C.F.R. homeSearch C.F.R.
C.F.R.Title 20Chapter VI—Office of Workers' Compensation Programs, Department of LaborSubchapter B—Federal Coal Mine Health and Safety Act of 1969, As AmendedPart 725—Claims for Benefits Under Part C of Title IV of the Federal Mine Safety and Health Act, As AmendedSubpart C—Filing of Claims

20 C.F.R. § 725.309 (2026)

Additional claims; effect of prior denial of benefits

Edition and currency
eCFR text as of Sept. 29, 2026. The text is the edition Syfert holds; for a past event, check the version in force on that date.
Other sources
CURRENTeCFR text as of Sept. 29, 2026 cited 1988–2026 133citing cases
At a glance

Courts have cited this section in 133 opinions since 1988, 9 of them in the last five years. The most litigated part is subsection (c) (4 cases).

(a) If a claimant files a claim under this part while another claim filed by the claimant under this part is still pending, the later claim must be merged with the earlier claim for all purposes. For purposes of this section, a claim must be considered pending if it has not yet been finally denied.

(b) If a claimant files a claim under this part within one year after the effective date of a final order denying a claim previously filed by the claimant under this part (see § 725.502(a)(2)), the later claim must be considered a request for modification of the prior denial and will be processed and adjudicated under § 725.310.

(c) If a claimant files a claim under this part more than one year after the effective date of a final order denying a claim previously filed by the claimant under this part (see § 725.502(a)(2)), the later claim must be considered a subsequent claim for benefits. A subsequent claim will be processed and adjudicated in accordance with the provisions of subparts E and F of this part. Except as provided in paragraph (1) below, a subsequent claim must be denied unless the claimant demonstrates that one of the applicable conditions of entitlement (see §§ 725.202(d) (miner), 725.212 (spouse), 725.218 (child), and 725.222 (parent, brother, or sister)) has changed since the date upon which the order denying the prior claim became final. The applicability of this paragraph may be waived by the operator or fund, as appropriate. The following additional rules apply to the adjudication of a subsequent claim:

(1) The requirement to establish a change in an applicable condition of entitlement does not apply to a survivor's claim if the requirements of §§ 725.212(a)(3)(ii), 725.218(a)(2), or 725.222(a)(5)(ii) are met, and the survivor's prior claim was filed—

(i) On or before January 1, 2005, or

(ii) After January 1, 2005 and was finally denied prior to March 23, 2010.

(2) Any evidence submitted in connection with any prior claim must be made a part of the record in the subsequent claim, provided that it was not excluded in the adjudication of the prior claim.

(3) For purposes of this section, the applicable conditions of entitlement are limited to those conditions upon which the prior denial was based. For example, if the claim was denied solely on the basis that the individual was not a miner, the subsequent claim must be denied unless the individual worked as a miner following the prior denial. Similarly, if the claim was denied because the miner did not meet one or more of the eligibility criteria contained in part 718 of this subchapter, the subsequent claim must be denied unless the miner meets at least one of the criteria that he or she did not meet previously.

(4) If the applicable condition(s) of entitlement relate to the miner's physical condition, the subsequent claim may be approved only if new evidence submitted in connection with the subsequent claim establishes at least one applicable condition of entitlement. A subsequent claim filed by a surviving spouse, child, parent, brother, or sister must be denied unless the applicable conditions of entitlement in such claim include at least one condition unrelated to the miner's physical condition at the time of his death.

(5) If the claimant demonstrates a change in one of the applicable conditions of entitlement, no findings made in connection with the prior claim, except those based on a party's failure to contest an issue (see § 725.463), will be binding on any party in the adjudication of the subsequent claim. However, any stipulation made by any party in connection with the prior claim will be binding on that party in the adjudication of the subsequent claim.

(6) In any case in which a subsequent claim is awarded, no benefits may be paid for any period prior to the date upon which the order denying the prior claim became final.

(d) In any case involving more than one claim filed by the same claimant, under no circumstances are duplicate benefits payable for concurrent periods of eligibility. Any duplicate benefits paid will be subject to collection or offset under subpart H of this part.

[78 FR 59118, Sept. 25, 2013]
The 20 cases that cite 20 C.F.R. § 725.309 most heavily, weighted by court and treatment. RelevanceNewestTreatment
1
GREENCumberland River Coal Co. v. Billie Banks, 690 F.3d 477 (6th Cir. 2012).
cites § 725.309 16×cited by 29 cases
Where it cites § 725.309
“Cumberland River Coal Company appeals this determination, arguing that Banks failed to establish a change in his condition under 20 C.F.R. § 725.309 (d). Additionally, it argues that Banks failed to establish that he suffers from pneumoconiosis or that he is disabled due to this…”
The case’s holding
A decision is supported by substantial evidence when it rests within the realm of rationality; a subsequent black lung claimant shows change in condition via new evidence disproving prior conclusions.
Later courts cite it for
“a decision that rests within the realm of rationality is supported by substantial evidence.” · 3 citing courts
2
GREENUnion Carbide Corp. v. Virginia Richards, 721 F.3d 307 (4th Cir. 2013).
cites § 725.309 8×cited by 115 cases
Where it cites § 725.309
“” 2 20 C.F.R. § 725.309 (d). The regulations provide: *311 A subsequent claim shall be processed and adjudicated in accordance with the provisions [that govern original claims], except that the claim shall be denied unless the claimant demonstrates that one of the applicable…”
The case’s holding
Res judicata does not bar a subsequent claim when a statutory amendment creates a new cause of action that did not exist at the time of prior litigation.
Later courts cite it for
“typically it is a new factual development that gives rise to a fresh cause of action.” · 98 citing courts
3
GREENU.S. Steel Mining Co. v. Dir., OWCP, 386 F.3d 977 (11th Cir. 2004).
cites § 725.309 8×cited by 24 cases
Where it cites § 725.309
“20 C.F.R. § 725.309 (d). Indeed, duplicate claims are feasible under the BLBA precisely because pneumoconiosis is a latent and progressive disease, from which a miner’s condition may deteriorate over time.”
Later courts cite it for
“decisions of the administrative law judge are renewable only as to whether they are in accordance with law and supported by substantial evidence in light of the entire record.” · 2 citing courts
4
GREENBuck Creek Coal Co. v. Gay Sexton, 706 F.3d 756 (6th Cir. 2013).
cites § 725.309 11×cited by 11 cases
Where it cites § 725.309
“Buck Creek Coal Company appeals this determination, arguing that its application of 20 C.F.R. § 725.309 is invalid and that it violates due process because it contravenes the principles of finality and res judicata by permitting the re-adjudication of the cause of black lung…”
5
GREENArkansas Coals, Inc. v. Albert Lawson, 739 F.3d 309 (6th Cir. 2014).
cites § 725.309 8×cited by 19 cases
Where it cites § 725.309
“As the claimant was entitled to bring a second claim under 20 C.F.R. § 725.309 (d)(4) 1 and as the determination that Arkansas Coals was the responsible operator was not “necessary” to the resolution of the initial claim, we reject the finality and collateral estoppel arguments.”
The case’s holding
Under the Black Lung Benefits Act, coal mine operators are liable to the maximum extent feasible for awarded claims, and an unnecessary responsible-operator finding in a denied claim does not bind later claims.
Later courts cite it for
“collateral estoppel, otherwise termed issue preclusion, bars 'successive litigation of an issue of fact or law actually litigated and resolved in a valid court determination essential to the prior judgment, even if the issue recurs in the context of a different claim.” · 4 citing courts
cites § 725.309 3×subsections: (c) 2×cited by 105 cases
Where it cites § 725.309
“20 C.F.R. § 725.309 (d). A “subsequent” claim is a claim filed “more than one year after the effective date of a final order denying a claim previously filed by the claimant.”
The case’s holding
Res judicata requires a final judgment on the merits, the same parties, and a subsequent suit based on the same cause of action.
Later courts cite it for
“the purpose of res judicata is to 'relieve parties of the cost and vexation of multiple lawsuits, conserve judicial resources, and, by preventing inconsistent decisions, encourage reliance on adjudication.” · 8 citing courts
7
GREENEnergy West Mining Co. v. Oliver, 555 F.3d 1211 (10th Cir. 2009).
cites § 725.309 5×cited by 31 cases
The case’s holding
A party challenging administrative proceedings must demonstrate that the adjudication was infected by a prejudicial and fundamentally unfair element.
Later courts cite it for
“apart from core due-process violations such as the failure to give notice or any opportunity to be heard, when (as here) a party complains about the course of administrative proceedings, that party must demonstrate that the adjudication was infected by some prejudicial, fundamentally unfair element.” · 4 citing courts
8
GREENWestmoreland Coal Co. v. Cox, 602 F.3d 276 (4th Cir. 2010).
cites § 725.309 5×cited by 30 cases
Where it cites § 725.309
“” 20 C.F.R. § 725.309 (d). The Act provides a statutory presumption of total disability resulting from pneumoconiosis where the coal miner suffers from: a chronic dust disease of the lung which (A) when diagnosed by chest [x-ray], yields one or more large opacities (greater than…”
The case’s holding
An ALJ may find statutory complicated pneumoconiosis from all the evidence, reject speculative expert opinions, and must establish a prevailing market rate before awarding attorney's fees.
9
NO FLAGNat'l Mining Ass'n v. Dep't of Labor, 292 F.3d 849 (D.C. Cir. 2002).
cites § 725.309 6×cited by 115 cases
Where it cites § 725.309
“See 20 C.F.R. § 725.309 (d). As we explain in more detail below, a claimant bringing such a claim still bears the burden of demonstrating that he meets all of the relevant conditions.”
cites § 725.309 6×cited by 13 cases
Where it cites § 725.309
“” See 20 C.F.R. § 725.309 (c). The regulations limit the “applicable conditions of entitlement” to “those conditions upon which the-prior denial was based.”
cites § 725.309 2×subsections: (c) 2×cited by 61 cases
Where it cites § 725.309
“Section 1556 applies immediately to all pending claims, including claims that were finally awarded or denied prior to the date of enactment of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, for which the claimant seeks to modify a denial, or for which other actions are taken in…”
The case’s holding
The Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment applies to state actions while the Fifth Amendment applies to federal government actions.
Later courts cite it for
“the fifth amendment applies to actions of the federal government.” · 5 citing courts
12
GREENColeman v. Dir., OWCP, 345 F.3d 861 (11th Cir. 2003).
cites § 725.309 7×cited by 6 cases
Summary
No passage or summary on file for this case yet.
13
GREENLabelle Processing Co. v. John Swarrow & Dir., 72 F.3d 308 (3d Cir. 1996).
cites § 725.309 3×cited by 63 cases
Where it cites § 725.309
“Under 20 C.F.R. § 725.309 (d), when a miner files more than one claim for benefits, the later claims are merged with the first claim if the earlier claim is still pending.”
The case’s holding
New facts occurring after the events of an earlier claim may give rise to a new claim that is not precluded by a prior judgment.
Later courts cite it for
“new facts (i.e., events occurring after the events giving rise to the earlier claim) may give rise to a new claim, which is not precluded by the earlier judgment.” · 6 citing courts
14
GREENGrundy Mining Co. v. Douglas W. Flynn & Dir., 353 F.3d 467 (6th Cir. 2004).
cites § 725.309 3×cited by 24 cases
Where it cites § 725.309
“Pursuant to 20 C.F.R. § 725.309 (1999), this claim was considered a “duplicate.”
Later courts cite it for
“we are bound by the published opinions of previous panels” · 3 citing courts
15
GREENHelen Mining Co. v. Dir. OWCP, 650 F.3d 248 (3d Cir. 2011).
cites § 725.309 3×cited by 23 cases
Where it cites § 725.309
“See 20 C.F.R. § 725.309 (d). 6 The very fact that successive claims are permitted — on evidence of material changes to the health of a miner — makes an interpretation of the statute of limitations that effectively precludes such claims untenable.”
The case’s holding
A medical diagnosis of pneumoconiosis discredited in a final denial of a prior claim is a misdiagnosis and does not trigger the three-year limitations period for subsequent claims.
Later courts cite it for
“cannot be a 'medical determination' of pneumoconiosis, as set out in section 932.” · 1 citing court
16
GREENConsolidation Coal Co. v. Albert A. Borda Dir., 171 F.3d 175 (4th Cir. 1999).
cites § 725.309 3×cited by 49 cases
Where it cites § 725.309
“See 20 C.F.R. § 725.309 (c). To justify his current position that the 1981 letter was indeed a request for modification, the Director explains that he did not have the 1981 letter in Borda's file (although no one contests that it was sent at the time indicated).”
The case’s holding
Government delay violates due process only when the resulting prejudice deprives an employer of a fair opportunity to mount a meaningful defense.
Later courts cite it for
“it is not the mere fact of the government's delay that violates due process, but rather the prejudice resulting from such delay.” · 26 citing courts
17
GREENSea \B\" Mining Co. v. Shirley Addison", 831 F.3d 244 (4th Cir. 2016).
cites § 725.309 1×cited by 65 cases
Where it cites § 725.309
“20 C.F.R. § 725.309 (c). The ALJ determined that Addison had demonstrated such a change, in that he had become totally disabled, and Sea-13 has not challenged this determination on appeal.”
The case’s holding
Administrative adjudications are subject to the same harmless error rule that generally applies to civil cases.
Later courts cite it for
“administrative adjudications are subject to the same harmless error rule that generally applies to civil cases.” · 11 citing courts
18
GREENSahara Coal Co. v. Off. of Workers' Comp. Programs, 946 F.2d 554 (7th Cir. 1991).
cites § 725.309 2×cited by 90 cases
Where it cites § 725.309
“(These delays in acting on a benefits claim are unpardonable. It is now eight years since McNew filed his second application.”
The case’s holding
The harmless error doctrine applies to judicial review of administrative law judge decisions in black lung cases if the outcome of a remand is foreordained.
Later courts cite it for
“miner did not have black lung disease at the time of the first application but has since contracted it and become totally disabled by it, or that his disease has progressed to the point of becoming totally disabling although it was not at the time of the first application.” · 13 citing courts
cites § 725.309 4×cited by 9 cases
Where it cites § 725.309
“The regulations provide that a subsequent claim “shall be denied unless the claimant demonstrates that one of the applicable conditions of entitlement .”
20
cites § 725.309 1×cited by 39 cases
Where it cites § 725.309
“See 20 C.F.R. § 725.309 (c). On the basis of three medical opinions, the ALJ answered this question in the affirmative.”
The case’s holding
Under the law of the case doctrine, findings made at one stage of litigation should not be reconsidered at subsequent stages of the same litigation.
Later courts cite it for
“under the law of the case doctrine, findings made at one stage in the litigation should not be reconsidered at subsequent stages of that same litigation.” · 8 citing courts

Show all 133 citing cases (list view) →

The flag is Syfertize’s treatment of the citing case itself, not of the statute. “Where it cites” is the passage in the opinion; the holding is a summary of the whole case and may concern another point. Annotations are extracted automatically from the opinions in the Syfert caselaw corpus.

Citing cases by year
198820072026

One bar per year. Tallest: 9 cases in 2001. 2026 is a partial year. These are opinions in the Syfert collection, which holds more of some courts’ recent opinions than their older ones, so a rise can reflect what the collection holds and not more litigation.

By court
6th Cir.484th Cir.353rd Cir.167th Cir.1410th Cir.911th Cir.58th Cir.4D.C. Cir.1

The 8 courts with the most citing cases, of 9 courts in all.

By subsection
(c)4 cases
Marmon Coal Co. v. Dir., Off. of Workers' Comp. Programs, 726 F.3d 387 (3d Cir. 2013).“20 C.F.R. § 725.309 (d). A “subsequent” claim is a claim filed “more than one year after the effective date of a final order denying a claim previously filed by the claimant.”
B & G Constr. Co. v. Dir., Off. of Workers' Comp. Programs, 662 F.3d 233 (3d Cir. 2011).“Section 1556 applies immediately to all pending claims, including claims that were finally awarded or denied prior to the date of enactment of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, for which the claimant seeks to modify a denial, or for which other actions are taken in…”
Peabody Coal Co. v. Spese, 94 F.3d 369 (7th Cir. 1996).
Peabody Coal Co. v. Spese, 94 F.3d 369 (7th Cir. 1996).

Show all 133 citing cases (list view) →

Enactment and amendments

Syfert holds no separate history line for this section. Where this code prints a source or history note, it appears with the text, usually at the end.

Versions

Edition shown: eCFR text as of Sept. 29, 2026. Syfert holds no earlier or later version of this section.

C.F.R. Home  |  Search C.F.R.  |  Search cases for this section  |  syfert.com