Bonanno v. Thomas, 309 F.2d 320 (9th Cir. 1962)
An order dismissing a complaint for failure to state a claim must state the reason for dismissal to allow the plaintiff to make an intelligent choice regarding amendment.
A plaintiff filed a civil rights complaint against city officials, which the district court dismissed via minute entry without specifying the legal grounds for the decision. The appellate court reviews whether the dismissal was procedurally proper. The court holds that when a complaint is dismissed for failing to state a claim, the order must inform the plaintiff of the specific reason to allow an intelligent choice regarding amendment. Furthermore, leave to amend must be granted unless the court determines that no possible amendment could cure the deficiency. Because the district court provided no reasoning and made no determination regarding the futility of amendment, the appellate court reverses the judgment and remands the case for further proceedings.
At page 322Requiring reasons for dismissal of pleadings67 citing cases“where a complaint is dismissed on the ground that it fails to state a claim, the order should also inform the plaintiff of the reason for dismissal so that he can make an intelligent choice as to amending.”
- Metzler Inv. GMBH v. Corinthian Colleges, Inc., 540 F.3d 1049 (9th Cir. 2008).published (Where a complaint is dismissed on the ground that it fails to state a claim, the order should also inform the plaintiff of the reason for dismissal so that he can make an intelligent choice as to amending.)
- Abraham Considine Living Est. Trust v. Unknown Party, No. 4:25-cv-00716 (D. Ariz. Feb. 26, 2026).More information is available at https://www.azd.uscourts.gov/federal-court- 28 advice-only-clinic-tucson (last visited Feb. 26, 2026). 1 || See Bonanno v. Thomas, 309 F.2d 320, 322 (9th Cir. 1962). 2 Any amended complaint filed by Plainti…
- Taylor, No. 2:24-cv-03653 (D. Ariz. Dec. 4, 2025).Co. v. Serv-Well Furniture Co., 806 F.2d 1393 , 1401 20 (9th Cir. 1986) (citing Bonanno v. Thomas, 309 F.2d 320, 322 (9th Cir. 1962)).
- Guercia v. AON Affinity Ins. Servs. Inc, No. 4:24-cv-05088 (E.D. Wash. Jan. 15, 2025).Co. v. Serv-Well Furniture Co., 806 F.2d 1393 , 12 1401 (9th Cir. 1986) (citing Bonanno v. Thomas, 309 F.2d 320, 322 (9th Cir. 13 1962)).
- Tamez v. Fed. Bureau of Investigations, No. 4:24-cv-00458 (D. Ariz. Nov. 13, 2024).The Court has provided the reasons for the dismissal to 3 permit Plaintiff to make an intelligent decision whether to file a First Amended Complaint. 4 See Bonanno v. Thomas, 309 F.2d 320, 322 (9th Cir. 1962).
- Myhre v. Vroom Auto., LLC, No. 6:24-cv-00028 (D. Mont. Oct. 30, 2024).“the court determine[s] that the allegation of other facts consistent with the challenged pleading could not possibly cure the deficiency”
- Olson v. Missoula Field Off., No. 9:23-cv-00038 (D. Mont. Oct. 24, 2023).“the court determine[s] that the allegation of other facts consistent with the 24 challenged pleading could not possibly cure the deficiency”
- Forbes v. Macchione, FACHE, No. 3:20-cv-00998 (S.D. Cal. Mar. 4, 2021).Co., 806 F.2d at 1401 (citing Bonanno 17 v. Thomas, 309 F.2d 320, 322 (9th Cir. 1962)). 18 III.
- Fulkerson v. Pub. Utils. Comm'n Nevada, No. 3:20-cv-00007 (D. Nev. Sept. 22, 2020).Co. v. Serv-Well Furniture 8 Co., Inc., 806 F.2d 1393, 1401 (9th Cir. 1986) (citing Bonanno v. Thomas, 309 F.2d 320, 322 (9th 9 Cir. 1962)). 10 ANALYSIS 11 I.
- Himes v. Hadjadj, No. 3:19-cv-02216 (S.D. Cal. Aug. 10, 2020).However, leave to amend may be denied when “the 23 court determines that the allegation of other facts consistent with the challenged 24 pleading could not possibly cure the deficiency.” Schreiber Distrib., 806 F.2d at 1401 25 (citing Bona…
Show 50 more citing cases
- Sekerke v. City of Nat'l City, No. 3:19-cv-01360 (S.D. Cal. Aug. 3, 2020).However, leave to amend may be denied when “the court determines 6 that the allegation of other facts consistent with the challenged pleading could not 7 possibly cure the deficiency.” Schreiber Distrib., 806 F.2d at 1401 (citing Bonanno v…
- Asire v. Carson City Sch. Dist., No. 3:20-cv-00039 (D. Nev. July 8, 2020).Co. v. Serv-Well Furniture 18 Co., Inc., 806 F.2d 1393, 1401 (9th Cir. 1986) (citing Bonanno v. Thomas, 309 F.2d 320, 322 (9th 19 Cir. 1962)).
- Renck v. Novak, No. 3:19-cv-00622 (D. Nev. May 20, 2020).Co. v. Serv-Well Furniture 1 Co., Inc., 806 F.2d 1393, 1401 (9th Cir. 1986) (citing Bonanno v. Thomas, 309 F.2d 320, 322 (9th 2 Cir. 1962)). 3 ANALYSIS 4 Defendant Novak’s motion to dismiss provides five arguments as to why Plaintiff’s 5 c…
- New Horizon Home Care, LLC v. Ne. Nevada Reg'l Hosp., No. 3:19-cv-00521 (D. Nev. May 20, 2020).Co. v. Serv-Well Furniture 20 Co., Inc., 806 F.2d 1393, 1401 (9th Cir. 1986) (citing Bonanno v. Thomas, 309 F.2d 320, 322 (9th 21 /// 22 /// 23 /// 24 /// 1 |} Cir. 1962)).
- Code v. Vail Resorts, Inc., No. 3:19-cv-00728 (D. Nev. May 20, 2020).Co. v. Serv-Well Furniture 3 Co., Inc., 806 F.2d 1393, 1401 (9th Cir. 1986) (citing Bonanno v. Thomas, 309 F.2d 320, 322 (9th 4 Cir. 1962)). 5 ANALYSIS 6 Defendant argues that the complaint should be dismissed as this Court has neither sub…
- Taylor v. Sullivan, No. 3:19-cv-00668 (D. Nev. May 20, 2020).Co. v. Serv-Well Furniture 10 Co., Inc., 806 F.2d 1393, 1401 (9th Cir. 1986) (citing Bonanno v. Thomas, 309 F.2d 320, 322 (9th 11 Cir. 1962)). 12 ANALYSIS 13 Although the motion to dismiss from the federal defendants was the last to be fil…
- Kealey v. Russell, No. 3:19-cv-00741 (D. Nev. May 20, 2020).Co. v. Serv-Well Furniture 7 Co., Inc., 806 F.2d 1393, 1401 (9th Cir. 1986) (citing Bonanno v. Thomas, 309 F.2d 320, 322 (9th 8 Cir. 1962)). 9 ANALYSIS 10 I.
- Masimo Corp. v. Sotera Wireless, No. 3:19-cv-01100 (S.D. Cal. May 8, 2020).Co., 806 F.2d at 1401 9 (citing Bonanno v. Thomas, 309 F.2d 320, 322 (9th Cir. 1962)). 10 III.
- Valenzuela v. San Diego Police Dep't, No. 3:19-cv-00002, 2020 WL 804923 (S.D. Cal. Feb. 18, 2020).Co., 806 F.2d at 1401 (citing Bonanno 23 v. Thomas, 309 F.2d 320, 322 (9th Cir. 1962)). 24 III.
- Webb v. Trader Joe's Co., No. 3:19-cv-01587 (S.D. Cal. Oct. 29, 2019).Co. v. ServWell Furniture Co., Inc., 806 F.2d 1393, 1401 (9th Cir. 1986) (citing Bonanno v. Thomas, 309 F.2d 320, 322 (9th Cir. 1962)). oO
- In re Packaged Seafood Prods. Antitrust Litig., 277 F. Supp. 3d 1167 (S.D. Cal. 2017).publishedCo. v. Serv-Well Furniture Co., 806 F.2d 1393 , 1401 (9th Cir. 1986) ("If a complaint is dismissed for failure to state a claim, leave to amend should be granted unless the court determines that the allegation of other facts consistent wit…
- Erhart v. BofI Holding, Inc., 269 F. Supp. 3d 1059 (S.D. Cal. 2017).publishedCo., 806 F.2d at 1401 (citing Bonanno v. Thomas, 309 F.2d 320, 322 (9th Cir. 1962)).
- Wilson v. Hays, 228 F. Supp. 3d 1100 (S.D. Cal. 2017).publishedCo., 806 F.2d at 1401 (citing Bonanno v. Thomas, 309 F.2d 320, 322 (9th Cir. 1962)).
- Little v. Gore, 148 F. Supp. 3d 936 (S.D. Cal. 2015).publishedCo., 806 F.2d at 1401 (citing Bonanno v. Thomas, 309 F.2d 320, 322 (9th Cir.1962)).
- Osinubepi-Alao v. Plainview Fin. Servs., Ltd, 44 F. Supp. 3d 84 (D.D.C. 2014).publishedTherefore, “courts should hesitate to dismiss a complaint on statute of limitations grounds based solely on the face of the complaint,” id. (citing Richards v. Mileski, 662 F.2d 65, 73 (D.C.Cir.1981); Jones v. Rogers Mem’l Hosp., 442 F.2d…
- Shalaby v. Bernzomatic, 281 F.R.D. 565 (S.D. Cal. 2012).publishedCo. v. Serv-Well Furniture Co., Inc., 806 F.2d 1393 , 1401 (9th Cir.1986); Bonanno v. Thomas, 309 F.2d 320, 322 (9th Cir.1962); City of Industry v. City of Fillmore, 198 Cal.App.4th 191 , 129 Cal.Rptr.3d 433 (2011); Vess v. Ciba-Geigy Corp…
- Busby v. Capital One, N.A., 772 F. Supp. 2d 268 (D.D.C. 2011).publishedAlthough the aforementioned claims are woefully inadequate and must be dis *287 missed, this Circuit has cautioned that “dismissal with prejudice should be granted only when a trial court determines that ‘the allegation of other facts cons…
- Telesaurus VPC, LLC v. Power, 623 F.3d 998 (9th Cir. 2010).publishedSee Schreiber, 806 F.2d at 1402; Bonanno v. Thomas, 309 F.2d 320, 322 (9th Cir.1962). 8 IV Telesaurus also appeals from the dismissal of its state tort claims for conversion, unjust enrichment, and intentional interference with prospective…
- Robertson v. Dist. of Columbia, No. 2009-1188, 2010 WL 3238996 (D.D.C. Aug. 16, 2010).published“dismissal with prejudice should be granted only when a trial court determines that ‘the allegation of other facts consistent with the challenged pleading could not possibly cure the deficiency”
- Jung Ja Kim v. Quichocho, 708 F. Supp. 2d 1079 (D. N. Mar. I. 2010).published“If a complaint is dismissed for failure to state a claim, leave to amend should be granted unless the court determines that the allegation of other facts consistent with the challenged pleading could not possibly cure the deficiency.” Id.…
- Norblad v. Veronex Tech., Inc., 183 F. App'x 698 (9th Cir. 2006).unpublished“makfing] an intelligent choice as to amending”
- Diaz v. Parks, 420 F.3d 897 (9th Cir. 2005).published Cf. Bonanno v. Thomas, 309 F.2d 320, 322 (9th Cir.1962).
- Qarbon. Com Inc. v. eHelp Corp., 315 F. Supp. 2d 1046 (N.D. Cal. 2004).publishedBonanno v. Thomas, 309 F.2d 320, 322 (9th Cir.1962).
- Andrx Pharm., Inc. v. Biovail Corp. Int'l, 256 F.3d 799 (D.C. Cir. 2001).publishedServ., 753 F.2d 1088, 1091 (D.C.Cir.1985) (quoting Bonanno v. Thomas, 309 F.2d 320, 322 (9th Cir.1962)).
- Dees v. California State Univ., Hayward, 33 F. Supp. 2d 1190 (N.D. Cal. 1998).publishedDismissal without Leave to Amend “[L]eave to amend should be granted unless the court determines that the allegation of other facts consistent with the challenged pleading could not possibly cure the deficiency.” Schreiber Distributing Co.…
- Myrna O'Dell Firestone v. Leonard K. Firestone, 76 F.3d 1205 (D.C. Cir. 1996).publishedA dismissal with prejudice is warranted only when a trial court “determines that ‘the allegation of other facts consistent with the challenged pleading could not possibly cure the deficiency.’ ” Jarrell v. United States Postal Serv., 753 F…
- John Doe v. United States of Am., in re John Doe, Debtor. John Doe v. United States, 58 F.3d 494 (9th Cir. 1995).published “no indication of such a determination”
- Cook, Perkiss & Liehe, Inc. v. N. California Collection Serv. Inc., 911 F.2d 242 (9th Cir. 1990).published Bonanno v. Thomas, 309 F.2d 320, 322 (9th Cir.1962) (citing Sidebotham v. Robison, 216 F.2d 816, 826 (9th Cir.1954); see also Erlich v. Glasner, 352 F.2d 119, 122 (9th Cir.1965).
- Schreiber Distrib. Co. v. Serv-Well Furniture Co., 806 F.2d 1393 (9th Cir. 1986).published Bonanno v. Thomas, 309 F.2d 320, 322 (9th Cir.1962). 48 We find no indication of such a determination in this record.
- Leonard Jarrell v. United States Postal Serv., 753 F.2d 1088 (D.C. Cir. 1985).published“the allegation of other facts consistent with the challenged pleading could not possibly cure the deficiency”
- Kenneth Adams v. Terrel H. Bell, 711 F.2d 161 (D.C. Cir. 1983).published Comm’r v. Shapiro, 424 U.S. 614 , 96 S.Ct. 1062 , 47 L.Ed.2d 278 (1976); Bal-lou v. General Electric Co., 393 F.2d 398, 399-400 (1st Cir.1968); Bonanno v. Thomas, 309 F.2d 320, 322 (9th Cir. 1962); McLaughlin v. Union Switch & Signal Co.,…
- Council of & for the Blind of Delaware Cnty. Valley, Inc. v. Donald T. Regan, 709 F.2d 1521 (D.C. Cir. 1983).published Co., 393 F.2d 398, 399-100 (1st Cir.1968); McLaughlin v. Union Switch & Signal Co., 166 F.2d 46, 49 (3d Cir.1948); Bonanno v. Thomas, 309 F.2d 320, 322 (9th Cir.1962). .
- Samuel Shapiro v. Sec'y of State, 499 F.2d 527 (D.C. Cir. 1974).publishedSee Fed.R.Civ.P. 15 ; Bonanno v. Thomas, 309 F.2d 320, 322 (9th Cir. 1962). 26 . 370 U.S. at 7 . 27 .
- James P. Asher v. Fred Harvey Harrington, 461 F.2d 890 (7th Cir. 1972).published Bonanno v. Thomas, 309 F.2d 320, 322 (9th Cir. 1962).
- Francis Gaffney v. Norman Silk, 488 F.2d 1248 (1st Cir. 1973).published
- Unified Data Servs., LLC v. FTC, 39 F.4th 1200 (9th Cir. 2022).published
- Trudeau v. Direct Mktg. Concepts, Inc., 90 F. App'x 486 (9th Cir. 2003).unpublished
- Woodhull Freedom Found. v. United States, 72 F.4th 1286 (D.C. Cir. 2023).published
- Memory v. EmployBridge, No. 4:23-cv-00481 (D. Ariz. Apr. 16, 2024).
- Henry v. Newman, No. 4:24-cv-00122 (D. Ariz. Apr. 17, 2024).
- Gonzalez v. Chase, No. 4:24-cv-00315 (D. Ariz. June 28, 2024).
- Drake v. Pima, Cnty. of, No. 4:24-cv-00246 (D. Ariz. June 24, 2024).
- Gonzalez v. Tucson City Court, No. 4:24-cv-00300 (D. Ariz. July 3, 2024).
- Pelt v. LVNV Funding LLC, No. 4:24-cv-00222 (D. Ariz. Aug. 15, 2024).
- Rong v. Arizona, State of, No. 4:25-cv-00351 (D. Ariz. Aug. 26, 2025).
- Jensen v. Navy Fed. Credit Union, No. 4:25-cv-00460 (D. Ariz. Sept. 18, 2025).
- Jensen v. Pinkney, No. 4:25-cv-00240 (D. Ariz. Sept. 22, 2025).
- Escalante, No. 4:25-cv-00339 (D. Ariz. Nov. 19, 2025).
- Yourish v. California Amplifier, 191 F.3d 983 (9th Cir. 1999).published
- Fremont Sheep Co. v. Big Bend Drainage Dist., 418 P.2d 784 (Wyo. 1966).published
At page 321Review of prior case law regarding summary judgment standards4 citing casestered by minute entry, reading as follows: “It is Ordered that Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss First Amended Complaint is granted, and that this action is…
- Jang v. Boston Sci. Corp., 532 F.3d 1330 (Fed. Cir. 2008).publishedAirlines, Inc., 218 F.3d 1078, 1081 (9th Cir.2000) (per curiam) (“[W]hen multiple grounds are presented by the movant and the reasons for the district court’s decision are not otherwise clear from the record, [the court] may vacate a summa…
- Bd. of Trs. of the Leland Stanford Junior Univ. v. Motorola, Inc., 314 F. App'x 284 (Fed. Cir. 2008).unpublished
- Davis Lee v. Dr. J. B. Hodges, 321 F.2d 480 (4th Cir. 1963).published
- Nanez v. Ritger, 304 F. Supp. 354 (E.D. Wis. 1969).published
v.
BONANNO v. Charles THOMAS, Gordon Selby, Leon Orr, Charles Hodges, Don Rust, Harold Harrett, John Doe Bingaman, John Doe Bentz, John Doe I, John Doe II, John Doe III, John Doe IV, John Doe V, Richard Roe I, Richard Roe II, Richard Roe III, Richard Roe IV, and Richard Roe V
Salvatore V. Bonanno appeals, in part, from a district court judgment dismissing his first amended complaint in this civil rights damage suit, and dismissing the action.
The suit was commenced on May 3, 1961. The City of Phoenix, Arizona, the chief of police of that city, and two detective lieutenants of Phoenix were named as defendants. Defendants filed and noticed for hearing a motion to dismiss the action. On July 13, 1961, no ruling having been made on the motion to dismiss, Bonanno filed his first amended complaint. In this pleading Bonanno named, as additional defendants, five named persons, five “John Does,” and five “Richard Roes,” all alleged to be Phoenix police officers.
On July 24, 1961, defendants moved to strike certain words from the first amended complaint, and to dismiss that complaint. The record does not indicate that these motions were noticed for hearing or that any hearing was had thereon. On September 20, 1961, an order was en[*321]tered by minute entry, reading as follows: “It is Ordered that Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss First Amended Complaint is granted, and that this action is dismissed.”
Bonanno thereupon appealed, but only as to the personal defendants, thereby permitting the judgment of dismissal to stand as to the City of Phoenix.
There are two specifications of error, namely: (1) the first amended complaint states a valid claim for relief under the Civil Rights Act and other general law, and sets forth all jurisdictional requirements;[1] and (2) if the first amended complaint was, in fact, deficient, appellant should have been, but was not, afforded an opportunity to amend that pleading.
We turn to the second of these specifications of error.
In the motion which was acted upon by the district court, appellees sought dismissal of the complaint on the following grounds: (1) the complaint fails to state a claim under any theory upon which relief can be granted by the federal courts, appellant’s relief, if any, being available only in the state courts; (2) the complaint framed under the theory of conspiracy fails to state a claim because it is not alleged that plaintiff was discriminated against as a class of persons because of race, religion or nationality; (3) the complaint framed under the theory of conspiracy fails to state a claim because no facts showing a conspiracy are alleged; and (4) the court lacks jurisdiction for the reason that the parties are citizens of the same state and the subject matter presents for determination no question arising under the Constitution of the United States, or otherwise within the jurisdiction of the United States District Court.[2]
As indicated above, the district court did not state which of these four grounds was relied upon in dismissing the action.
For all that can be determined from the record, the action may have been dismissed on ground (2) listed above, and on no other ground. If so, it would be necessary to reverse in view of our decisions in Cohen v. Norris, 9 Cir., 300 F.2d 24, 29-30, and Marshall v. Sawyer, 9 Cir., 301 F.2d 639, 646, which were handed down several months after this judgment of dismissal was entered. While discrimination on the basis of race, religion or nationality may provide a basis for a civil rights damage claim, other violations of Constitutional rights, not involving discriminations of this kind, may also provide an adequate basis for such a claim.
It is likewise possible that the district court, applying what it may have believed to be a reason available under grounds (1) and (4), dismissed on the theory that the federal courts should abstain in favor of state judicial remedies. If so, it would be necessary to reverse on the authority of the Marshall case referred to above.
On the other hand, the district court may have felt that under the allegations of the amended complaint, no violation of any Constitutional right, cognizable under the Due Process or the Privileges and Immunities Clauses of the Fourteenth Amendment, and hence amenable to the sanctions of the Civil Rights Acts, was shown or could be shown. If this was the basis for the judgment of dismissal a review thereof would present important Constitutional questions.
It does not seem to us that either appellant or this court ought to be called upon to guess which ground was relied upon by the district court, or in the alternative to explore ail grounds which were made the basis of the motion, in order to be sure we deal with the ground relied upon by the court. Such an appellate task is particularly inappropriate where, as here, Constitutional questions[*322] are at issue as to some but not all of the grounds on which the motion was based.
Moreover, if this complaint was dismissed for failure to state a claim on which relief could be granted, leave should have been granted to amend unless the court determined that the allegation of other facts consistent with the challenged pleading could not possibly cure the deficiency. We find no indication of such a determination in this record. It is of no consequence that no request to amend the pleading was made in the district court. Sidebotham v. Robison, 9 Cir., 216 F.2d 816, 826.
Where a complaint is dismissed on the ground that it fails to state a claim, the order should also inform the plaintiff of the reason for dismissal so that he can make an intelligent choice as to amending. Griffin v. Locke, 9 Cir., 286 F.2d 514, 515.
The judgment is reversed and the cause is remanded for further proceedings consistent with this opinion.
The principal provisions of the Civil Rights Act upon which appellant relied in the first amended complaint are 28 U.S.C. § 1348; 42 U.S.C. §§ 1981-1988.
Not included are two grounds having reference only to defendant City of Phoenix.