defendant from asserting claim (Mississippi) · Go Syfert
← Mississippi issues

defendant from asserting claim in Mississippi

8 Mississippi opinions name it 2 courts 1982–2021 1 in the last five years

The cases below were cited by Mississippi courts in a sentence that names this issue. Sides come from how each citing opinion treated the case (Syfertize flag on that citation), so a case can appear on both: that is where the law is contested. A red or yellow chip is the case's own overall treatment.

Followed or applied (3)

CaseFollowedCited
Keys v. Stategreen
miss · 1994 · cited in 4 Mississippi opinions naming this issue, 2004–2018
2 sentences

2018The supreme court “has condemned outright the granting of any [jury] instruction that precludes a defendant from asserting a claim of self-defense[,]” explaining that “[a] criminal defendant is entitled to present his defense to the finder of fact.” Johnson v. State, 12 908 So. 2d 758, 762 (¶15) (Miss. 2005) (quoting Keys v. State, 635 So. 2d 845, 848 (Miss. 1984)). ¶34.

2017This Court has condemned outright the granting of any instruction that precludes a defendant from asserting a claim of self-defense.” Keys v. State, 635 So. 2d 845, 848 (Miss. 1984) (citations omitted).

44
Johnson v. Stategreen
miss · 2005 · cited in 2 Mississippi opinions naming this issue, 2018–2021
2 sentences

2021Hearns is correct that the Mississippi Supreme Court “has condemned outright the granting of any instruction that precludes a defendant from asserting a claim of self-defense.” Boston v. State, 234 So. 3d 1231 , 1234 (¶10) (Miss. 2017) (quoting Johnson v. State, 908 So. 2d 758, 762 (¶15) (Miss. 2005)).

2018The supreme court “has condemned outright the granting of any [jury] instruction that precludes a defendant from asserting a claim of self-defense[,]” explaining that “[a] criminal defendant is entitled to present his defense to the finder of fact.” Johnson v. State, 12 908 So. 2d 758, 762 (¶15) (Miss. 2005) (quoting Keys v. State, 635 So. 2d 845, 848 (Miss. 1984)). ¶34.

22
McMullen v. Stategreen
miss · 1974 · cited in 2 Mississippi opinions naming this issue, 1982–1994
2 sentences

1994See McMullen v. State, 291 So.2d 537 (Miss. 1974); Patrick v. State, 285 So.2d 165 (Miss. 1973); Craft v. State, 271 So.2d 735 (Miss. 1973); Ellis v. State, 208 So.2d 49 (Miss. 1968); Tate v. State, 192 So.2d 923 (Miss. 1966); Thompson v. State, 190 Miss. 639 , 200 So. 715 (1941); Brown v. State, 186 Miss. 734 , 191 So. 818 (1939); Vance v. State, 182 Miss. 840 , 183 So. 280 (1938); Coleman v. State, 179 Miss. 661 , 176 So. 714 (1937); Lee v. State, 138 Miss. 474 , 103 So. 233 (1925); Adams v. State, 136 Miss. 298 , 101 So. 437 (1924); Garner v. State, 93 Miss. 843 , 47 So. 500 (1908); Pulpus

1982This Court condemned outright the giving of any instruction precluding the defendant from asserting the claim of self-defense in the following cases: McMullen v. State, 291 So.2d 537 (Miss. 1974); Patrick v. State, 285 So.2d 165 (Miss. 1973); Craft v. State, 271 So.2d 735 (Miss. 1973); Ellis v. State, 208 So.2d 49 (Miss. 1968); Tate v. State, 192 So.2d 923 (Miss. 1966); Thompson v. State, 190 Miss. 639 , 200 So. 715 (1941); Brown v. State, 186 Miss. 734 , 191 So. 818 (1939); Vance v. State, 182 Miss. 840 , 183 So. 280 (1938); Coleman v. State, 179 Miss. 661 , 176 So. 714 (1937); Lee v. State,

12

Distinguished, questioned or overruled (0)

CaseNegativeCited
No negative-treatment citations attached to this issue in Mississippi. Read the followed side critically anyway.

Also cited on this issue (15)

CaseCitedYears
Patrick v. State green
miss · 1973
2 sentences

1994See McMullen v. State, 291 So.2d 537 (Miss. 1974); Patrick v. State, 285 So.2d 165 (Miss. 1973); Craft v. State, 271 So.2d 735 (Miss. 1973); Ellis v. State, 208 So.2d 49 (Miss. 1968); Tate v. State, 192 So.2d 923 (Miss. 1966); Thompson v. State, 190 Miss. 639 , 200 So. 715 (1941); Brown v. State, 186 Miss. 734 , 191 So. 818 (1939); Vance v. State, 182 Miss. 840 , 183 So. 280 (1938); Coleman v. State, 179 Miss. 661 , 176 So. 714 (1937); Lee v. State, 138 Miss. 474 , 103 So. 233 (1925); Adams v. State, 136 Miss. 298 , 101 So. 437 (1924); Garner v. State, 93 Miss. 843 , 47 So. 500 (1908); Pulpus

1982This Court condemned outright the giving of any instruction precluding the defendant from asserting the claim of self-defense in the following cases: McMullen v. State, 291 So.2d 537 (Miss. 1974); Patrick v. State, 285 So.2d 165 (Miss. 1973); Craft v. State, 271 So.2d 735 (Miss. 1973); Ellis v. State, 208 So.2d 49 (Miss. 1968); Tate v. State, 192 So.2d 923 (Miss. 1966); Thompson v. State, 190 Miss. 639 , 200 So. 715 (1941); Brown v. State, 186 Miss. 734 , 191 So. 818 (1939); Vance v. State, 182 Miss. 840 , 183 So. 280 (1938); Coleman v. State, 179 Miss. 661 , 176 So. 714 (1937); Lee v. State,

21982–1994
Tate v. State green
miss · 1966
2 sentences

1994See McMullen v. State, 291 So.2d 537 (Miss. 1974); Patrick v. State, 285 So.2d 165 (Miss. 1973); Craft v. State, 271 So.2d 735 (Miss. 1973); Ellis v. State, 208 So.2d 49 (Miss. 1968); Tate v. State, 192 So.2d 923 (Miss. 1966); Thompson v. State, 190 Miss. 639 , 200 So. 715 (1941); Brown v. State, 186 Miss. 734 , 191 So. 818 (1939); Vance v. State, 182 Miss. 840 , 183 So. 280 (1938); Coleman v. State, 179 Miss. 661 , 176 So. 714 (1937); Lee v. State, 138 Miss. 474 , 103 So. 233 (1925); Adams v. State, 136 Miss. 298 , 101 So. 437 (1924); Garner v. State, 93 Miss. 843 , 47 So. 500 (1908); Pulpus

1982This Court condemned outright the giving of any instruction precluding the defendant from asserting the claim of self-defense in the following cases: McMullen v. State, 291 So.2d 537 (Miss. 1974); Patrick v. State, 285 So.2d 165 (Miss. 1973); Craft v. State, 271 So.2d 735 (Miss. 1973); Ellis v. State, 208 So.2d 49 (Miss. 1968); Tate v. State, 192 So.2d 923 (Miss. 1966); Thompson v. State, 190 Miss. 639 , 200 So. 715 (1941); Brown v. State, 186 Miss. 734 , 191 So. 818 (1939); Vance v. State, 182 Miss. 840 , 183 So. 280 (1938); Coleman v. State, 179 Miss. 661 , 176 So. 714 (1937); Lee v. State,

21982–1994
Prine v. State green
miss · 1896
2 sentences

1982This Court condemned outright the giving of any instruction precluding the defendant from asserting the claim of self-defense in the following cases: McMullen v. State, 291 So.2d 537 (Miss. 1974); Patrick v. State, 285 So.2d 165 (Miss. 1973); Craft v. State, 271 So.2d 735 (Miss. 1973); Ellis v. State, 208 So.2d 49 (Miss. 1968); Tate v. State, 192 So.2d 923 (Miss. 1966); Thompson v. State, 190 Miss. 639 , 200 So. 715 (1941); Brown v. State, 186 Miss. 734 , 191 So. 818 (1939); Vance v. State, 182 Miss. 840 , 183 So. 280 (1938); Coleman v. State, 179 Miss. 661 , 176 So. 714 (1937); Lee v. State,

1982This Court condemned outright the giving of any instruction precluding the defendant from asserting the claim of self-defense in the following cases: McMullen v. State, 291 So.2d 537 (Miss. 1974); Patrick v. State, 285 So.2d 165 (Miss. 1973); Craft v. State, 271 So.2d 735 (Miss. 1973); Ellis v. State, 208 So.2d 49 (Miss. 1968); Tate v. State, 192 So.2d 923 (Miss. 1966); Thompson v. State, 190 Miss. 639 , 200 So. 715 (1941); Brown v. State, 186 Miss. 734 , 191 So. 818 (1939); Vance v. State, 182 Miss. 840 , 183 So. 280 (1938); Coleman v. State, 179 Miss. 661 , 176 So. 714 (1937); Lee v. State,

21982–1994
Garner v. State neutral
miss · 1908
2 sentences

1982This Court condemned outright the giving of any instruction precluding the defendant from asserting the claim of self-defense in the following cases: McMullen v. State, 291 So.2d 537 (Miss. 1974); Patrick v. State, 285 So.2d 165 (Miss. 1973); Craft v. State, 271 So.2d 735 (Miss. 1973); Ellis v. State, 208 So.2d 49 (Miss. 1968); Tate v. State, 192 So.2d 923 (Miss. 1966); Thompson v. State, 190 Miss. 639 , 200 So. 715 (1941); Brown v. State, 186 Miss. 734 , 191 So. 818 (1939); Vance v. State, 182 Miss. 840 , 183 So. 280 (1938); Coleman v. State, 179 Miss. 661 , 176 So. 714 (1937); Lee v. State,

1982This Court condemned outright the giving of any instruction precluding the defendant from asserting the claim of self-defense in the following cases: McMullen v. State, 291 So.2d 537 (Miss. 1974); Patrick v. State, 285 So.2d 165 (Miss. 1973); Craft v. State, 271 So.2d 735 (Miss. 1973); Ellis v. State, 208 So.2d 49 (Miss. 1968); Tate v. State, 192 So.2d 923 (Miss. 1966); Thompson v. State, 190 Miss. 639 , 200 So. 715 (1941); Brown v. State, 186 Miss. 734 , 191 So. 818 (1939); Vance v. State, 182 Miss. 840 , 183 So. 280 (1938); Coleman v. State, 179 Miss. 661 , 176 So. 714 (1937); Lee v. State,

21982–1994
Lofton v. State neutral
miss · 1901
2 sentences

1994See McMullen v. State, 291 So.2d 537 (Miss. 1974); Patrick v. State, 285 So.2d 165 (Miss. 1973); Craft v. State, 271 So.2d 735 (Miss. 1973); Ellis v. State, 208 So.2d 49 (Miss. 1968); Tate v. State, 192 So.2d 923 (Miss. 1966); Thompson v. State, 190 Miss. 639 , 200 So. 715 (1941); Brown v. State, 186 Miss. 734 , 191 So. 818 (1939); Vance v. State, 182 Miss. 840 , 183 So. 280 (1938); Coleman v. State, 179 Miss. 661 , 176 So. 714 (1937); Lee v. State, 138 Miss. 474 , 103 So. 233 (1925); Adams v. State, 136 Miss. 298 , 101 So. 437 (1924); Garner v. State, 93 Miss. 843 , 47 So. 500 (1908); Pulpus

1982This Court condemned outright the giving of any instruction precluding the defendant from asserting the claim of self-defense in the following cases: McMullen v. State, 291 So.2d 537 (Miss. 1974); Patrick v. State, 285 So.2d 165 (Miss. 1973); Craft v. State, 271 So.2d 735 (Miss. 1973); Ellis v. State, 208 So.2d 49 (Miss. 1968); Tate v. State, 192 So.2d 923 (Miss. 1966); Thompson v. State, 190 Miss. 639 , 200 So. 715 (1941); Brown v. State, 186 Miss. 734 , 191 So. 818 (1939); Vance v. State, 182 Miss. 840 , 183 So. 280 (1938); Coleman v. State, 179 Miss. 661 , 176 So. 714 (1937); Lee v. State,

21982–1994
Pulpus v. State green
miss · 1903
2 sentences

1982This Court condemned outright the giving of any instruction precluding the defendant from asserting the claim of self-defense in the following cases: McMullen v. State, 291 So.2d 537 (Miss. 1974); Patrick v. State, 285 So.2d 165 (Miss. 1973); Craft v. State, 271 So.2d 735 (Miss. 1973); Ellis v. State, 208 So.2d 49 (Miss. 1968); Tate v. State, 192 So.2d 923 (Miss. 1966); Thompson v. State, 190 Miss. 639 , 200 So. 715 (1941); Brown v. State, 186 Miss. 734 , 191 So. 818 (1939); Vance v. State, 182 Miss. 840 , 183 So. 280 (1938); Coleman v. State, 179 Miss. 661 , 176 So. 714 (1937); Lee v. State,

1982This Court condemned outright the giving of any instruction precluding the defendant from asserting the claim of self-defense in the following cases: McMullen v. State, 291 So.2d 537 (Miss. 1974); Patrick v. State, 285 So.2d 165 (Miss. 1973); Craft v. State, 271 So.2d 735 (Miss. 1973); Ellis v. State, 208 So.2d 49 (Miss. 1968); Tate v. State, 192 So.2d 923 (Miss. 1966); Thompson v. State, 190 Miss. 639 , 200 So. 715 (1941); Brown v. State, 186 Miss. 734 , 191 So. 818 (1939); Vance v. State, 182 Miss. 840 , 183 So. 280 (1938); Coleman v. State, 179 Miss. 661 , 176 So. 714 (1937); Lee v. State,

21982–1994
Adams v. State neutral
miss · 1924
2 sentences

1982This Court condemned outright the giving of any instruction precluding the defendant from asserting the claim of self-defense in the following cases: McMullen v. State, 291 So.2d 537 (Miss. 1974); Patrick v. State, 285 So.2d 165 (Miss. 1973); Craft v. State, 271 So.2d 735 (Miss. 1973); Ellis v. State, 208 So.2d 49 (Miss. 1968); Tate v. State, 192 So.2d 923 (Miss. 1966); Thompson v. State, 190 Miss. 639 , 200 So. 715 (1941); Brown v. State, 186 Miss. 734 , 191 So. 818 (1939); Vance v. State, 182 Miss. 840 , 183 So. 280 (1938); Coleman v. State, 179 Miss. 661 , 176 So. 714 (1937); Lee v. State,

1982This Court condemned outright the giving of any instruction precluding the defendant from asserting the claim of self-defense in the following cases: McMullen v. State, 291 So.2d 537 (Miss. 1974); Patrick v. State, 285 So.2d 165 (Miss. 1973); Craft v. State, 271 So.2d 735 (Miss. 1973); Ellis v. State, 208 So.2d 49 (Miss. 1968); Tate v. State, 192 So.2d 923 (Miss. 1966); Thompson v. State, 190 Miss. 639 , 200 So. 715 (1941); Brown v. State, 186 Miss. 734 , 191 So. 818 (1939); Vance v. State, 182 Miss. 840 , 183 So. 280 (1938); Coleman v. State, 179 Miss. 661 , 176 So. 714 (1937); Lee v. State,

21982–1994
Ellis v. State neutral
miss · 1968
2 sentences

1994See McMullen v. State, 291 So.2d 537 (Miss. 1974); Patrick v. State, 285 So.2d 165 (Miss. 1973); Craft v. State, 271 So.2d 735 (Miss. 1973); Ellis v. State, 208 So.2d 49 (Miss. 1968); Tate v. State, 192 So.2d 923 (Miss. 1966); Thompson v. State, 190 Miss. 639 , 200 So. 715 (1941); Brown v. State, 186 Miss. 734 , 191 So. 818 (1939); Vance v. State, 182 Miss. 840 , 183 So. 280 (1938); Coleman v. State, 179 Miss. 661 , 176 So. 714 (1937); Lee v. State, 138 Miss. 474 , 103 So. 233 (1925); Adams v. State, 136 Miss. 298 , 101 So. 437 (1924); Garner v. State, 93 Miss. 843 , 47 So. 500 (1908); Pulpus

1982This Court condemned outright the giving of any instruction precluding the defendant from asserting the claim of self-defense in the following cases: McMullen v. State, 291 So.2d 537 (Miss. 1974); Patrick v. State, 285 So.2d 165 (Miss. 1973); Craft v. State, 271 So.2d 735 (Miss. 1973); Ellis v. State, 208 So.2d 49 (Miss. 1968); Tate v. State, 192 So.2d 923 (Miss. 1966); Thompson v. State, 190 Miss. 639 , 200 So. 715 (1941); Brown v. State, 186 Miss. 734 , 191 So. 818 (1939); Vance v. State, 182 Miss. 840 , 183 So. 280 (1938); Coleman v. State, 179 Miss. 661 , 176 So. 714 (1937); Lee v. State,

21982–1994
Craft v. State green
miss · 1973
2 sentences

1994See McMullen v. State, 291 So.2d 537 (Miss. 1974); Patrick v. State, 285 So.2d 165 (Miss. 1973); Craft v. State, 271 So.2d 735 (Miss. 1973); Ellis v. State, 208 So.2d 49 (Miss. 1968); Tate v. State, 192 So.2d 923 (Miss. 1966); Thompson v. State, 190 Miss. 639 , 200 So. 715 (1941); Brown v. State, 186 Miss. 734 , 191 So. 818 (1939); Vance v. State, 182 Miss. 840 , 183 So. 280 (1938); Coleman v. State, 179 Miss. 661 , 176 So. 714 (1937); Lee v. State, 138 Miss. 474 , 103 So. 233 (1925); Adams v. State, 136 Miss. 298 , 101 So. 437 (1924); Garner v. State, 93 Miss. 843 , 47 So. 500 (1908); Pulpus

1982This Court condemned outright the giving of any instruction precluding the defendant from asserting the claim of self-defense in the following cases: McMullen v. State, 291 So.2d 537 (Miss. 1974); Patrick v. State, 285 So.2d 165 (Miss. 1973); Craft v. State, 271 So.2d 735 (Miss. 1973); Ellis v. State, 208 So.2d 49 (Miss. 1968); Tate v. State, 192 So.2d 923 (Miss. 1966); Thompson v. State, 190 Miss. 639 , 200 So. 715 (1941); Brown v. State, 186 Miss. 734 , 191 So. 818 (1939); Vance v. State, 182 Miss. 840 , 183 So. 280 (1938); Coleman v. State, 179 Miss. 661 , 176 So. 714 (1937); Lee v. State,

21982–1994
Coleman v. State green
miss · 1937
2 sentences

1982This Court condemned outright the giving of any instruction precluding the defendant from asserting the claim of self-defense in the following cases: McMullen v. State, 291 So.2d 537 (Miss. 1974); Patrick v. State, 285 So.2d 165 (Miss. 1973); Craft v. State, 271 So.2d 735 (Miss. 1973); Ellis v. State, 208 So.2d 49 (Miss. 1968); Tate v. State, 192 So.2d 923 (Miss. 1966); Thompson v. State, 190 Miss. 639 , 200 So. 715 (1941); Brown v. State, 186 Miss. 734 , 191 So. 818 (1939); Vance v. State, 182 Miss. 840 , 183 So. 280 (1938); Coleman v. State, 179 Miss. 661 , 176 So. 714 (1937); Lee v. State,

1982This Court condemned outright the giving of any instruction precluding the defendant from asserting the claim of self-defense in the following cases: McMullen v. State, 291 So.2d 537 (Miss. 1974); Patrick v. State, 285 So.2d 165 (Miss. 1973); Craft v. State, 271 So.2d 735 (Miss. 1973); Ellis v. State, 208 So.2d 49 (Miss. 1968); Tate v. State, 192 So.2d 923 (Miss. 1966); Thompson v. State, 190 Miss. 639 , 200 So. 715 (1941); Brown v. State, 186 Miss. 734 , 191 So. 818 (1939); Vance v. State, 182 Miss. 840 , 183 So. 280 (1938); Coleman v. State, 179 Miss. 661 , 176 So. 714 (1937); Lee v. State,

21982–1994
Thompson v. State green
miss · 1941
2 sentences

1982This Court condemned outright the giving of any instruction precluding the defendant from asserting the claim of self-defense in the following cases: McMullen v. State, 291 So.2d 537 (Miss. 1974); Patrick v. State, 285 So.2d 165 (Miss. 1973); Craft v. State, 271 So.2d 735 (Miss. 1973); Ellis v. State, 208 So.2d 49 (Miss. 1968); Tate v. State, 192 So.2d 923 (Miss. 1966); Thompson v. State, 190 Miss. 639 , 200 So. 715 (1941); Brown v. State, 186 Miss. 734 , 191 So. 818 (1939); Vance v. State, 182 Miss. 840 , 183 So. 280 (1938); Coleman v. State, 179 Miss. 661 , 176 So. 714 (1937); Lee v. State,

1982This Court condemned outright the giving of any instruction precluding the defendant from asserting the claim of self-defense in the following cases: McMullen v. State, 291 So.2d 537 (Miss. 1974); Patrick v. State, 285 So.2d 165 (Miss. 1973); Craft v. State, 271 So.2d 735 (Miss. 1973); Ellis v. State, 208 So.2d 49 (Miss. 1968); Tate v. State, 192 So.2d 923 (Miss. 1966); Thompson v. State, 190 Miss. 639 , 200 So. 715 (1941); Brown v. State, 186 Miss. 734 , 191 So. 818 (1939); Vance v. State, 182 Miss. 840 , 183 So. 280 (1938); Coleman v. State, 179 Miss. 661 , 176 So. 714 (1937); Lee v. State,

21982–1994
Brown v. State green
miss · 1939
2 sentences

1982This Court condemned outright the giving of any instruction precluding the defendant from asserting the claim of self-defense in the following cases: McMullen v. State, 291 So.2d 537 (Miss. 1974); Patrick v. State, 285 So.2d 165 (Miss. 1973); Craft v. State, 271 So.2d 735 (Miss. 1973); Ellis v. State, 208 So.2d 49 (Miss. 1968); Tate v. State, 192 So.2d 923 (Miss. 1966); Thompson v. State, 190 Miss. 639 , 200 So. 715 (1941); Brown v. State, 186 Miss. 734 , 191 So. 818 (1939); Vance v. State, 182 Miss. 840 , 183 So. 280 (1938); Coleman v. State, 179 Miss. 661 , 176 So. 714 (1937); Lee v. State,

1982This Court condemned outright the giving of any instruction precluding the defendant from asserting the claim of self-defense in the following cases: McMullen v. State, 291 So.2d 537 (Miss. 1974); Patrick v. State, 285 So.2d 165 (Miss. 1973); Craft v. State, 271 So.2d 735 (Miss. 1973); Ellis v. State, 208 So.2d 49 (Miss. 1968); Tate v. State, 192 So.2d 923 (Miss. 1966); Thompson v. State, 190 Miss. 639 , 200 So. 715 (1941); Brown v. State, 186 Miss. 734 , 191 So. 818 (1939); Vance v. State, 182 Miss. 840 , 183 So. 280 (1938); Coleman v. State, 179 Miss. 661 , 176 So. 714 (1937); Lee v. State,

21982–1994
Vance v. State neutral
miss · 1938
2 sentences

1982This Court condemned outright the giving of any instruction precluding the defendant from asserting the claim of self-defense in the following cases: McMullen v. State, 291 So.2d 537 (Miss. 1974); Patrick v. State, 285 So.2d 165 (Miss. 1973); Craft v. State, 271 So.2d 735 (Miss. 1973); Ellis v. State, 208 So.2d 49 (Miss. 1968); Tate v. State, 192 So.2d 923 (Miss. 1966); Thompson v. State, 190 Miss. 639 , 200 So. 715 (1941); Brown v. State, 186 Miss. 734 , 191 So. 818 (1939); Vance v. State, 182 Miss. 840 , 183 So. 280 (1938); Coleman v. State, 179 Miss. 661 , 176 So. 714 (1937); Lee v. State,

1982This Court condemned outright the giving of any instruction precluding the defendant from asserting the claim of self-defense in the following cases: McMullen v. State, 291 So.2d 537 (Miss. 1974); Patrick v. State, 285 So.2d 165 (Miss. 1973); Craft v. State, 271 So.2d 735 (Miss. 1973); Ellis v. State, 208 So.2d 49 (Miss. 1968); Tate v. State, 192 So.2d 923 (Miss. 1966); Thompson v. State, 190 Miss. 639 , 200 So. 715 (1941); Brown v. State, 186 Miss. 734 , 191 So. 818 (1939); Vance v. State, 182 Miss. 840 , 183 So. 280 (1938); Coleman v. State, 179 Miss. 661 , 176 So. 714 (1937); Lee v. State,

21982–1994
Lee v. State neutral
miss · 1925
2 sentences

1982This Court condemned outright the giving of any instruction precluding the defendant from asserting the claim of self-defense in the following cases: McMullen v. State, 291 So.2d 537 (Miss. 1974); Patrick v. State, 285 So.2d 165 (Miss. 1973); Craft v. State, 271 So.2d 735 (Miss. 1973); Ellis v. State, 208 So.2d 49 (Miss. 1968); Tate v. State, 192 So.2d 923 (Miss. 1966); Thompson v. State, 190 Miss. 639 , 200 So. 715 (1941); Brown v. State, 186 Miss. 734 , 191 So. 818 (1939); Vance v. State, 182 Miss. 840 , 183 So. 280 (1938); Coleman v. State, 179 Miss. 661 , 176 So. 714 (1937); Lee v. State,

1982This Court condemned outright the giving of any instruction precluding the defendant from asserting the claim of self-defense in the following cases: McMullen v. State, 291 So.2d 537 (Miss. 1974); Patrick v. State, 285 So.2d 165 (Miss. 1973); Craft v. State, 271 So.2d 735 (Miss. 1973); Ellis v. State, 208 So.2d 49 (Miss. 1968); Tate v. State, 192 So.2d 923 (Miss. 1966); Thompson v. State, 190 Miss. 639 , 200 So. 715 (1941); Brown v. State, 186 Miss. 734 , 191 So. 818 (1939); Vance v. State, 182 Miss. 840 , 183 So. 280 (1938); Coleman v. State, 179 Miss. 661 , 176 So. 714 (1937); Lee v. State,

21982–1994
Gwin v. Fountain green
miss · 1930
2 sentences

1989Gwin v. Fountain, 159 Miss. 619 , 126 So. 18 (1930). [3] In Stockstill v. Gerson, 35 So.2d 60 (Miss. 1948), there was a dispute as to whether the appellant ordered, purchased or received the goods sued on.

1989Gwin v. Fountain, 159 Miss. 619 , 126 So. 18 (1930). [3] In Stockstill v. Gerson, 35 So.2d 60 (Miss. 1948), there was a dispute as to whether the appellant ordered, purchased or received the goods sued on.

11989–1989

Where else courts name it

MS 8 (1982–2021) NY 7 (1928–2015) OH 7 (1999–2014) NJ 6 (1908–2024) WA 5 (1980–2013) CA 4 (1963–2014) AL 3 (1912–2006) GA 3 (2006–2019) IL 2 (1981–1993) ID 2 (2019–2024) UT 2 (1950–1995) CT 2 (1967–1987) VA 2 (1992–2024) IN 2 (1921–1992) WV 2 (2013–2013)

Opinions by the citing court's state. A doctrine retained in one state and abandoned in another shows up here as a year span that stalls.

← Caselaw search · G Cite Topics · Brief Check