Already have an account? Sign in instead.
You stay signed in for 30 days on this browser.
Continue with Google Continue with MicrosoftNo account yet? Create a free one.
We sent a six-digit code.
It expires in ten minutes, works once, and only in this browser. Five wrong tries void it. Send another code.
Your account is live and the Cloudflare checks are off for this browser.
5 California opinions name it 2 courts 1898–1944 0 in the last five years
The cases below were cited by California courts in a sentence that names this issue. Sides come from how each citing opinion treated the case (Syfertize flag on that citation), so a case can appear on both: that is where the law is contested. A red or yellow chip is the case's own overall treatment.
| Case | Followed | Cited |
|---|---|---|
Matter of Application of Throopgreen2 sentences1944(Dobbins v. Los Angeles, 195 U.S. 223 [ 49 L.Ed. 169 , 25 S.Ct. 18 ]; In re Application of Throop, 169 Cal. 93, 99 [ 145 P. 1029 ]; Curtis v. City of Los Angeles, 172 Cal. 230, 234 [ 156 P. 462 '].)’ ” Bearing said rules in mind in that ease the trial court heard a large amount of evidence and made findings among others including the following. 1944(Dobbins v. Los Angeles, 195 U.S. 223 [ 49 L.Ed. 169 , 25 S.Ct. 18 ]; In re Application of Throop, 169 Cal. 93, 99 [ 145 P. 1029 ]; Curtis v. City of Los Angeles, 172 Cal. 230, 234 [ 156 P. 462 '].)’ ” Bearing said rules in mind in that ease the trial court heard a large amount of evidence and made findings among others including the following. | 1 | 1 |
Pennsylvania Coal Co. v. Mahongreen2 sentences1944But, as was recently said by the Supreme Court of the United States, “While property may be regulated to a certain extent if regulation, goes too far it will be recognized as a taking.” (Pennsylvania Coal Co. v. Mahon, 260 U.S. 393, 415 [ 28 A.L.R. 1321 , 67 L.Ed. 322 , 43 S.Ct. 158 , see, also, Rose’s U.S. Notes].) Therefore, notwithstanding this general grant of power^ it is a thoroughly well-settled doctrine that municipal by-laws, and ordinances undertaking to regulate useful business enterprises, are subject to investigation in the court, with a view to determining whether the law or ordi 1944But, as was recently said by the Supreme Court of the United States, “While property may be regulated to a certain extent if regulation, goes too far it will be recognized as a taking.” (Pennsylvania Coal Co. v. Mahon, 260 U.S. 393, 415 [ 28 A.L.R. 1321 , 67 L.Ed. 322 , 43 S.Ct. 158 , see, also, Rose’s U.S. Notes].) Therefore, notwithstanding this general grant of power^ it is a thoroughly well-settled doctrine that municipal by-laws, and ordinances undertaking to regulate useful business enterprises, are subject to investigation in the court, with a view to determining whether the law or ordi | 1 | 1 |
Curtis v. City of Los Angelesgreen2 sentences1944(Dobbins v. Los Angeles, 195 U.S. 223 [ 49 L.Ed. 169 , 25 S.Ct. 18 ]; In re Application of Throop, 169 Cal. 93, 99 [ 145 P. 1029 ]; Curtis v. City of Los Angeles, 172 Cal. 230, 234 [ 156 P. 462 '].)’ ” Bearing said rules in mind in that ease the trial court heard a large amount of evidence and made findings among others including the following. 1944(Dobbins v. Los Angeles, 195 U.S. 223 [ 49 L.Ed. 169 , 25 S.Ct. 18 ]; In re Application of Throop, 169 Cal. 93, 99 [ 145 P. 1029 ]; Curtis v. City of Los Angeles, 172 Cal. 230, 234 [ 156 P. 462 '].)’ ” Bearing said rules in mind in that ease the trial court heard a large amount of evidence and made findings among others including the following. | 1 | 1 |
| Case | Negative | Cited |
|---|---|---|
| No negative-treatment citations attached to this issue in California. Read the followed side critically anyway. | ||
| Case | Cited | Years |
|---|---|---|
Dobbins v. Los Angeles
green
2 sentences1944(Dobbins v. Los Angeles, 195 U.S. 223 [ 49 L.Ed. 169 , 25 S.Ct. 18 ]; In re Application of Throop, 169 Cal. 93, 99 [ 145 P. 1029 ]; Curtis v. City of Los Angeles, 172 Cal. 230, 234 [ 156 P. 462 '].)’ ” Bearing said rules in mind in that ease the trial court heard a large amount of evidence and made findings among others including the following. 1944(Dobbins v. Los Angeles, 195 U.S. 223 [ 49 L.Ed. 169 , 25 S.Ct. 18 ]; In re Application of Throop, 169 Cal. 93, 99 [ 145 P. 1029 ]; Curtis v. City of Los Angeles, 172 Cal. 230, 234 [ 156 P. 462 '].)’ ” Bearing said rules in mind in that ease the trial court heard a large amount of evidence and made findings among others including the following. | 3 | 1925–1944 |
Cashman v. Harrison
green
1 sentence1929Bank v. Stone, 59 Cal. 187 ; Cashman v. Harrison, 90 Cal. 304 [ 27 Pac. 283 ] ; Bradford Investment Co. v. Joost, 117 Cal. 210 [ 48 Pac. 1083 ] ; Leonard v. Miner, 120 Cal. 403 [ 52 Pac. 655 ] ; Carver v. San Joaquin Cigar Co., 16 Cal. App. 767 [ 118 Pac. 92 ]; Rottman v. Hevener, 54 Cal. App. 478 [ 202 Pac. 329 ], and cases there cited; Dollar v. International Banking Corp., 13 Cal. App. 331 [ 109 Pac. 499 ]; Consolidated, Lumber Co. v. Frew, 32 Cal. App. 118 [ 162 Pac. 430 ].) In Leonard v. Miner, supra, the court said: “It is a thoroughly well-settled principle of evidence that a written co | 1 | 1929–1929 |
Leonard v. Miner
green
2 sentences1929Bank v. Stone, 59 Cal. 187 ; Cashman v. Harrison, 90 Cal. 304 [ 27 Pac. 283 ] ; Bradford Investment Co. v. Joost, 117 Cal. 210 [ 48 Pac. 1083 ] ; Leonard v. Miner, 120 Cal. 403 [ 52 Pac. 655 ] ; Carver v. San Joaquin Cigar Co., 16 Cal. App. 767 [ 118 Pac. 92 ]; Rottman v. Hevener, 54 Cal. App. 478 [ 202 Pac. 329 ], and cases there cited; Dollar v. International Banking Corp., 13 Cal. App. 331 [ 109 Pac. 499 ]; Consolidated, Lumber Co. v. Frew, 32 Cal. App. 118 [ 162 Pac. 430 ].) In Leonard v. Miner, supra, the court said: “It is a thoroughly well-settled principle of evidence that a written co 1929Bank v. Stone, 59 Cal. 187 ; Cashman v. Harrison, 90 Cal. 304 [ 27 Pac. 283 ] ; Bradford Investment Co. v. Joost, 117 Cal. 210 [ 48 Pac. 1083 ] ; Leonard v. Miner, 120 Cal. 403 [ 52 Pac. 655 ] ; Carver v. San Joaquin Cigar Co., 16 Cal. App. 767 [ 118 Pac. 92 ]; Rottman v. Hevener, 54 Cal. App. 478 [ 202 Pac. 329 ], and cases there cited; Dollar v. International Banking Corp., 13 Cal. App. 331 [ 109 Pac. 499 ]; Consolidated, Lumber Co. v. Frew, 32 Cal. App. 118 [ 162 Pac. 430 ].) In Leonard v. Miner, supra, the court said: “It is a thoroughly well-settled principle of evidence that a written co | 1 | 1929–1929 |
Bradford Investment Co. v. Joost
green
1 sentence1929Bank v. Stone, 59 Cal. 187 ; Cashman v. Harrison, 90 Cal. 304 [ 27 Pac. 283 ] ; Bradford Investment Co. v. Joost, 117 Cal. 210 [ 48 Pac. 1083 ] ; Leonard v. Miner, 120 Cal. 403 [ 52 Pac. 655 ] ; Carver v. San Joaquin Cigar Co., 16 Cal. App. 767 [ 118 Pac. 92 ]; Rottman v. Hevener, 54 Cal. App. 478 [ 202 Pac. 329 ], and cases there cited; Dollar v. International Banking Corp., 13 Cal. App. 331 [ 109 Pac. 499 ]; Consolidated, Lumber Co. v. Frew, 32 Cal. App. 118 [ 162 Pac. 430 ].) In Leonard v. Miner, supra, the court said: “It is a thoroughly well-settled principle of evidence that a written co | 1 | 1929–1929 |
Carver v. San Joaquin Cigar Co.
green
1 sentence1929Bank v. Stone, 59 Cal. 187 ; Cashman v. Harrison, 90 Cal. 304 [ 27 Pac. 283 ] ; Bradford Investment Co. v. Joost, 117 Cal. 210 [ 48 Pac. 1083 ] ; Leonard v. Miner, 120 Cal. 403 [ 52 Pac. 655 ] ; Carver v. San Joaquin Cigar Co., 16 Cal. App. 767 [ 118 Pac. 92 ]; Rottman v. Hevener, 54 Cal. App. 478 [ 202 Pac. 329 ], and cases there cited; Dollar v. International Banking Corp., 13 Cal. App. 331 [ 109 Pac. 499 ]; Consolidated, Lumber Co. v. Frew, 32 Cal. App. 118 [ 162 Pac. 430 ].) In Leonard v. Miner, supra, the court said: “It is a thoroughly well-settled principle of evidence that a written co | 1 | 1929–1929 |
Consolidated Lumber Co. v. Frew
green
2 sentences1929Bank v. Stone, 59 Cal. 187 ; Cashman v. Harrison, 90 Cal. 304 [ 27 Pac. 283 ] ; Bradford Investment Co. v. Joost, 117 Cal. 210 [ 48 Pac. 1083 ] ; Leonard v. Miner, 120 Cal. 403 [ 52 Pac. 655 ] ; Carver v. San Joaquin Cigar Co., 16 Cal. App. 767 [ 118 Pac. 92 ]; Rottman v. Hevener, 54 Cal. App. 478 [ 202 Pac. 329 ], and cases there cited; Dollar v. International Banking Corp., 13 Cal. App. 331 [ 109 Pac. 499 ]; Consolidated, Lumber Co. v. Frew, 32 Cal. App. 118 [ 162 Pac. 430 ].) In Leonard v. Miner, supra, the court said: “It is a thoroughly well-settled principle of evidence that a written co 1929Bank v. Stone, 59 Cal. 187 ; Cashman v. Harrison, 90 Cal. 304 [ 27 Pac. 283 ] ; Bradford Investment Co. v. Joost, 117 Cal. 210 [ 48 Pac. 1083 ] ; Leonard v. Miner, 120 Cal. 403 [ 52 Pac. 655 ] ; Carver v. San Joaquin Cigar Co., 16 Cal. App. 767 [ 118 Pac. 92 ]; Rottman v. Hevener, 54 Cal. App. 478 [ 202 Pac. 329 ], and cases there cited; Dollar v. International Banking Corp., 13 Cal. App. 331 [ 109 Pac. 499 ]; Consolidated, Lumber Co. v. Frew, 32 Cal. App. 118 [ 162 Pac. 430 ].) In Leonard v. Miner, supra, the court said: “It is a thoroughly well-settled principle of evidence that a written co | 1 | 1929–1929 |
Rottman v. Hevener
green
1 sentence1929Bank v. Stone, 59 Cal. 187 ; Cashman v. Harrison, 90 Cal. 304 [ 27 Pac. 283 ] ; Bradford Investment Co. v. Joost, 117 Cal. 210 [ 48 Pac. 1083 ] ; Leonard v. Miner, 120 Cal. 403 [ 52 Pac. 655 ] ; Carver v. San Joaquin Cigar Co., 16 Cal. App. 767 [ 118 Pac. 92 ]; Rottman v. Hevener, 54 Cal. App. 478 [ 202 Pac. 329 ], and cases there cited; Dollar v. International Banking Corp., 13 Cal. App. 331 [ 109 Pac. 499 ]; Consolidated, Lumber Co. v. Frew, 32 Cal. App. 118 [ 162 Pac. 430 ].) In Leonard v. Miner, supra, the court said: “It is a thoroughly well-settled principle of evidence that a written co | 1 | 1929–1929 |
Dollar v. International Banking Corp.
green
2 sentences1929Bank v. Stone, 59 Cal. 187 ; Cashman v. Harrison, 90 Cal. 304 [ 27 Pac. 283 ] ; Bradford Investment Co. v. Joost, 117 Cal. 210 [ 48 Pac. 1083 ] ; Leonard v. Miner, 120 Cal. 403 [ 52 Pac. 655 ] ; Carver v. San Joaquin Cigar Co., 16 Cal. App. 767 [ 118 Pac. 92 ]; Rottman v. Hevener, 54 Cal. App. 478 [ 202 Pac. 329 ], and cases there cited; Dollar v. International Banking Corp., 13 Cal. App. 331 [ 109 Pac. 499 ]; Consolidated, Lumber Co. v. Frew, 32 Cal. App. 118 [ 162 Pac. 430 ].) In Leonard v. Miner, supra, the court said: “It is a thoroughly well-settled principle of evidence that a written co 1929Bank v. Stone, 59 Cal. 187 ; Cashman v. Harrison, 90 Cal. 304 [ 27 Pac. 283 ] ; Bradford Investment Co. v. Joost, 117 Cal. 210 [ 48 Pac. 1083 ] ; Leonard v. Miner, 120 Cal. 403 [ 52 Pac. 655 ] ; Carver v. San Joaquin Cigar Co., 16 Cal. App. 767 [ 118 Pac. 92 ]; Rottman v. Hevener, 54 Cal. App. 478 [ 202 Pac. 329 ], and cases there cited; Dollar v. International Banking Corp., 13 Cal. App. 331 [ 109 Pac. 499 ]; Consolidated, Lumber Co. v. Frew, 32 Cal. App. 118 [ 162 Pac. 430 ].) In Leonard v. Miner, supra, the court said: “It is a thoroughly well-settled principle of evidence that a written co | 1 | 1929–1929 |
Perry v. Bigelow
neutral
1 sentence1898(Burnes v. Scott, 117 U. S. 582 ; Harvey v. Laflin, 2 Ind. 477 ; Perry v. Bigelow, 128 Mass. 129 ; Jones v. Shaw, 67 Mo. 667 ; Brown v. Hull, 1 Denio, 400; Erwin v. Saunders, 1 Cow. 249 ; 13 Am. | 1 | 1898–1898 |
Jones v. Shaw
neutral
1 sentence1898(Burnes v. Scott, 117 U. S. 582 ; Harvey v. Laflin, 2 Ind. 477 ; Perry v. Bigelow, 128 Mass. 129 ; Jones v. Shaw, 67 Mo. 667 ; Brown v. Hull, 1 Denio, 400; Erwin v. Saunders, 1 Cow. 249 ; 13 Am. | 1 | 1898–1898 |
Burnes v. Scott
green
1 sentence1898(Burnes v. Scott, 117 U. S. 582 ; Harvey v. Laflin, 2 Ind. 477 ; Perry v. Bigelow, 128 Mass. 129 ; Jones v. Shaw, 67 Mo. 667 ; Brown v. Hull, 1 Denio, 400; Erwin v. Saunders, 1 Cow. 249 ; 13 Am. | 1 | 1898–1898 |
Brown v. Hull
neutral
1 sentence1898(Burnes v. Scott, 117 U. S. 582 ; Harvey v. Laflin, 2 Ind. 477 ; Perry v. Bigelow, 128 Mass. 129 ; Jones v. Shaw, 67 Mo. 667 ; Brown v. Hull, 1 Denio, 400; Erwin v. Saunders, 1 Cow. 249 ; 13 Am. | 1 | 1898–1898 |
Erwin v. Saunders
neutral
1 sentence1898(Burnes v. Scott, 117 U. S. 582 ; Harvey v. Laflin, 2 Ind. 477 ; Perry v. Bigelow, 128 Mass. 129 ; Jones v. Shaw, 67 Mo. 667 ; Brown v. Hull, 1 Denio, 400; Erwin v. Saunders, 1 Cow. 249 ; 13 Am. | 1 | 1898–1898 |
Harvey v. Laflin
neutral
1 sentence1898(Burnes v. Scott, 117 U. S. 582 ; Harvey v. Laflin, 2 Ind. 477 ; Perry v. Bigelow, 128 Mass. 129 ; Jones v. Shaw, 67 Mo. 667 ; Brown v. Hull, 1 Denio, 400; Erwin v. Saunders, 1 Cow. 249 ; 13 Am. | 1 | 1898–1898 |
Opinions by the citing court's state. A doctrine retained in one state and abandoned in another shows up here as a year span that stalls.