Already have an account? Sign in instead.
You stay signed in for 30 days on this browser.
Continue with Google Continue with MicrosoftNo account yet? Create a free one.
We sent a six-digit code.
It expires in ten minutes, works once, and only in this browser. Five wrong tries void it. Send another code.
Your account is live and the Cloudflare checks are off for this browser.
7 Oklahoma opinions name it 1 courts 1915–1967 0 in the last five years
The cases below were cited by Oklahoma courts in a sentence that names this issue. Sides come from how each citing opinion treated the case (Syfertize flag on that citation), so a case can appear on both: that is where the law is contested. A red or yellow chip is the case's own overall treatment.
| Case | Followed | Cited |
|---|---|---|
Barbe v. Barbegreen1 sentence1967See also Barbe v. Barbe, Okl., 378 P.2d 314 . *753 It necessarily follows that defendant’s negligence is immaterial in resolving the issue presented for the reason plaintiff could not recover if he were guilty of contributory negligence. | 1 | 1 |
Mount v. Nicholsgreen2 sentences1961See Mount v. Nichols et al., 198 Okl. 282 , 177 P.2d 1013 and cited cases. *93 It is settled law in this jurisdiction that the concurring negligence of plaintiff and defendant will not be weighed or apportioned; that there can be no recovery by a plaintiff who has been found guilty of contributory negligence. 1961See Mount v. Nichols et al., 198 Okl. 282 , 177 P.2d 1013 and cited cases. *93 It is settled law in this jurisdiction that the concurring negligence of plaintiff and defendant will not be weighed or apportioned; that there can be no recovery by a plaintiff who has been found guilty of contributory negligence. | 1 | 1 |
| Case | Negative | Cited |
|---|---|---|
| No negative-treatment citations attached to this issue in Oklahoma. Read the followed side critically anyway. | ||
| Case | Cited | Years |
|---|---|---|
Hailey-Ola Coal Co. v. Morgan
neutral
2 sentences1947That is, you will find the amount of damages sustained by thq plaintiff, and then take therefrom a sum equal to the proportion which the negligence of the plaintiff bears to the negligence of the plaintiff and defendant.” In Gourley v. City of Oklahoma City, 104 Okla. 210 , 230 P. 923 , it is held: “The doctrine of comparative negligence does not obtain in this state.” Von Keller v. Ream, 93 Okla. 179 , 220 P. 330 ; Hailey-Ola Coal Co. v. Morgan, 39 Okla. 71 , 134 P. 29 . 1947That is, you will find the amount of damages sustained by thq plaintiff, and then take therefrom a sum equal to the proportion which the negligence of the plaintiff bears to the negligence of the plaintiff and defendant.” In Gourley v. City of Oklahoma City, 104 Okla. 210 , 230 P. 923 , it is held: “The doctrine of comparative negligence does not obtain in this state.” Von Keller v. Ream, 93 Okla. 179 , 220 P. 330 ; Hailey-Ola Coal Co. v. Morgan, 39 Okla. 71 , 134 P. 29 . | 2 | 1915–1947 |
Gourley v. City of Oklahoma City
neutral
2 sentences1947That is, you will find the amount of damages sustained by thq plaintiff, and then take therefrom a sum equal to the proportion which the negligence of the plaintiff bears to the negligence of the plaintiff and defendant.” In Gourley v. City of Oklahoma City, 104 Okla. 210 , 230 P. 923 , it is held: “The doctrine of comparative negligence does not obtain in this state.” Von Keller v. Ream, 93 Okla. 179 , 220 P. 330 ; Hailey-Ola Coal Co. v. Morgan, 39 Okla. 71 , 134 P. 29 . 1947That is, you will find the amount of damages sustained by thq plaintiff, and then take therefrom a sum equal to the proportion which the negligence of the plaintiff bears to the negligence of the plaintiff and defendant.” In Gourley v. City of Oklahoma City, 104 Okla. 210 , 230 P. 923 , it is held: “The doctrine of comparative negligence does not obtain in this state.” Von Keller v. Ream, 93 Okla. 179 , 220 P. 330 ; Hailey-Ola Coal Co. v. Morgan, 39 Okla. 71 , 134 P. 29 . | 2 | 1935–1947 |
Public Service Company of Oklahoma v. Sanders
neutral
1 sentence1967In Public Service Company of Oklahoma v. Sanders, Okl., 362 P.2d 90 , we held that the doctrine of comparative negligence does not obtain in Oklahoma; the law will not weigh or apportion the concurring negligence of plaintiff and defendant; and there can be no recovery by the plaintiff who has been found guilty of contributory negligence. | 1 | 1967–1967 |
Von Keller v. Ream
neutral
2 sentences1947That is, you will find the amount of damages sustained by thq plaintiff, and then take therefrom a sum equal to the proportion which the negligence of the plaintiff bears to the negligence of the plaintiff and defendant.” In Gourley v. City of Oklahoma City, 104 Okla. 210 , 230 P. 923 , it is held: “The doctrine of comparative negligence does not obtain in this state.” Von Keller v. Ream, 93 Okla. 179 , 220 P. 330 ; Hailey-Ola Coal Co. v. Morgan, 39 Okla. 71 , 134 P. 29 . 1947That is, you will find the amount of damages sustained by thq plaintiff, and then take therefrom a sum equal to the proportion which the negligence of the plaintiff bears to the negligence of the plaintiff and defendant.” In Gourley v. City of Oklahoma City, 104 Okla. 210 , 230 P. 923 , it is held: “The doctrine of comparative negligence does not obtain in this state.” Von Keller v. Ream, 93 Okla. 179 , 220 P. 330 ; Hailey-Ola Coal Co. v. Morgan, 39 Okla. 71 , 134 P. 29 . | 1 | 1947–1947 |
Rose v. Cochran
neutral
2 sentences1924This is the rule adopted by this court ini the case of Rose v. Cochran, 84 Okla. 148 , 202 Pac. 1003 , and the more recent case of Central Petroleum Company v. A. E. 1924This is the rule adopted by this court ini the case of Rose v. Cochran, 84 Okla. 148 , 202 Pac. 1003 , and the more recent case of Central Petroleum Company v. A. E. | 1 | 1924–1924 |
Nottingham v. Ackiss
neutral
1 sentence1923Co., 110 Va. 853 , 67 S. E. 351 , wherein it was said : "The law will not weigh or apportion the concurring negligence of a plaintiff and defendant. | 1 | 1923–1923 |
Templeton's Administrator v. Lynchburg Traction & Light Co.
neutral
1 sentence1923Co., 110 Va. 853 , 67 S. E. 351 , wherein it was said : "The law will not weigh or apportion the concurring negligence of a plaintiff and defendant. | 1 | 1923–1923 |
Opinions by the citing court's state. A doctrine retained in one state and abandoned in another shows up here as a year span that stalls.