United States v. Allard, 240 F.2d 840 (3d Cir. 1957)
Circumstantial evidence sustains a conviction if the totality of the evidence allows a jury to find guilt beyond a reasonable doubt, even if not inconsistent with every other conclusion.
The defendant appeals a conviction for conspiracy to illegally distill liquor, arguing that the circumstantial evidence was insufficient to sustain the verdict. The court rejects the argument that the evidence must be inconsistent with every conclusion save guilt. Instead, the court applies the rule that the question is whether all pieces of evidence, taken together, make a strong enough case for a jury to find the defendant guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. The court finds that the evidence, including the purchase of specific equipment under fictitious names and the defendant's presence at the distillation site, is sufficient to support the conviction. The court affirms the judgment of the district court.
At page 841“the evidence does not need to be inconsistent with every conclusion save that of guilt if it does establish a case from which the jury can find the defendant guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.”40 citing cases
- United States v. Lashaumba Randolph, No. 24-1613 (3d Cir. Sept. 30, 2025).unpublishedA factfinder could reasonably find Randolph’s connection to this sequence of events and his role in them were “too strong to be dismissed as mere coincidences.” United States v. Allard, 240 F.2d 840, 841 (3d Cir. 1957) (per curiam). 6 Draw…
- Everett Moore v. State of Mississippi, 247 So. 3d 1198 (Miss. 2018).publishedCir. 1963); United States v. Thomas, 303 F.2d 561, 563 (6th Cir. 1962); United States v. Moia, 251 F.2d 255, 258 (2d Cir. 1958); Corbin v. United States, 253 F.2d 646, 649 (10th Cir. 1958); United States v. Allard, 240 F.2d 840, 841 (3d Ci…
- Heyliger v. People, 66 V.I. 340 (V.I. 2017).publishedNotwithstanding the foregoing, “this evidence does not need to be inconsistent with every conclusion save that of guilt in order to sustain the verdict.” Latalladi, 51 V.I. at 145 (quoting United States v. Allard, 240 F.2d 840, 841 (3d Cir…
- Phillip v. People, 58 V.I. 569 (V.I. 2013).published“This evidence ‘does not need to be inconsistent with every conclusion save that of guilt’ in order to sustain the verdict.” Id. at 145 (quoting United States v. Allard, 240 F.2d 840, 841 (3d Cir. 1957) (citing Holland v. United States, 34…
- Christopher v. People, 57 V.I. 500 (V.I. 2012).publishedIndeed, “[t]his evidence ‘does not need to be inconsistent with every conclusion save that of guilt’ in order to sustain the verdict.” Id. (quoting United States v. Allard, 240 F.2d 840, 841 (3d Cir. 1957)).
- Richardson v. Gov't of the Virgin Islands, 55 V.I. 1193 (D.V.I. 2011).publishedFurthermore, “ ‘[t]he evidence does not need to be inconsistent with every conclusion save that of guilt if it does establish a case from which the jury can find the defendant guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.’ ” Williams, 739 F.2d at 940…
- Stanislas v. People, 55 V.I. 485 (V.I. 2011).publishedThe evidence “does not need to be inconsistent with every conclusion save that of guilt in order to sustain the verdict.” Latalladi, 51 V.I. at 145 (quoting United States v. Allard, 240 F.2d 840, 841 (3d Cir. 1957)) (quotation marks omitte…
- People v. Clark, 54 V.I. 154 (V.I. Super. Ct. 2010).publishedThe Court must determine “whether all the pieces of evidence against the defendant, taken together, make a strong enough case to let the jury find him guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.” United States v. Allard, 240 F.2d 840, 841 (3d Cir. 1…
- Murrell v. People, 54 V.I. 327 (V.I. 2010).publishedHowever, “[tjhis evidence ‘does not need to be inconsistent with every conclusion save that of guilt’ in order to sustain the verdict.” Id. (quoting United States v. Allard, 240 F.2d 840, 841 (3d Cir. 1957)).
- Francis v. People, 52 V.I. 381 (V.I. 2009).publishedHowever, “[t]his evidence ‘does not need to be inconsistent with every conclusion save that of guilt’ in order to sustain the verdict.” Id. (quoting United States v. Allard, 240 F.2d 840, 841 (3d Cir. 1957)).
Show 26 more citing cases
- Bowry v. People, 52 V.I. 264 (V.I. 2009).publishedHowever, “[tjhis evidence ‘does not need to be inconsistent with every conclusion save that of guilt’ in order to sustain the verdict.” Id. (quoting United States v. Allard, 240 F.2d 840, 841 (3d Cir. 1957)).
- United States v. Joyce, 257 F. App'x 501 (3d Cir. 2007).unpublishedThe evidence “need not be inconsistent with every conclusion save that of guilt.” United States v. Allard, 240 F.2d 840, 841 (3d Cir.1957).
- United States v. Stefan E. Brodie, 403 F.3d 123 (3d Cir. 2005).published “The court must determine ‘whether all the pieces of evidence, taken together, make a strong enough case to let a jury find [the defendant] guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.’” Coleman, 811 F.2d at 807 (quoting United States v. Allard, 240…
- United States v. Abraham Nee Ntreh, 45 V.I. 416 (D.V.I. 2003).publishedThe Court must determine “whether all the pieces of evidence against the defendant, taken together, make a strong enough case to let the jury find him guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.” United States v. Allard, 240 F.2d 840, 841 (3d Cir. 1…
- United States v. Henrich Barel, 939 F.2d 26 (3d Cir. 1991).publishedThe evidence “does not need to be inconsistent with every conclusion save that of guilt,” United States v. Allard, 240 F.2d 840, 841 (3d Cir.), cert. denied, 353 U.S. 939 , 77 S.Ct. 814 , 1 L.Ed.2d 761 (1957), to sustain the jury’s verdict…
- United States v. Leo, 941 F.2d 181 (3d Cir. 1991).published For us to sustain the verdict against Leo, the evidence against him “does not need to be inconsistent with every conclusion save that of guilt.” Government of Virgin Islands v. Williams, 739 F.2d 936, 940 (3d Cir.1984) (quoting United Stat…
- United States v. Lorenzo Gonzalez, A/K/A "Tito," United States of Am. v. Modesto Anthony Caba, United States of Am. v. Raphael Vasquez, 918 F.2d 1129 (3d Cir. 1991).publishedTo sustain the jury’s verdict, the evidence “does not need to be inconsistent with every conclusion save that of guilt.” Id. (quoting United States v. Allard, 240 F.2d 840, 841 (3d Cir.), cert. denied, 353 U.S. 939 , 77 S.Ct. 814 , 1 L.Ed.…
- United States v. Nathaniel Coleman, 811 F.2d 804 (3d Cir. 1987).publishedThis court must determine “whether all the pieces of evidence against the defendant, taken together, make a strong enough case to let the jury find him guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.” United States v. Allard, 240 F.2d 840, 841 (3d Cir.)…
- United States v. Thomas Pecora, 798 F.2d 614 (3d Cir. 1986).publishedId. ■ In addition, “ ‘[t]he evidence does not need to be inconsistent with every conclusion save that of guilt if it does establish a case from which the jury can find the defendant guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.’ ” Id., quoting United…
- United States v. Shirl F. Kapp, 781 F.2d 1008 (3d Cir. 1986).published As we stated in United States v. Allard, 240 F.2d 840, 841 (3d Cir.), cert. denied, 353 U.S. 939 , 77 S.Ct. 814 , 1 L.Ed.2d 761 (1957), “The question is whether all the pieces of evidence against the defendant, taken together, make a stron…
- Gov't of the Virgin Islands v. Williams, Frederico, in No. 83-3480 v. Ayala, Jorge, in No. 83-3481 v. Guadalupe, Leocadio, in No. 83-3501, 739 F.2d 936 (3d Cir. 1984).published“The‘evidence does not need to be inconsistent with every conclusion save that of guilt if it does establish a case from which the jury can find the defendant guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.” United States v. Allard, 240 F.2d 840, 841 (3…
- United States v. Leon, 739 F.2d 885 (3d Cir. 1984).published Moreover, “[t]he evidence does not need to be inconsistent with every conclusion save that of guilt if it does establish a case from which the jury can find the defendant guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.” United States v. Allard, 240 F.2d…
- United States v. Dabney, 393 F. Supp. 529 (E.D. Pa. 1975).publishedWe next must determine whether all of the evidence against the defendant, taken in its totality, rises to a level which would permit reasonable jurymen to find the defendant guilty beyond a reasonable doubt, United States v. Sutton, 138 U.…
- United States v. Morris, 308 F. Supp. 1348 (E.D. Pa. 1970).published“The question is whether all the pieces of evidence against the defendant, taken together, make a strong enough case to let a jury find him guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.” United States v. Allard, 240 F.2d 840, 841 (3rd Cir. 1957); cert…
- United States v. Roy Arthur Nelson, 419 F.2d 1237 (9th Cir. 1969).publishedE. g., Dirring v. United States, 328 F.2d 512, 515 (1st Cir. 1985); United States v. Press, 336 F.2d 1003, 1010 (2d Cir. 1964) ; United States v. Tutino, 269 F.2d 488, 490 (2d Cir. 1959) ; United States v. Allard, 240 F.2d 840, 841 (3d Cir…
- United States v. David Galvin, 394 F.2d 228 (3d Cir. 1968).publishedUnited States v. Chappell, 353 F.2d 83, 84 (4th Cir. 1965); United States v. Allard, 240 F.2d 840, 841 (3rd Cir. 1957); cert. den. sub nom.
- United States v. Nicholas A. Stirone, 311 F.2d 277 (3d Cir. 1963).publishedCf. United States v. Giuliano, supra at 583 ; United States v. Allard, 240 F.2d 840, 841 (3 Cir.1957).
- United States v. O'Day, 186 F. Supp. 572 (D. Del. 1960).published There, upon the basis of Holland v. United States, 1954, 348 U.S. 121, 139 , 75 S.Ct. 127 , 99 L.Ed. 150 and United States v. Allard, 3 Cir., 1957, 240 F.2d 840 , 841, it was held that the evidence need not be inconsistent with every concl…
- United States v. Zavala, 190 F. App'x 131 (3d Cir. 2006).unpublished(The evidence does not need to be inconsistent with every conclusion save that of guilt if it does establish a case from which the jury can find the defendant guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.)
- United States v. McGlory, 968 F.2d 309 (3d Cir. 1992).published United States v. Glasser, 315 U.S. 60, 80 , 62 S.Ct. 457, 469 , 86 L.Ed. 680 (1942); see United States v. Cooper, 567 F.2d 252, 254 (3d Cir.1977) (“The evidence does not need to be inconsistent with every conclusion save that of guilt if i…
- Latalladi v. People, 51 V.I. 137 (V.I. 2009).published
- Francis v. People, 54 V.I. 313 (V.I. 2010).published
- Brown v. People, 54 V.I. 496 (V.I. 2010).published
- Ambrose v. People, 56 V.I. 99 (V.I. 2012).published
- Fontaine v. People, 56 V.I. 571 (V.I. 2012).published
- Francis v. People, 57 V.I. 201 (V.I. 2012).published
Other citing cases
- United States v. Ehrenberg, 354 F. Supp. 460 (E.D. Pa. 1973).published
- United States v. Nicholas J. Nardiello, Jr., United States of Am. v. Alfred Salerno, 303 F.2d 876 (3d Cir. 1962).published
- Harms, Inc. v. Sansom House Enter., Inc., 162 F. Supp. 129 (E.D. Pa. 1958).published
- Zenith Radio Corp. v. Matsushita Elec. Indus. Co., 513 F. Supp. 1100 (E.D. Pa. 1981).published
- Noel v. United Aircraft Corp., 219 F. Supp. 556 (D. Del. 1963).published
v.
Solomon ALLARD, alias Joseph David Perry J. Fishman, alias Fisher Armando P. Gervasoni Charles Leonard and Harry Minkoff, Perry J. Fishman
The defendant was convicted of conspiracy to distill liquor illegally in violation of United States liquor laws. The indictment charged a conspiracy to defraud the United States, 18 U.S.C. § 371, and violation of the following sections of the Internal Revenue Code of 1939: 26 U.S.C.A. §§ 2810(a), 2833(a), 3321. In this appeal it is argued that the evidence was insufficient to sustain a conviction.
[*841] A favorite method of attack on convictions in this and similar cases is to use the analogy of the links of a chain. If the chain has a weak link, the argument runs, the whole chain breaks and the defendant is entitled to a judgment of acquittal. We think this is not an accurate way to pose the legal problem. The question is whether all the pieces of evidence against the defendant, taken together, make a strong enough case to let a jury find him guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.
In this case the evidence against the defendant was all circumstantial. He was apprenhended at the end of a lane near a dwelling house upon a farm. At the time he was accompanied by another person who was driving the automobile. At this farm illicit distillation was in progress.
Prior to that the defendant had bought an oil burner in Trenton under a fictitious name, paying cash for it. This oil burner was a larger one than usually sold for household use. It was identified by brand name by the seller. In answer to a question whether he could tell whether it was the same oil burner as that found on the premises of the still, he said, “It would seem so.” That was as definite as his identification was.
There was evidence that the defendant, accompanied by a man named Minkoff, purchased a certain filter press from an equipment company in New York in the name of a fictitious company and that a filter press of that type was found at the still when it was raided. Minkoff, himself, purchased, not in the defendant’s company, five-gallon cans and caps which were found at the still’s site. This links Minkoff with the conspiracy. No one of these facts by itself would justify a conviction. But all of them taken together are too strong to be dismissed as mere coincidences. We think the jury could properly have found the defendant guilty under the very careful charge of the trial judge. The evidence does not need to be inconsistent with every conclusion save that of guilt if it does establish a case from which the jury can find the defendant guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. Holland v. United States, 1954, 348 U.S. 121, 75 S.Ct. 127, 99 L.Ed. 150, rehearing denied 1955, 348 U.S. 932, 75 S.Ct. 334, 99 L.Ed. 731.
The judgment of the district court will be affirmed.