advantage of seeing hearing in Oregon

9 Oregon opinions name it 2 courts 1951–1994 0 in the last five years

The cases below were cited by Oregon courts in a sentence that names this issue. Sides come from how each citing opinion treated the case (Syfertize flag on that citation), so a case can appear on both: that is where the law is contested. A red or yellow chip is the case's own overall treatment.

Followed or applied (2)

Case	Followed	Cited
Tingen v. Tingengreen or · 1968 · cited in 4 Oregon opinions naming this issue, 1972–1976 2 sentences 1972In reaching our decision we have considered all the factors set out in Tingen v. Tingen, 251 Or 458, 459 , 446 P2d 185 (1968), and in addition have accorded weight to the decision of the trial judge, who had the advantage of seeing and hearing the witnesses. 1972In reaching our decision we have considered all the factors set out in Tingen v. Tingen, 251 Or 458, 459 , 446 P2d 185 (1968), and in addition have accorded weight to the decision of the trial judge, who had the advantage of seeing and hearing the witnesses.	1	4
Hannan v. Good Samaritan Hospitalgreen orctapp · 1970 · cited in 1 Oregon opinions naming this issue, 1976–1976 2 sentences 1976L and L, 18 Or App 642, 646 , 526 P2d 491 (1974); Hannan v. Good Samaritan Hosp., 4 Or App 178, 187, 471 P2d 831 , 476 P2d 931 (1970), Sup Ct review denied (1971); Bennehoff v. Bennehoff, 209 Or 224, 225-26 , 304 P2d 1079 (1956). 1976L and L, 18 Or App 642, 646 , 526 P2d 491 (1974); Hannan v. Good Samaritan Hosp., 4 Or App 178, 187, 471 P2d 831 , 476 P2d 931 (1970), Sup Ct review denied (1971); Bennehoff v. Bennehoff, 209 Or 224, 225-26 , 304 P2d 1079 (1956).	1	1

Distinguished, questioned or overruled (0)

Case	Negative	Cited
No negative-treatment citations attached to this issue in Oregon. Read the followed side critically anyway.

Also cited on this issue (11)

Case	Cited	Years
Bennehoff v. Bennehoff neutral or · 1956 2 sentences 1976L and L, 18 Or App 642, 646 , 526 P2d 491 (1974); Hannan v. Good Samaritan Hosp., 4 Or App 178, 187, 471 P2d 831 , 476 P2d 931 (1970), Sup Ct review denied (1971); Bennehoff v. Bennehoff, 209 Or 224, 225-26 , 304 P2d 1079 (1956). 1976L and L, 18 Or App 642, 646 , 526 P2d 491 (1974); Hannan v. Good Samaritan Hosp., 4 Or App 178, 187, 471 P2d 831 , 476 P2d 931 (1970), Sup Ct review denied (1971); Bennehoff v. Bennehoff, 209 Or 224, 225-26 , 304 P2d 1079 (1956).	4	1972–1976
In Re Provolt's Estate green or · 1944 2 sentences 1994In re Provolt’s Estate, supra, 175 Or at 135 . 1951Morley v. Silverton Hospital, supra, 138 Or. 75, 95 , 5 P. 2d 92 ; In re Murray’s Estate, supra, 173 Or. 209, 227 , 144 P. 2d 1016 ; In re Provolt’s Estate, supra, 175 Or. 128, 135 , 151 P. 2d 736 ; In re Southman’s Estate, 178 Or. 462, 483 , 168 P. 2d 572 .	2	1951–1994
Fredrickson v. GRANDMA COOKIE COMPANY neutral orctapp · 1973 2 sentences 1987Miller v. Granite Construction Co., 28 Or App 473 , 559 P2d 944 (1977); Fredrickson v. Grandma Cookie Co., 13 Or App 334, 337-38 , 509 P2d 1213 (1973). 1987Miller v. Granite Construction Co., 28 Or App 473 , 559 P2d 944 (1977); Fredrickson v. Grandma Cookie Co., 13 Or App 334, 337-38 , 509 P2d 1213 (1973).	2	1977–1987
Miller v. Granite Construction Co. green orctapp · 1977 2 sentences 1987Miller v. Granite Construction Co., 28 Or App 473 , 559 P2d 944 (1977); Fredrickson v. Grandma Cookie Co., 13 Or App 334, 337-38 , 509 P2d 1213 (1973). 1987Miller v. Granite Construction Co., 28 Or App 473 , 559 P2d 944 (1977); Fredrickson v. Grandma Cookie Co., 13 Or App 334, 337-38 , 509 P2d 1213 (1973).	1	1987–1987
Etchison v. State Accident Insurance Fund green orctapp · 1972 2 sentences 1977Fredrickson v. Grandma Cookie Co., 13 Or App 334, 337-38 , 509 P2d 1213 (1973); Etchison v. SAIF, 8 Or App 395 , 494 P2d 455 (1972); Bailey v. Morrison-Knudsen, 5 Or App 592, 597 , 485 P2d 1254 (1971). 1977Fredrickson v. Grandma Cookie Co., 13 Or App 334, 337-38 , 509 P2d 1213 (1973); Etchison v. SAIF, 8 Or App 395 , 494 P2d 455 (1972); Bailey v. Morrison-Knudsen, 5 Or App 592, 597 , 485 P2d 1254 (1971).	1	1977–1977
Bailey v. Morrison-Knudsen Company green orctapp · 1971 2 sentences 1977Fredrickson v. Grandma Cookie Co., 13 Or App 334, 337-38 , 509 P2d 1213 (1973); Etchison v. SAIF, 8 Or App 395 , 494 P2d 455 (1972); Bailey v. Morrison-Knudsen, 5 Or App 592, 597 , 485 P2d 1254 (1971). 1977Fredrickson v. Grandma Cookie Co., 13 Or App 334, 337-38 , 509 P2d 1213 (1973); Etchison v. SAIF, 8 Or App 395 , 494 P2d 455 (1972); Bailey v. Morrison-Knudsen, 5 Or App 592, 597 , 485 P2d 1254 (1971).	1	1977–1977
In Re the Dissolution of the Marriage of L neutral orctapp · 1974 2 sentences 1976L and L, 18 Or App 642, 646 , 526 P2d 491 (1974); Hannan v. Good Samaritan Hosp., 4 Or App 178, 187, 471 P2d 831 , 476 P2d 931 (1970), Sup Ct review denied (1971); Bennehoff v. Bennehoff, 209 Or 224, 225-26 , 304 P2d 1079 (1956). 1976L and L, 18 Or App 642, 646 , 526 P2d 491 (1974); Hannan v. Good Samaritan Hosp., 4 Or App 178, 187, 471 P2d 831 , 476 P2d 931 (1970), Sup Ct review denied (1971); Bennehoff v. Bennehoff, 209 Or 224, 225-26 , 304 P2d 1079 (1956).	1	1976–1976
Hannan v. Good Samaritan Hospital green orctapp · 1970 1 sentence 1976L and L, 18 Or App 642, 646 , 526 P2d 491 (1974); Hannan v. Good Samaritan Hosp., 4 Or App 178, 187, 471 P2d 831 , 476 P2d 931 (1970), Sup Ct review denied (1971); Bennehoff v. Bennehoff, 209 Or 224, 225-26 , 304 P2d 1079 (1956).	1	1976–1976
Morley v. Silverton Hospital green or · 1931 2 sentences 1951Morley v. Silverton Hospital, supra, 138 Or. 75, 95 , 5 P. 2d 92 ; In re Murray’s Estate, supra, 173 Or. 209, 227 , 144 P. 2d 1016 ; In re Provolt’s Estate, supra, 175 Or. 128, 135 , 151 P. 2d 736 ; In re Southman’s Estate, 178 Or. 462, 483 , 168 P. 2d 572 . 1951Morley v. Silverton Hospital, supra, 138 Or. 75, 95 , 5 P. 2d 92 ; In re Murray’s Estate, supra, 173 Or. 209, 227 , 144 P. 2d 1016 ; In re Provolt’s Estate, supra, 175 Or. 128, 135 , 151 P. 2d 736 ; In re Southman’s Estate, 178 Or. 462, 483 , 168 P. 2d 572 .	1	1951–1951
In Re Murray's Estate neutral or · 1943 2 sentences 1951Morley v. Silverton Hospital, supra, 138 Or. 75, 95 , 5 P. 2d 92 ; In re Murray’s Estate, supra, 173 Or. 209, 227 , 144 P. 2d 1016 ; In re Provolt’s Estate, supra, 175 Or. 128, 135 , 151 P. 2d 736 ; In re Southman’s Estate, 178 Or. 462, 483 , 168 P. 2d 572 . 1951Morley v. Silverton Hospital, supra, 138 Or. 75, 95 , 5 P. 2d 92 ; In re Murray’s Estate, supra, 173 Or. 209, 227 , 144 P. 2d 1016 ; In re Provolt’s Estate, supra, 175 Or. 128, 135 , 151 P. 2d 736 ; In re Southman’s Estate, 178 Or. 462, 483 , 168 P. 2d 572 .	1	1951–1951
In Re Southman's Estate green or · 1946 2 sentences 1951Morley v. Silverton Hospital, supra, 138 Or. 75, 95 , 5 P. 2d 92 ; In re Murray’s Estate, supra, 173 Or. 209, 227 , 144 P. 2d 1016 ; In re Provolt’s Estate, supra, 175 Or. 128, 135 , 151 P. 2d 736 ; In re Southman’s Estate, 178 Or. 462, 483 , 168 P. 2d 572 . 1951Morley v. Silverton Hospital, supra, 138 Or. 75, 95 , 5 P. 2d 92 ; In re Murray’s Estate, supra, 173 Or. 209, 227 , 144 P. 2d 1016 ; In re Provolt’s Estate, supra, 175 Or. 128, 135 , 151 P. 2d 736 ; In re Southman’s Estate, 178 Or. 462, 483 , 168 P. 2d 572 .	1	1951–1951

Where else courts name it

NY 304 (1931–2026) PA 19 (1934–1980) AL 18 (1916–2014) LA 16 (1939–2008) MI 16 (1915–1978) SD 14 (1993–2025) IA 11 (1915–2024) MA 11 (1940–2023) UT 10 (1979–2019) AR 9 (1954–1996) OR 9 (1951–1994) RI 5 (1911–2015) NH 4 (1984–2018) ND 3 (1926–1931) MT 3 (1928–1934) NJ 3 (1965–1985) IL 3 (1936–1968) WA 3 (1934–1942) NC 3 (1967–2009) MD 2 (1973–1973) OH 2 (2003–2011) NM 2 (1966–1967) SC 2 (2007–2017) CO 2 (1943–1975)

Opinions by the citing court's state. A doctrine retained in one state and abandoned in another shows up here as a year span that stalls.

← Caselaw search · G Cite Topics · Brief Check