Seese v. Volkswagenwerk, A.G.
A district court lacks jurisdiction to alter an appellate mandate based on matters that were included or includable in a prior appeal.
After a jury verdict was affirmed on appeal and the Supreme Court denied certiorari, defendants moved for relief from judgment under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 60(b)(6) based on a subsequent decision from a different federal circuit regarding state law. The question is whether the district court may grant such relief based on matters that were included or includable in a prior appeal. Because the litigation was no longer sub judice following the denial of certiorari, the district court lacks jurisdiction to alter the appellate mandate. The court holds that once a final disposition is achieved, the case is no longer sub judice.
At page 337District court jurisdiction over prior appeal matters44 citing casesholding that even if there was a possible misinterpretation of North Carolina law, the litigation was "over" and "the district court was without jurisdiction to alter the mandate of [the Third Circuit] on the basis of matter included or includable in defendants' prior appeal.
- Paul Taylor v. Comm'r of Pennsylvania D, No. 14-9005 (3d Cir. Aug. 13, 2025).published([A] district court is without jurisdiction to alter the mandate of this court on the basis of matters included or includable in [a] prior appeal.)
- Kaetz v. United States, No. 2:22-cv-03469 (D.N.J. Mar. 30, 2023).“the district court is without jurisdiction to alter the mandate of this court on the basis of matters included or includable in defendants' prior appeal.”
- Law Offices of Bruce J. Chasan, LLC v. John Pierce, No. 24-1778 (3d Cir. Aug. 25, 2025).unpublished And because Chasan did not appeal the District Court’s decision in Chasan II, he cannot seek review of that decision now. evidence that could have been included in a prior appeal to us, see Seese v. Volkswagenwerk, A.G., 679 F.2d 336, 337…
- Am. Telecom Comany, L. L. C. v. Repub. of Lebanon, No. 2:04-cv-72596 (E.D. Mich. Mar. 10, 2025).“A district court also does not have jurisdiction to alter an appellate ruling where the appellate court has already considered and rejected the basis for relief cited in the Rule 60(b) motion.” Id. at 1159 (citing DeWeerth v. Baldinger, 3…
- Mccollister v. Cameron, No. 2:11-cv-00525 (E.D. Pa. Feb. 12, 2025).Analogously, “when reviewing a Rule 60(b) motion brought following an appeal, district courts are ‘without jurisdiction to alter the mandate of [the Court of Appeals] on the basis of matters included or includable in [the party]’s prior ap…
- Fernandez v. Bd. of Pemberton Twp., No. 1:20-cv-08600 (D.N.J. Nov. 3, 2022).“[t]he district court is without jurisdiction to alter the mandate of this court on the basis of matters included or includable in defendants' prior appeal”
- Kamdem-ouaffo v. Colgate Palmolive Co., No. 2:15-cv-07902 (D.N.J. Sept. 27, 2022).unpublishedHowever, the Third Circuit has counseled that “when reviewing a Rule 60(b) motion brought following an appeal, district courts are ‘without jurisdiction to alter the mandate of [the Third Circuit] on the basis of matters included or includ…
- Woodson v. Belbalso, No. 3:14-cv-00558-MEM-DB (M.D. Pa. Aug. 23, 2022).“The district court is without jurisdiction to alter the mandate of this court on the basis of matters included or includable in defendants’ prior appeal”
- Brooks v. Rozum, No. 2:13-cv-06805 (E.D. Pa. July 28, 2022).“The district court is without jurisdiction to alter the mandate of this court on the basis of matters included or includable in defendants’ prior appeal”
- Muir v. Link, No. 2:16-cv-02256 (E.D. Pa. Sept. 21, 2021).In this situation, district courts are “without jurisdiction to alter the mandate of [the Third Circuit] on the basis of matters included or includable in [the party’s] prior appeal.” Seese v. Volkswagenwerk, A.G., 679 F.2d 336, 337 (3d Ci…
Show 30 more citing cases
- Lee Mem'l Hosp. v. Xavier Becerra, 10 F.4th 859 (D.C. Cir. 2021).publishedA district court “is without power to do anything which is contrary to either the letter or spirit of the mandate[.]” City of Cleveland v. Fed. Power Comm’n, 561 F.2d 344, 346 (D.C. Cir. 1977) (quoting Yablonski v. United Mine Workers, 454…
- Reardon v. Zonies, No. 1:15-cv-08597 (D.N.J. Nov. 16, 2020).unpublishedThe Third Circuit has also held that, “when reviewing a Rule 60(b) motion brought following an appeal, district courts are ‘without jurisdiction to alter the mandate of [the appellate court] on the basis of matters included or includable i…
- Boldrini v. Wilson, No. 3:11-cv-01771 (M.D. Pa. Nov. 16, 2020).“To grant such a motion would in effect alter the appellate court’s mandate.” Id. (citing Seese v. Volkswagenwerk, A.G., 679 F.2d 336, 337 (3d Cir. 1982)).
- Reardon v. Zonies, No. 1:15-cv-08597 (D.N.J. Feb. 10, 2020).The Third Circuit has also held that, “when reviewing a Rule 60(b) motion brought following an appeal, district courts are ‘without jurisdiction to alter the mandate of [the appellate court] on the basis of matters included or includable i…
- Doherty v. Allstate Indem. Co., No. 2:15-cv-05165 (E.D. Pa. Sept. 30, 2019).Cf. Seese v. Volkswagenwerk, A.G., 679 F.2d 336, 337 (3d Cir. 1982) (per curiam) (holding “that the Supreme Court's denial of certiorari ended this litigation” for purposes of assessing “reasonable time” under Fed. R.
- Theresa Ellis v. Ethicon Inc, 614 F. App'x 613 (3d Cir. 2015).unpublishedMoreover, our Ellis I opinion did not affect the District Court’s jurisdiction, as Ellis contends, be *615 cause Ethicon’s compliance with its reinstatement obligation and the parties’ mediated settlement arose subsequent to the appealed j…
- Rothe Dev. Corp. v. U.S. Dep't of Def., 499 F. Supp. 2d 775 (W.D. Tex. 2007).published“The district court is without jurisdiction to alter the mandate of this [appellate] court on the basis of matters included or includable in defendants’ prior appeal”
- United States v. Enigwe, 17 F. Supp. 2d 388 (E.D. Pa. 1998).published“The district court is without jurisdiction to alter the mandate of this [the circuit] court on the basis of matters included or includable in defendants’ prior appeal”
- Biggins v. Hazen Paper Co., 111 F.3d 205 (1st Cir. 1997).publishedSee, e.g., Batts v. Tow-Motor Forklift Co., 66 F.3d 743, 750 (5th Cir.1995), cert. denied, - U.S. -, 116 S.Ct. 1851 , 134 L.Ed.2d 951 (1996); Overbee v. Van Waters & Rogers, 765 F.2d 578, 580 (6th Cir.1985); Seese v. Volkswagenwerk A.G., 6…
- Ute Indian Tribe v. State of Utah, 935 F. Supp. 1473 (D. Utah 1996).published(district court denial of Rule 60(b) relief based upon subsequent Fourth Circuit decision affirmed)
- Laborers' Int'l Union of North Am., Afl-Cio, in No. 93-5208 v. Foster Wheeler Corp. Foster Wheeler Energy Corp.. Laborers' Int'l Union of North Am., Afl-Cio v. Foster Wheeler Corp. Foster Wheeler Energy Corp., Foster Wheeler Energy Corp. in No. 93-5233. Laborers' Int'l Union of North Am., Afl-Cio v. Foster Wheeler Corp. Foster Wheeler Energy Corp., Foster Wheeler Corp., 26 F.3d 375 (3d Cir. 1994).published Co., 942 F.2d 210 , 218 (3d Cir.1991) (stating that a district court may enter any order or reach any decision so long as it was neither disposed of by an earlier district court order and not pursued on appeal, nor disposed of by the appel…
- Yaron v. Twp. of Northampton, 963 F.2d 33 (3d Cir. 1992).published Co., 334 U.S. 304, 306 , 68 S.Ct. 1039, 1040 , 92 L.Ed. 1403 (1948); Seese v. Volkswagenwerk, A.G., 679 F.2d 336, 337 (3d Cir.1982); Noel v. United Aircraft Corp., 359 F.2d 671, 674 (3d Cir.1966)).
- In re Rheam of Indiana, Inc., 137 B.R. 151 (Bankr. E.D. Pa. 1992).publishedSee Taylor v. United States, 815 F.2d 249, 252 (3d Cir.1987); Bankers Trust Co. v. Bethlehem Steel Corp., 761 F.2d 943, 949 (3d Cir.1985); and Seese v. Volkswagenwerk, A.G., 679 F.2d 336, 337 (3d Cir.1982).
- Alton J. Bailey v. Ryan Stevedoring Co., 894 F.2d 157 (5th Cir. 1990).published “[t]he district court is without jurisdiction to alter the mandate of the court of appeals on the basis of matters included or includable in defendants’ prior appeal”
- Bankers Trust Co. v. Bethlehem Steel Corp., 761 F.2d 943 (3d Cir. 1985).publishedCo., 334 U.S. 304, 306 , 68 S.Ct. 1039, 1040 , 92 L.Ed. 1403 (1948); Seese v. Volkswagenwerk, A.G., 679 F.2d 336, 337 (3d Cir.1982); Noel v. United Aircraft Corp., 359 F.2d 671, 674 (3d Cir.1966); Matter of Beverly Hills Bancorp, 752 F.2d…
- John Fink v. Jonathan Bishop, No. 24-3203 (3d Cir. Aug. 29, 2025).unpublishedSee Seese v. Volkswagenwerk, A.G., 679 F.2d 336, 337 (3d Cir. 1982) (per curiam) (recognizing that district courts are “without jurisdiction to alter the mandate of 4 that denial.
- Joseph Aruanno v. IRS, No. 24-2412 (3d Cir. Dec. 31, 2024).unpublishedSee Seese v. Volkswagenwerk, A.G., 679 F.2d 336, 337 (3d Cir. 1982) (per curiam).
- Gilbert Martinez v. Comm'r Soc. Sec., No. 23-3000 (3d Cir. Mar. 1, 2024).unpublished“[A] district court is without jurisdiction to alter the mandate of this court on the basis of matters included or includable in [a] prior appeal”
- Williams v. Sci-fayette, No. 2:20-cv-02979 (E.D. Pa. Oct. 26, 2022).See Seese v. Volkswagenwerk, A.G., 679 F.2d 336, 337 (3d Cir. 1982) (holding district courts cannot grant 60(b) motions on the basis of claims that were “includable” in prior proceedings).
- United States v. Pole, No. 2009-0354, 2021 WL 5796518 (D.D.C. Dec. 7, 2021).publishedSee Seese v. Volkswagenwerk, A.G., 679 F.2d 336, 337 (3d Cir. 1982) (“The district court is without jurisdiction to alter the mandate of this court on the 5 “Although the D.C.
- Concept Design Elec. & Mfg., Inc. v. Duplitronics, Inc., 104 F.3d 376 (Fed. Cir. 1996).unpublished(holding that even if there was a possible misinterpretation of North Carolina law, the litigation was "over" and "the district court was without jurisdiction to alter the mandate of [the Third Circuit] on the basis of m…)
- Whittington v. Gilbralter Sav. & Loan Ass'n (In re Spain), 103 B.R. 286 (N.D. Ala. 1988).publishedSee Seese v. Volkswagenwerk, A.G., 679 F.2d 336, 337 (3d Cir.1982); Ohio-Sealy Mattress Mfg.
- Devex Corp. v. Gen. Motors Corp., 638 F. Supp. 940 (D. Del. 1986).published (motion under Fed.R.Civ.P. 60(b)(6))
- Wheeler v. City of Pleasant Grove, 746 F.2d 1437 (11th Cir. 1984).published See Seese v. Volkswagenwerk, A.G., 679 F.2d 336, 337 (3d Cir.1982); Ohio-Sealy Mattress Mfg.
- Tyrone Green v. Sec'y John Wetzel, No. 25-2744 (3d Cir. Apr. 20, 2026).unpublishedSee id. at 270 ; see also Seese v. Volkswagenwerk, A.G., 679 F.2d 336, 337 (3d Cir. 1982) (per curiam) (explaining that a district court cannot alter an appellate mandate “on the basis of matters included or includable in [a] prior appeal”…
- United States v. McMurrin, 72 M.J. 697 (N.M.C.C.A. 2013).publishedCompare United States v. Thrasher, 483 F.3d 977, 982 (9th Cir.2007), United States v. Rivera, 844 F.2d 916, 921 (2d Cir.1988), and Seese v. Volkswagenwerk, A.G., 679 F.2d 336, 337 (3d Cir.1982) with United States v. Matthews, 312 F.3d 652,…
- United States v. Ronald Thrasher, 483 F.3d 977 (9th Cir. 2007).published See, e.g., Seese v. Volkswagenwerk, A.G., 679 F.2d 336 , 337 (3d Cir.1982); Tapco Prods.
- Gerda Dorothea Deweerth v. Edith Marks Baldinger, 38 F.3d 1266 (2d Cir. 1994).published
- Tu v. State, 648 A.2d 993 (Md. 1994).published
- Landano v. Rafferty, 126 F.R.D. 627 (D.N.J. 1989).published
on appeal from denial of Rule 60(b)(6) motion following this court's decision in Wilson
- No. 82-1559, 707 F.2d 823 (4th Cir. 1983).published(on appeal from denial of Rule 60(b)(6) motion following this court's decision in Wilson)
- Martin v. Volkswagen of Am., Inc., 707 F.2d 823 (4th Cir. 1983).published(on appeal from denial of Rule 60(b)(6) motion following this court’s decision in Wilson)
Other citing cases
- Christopher Rogalski v. Laureate Educ. Inc, No. 25-1441 (3d Cir. Apr. 30, 2026).unpublished
- Rogalski v. Laureate Educ., Inc., No. 1:20-cv-11747 (D.N.J. Oct. 16, 2024).
- Catherine Fernandez v. Bd. of Pemberton Twp., No. 22-3157 (3d Cir. June 20, 2023).unpublished
- Gina Russomanno v. Sunovion Pharm., No. 22-2822 (3d Cir. Dec. 29, 2022).unpublished
- Fink v. Kirchner, No. 2:19-cv-09374 (D.N.J. Jan. 8, 2020).
- Thomas Davis v. Cnty. of Allegheny, No. 19-2703 (3d Cir. Oct. 15, 2019).unpublished
- Talasila, Inc. v. United States, 524 F. App'x 671 (Fed. Cir. 2013).unpublished
v.
VOLKSWAGENWERK, A.G., a West German Corporation and Volkswagen of America, Inc., a New Jersey Corporation
[*337] OPINION OF THE COURT
PER CURIAM:A car accident in North Carolina gave rise to this diversity case brought in the District Court for the District of New Jersey. The jury awarded plaintiffs-appellees a verdict for nearly $2 million on two claims, one based on a theory of strict liability and the other based on a theory of negligence in failing to design a crashworthy vehicle. On appeal, this court held that the law of North Carolina, which controls this case, would not recognize the strict liability cause of action, although it would recognize the negligence cause of action. See Seese v. Volkswagenwerk, A.G., 648 F.2d 833 (3d Cir. 1981). This court denied defendants’ petition for rehearing on June 26, 1981. On August 14, 1981, the United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit ruled that North Carolina would not recognize the negligence theory. See Wilson v. Ford Motor Co., 656 F.2d 960 (4th Cir. 1981) (per curiam). On August 18, defendants moved for stay of mandate and for leave to file a second petition for rehearing, relying on Wilson. This court denied the motions. The United States Supreme Court denied defendants’ petition for certiorari on October 5, 1981. Volkswagenwerk, A.G. v. Seese, 102 S.Ct. 330 (1981). This court on October 15 issued its mandate affirming the judgment of the district court.
On October 15, defendants returned to the district court and moved under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 60(b)(6) for relief from the judgment, relying on Wilson. The district court denied the motion, and defendants appeal. This court now has jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 1291 (1976).
The district court stated at the hearing on defendants’ rule 60(b)(6) motion that:
The fact of the matter is that this litigation is over. It is final. It has gone through District Court, Third Circuit, rehearings, cert, petitions to the Supreme Court of the United States, cert, denied.
Even if it were true, which [ Wilson ] doesn’t make it true, that we have incorrectly guessed as to what North Carolina law would ultimately be, that would not be cognizable under Rule 60 at this time.
We believe the district court’s analysis was substantially correct. The district court is without jurisdiction to alter the mandate of this court on the basis of matters included or includable in defendants’ prior appeal. See Eutectic Corp. v. Metco, Inc., 597 F.2d 32, 34 (2d Cir. 1979); Tapco Products Co. v. Van Mark Products Corp., 466 F.2d 109, 110 (6th Cir. 1972).[1]
It is true, as defendants assert, that under Erie Railroad v. Tompkins, 304 U.S. 64, 58 S.Ct. 817, 82 L.Ed. 1188 (1938), federal courts must “apply state law ... in accordance with the then controlling decision of the highest state court,” as long as the matter is sub judice. Vandenbark v. Owens-Illinois Glass Co., 311 U.S. 538, 543, 61 S.Ct. 347, 350, 85 L.Ed. 327 (1941). We note that sub judice “means ‘under judicial consideration’ or in court and not yet decided.” Black’s Law Dictionary 1277 (5th ed. 1979). We thus hold that the Supreme Court’s denial of certiorari ended this litigation, and the case was not sub judice when the defendants made their rule 60(b)(6) motion.
Defendants argue that the present case is controlled by Huddleston v. Dwyer, 322 U.S. 232, 64 S.Ct. 1015, 88 L.Ed.2d 1246 (1944) (per curiam). Huddleston, however, is plainly and fairly distinguishable. In that case, petitioners in their second petition for rehearing had brought to the atten[*338]tion of the United States court of appeals an intervening, possibly controlling state court decision.[2] The court of appeals denied the petition. The United States Supreme Court granted certiorari and vacated the court of appeals’ judgment for reconsideration in light of the state court decision. In the present case, however, the Supreme Court denied certiorari.
Our holding that the present case was not sub judice when defendants made their rule 60(b)(6) motion reconciles the Eutectic, Tapco, and Vandenbark cases. While a case is on appeal, that case is sub judice for whichever appellate court is considering the appeal, and the appellate court must follow the teaching of Vandenbark. However, once a case has been appealed as far as it can be, and a final disposition of the case has been achieved, then the case is not sub judice and the principle of Eutectic and Tapco controls.
We will affirm the district court’s order denying the rule 60(b)(6) motion.
Standard Oil Co. v. United States, 429 U.S. 17, 97 S.Ct. 31, 50 L.Ed.2d 21 (1976) (per curiam), is not to the contrary. In that case the Supreme Court held that a district court could consider a rule 60(b) motion to reopen a case, which had been appealed, without seeking leave of the appellate court to recall its mandate. The Court stated that, “the appellate mandate relates to the record and issues then before the court, and does not purport to deal with possible later events. Hence, the district judge is not flouting the mandate by acting on the motion.” Id. at 18. In the present case, however, the basis of the rule 60(b)(6) motion was before this court and the Supreme Court, and thus could not be considered by the district court. See Commonwealth of Puerto Rico v. SS Zoe Colocotroni, 601 F.2d 39, 41 n.2 (1st Cir. 1979), cert. denied, 450 U.S. 912, 101 S.Ct. 1350, 67 L.Ed.2d 336 (1981).
We note that in the instant case defendants do not claim an intervening state court decision. We assume, but expressly do not decide, that the Vandenbark principle is to some extent applicable where there is an intervening decision of the federal court of appeals that is, by virtue of its location, most familiar with the relevant state law.
Thus, this case was in a comparable position to Huddleston at the point when defendants moved before this court for a stay of mandate and leave to file a second petition for rehearing.