contention of plaintiff error (Illinois) · Go Syfert
← Illinois issues

contention of plaintiff error in Illinois

64 Illinois opinions name it 2 courts 1889–1958 0 in the last five years

The cases below were cited by Illinois courts in a sentence that names this issue. Sides come from how each citing opinion treated the case (Syfertize flag on that citation), so a case can appear on both: that is where the law is contested. A red or yellow chip is the case's own overall treatment.

Followed or applied (1)

CaseFollowedCited
People v. McGowangreen
ill · 1953 · cited in 1 Illinois opinions naming this issue, 1953–1953
1 sentence

1953See People v. McGowan, 415 Ill. 375 .

11

Distinguished, questioned or overruled (0)

CaseNegativeCited
No negative-treatment citations attached to this issue in Illinois. Read the followed side critically anyway.

Also cited on this issue (79)

CaseCitedYears
Maloney v. People neutral
ill · 1907
2 sentences

1953In support of this contention counsel cite the case of Maloney v. People, 229 Ill. 593 .

1946In support of this contention counsel cite the case of Maloney v. People, 229 Ill. 593 .

21946–1953
The People v. Tyson neutral
ill · 1946
2 sentences

1949The second error assigned, that the sentence imposed under the Parole Act, as amended in 1943, is unconstitutional, has been decided against the contention of plaintiff in error in People v. Norwitt, 394 Ill. 553 ; People v. Tyson, 393 Ill. 108 ; People v. Wilson, 391 Ill. 463 , and other cases.

1947This question was presented to this court in People v. Tyson, 393 Ill. 108 , where this exact objection was passed upon contrary to the contention of plaintiff in error.

21947–1949
People v. Hardgrave neutral
ill · 1950
1 sentence

1958It is based upon People v. Hardgrave, 406 Ill. 211 , which supports his argument.

11958–1958
Springer v. City of Chicago green
ill · 1891
1 sentence

1955Springer v. City of Chicago, 135 Ill. 552 ; McInturff v. Insurance Company of North America, 248 id. 92; Harney v. Sanitary District, 260 id. 54.” In the ease of Mclnturff v. Insurance Co. of North America, supra, we find the following: “There is, however, another satisfactory answer to the contention of plaintiff in error in this regard.

11955–1955
The People v. Borrelli green
ill · 1946
1 sentence

1953Certainly not, unless it could be said that such illegal act also had the quality of being ‘injurious to the public trade, health, morals, police or administration of public justice.’ ” In the later case of People v. Borrelli, 392 Ill. 481 , the court reviewed the case of Maloney v. People, supra, and stated as follows: “It is the contention of plaintiff in error that the indictments are fatally defective and not sufficient to charge him with a criminal offense.

11953–1953
The People v. Shoffner neutral
ill · 1948
1 sentence

1951(People v. Shoffner, 400 Ill. 174 .) An examination of the record discloses the judgment below was properly entered upon the plea of guilty to burglary and larceny.

11951–1951
The People v. Hatcher neutral
ill · 1929
1 sentence

1949(People v. Hatcher, 334 Ill. 526 .) The contention of plaintiff in error that the court erred in not granting him a separate trial is also subject to the same rule.

11949–1949
The People v. Thompson neutral
ill · 1947
1 sentence

1949Swanson v. Fisher, 340 Ill. 250 ; People v. Berkowshi, 385 Ill. 392 ; People v. Thompson, 398 Ill. 114 .) In the light of these holdings there is no merit to this contention of plaintiff in error.

11949–1949
The People v. Berkowski neutral
ill · 1944
1 sentence

1949Swanson v. Fisher, 340 Ill. 250 ; People v. Berkowshi, 385 Ill. 392 ; People v. Thompson, 398 Ill. 114 .) In the light of these holdings there is no merit to this contention of plaintiff in error.

11949–1949
The People v. Wilson neutral
ill · 1945
1 sentence

1949The second error assigned, that the sentence imposed under the Parole Act, as amended in 1943, is unconstitutional, has been decided against the contention of plaintiff in error in People v. Norwitt, 394 Ill. 553 ; People v. Tyson, 393 Ill. 108 ; People v. Wilson, 391 Ill. 463 , and other cases.

11949–1949
The People v. Norwitt neutral
ill · 1946
1 sentence

1949The second error assigned, that the sentence imposed under the Parole Act, as amended in 1943, is unconstitutional, has been decided against the contention of plaintiff in error in People v. Norwitt, 394 Ill. 553 ; People v. Tyson, 393 Ill. 108 ; People v. Wilson, 391 Ill. 463 , and other cases.

11949–1949
People Ex Rel. Swanson v. Fisher green
ill · 1930
1 sentence

1949Swanson v. Fisher, 340 Ill. 250 ; People v. Berkowshi, 385 Ill. 392 ; People v. Thompson, 398 Ill. 114 .) In the light of these holdings there is no merit to this contention of plaintiff in error.

11949–1949
Groveland Coal Mining Co. v. Industrial Commission neutral
ill · 1923
1 sentence

1947There is no departure from the rule in Groveland Coal Co. v. Industrial Com. 309 Ill. 73 , or anything that would sustain the contention of plaintiff in error that the gross yearly income amount controls, without reference to increased wages, overtime, or increased hours of work.

11947–1947
People v. Jacobson neutral
ill · 1910
1 sentence

1946The court there reviewed and distinguished the cases of People v. Jacobson, 247 Ill. 394 , and People v. Warren, 260 Ill. 297 , both of which expressly hold that jurisdiction in criminal cases conferred upon the criminal court of Cook county is not exclusive.

11946–1946
People v. Warren neutral
ill · 1913
1 sentence

1946The court there reviewed and distinguished the cases of People v. Jacobson, 247 Ill. 394 , and People v. Warren, 260 Ill. 297 , both of which expressly hold that jurisdiction in criminal cases conferred upon the criminal court of Cook county is not exclusive.

11946–1946
The People v. Sain neutral
ill · 1943
1 sentence

1944People v. Sain, 384 Ill. 394 ; Hammond v. People, 199 Ill. 173 .

11944–1944
Anderson v. Anderson neutral
ill · 1930
1 sentence

1944(Anderson v. Anderson, 339 Ill. 400 ; Chicago Title and Trust Co. v. Ward, 332 Ill. 126 ; Feyerabend v. Feyerabend, 312 Ill. 559 ; Allen v. LeMoyne, 102 Ill. 25 .) Gauged by these rules, the findings of fact of the decree before us are sufficient to support it and this contention of plaintiff in error cannot be sustained.

11944–1944
The People v. Bain neutral
ill · 1934
1 sentence

1944This exact question was presented to this court in the case of People v. Bain, 358 Ill. 177 .

11944–1944
Chicago Title & Trust Co. v. Ward green
ill · 1928
1 sentence

1944(Anderson v. Anderson, 339 Ill. 400 ; Chicago Title and Trust Co. v. Ward, 332 Ill. 126 ; Feyerabend v. Feyerabend, 312 Ill. 559 ; Allen v. LeMoyne, 102 Ill. 25 .) Gauged by these rules, the findings of fact of the decree before us are sufficient to support it and this contention of plaintiff in error cannot be sustained.

11944–1944
Allen v. LeMoyne green
ill · 1881
1 sentence

1944(Anderson v. Anderson, 339 Ill. 400 ; Chicago Title and Trust Co. v. Ward, 332 Ill. 126 ; Feyerabend v. Feyerabend, 312 Ill. 559 ; Allen v. LeMoyne, 102 Ill. 25 .) Gauged by these rules, the findings of fact of the decree before us are sufficient to support it and this contention of plaintiff in error cannot be sustained.

11944–1944
Hammond v. People neutral
ill · 1902
1 sentence

1944People v. Sain, 384 Ill. 394 ; Hammond v. People, 199 Ill. 173 .

11944–1944
People v. Rosenwald green
ill · 1915
1 sentence

1944Application of the Wallahan case was considered in People v. Rosenwald, 266 Ill. 548 , and it was there held that if the bill of exceptions is signed on a date within the time fixed by the court, but not on the date actually presented, it can be filed as of the date presented nunc pro tunc.

11944–1944
Feyerabend v. Feyerabend neutral
ill · 1924
1 sentence

1944(Anderson v. Anderson, 339 Ill. 400 ; Chicago Title and Trust Co. v. Ward, 332 Ill. 126 ; Feyerabend v. Feyerabend, 312 Ill. 559 ; Allen v. LeMoyne, 102 Ill. 25 .) Gauged by these rules, the findings of fact of the decree before us are sufficient to support it and this contention of plaintiff in error cannot be sustained.

11944–1944
People v. Jones green
ill · 1914
1 sentence

1943The refusal of the court to permit a withdrawal of the plea of not guilty and the entry of a motion to quash the indictment is a matter within the sound discretion of the trial court (People v. Jones, 263 Ill. 564 ;) and unless it is shown there was an abuse of this discretion it is not reversible error to deny the motion.

11943–1943
The People v. Peterson green
ill · 1936
2 sentences

1938(People v. Peterson, 364 Ill. 80 ; People v. Herkless, 361 id. 32.) * * * It is the province of the jury to determine, from a consideration of all the evidence, under correct instructions, whether defendant is guilty of culpable or criminal negligence which was the proximate cause of the resultant death. — People v. Peterson, supra; People v. Herkless, supra; People v. Smaszcz, supra.” The contention of plaintiff in error that death was caused by accidental means, is not borne out by the testimony.

1938(People v. Peterson, 364 Ill. 80 ; People v. Herkless, 361 id. 32.) * * * It is the province of the jury to determine, from a consideration of all the evidence, under correct instructions, whether defendant is guilty of culpable or criminal negligence which was the proximate cause of the resultant death. — People v. Peterson, supra; People v. Herkless, supra; People v. Smaszcz, supra.” The contention of plaintiff in error that death was caused by accidental means, is not borne out by the testimony.

11938–1938
People Ex Rel. Courtney v. Prystalski green
ill · 1934
1 sentence

1935(People v. Prystalski, supra; Sokel v. People, 212 Ill. 238 ; Beasley v. People, 89 id. 571.) This contention of plaintiff in error cannot be sustained.

11935–1935
Sokel v. People green
ill · 1904
1 sentence

1935(People v. Prystalski, supra; Sokel v. People, 212 Ill. 238 ; Beasley v. People, 89 id. 571.) This contention of plaintiff in error cannot be sustained.

11935–1935
Gebhardt v. Village of Lagrange Park green
ill · 1933
1 sentence

1934The contention of plaintiff in error that it is engaged in a governmental rather, than a proprietary function, in support of which it relies upon the case of Gebhardt v. Village of LaGrange Park, 354 Ill. 234 , is of no force in this case.

11934–1934
The People v. Scornavache green
ill · 1931
1 sentence

1934This point was decided contrary to the contention of plaintiff in error in People v. Scornavache, 347 Ill. 403 .

11934–1934
The People v. Mueller neutral
ill · 1933
11933–1933
United States v. Herrig green
mtd · 1913
11933–1933
Webb v. Lines green
conn · 1904
11931–1931
The People v. Lavendowski neutral
ill · 1927
11931–1931
People v. Byzon neutral
ill · 1915
11931–1931
East St. Louis Board of Education v. Industrial Commission neutral
ill · 1921
11931–1931
The People v. Taylor green
ill · 1925
11930–1930
Goodman v. People green
ill · 1907
11929–1929
Hoopeston Public Library v. Eaton neutral
ill · 1918
11929–1929
Bouslough v. Bouslough neutral
ill · 1922
11929–1929
The People v. Lavendowski green
ill · 1928
11928–1928

Where else courts name it

IL 64 (1889–1958) OK 54 (1898–1960) TX 24 (1894–1952) CO 18 (1900–1958) GA 13 (1907–1964) FL 11 (1890–1949) OH 10 (1905–1935) NE 7 (1893–1937) VA 6 (1906–1924) KS 6 (1896–1904) WI 2 (1902–1912) MO 2 (1913–1930) TN 2 (1907–1957) WA 2 (1891–1920) SC 2 (1928–1929)

Opinions by the citing court's state. A doctrine retained in one state and abandoned in another shows up here as a year span that stalls.

← Caselaw search · G Cite Topics · Brief Check