State (1908), 170 Ind. 630, 632 , 85 N. E. 113 ; Ludwig v. State (1908), 170 Ind. 648, 654 , 85 N. E. 345 ; Ray v. Baker (1905), 165 Ind. 74, 88 , 74 N. E. 619 ; City of Hammond v. Jahnke (1912), 178 Ind. 177 , 99 N. E. 39 ; Thain v. State (1914), 182 Ind. 345, 349 , 106 N. E. 690 . 6. 7.

11917–1917
Ray v. Baker green
ind · 1905
2 sentences

1917Sutherlin v. State (1886), 108 Ind. 389, 391 , 9 N. E. 298 ; Williams v. State (1908), 170 Ind. 630, 632 , 85 N. E. 113 ; Ludwig v. State (1908), 170 Ind. 648, 654 , 85 N. E. 345 ; Ray v. Baker (1905), 165 Ind. 74, 88 , 74 N. E. 619 ; City of Hammond v. Jahnke (1912), 178 Ind. 177 , 99 N. E. 39 ; Thain v. State (1914), 182 Ind. 345, 349 , 106 N. E. 690 . 6. 7.

1917Sutherlin v. State (1886), 108 Ind. 389, 391 , 9 N. E. 298 ; Williams v. State (1908), 170 Ind. 630, 632 , 85 N. E. 113 ; Ludwig v. State (1908), 170 Ind. 648, 654 , 85 N. E. 345 ; Ray v. Baker (1905), 165 Ind. 74, 88 , 74 N. E. 619 ; City of Hammond v. Jahnke (1912), 178 Ind. 177 , 99 N. E. 39 ; Thain v. State (1914), 182 Ind. 345, 349 , 106 N. E. 690 . 6. 7.

11917–1917
Ludwig v. State neutral
ind · 1908
2 sentences

1917Sutherlin v. State (1886), 108 Ind. 389, 391 , 9 N. E. 298 ; Williams v. State (1908), 170 Ind. 630, 632 , 85 N. E. 113 ; Ludwig v. State (1908), 170 Ind. 648, 654 , 85 N. E. 345 ; Ray v. Baker (1905), 165 Ind. 74, 88 , 74 N. E. 619 ; City of Hammond v. Jahnke (1912), 178 Ind. 177 , 99 N. E. 39 ; Thain v. State (1914), 182 Ind. 345, 349 , 106 N. E. 690 . 6. 7.

1917Sutherlin v. State (1886), 108 Ind. 389, 391 , 9 N. E. 298 ; Williams v. State (1908), 170 Ind. 630, 632 , 85 N. E. 113 ; Ludwig v. State (1908), 170 Ind. 648, 654 , 85 N. E. 345 ; Ray v. Baker (1905), 165 Ind. 74, 88 , 74 N. E. 619 ; City of Hammond v. Jahnke (1912), 178 Ind. 177 , 99 N. E. 39 ; Thain v. State (1914), 182 Ind. 345, 349 , 106 N. E. 690 . 6. 7.

11917–1917
City of Hammond v. Jahnke neutral
ind · 1912
2 sentences

1917Sutherlin v. State (1886), 108 Ind. 389, 391 , 9 N. E. 298 ; Williams v. State (1908), 170 Ind. 630, 632 , 85 N. E. 113 ; Ludwig v. State (1908), 170 Ind. 648, 654 , 85 N. E. 345 ; Ray v. Baker (1905), 165 Ind. 74, 88 , 74 N. E. 619 ; City of Hammond v. Jahnke (1912), 178 Ind. 177 , 99 N. E. 39 ; Thain v. State (1914), 182 Ind. 345, 349 , 106 N. E. 690 . 6. 7.

1917Sutherlin v. State (1886), 108 Ind. 389, 391 , 9 N. E. 298 ; Williams v. State (1908), 170 Ind. 630, 632 , 85 N. E. 113 ; Ludwig v. State (1908), 170 Ind. 648, 654 , 85 N. E. 345 ; Ray v. Baker (1905), 165 Ind. 74, 88 , 74 N. E. 619 ; City of Hammond v. Jahnke (1912), 178 Ind. 177 , 99 N. E. 39 ; Thain v. State (1914), 182 Ind. 345, 349 , 106 N. E. 690 . 6. 7.

11917–1917
Thain v. State neutral
ind · 1914
1 sentence

1917Sutherlin v. State (1886), 108 Ind. 389, 391 , 9 N. E. 298 ; Williams v. State (1908), 170 Ind. 630, 632 , 85 N. E. 113 ; Ludwig v. State (1908), 170 Ind. 648, 654 , 85 N. E. 345 ; Ray v. Baker (1905), 165 Ind. 74, 88 , 74 N. E. 619 ; City of Hammond v. Jahnke (1912), 178 Ind. 177 , 99 N. E. 39 ; Thain v. State (1914), 182 Ind. 345, 349 , 106 N. E. 690 . 6. 7.

11917–1917
Brane v. Kendall neutral
ind · 1914
1 sentence

1917Sutherlin v. State (1886), 108 Ind. 389, 391 , 9 N. E. 298 ; Williams v. State (1908), 170 Ind. 630, 632 , 85 N. E. 113 ; Ludwig v. State (1908), 170 Ind. 648, 654 , 85 N. E. 345 ; Ray v. Baker (1905), 165 Ind. 74, 88 , 74 N. E. 619 ; City of Hammond v. Jahnke (1912), 178 Ind. 177 , 99 N. E. 39 ; Thain v. State (1914), 182 Ind. 345, 349 , 106 N. E. 690 . 6. 7.

11917–1917

Where else courts name it

OK 17 (1916–1983) MO 16 (1878–2019) CA 14 (1919–2023) IN 10 (1917–2013) IL 9 (1907–2023) AL 7 (1917–1978) NY 7 (1990–2026) TX 7 (1922–1974) GA 7 (1906–1979) MT 7 (1922–1987) FL 6 (1953–2002) NC 6 (1968–1985) AR 5 (1912–1980) CT 4 (1976–2021) ME 4 (2003–2019) OH 4 (1951–2026) OR 3 (1923–2021) AZ 2 (1923–1961) ND 2 (1938–1938) KY 2 (1968–1969) WA 2 (1938–1943) VT 2 (1936–1993) PA 2 (1949–2015)

Opinions by the citing court's state. A doctrine retained in one state and abandoned in another shows up here as a year span that stalls.

← Caselaw search · G Cite Topics · Brief Check