reversal error in Montana

7 Montana opinions name it 1 courts 1926–2010 0 in the last five years

The cases below were cited by Montana courts in a sentence that names this issue. Sides come from how each citing opinion treated the case (Syfertize flag on that citation), so a case can appear on both: that is where the law is contested. A red or yellow chip is the case's own overall treatment.

Followed or applied (3)

Case	Followed	Cited
Moran v. Shotgun Willies, Inc.green mont · 1995 · cited in 2 Montana opinions naming this issue, 2005–2005 2 sentences 2005See Moran, 270 Mont. at 51 , 889 P.2d at 1187 (an agency’s reversal of a hearing examiner’s findings cannot survive judicial review unless the court determines as a matter of law that the hearing examiner’s findings are not supported by substantial evidence). 2005See Moran, 270 Mont. at 51 , 889 P.2d at 1187 (an agency’s reversal of a hearing examiner’s findings cannot survive judicial review unless the court determines as a matter of law that the hearing examiner’s findings are not supported by substantial evidence).	1	2
Silva v. City of Columbia Fallsgreen mont · 1993 · cited in 1 Montana opinions naming this issue, 2010–2010 2 sentences 2010Rather, the decision being challenged must appear to be random, unreasonable, or seemingly unmotivated, based on the existing record.’ ” Kiely Const., ¶ 69 (quoting Silva v. City of Columbia Falls, 258 Mont. 329, 335 , 852 P.2d 671, 675 (1993)). 2010Rather, the decision being challenged must appear to be random, unreasonable, or seemingly unmotivated, based on the existing record.’ ” Kiely Const., ¶ 69 (quoting Silva v. City of Columbia Falls, 258 Mont. 329, 335 , 852 P.2d 671, 675 (1993)).	1	1
State v. Harrisongreen · 1892 · cited in 1 Montana opinions naming this issue, 1955–1955 1 sentence 1955Fralick v. State, supra; Wilhite v. State, 158 Ark. 290, 294 , 250 S.W. 31 ; People v. Barnett, 27 Cal. (2d) 649, 657, 166 Pac. (2d) 4 ; People v. Vester, supra; People v. Maynard, 347 Ill. 422 , 179 N.E. 833 ; People v. West, 25 Cal. App. 369, 372 , 143 Pac. 793 ; People v. *1084 Jackson, 105 Cal. App. (2d) 811, 815, 234 Pac. (2d) 261 ; People v. Perry, 14 Cal. (2d) 387, 399, 94 Pac. (2d) 559 , 124 A.L.R. 1123 ; Deeb v. State, 118 Fla. 88 , 158 So. 880 ; State v. Detar, supra; State v. Gunter, supra, 208 La. at page 710 , 23 So. (2d) at pages 309, 310; Shipp v. State, 215 Miss. 541 , 61 So. (	1	1

Distinguished, questioned or overruled (0)

Case	Negative	Cited
No negative-treatment citations attached to this issue in Montana. Read the followed side critically anyway.

Also cited on this issue (18)

Case	Cited	Years
Wilhite v. State neutral ark · 1923 2 sentences 1955Fralick v. State, supra; Wilhite v. State, 158 Ark. 290, 294 , 250 S.W. 31 ; People v. Barnett, 27 Cal. (2d) 649, 657, 166 Pac. (2d) 4 ; People v. Vester, supra; People v. Maynard, 347 Ill. 422 , 179 N.E. 833 ; People v. West, 25 Cal. App. 369, 372 , 143 Pac. 793 ; People v. 1084 Jackson, 105 Cal. App. (2d) 811, 815, 234 Pac. (2d) 261 ; People v. Perry, 14 Cal. (2d) 387, 399, 94 Pac. (2d) 559 , 124 A.L.R. 1123 ; Deeb v. State, 118 Fla. 88 , 158 So. 880 ; State v. Detar, supra; State v. Gunter, supra, 208 La. at page 710 , 23 So. (2d) at pages 309, 310; Shipp v. State, 215 Miss. 541 , 61 So. ( 1955Fralick v. State, supra; Wilhite v. State, 158 Ark. 290, 294 , 250 S.W. 31 ; People v. Barnett, 27 Cal. (2d) 649, 657, 166 Pac. (2d) 4 ; People v. Vester, supra; People v. Maynard, 347 Ill. 422 , 179 N.E. 833 ; People v. West, 25 Cal. App. 369, 372 , 143 Pac. 793 ; People v. 1084 Jackson, 105 Cal. App. (2d) 811, 815, 234 Pac. (2d) 261 ; People v. Perry, 14 Cal. (2d) 387, 399, 94 Pac. (2d) 559 , 124 A.L.R. 1123 ; Deeb v. State, 118 Fla. 88 , 158 So. 880 ; State v. Detar, supra; State v. Gunter, supra, 208 La. at page 710 , 23 So. (2d) at pages 309, 310; Shipp v. State, 215 Miss. 541 , 61 So. (	1	1955–1955
Deeb v. State green fla · 1935 2 sentences 1955Fralick v. State, supra; Wilhite v. State, 158 Ark. 290, 294 , 250 S.W. 31 ; People v. Barnett, 27 Cal. (2d) 649, 657, 166 Pac. (2d) 4 ; People v. Vester, supra; People v. Maynard, 347 Ill. 422 , 179 N.E. 833 ; People v. West, 25 Cal. App. 369, 372 , 143 Pac. 793 ; People v. 1084 Jackson, 105 Cal. App. (2d) 811, 815, 234 Pac. (2d) 261 ; People v. Perry, 14 Cal. (2d) 387, 399, 94 Pac. (2d) 559 , 124 A.L.R. 1123 ; Deeb v. State, 118 Fla. 88 , 158 So. 880 ; State v. Detar, supra; State v. Gunter, supra, 208 La. at page 710 , 23 So. (2d) at pages 309, 310; Shipp v. State, 215 Miss. 541 , 61 So. ( 1955Fralick v. State, supra; Wilhite v. State, 158 Ark. 290, 294 , 250 S.W. 31 ; People v. Barnett, 27 Cal. (2d) 649, 657, 166 Pac. (2d) 4 ; People v. Vester, supra; People v. Maynard, 347 Ill. 422 , 179 N.E. 833 ; People v. West, 25 Cal. App. 369, 372 , 143 Pac. 793 ; People v. 1084 Jackson, 105 Cal. App. (2d) 811, 815, 234 Pac. (2d) 261 ; People v. Perry, 14 Cal. (2d) 387, 399, 94 Pac. (2d) 559 , 124 A.L.R. 1123 ; Deeb v. State, 118 Fla. 88 , 158 So. 880 ; State v. Detar, supra; State v. Gunter, supra, 208 La. at page 710 , 23 So. (2d) at pages 309, 310; Shipp v. State, 215 Miss. 541 , 61 So. (	1	1955–1955
State v. Gunter green la · 1945 1 sentence 1955Fralick v. State, supra; Wilhite v. State, 158 Ark. 290, 294 , 250 S.W. 31 ; People v. Barnett, 27 Cal. (2d) 649, 657, 166 Pac. (2d) 4 ; People v. Vester, supra; People v. Maynard, 347 Ill. 422 , 179 N.E. 833 ; People v. West, 25 Cal. App. 369, 372 , 143 Pac. 793 ; People v. *1084 Jackson, 105 Cal. App. (2d) 811, 815, 234 Pac. (2d) 261 ; People v. Perry, 14 Cal. (2d) 387, 399, 94 Pac. (2d) 559 , 124 A.L.R. 1123 ; Deeb v. State, 118 Fla. 88 , 158 So. 880 ; State v. Detar, supra; State v. Gunter, supra, 208 La. at page 710 , 23 So. (2d) at pages 309, 310; Shipp v. State, 215 Miss. 541 , 61 So. (	1	1955–1955
The People v. Maynard green ill · 1932 2 sentences 1955Fralick v. State, supra; Wilhite v. State, 158 Ark. 290, 294 , 250 S.W. 31 ; People v. Barnett, 27 Cal. (2d) 649, 657, 166 Pac. (2d) 4 ; People v. Vester, supra; People v. Maynard, 347 Ill. 422 , 179 N.E. 833 ; People v. West, 25 Cal. App. 369, 372 , 143 Pac. 793 ; People v. 1084 Jackson, 105 Cal. App. (2d) 811, 815, 234 Pac. (2d) 261 ; People v. Perry, 14 Cal. (2d) 387, 399, 94 Pac. (2d) 559 , 124 A.L.R. 1123 ; Deeb v. State, 118 Fla. 88 , 158 So. 880 ; State v. Detar, supra; State v. Gunter, supra, 208 La. at page 710 , 23 So. (2d) at pages 309, 310; Shipp v. State, 215 Miss. 541 , 61 So. ( 1955Fralick v. State, supra; Wilhite v. State, 158 Ark. 290, 294 , 250 S.W. 31 ; People v. Barnett, 27 Cal. (2d) 649, 657, 166 Pac. (2d) 4 ; People v. Vester, supra; People v. Maynard, 347 Ill. 422 , 179 N.E. 833 ; People v. West, 25 Cal. App. 369, 372 , 143 Pac. 793 ; People v. 1084 Jackson, 105 Cal. App. (2d) 811, 815, 234 Pac. (2d) 261 ; People v. Perry, 14 Cal. (2d) 387, 399, 94 Pac. (2d) 559 , 124 A.L.R. 1123 ; Deeb v. State, 118 Fla. 88 , 158 So. 880 ; State v. Detar, supra; State v. Gunter, supra, 208 La. at page 710 , 23 So. (2d) at pages 309, 310; Shipp v. State, 215 Miss. 541 , 61 So. (	1	1955–1955
People v. Jackson green calctapp · 1951 2 sentences 1955Fralick v. State, supra; Wilhite v. State, 158 Ark. 290, 294 , 250 S. W. 31 ; People v. Barnett, 27 Cal. (2d) 649, 657, 166 Pac. (2d) 4 ; People v. Vester, supra; People v. Maynard, 347 Ill. 422 , 179 N. E. 833 ; People v. West, 25 Cal. App. 369, 372 , 143 Pac. 793 ; People v. Jackson, 105 Cal. App. (2d) 811, 815, 234 Pac. (2d) 261 ; People v. Perry, 14 Cal. (2d) 387, 399, 94 Pac. (2d) 559 , 124 A. L. 1955Fralick v. State, supra; Wilhite v. State, 158 Ark. 290, 294 , 250 S.W. 31 ; People v. Barnett, 27 Cal. (2d) 649, 657, 166 Pac. (2d) 4 ; People v. Vester, supra; People v. Maynard, 347 Ill. 422 , 179 N.E. 833 ; People v. West, 25 Cal. App. 369, 372 , 143 Pac. 793 ; People v. *1084 Jackson, 105 Cal. App. (2d) 811, 815, 234 Pac. (2d) 261 ; People v. Perry, 14 Cal. (2d) 387, 399, 94 Pac. (2d) 559 , 124 A.L.R. 1123 ; Deeb v. State, 118 Fla. 88 , 158 So. 880 ; State v. Detar, supra; State v. Gunter, supra, 208 La. at page 710 , 23 So. (2d) at pages 309, 310; Shipp v. State, 215 Miss. 541 , 61 So. (	1	1955–1955
People v. Perry green cal · 1939 2 sentences 1955Fralick v. State, supra; Wilhite v. State, 158 Ark. 290, 294 , 250 S.W. 31 ; People v. Barnett, 27 Cal. (2d) 649, 657, 166 Pac. (2d) 4 ; People v. Vester, supra; People v. Maynard, 347 Ill. 422 , 179 N.E. 833 ; People v. West, 25 Cal. App. 369, 372 , 143 Pac. 793 ; People v. 1084 Jackson, 105 Cal. App. (2d) 811, 815, 234 Pac. (2d) 261 ; People v. Perry, 14 Cal. (2d) 387, 399, 94 Pac. (2d) 559 , 124 A.L.R. 1123 ; Deeb v. State, 118 Fla. 88 , 158 So. 880 ; State v. Detar, supra; State v. Gunter, supra, 208 La. at page 710 , 23 So. (2d) at pages 309, 310; Shipp v. State, 215 Miss. 541 , 61 So. ( 1955Fralick v. State, supra; Wilhite v. State, 158 Ark. 290, 294 , 250 S.W. 31 ; People v. Barnett, 27 Cal. (2d) 649, 657, 166 Pac. (2d) 4 ; People v. Vester, supra; People v. Maynard, 347 Ill. 422 , 179 N.E. 833 ; People v. West, 25 Cal. App. 369, 372 , 143 Pac. 793 ; People v. 1084 Jackson, 105 Cal. App. (2d) 811, 815, 234 Pac. (2d) 261 ; People v. Perry, 14 Cal. (2d) 387, 399, 94 Pac. (2d) 559 , 124 A.L.R. 1123 ; Deeb v. State, 118 Fla. 88 , 158 So. 880 ; State v. Detar, supra; State v. Gunter, supra, 208 La. at page 710 , 23 So. (2d) at pages 309, 310; Shipp v. State, 215 Miss. 541 , 61 So. (	1	1955–1955
People v. Barnett green cal · 1946 2 sentences 1955Fralick v. State, supra; Wilhite v. State, 158 Ark. 290, 294 , 250 S. W. 31 ; People v. Barnett, 27 Cal. (2d) 649, 657, 166 Pac. (2d) 4 ; People v. Vester, supra; People v. Maynard, 347 Ill. 422 , 179 N. E. 833 ; People v. West, 25 Cal. App. 369, 372 , 143 Pac. 793 ; People v. Jackson, 105 Cal. App. (2d) 811, 815, 234 Pac. (2d) 261 ; People v. Perry, 14 Cal. (2d) 387, 399, 94 Pac. (2d) 559 , 124 A. L. 1955Fralick v. State, supra; Wilhite v. State, 158 Ark. 290, 294 , 250 S.W. 31 ; People v. Barnett, 27 Cal. (2d) 649, 657, 166 Pac. (2d) 4 ; People v. Vester, supra; People v. Maynard, 347 Ill. 422 , 179 N.E. 833 ; People v. West, 25 Cal. App. 369, 372 , 143 Pac. 793 ; People v. *1084 Jackson, 105 Cal. App. (2d) 811, 815, 234 Pac. (2d) 261 ; People v. Perry, 14 Cal. (2d) 387, 399, 94 Pac. (2d) 559 , 124 A.L.R. 1123 ; Deeb v. State, 118 Fla. 88 , 158 So. 880 ; State v. Detar, supra; State v. Gunter, supra, 208 La. at page 710 , 23 So. (2d) at pages 309, 310; Shipp v. State, 215 Miss. 541 , 61 So. (	1	1955–1955
Evans v. State green · 1930 2 sentences 1955Fralick v. State, supra; Wilhite v. State, 158 Ark. 290, 294 , 250 S.W. 31 ; People v. Barnett, 27 Cal. (2d) 649, 657, 166 Pac. (2d) 4 ; People v. Vester, supra; People v. Maynard, 347 Ill. 422 , 179 N.E. 833 ; People v. West, 25 Cal. App. 369, 372 , 143 Pac. 793 ; People v. 1084 Jackson, 105 Cal. App. (2d) 811, 815, 234 Pac. (2d) 261 ; People v. Perry, 14 Cal. (2d) 387, 399, 94 Pac. (2d) 559 , 124 A.L.R. 1123 ; Deeb v. State, 118 Fla. 88 , 158 So. 880 ; State v. Detar, supra; State v. Gunter, supra, 208 La. at page 710 , 23 So. (2d) at pages 309, 310; Shipp v. State, 215 Miss. 541 , 61 So. ( 1955Fralick v. State, supra; Wilhite v. State, 158 Ark. 290, 294 , 250 S.W. 31 ; People v. Barnett, 27 Cal. (2d) 649, 657, 166 Pac. (2d) 4 ; People v. Vester, supra; People v. Maynard, 347 Ill. 422 , 179 N.E. 833 ; People v. West, 25 Cal. App. 369, 372 , 143 Pac. 793 ; People v. 1084 Jackson, 105 Cal. App. (2d) 811, 815, 234 Pac. (2d) 261 ; People v. Perry, 14 Cal. (2d) 387, 399, 94 Pac. (2d) 559 , 124 A.L.R. 1123 ; Deeb v. State, 118 Fla. 88 , 158 So. 880 ; State v. Detar, supra; State v. Gunter, supra, 208 La. at page 710 , 23 So. (2d) at pages 309, 310; Shipp v. State, 215 Miss. 541 , 61 So. (	1	1955–1955
Shipp v. State green · 1952 2 sentences 1955Fralick v. State, supra; Wilhite v. State, 158 Ark. 290, 294 , 250 S.W. 31 ; People v. Barnett, 27 Cal. (2d) 649, 657, 166 Pac. (2d) 4 ; People v. Vester, supra; People v. Maynard, 347 Ill. 422 , 179 N.E. 833 ; People v. West, 25 Cal. App. 369, 372 , 143 Pac. 793 ; People v. 1084 Jackson, 105 Cal. App. (2d) 811, 815, 234 Pac. (2d) 261 ; People v. Perry, 14 Cal. (2d) 387, 399, 94 Pac. (2d) 559 , 124 A.L.R. 1123 ; Deeb v. State, 118 Fla. 88 , 158 So. 880 ; State v. Detar, supra; State v. Gunter, supra, 208 La. at page 710 , 23 So. (2d) at pages 309, 310; Shipp v. State, 215 Miss. 541 , 61 So. ( 1955Fralick v. State, supra; Wilhite v. State, 158 Ark. 290, 294 , 250 S.W. 31 ; People v. Barnett, 27 Cal. (2d) 649, 657, 166 Pac. (2d) 4 ; People v. Vester, supra; People v. Maynard, 347 Ill. 422 , 179 N.E. 833 ; People v. West, 25 Cal. App. 369, 372 , 143 Pac. 793 ; People v. 1084 Jackson, 105 Cal. App. (2d) 811, 815, 234 Pac. (2d) 261 ; People v. Perry, 14 Cal. (2d) 387, 399, 94 Pac. (2d) 559 , 124 A.L.R. 1123 ; Deeb v. State, 118 Fla. 88 , 158 So. 880 ; State v. Detar, supra; State v. Gunter, supra, 208 La. at page 710 , 23 So. (2d) at pages 309, 310; Shipp v. State, 215 Miss. 541 , 61 So. (	1	1955–1955
People v. West green calctapp · 1914 2 sentences 1955Fralick v. State, supra; Wilhite v. State, 158 Ark. 290, 294 , 250 S.W. 31 ; People v. Barnett, 27 Cal. (2d) 649, 657, 166 Pac. (2d) 4 ; People v. Vester, supra; People v. Maynard, 347 Ill. 422 , 179 N.E. 833 ; People v. West, 25 Cal. App. 369, 372 , 143 Pac. 793 ; People v. 1084 Jackson, 105 Cal. App. (2d) 811, 815, 234 Pac. (2d) 261 ; People v. Perry, 14 Cal. (2d) 387, 399, 94 Pac. (2d) 559 , 124 A.L.R. 1123 ; Deeb v. State, 118 Fla. 88 , 158 So. 880 ; State v. Detar, supra; State v. Gunter, supra, 208 La. at page 710 , 23 So. (2d) at pages 309, 310; Shipp v. State, 215 Miss. 541 , 61 So. ( 1955Fralick v. State, supra; Wilhite v. State, 158 Ark. 290, 294 , 250 S.W. 31 ; People v. Barnett, 27 Cal. (2d) 649, 657, 166 Pac. (2d) 4 ; People v. Vester, supra; People v. Maynard, 347 Ill. 422 , 179 N.E. 833 ; People v. West, 25 Cal. App. 369, 372 , 143 Pac. 793 ; People v. 1084 Jackson, 105 Cal. App. (2d) 811, 815, 234 Pac. (2d) 261 ; People v. Perry, 14 Cal. (2d) 387, 399, 94 Pac. (2d) 559 , 124 A.L.R. 1123 ; Deeb v. State, 118 Fla. 88 , 158 So. 880 ; State v. Detar, supra; State v. Gunter, supra, 208 La. at page 710 , 23 So. (2d) at pages 309, 310; Shipp v. State, 215 Miss. 541 , 61 So. (	1	1955–1955
Finlen v. Heinze green · 1905 2 sentences 1935(Backer v. Parker-Morelli-Barclay Motor Co., supra; Finlen v. Heinze, 32 Mont. 354 , 80 Pac. 918 ; Downs v. Cassidy, 47 Mont. 471 , 133 Pac. 106 , Ann. 1935(Backer v. Parker-Morelli-Barclay Motor Co., supra; Finlen v. Heinze, 32 Mont. 354 , 80 Pac. 918 ; Downs v. Cassidy, 47 Mont. 471 , 133 Pac. 106 , Ann.	1	1935–1935
Downs v. Cassidy neutral mont · 1913 2 sentences 1935(Backer v. Parker-Morelli-Barclay Motor Co., supra; Finlen v. Heinze, 32 Mont. 354 , 80 Pac. 918 ; Downs v. Cassidy, 47 Mont. 471 , 133 Pac. 106 , Ann. 1935(Backer v. Parker-Morelli-Barclay Motor Co., supra; Finlen v. Heinze, 32 Mont. 354 , 80 Pac. 918 ; Downs v. Cassidy, 47 Mont. 471 , 133 Pac. 106 , Ann.	1	1935–1935
O'Donnell v. City of Butte neutral mont · 1922 1 sentence 1926R. 1284, 211 Pac. 190 , which reads, “Primarily, of course, it is the duty of every municipality to exercise active vigilance to keep all of its streets in a safe condition suitable for the public use, buf it can be held only to a reasonable performance of this duty,” and assert that this “language is stronger than the instruction complained of.” It may be that the quoted expression was inept, but it is not susceptible to a construction which would amount to a reversal of the rule theretofore declared in the decisions of this court above cited and the announcement of a new one making cities of	1	1926–1926
Beatty Oil & Gas Co. v. Blanton neutral kyed · 1917 1 sentence 1926C.), 245 Fed. 979 ; Munsey v. Marnet Oil & Gas Co. (Tex. Civ.	1	1926–1926
Culbertson v. Iola Portland Cement Co. neutral kan · 1912 2 sentences 1926This reversal of the rule to meet the new conditions arising in this state is supported by the weight of authority and is based upon reason and justice. (1 Thornton on Oil & Gas, p. 512; Brown v. Vandergrift, 80 Pa. 142 ; Dinsmoor v. Combs, 177 Ky. 740 , 198 S. W. 58 ; Soaper v. King, 167 Ky. 121 , 180 S. W. 46 ; Culbertson v. Iola Portland Cement Co., 87 Kan. 529 , 125 Pac. 81 ; Beatty Oil Co. v. Blandon (D. 1926This reversal of the rule to meet the new conditions arising in this state is supported by the weight of authority and is based upon reason and justice. (1 Thornton on Oil & Gas, p. 512; Brown v. Vandergrift, 80 Pa. 142 ; Dinsmoor v. Combs, 177 Ky. 740 , 198 S. W. 58 ; Soaper v. King, 167 Ky. 121 , 180 S. W. 46 ; Culbertson v. Iola Portland Cement Co., 87 Kan. 529 , 125 Pac. 81 ; Beatty Oil Co. v. Blandon (D.	1	1926–1926
Brown v. Vandergrift green pa · 1875 1 sentence 1926This reversal of the rule to meet the new conditions arising in this state is supported by the weight of authority and is based upon reason and justice. (1 Thornton on Oil & Gas, p. 512; Brown v. Vandergrift, 80 Pa. 142 ; Dinsmoor v. Combs, 177 Ky. 740 , 198 S. W. 58 ; Soaper v. King, 167 Ky. 121 , 180 S. W. 46 ; Culbertson v. Iola Portland Cement Co., 87 Kan. 529 , 125 Pac. 81 ; Beatty Oil Co. v. Blandon (D.	1	1926–1926
Soaper v. King green kyctapp · 1915 2 sentences 1926This reversal of the rule to meet the new conditions arising in this state is supported by the weight of authority and is based upon reason and justice. (1 Thornton on Oil & Gas, p. 512; Brown v. Vandergrift, 80 Pa. 142 ; Dinsmoor v. Combs, 177 Ky. 740 , 198 S. W. 58 ; Soaper v. King, 167 Ky. 121 , 180 S. W. 46 ; Culbertson v. Iola Portland Cement Co., 87 Kan. 529 , 125 Pac. 81 ; Beatty Oil Co. v. Blandon (D. 1926This reversal of the rule to meet the new conditions arising in this state is supported by the weight of authority and is based upon reason and justice. (1 Thornton on Oil & Gas, p. 512; Brown v. Vandergrift, 80 Pa. 142 ; Dinsmoor v. Combs, 177 Ky. 740 , 198 S. W. 58 ; Soaper v. King, 167 Ky. 121 , 180 S. W. 46 ; Culbertson v. Iola Portland Cement Co., 87 Kan. 529 , 125 Pac. 81 ; Beatty Oil Co. v. Blandon (D.	1	1926–1926
Dinsmoor v. Combs neutral kyctapp · 1917 2 sentences 1926This reversal of the rule to meet the new conditions arising in this state is supported by the weight of authority and is based upon reason and justice. (1 Thornton on Oil & Gas, p. 512; Brown v. Vandergrift, 80 Pa. 142 ; Dinsmoor v. Combs, 177 Ky. 740 , 198 S. W. 58 ; Soaper v. King, 167 Ky. 121 , 180 S. W. 46 ; Culbertson v. Iola Portland Cement Co., 87 Kan. 529 , 125 Pac. 81 ; Beatty Oil Co. v. Blandon (D. 1926This reversal of the rule to meet the new conditions arising in this state is supported by the weight of authority and is based upon reason and justice. (1 Thornton on Oil & Gas, p. 512; Brown v. Vandergrift, 80 Pa. 142 ; Dinsmoor v. Combs, 177 Ky. 740 , 198 S. W. 58 ; Soaper v. King, 167 Ky. 121 , 180 S. W. 46 ; Culbertson v. Iola Portland Cement Co., 87 Kan. 529 , 125 Pac. 81 ; Beatty Oil Co. v. Blandon (D.	1	1926–1926

Statutes the citing opinions construe

MT § Mont. Code Ann. § 2-4-704 (3)

Counted by distinct opinions that both name this issue and are annotated to the section; sections every opinion cites regardless of issue are not filtered here, so read the counts against the total above.

Where else courts name it

TX 224 (1911–2024) AL 36 (1845–2026) CA 20 (1903–2025) IL 20 (1884–2023) GA 15 (1904–2025) NY 15 (1877–2025) FL 11 (1977–2006) OH 10 (1926–2023) IN 10 (1887–2017) KY 9 (1902–2016) MO 8 (1884–2009) NJ 7 (1984–2024) ID 7 (1923–2021) MT 7 (1926–2010) AZ 7 (1949–2020) AR 6 (1985–2018) WA 6 (1926–2016) TN 6 (1926–2014) WI 5 (1877–2025) OK 5 (1913–1977) LA 4 (1996–2008) CT 4 (1958–2016) NC 3 (1967–2019) WY 3 (1906–2009) CO 3 (1952–2020) NM 3 (1928–2010) MN 3 (1916–1953) MS 3 (1990–1997) IA 3 (1946–1970) MA 3 (1981–2008) MI 2 (1904–1990) DC 2 (1990–1997)

Opinions by the citing court's state. A doctrine retained in one state and abandoned in another shows up here as a year span that stalls.

← Caselaw search · G Cite Topics · Brief Check