#1
green
State v. Blair, 691 S.W.2d 259 (Mo. 1985)
An arrest may not be used as a pretext to search for evidence.
Police arrest a murder suspect based on an outstanding traffic warrant, despite lacking probable cause for the homicide, and subsequently fingerprint her to gather evidence for the unrelated murder. The question presented is whether the arrest was a pretext for an unlawful search. The court applies the rule that an arrest may not be used as a pretext to search for evidence, noting that the reviewing court must affirm the trial court's suppression ruling if the evidence supports its findings. Because the trial court found the arrest was a subterfuge to obtain fingerprints for the homicide investigation, the court affirms the suppression of the fingerprints and subsequent statements as fruits of the illegal seizure.
co-cited 36×
#2
green
Terry v. Ohio, 392 U.S. 1 (1968)
An officer may conduct a limited pat-down of outer clothing if specific and articulable facts reasonably warrant the belief that a person is armed and dangerous.
A police officer observed two men engaging in suspicious behavior near a store window, which led him to believe they were casing the location for a robbery. Based on his experience, the officer approached the men and conducted a pat-down of their outer clothing for weapons. He discovered revolvers on the individuals. The court considers whether an officer may conduct a limited search of a person's outer clothing for weapons without probable cause for an arrest. The court holds that a search is reasonable if the officer has specific and articulable facts that lead him to reasonably believe the individual is armed and dangerous, provided the search is reasonably related in scope to the circumstances justifying the interference.
co-cited 13×
#3
green
Eichenlaub v. Yurky, 474 U.S. 1049 (1986)
Quick Summary
Generate summary
co-cited 9×
#4
green
State v. Schneider, 736 S.W.2d 392 (Mo. 1987)
A photograph is not rendered inadmissible because other evidence describes the scene or the defendant offers to stipulate to the facts depicted.
In a capital murder case, the defendant challenged the trial court's exclusion of evidence regarding a codefendant's plea agreement during the penalty phase, arguing it was relevant mitigating evidence. The court held that the trial court did not abuse its discretion in excluding the evidence because the plea agreement did not pertain to the defendant's character, prior record, or the specific circumstances of the offense. The court further affirmed the admission of autopsy photographs, noting that a photograph is not rendered inadmissible merely because other evidence describes the scene or the defendant offers to stipulate to the facts depicted. The court affirmed the conviction and death sentence, finding the evidence overwhelming and the sentence proportionate.
co-cited 7×
#5
green
Miranda v. Arizona, 384 U.S. 436 (1966)
Statements from custodial interrogation are inadmissible unless the prosecution demonstrates the use of procedural safeguards to secure the privilege against self-incrimination.
When law enforcement officers initiate questioning after a person has been taken into custody or otherwise deprived of their freedom of action in a significant way, the prosecution may not use statements stemming from that custodial interrogation unless it demonstrates the use of procedural safeguards effective to secure the privilege against self-incrimination. To protect these Fifth Amendment rights, prior to any questioning, the individual must be warned that they have a right to remain silent, that any statement made may be used as evidence against them, and that they have a right to the presence of an attorney. If the individual indicates a desire to remain silent or consult an attorney, questioning must cease.
co-cited 6×
#6
green
State v. Antwine, 743 S.W.2d 51 (Mo. 1987)
A reviewing court must grant great deference to trial court findings regarding juror selection that depend on assessments of prosecutor credibility and motives.
An appellant charged with capital murder and robbery argues that the trial court erred in its jury selection process, specifically regarding the use of peremptory challenges and the factual presentation during voir dire. The court applies the standard that a defendant must establish a prima facie case of racial discrimination by showing the prosecutor used peremptory challenges to exclude members of the defendant's race, shifting the burden to the State to provide a neutral explanation. The court finds that the State's explanations for striking certain jurors were legitimate and non-pretextual, and that the trial judge's discretion in managing voir dire and excluding jurors for cause was not abused. The court concludes that the defendant failed to establish a prima facie case of discrimination.
co-cited 6×
#7
green
State v. Johns, 679 S.W.2d 253 (Mo. 1984)
An accomplice is liable for capital murder if the jury finds the defendant acted with the purpose of promoting or furthering the commission of the offense.
In a capital murder prosecution, the defendant was convicted as an accomplice to a gas station robbery-murder. The defendant argued that the jury instruction on accomplice liability was improper because it did not require the jury to find that he possessed the specific intent to commit the underlying capital murder, only that he purposely aided the offense. The court applied the rule that an aider and abettor is liable for the same degree of offense as the principal if the jury finds the aider purposely acted with the purpose of promoting or furthering the commission of the capital murder. The court held that the instruction correctly submitted the law and affirmed the conviction and death sentence.
co-cited 6×
#8
green
United States v. Lefkowitz, 285 U.S. 452 (1932)
An arrest may not be used as a pretext to conduct a general search for evidence without a valid warrant.
After federal agents executed an arrest warrant for conspiracy to violate the National Prohibition Act, they searched the respondents' office desks, cabinets, and baskets, seizing various papers and articles. The respondents moved to suppress the evidence, arguing the searches violated the Fourth and Fifth Amendments. The court considers whether these searches, conducted without a search warrant, were reasonable incidents of the arrest. Because the agents conducted general, exploratory searches solely to uncover evidence of guilt rather than seizing items in plain view or items specifically described in a warrant, the court holds that an arrest may not be used as a pretext to search for evidence.
co-cited 5×
#9
green
Scott v. United States, 436 U.S. 128 (1978)
The reasonableness of electronic surveillance under the minimization requirement is determined by an objective assessment of the officer's actions in light of the facts and circumstances known at the time.
Government agents conducted a court-authorized wiretap on a telephone used in a narcotics conspiracy but failed to make efforts to minimize the interception of non-relevant communications. Petitioners argued that the agents' knowing and purposeful failure to comply with the statutory minimization requirement constituted a violation of the law. The Court held that the statutory requirement to conduct surveillance in a way that minimizes non-subject communications must be judged by an objective standard. The officer's subjective intent or lack of good faith does not invalidate the action if the circumstances, viewed objectively, justify the interception. Because the agents' actions were reasonable based on the facts known at the time, the interceptions were valid.
co-cited 5×
#10
green
Strickland v. Washington, 466 U.S. 668 (1984)
To establish ineffective assistance of counsel, a defendant must show counsel's performance was deficient and that the deficiency prejudiced the defense by creating a reasonable probability of a different outcome.
A defendant claims his Sixth Amendment right to counsel was violated because his attorney failed to investigate mitigating evidence and present character witnesses during a capital sentencing proceeding. To establish a claim of ineffective assistance of counsel, a defendant must show that counsel's performance was deficient and that the deficient performance prejudiced the defense. Performance is deficient if counsel's representation falls below an objective standard of reasonableness. Prejudice exists if there is a reasonable probability that, but for counsel's unprofessional errors, the result of the proceeding would have been different, where a reasonable probability is a probability sufficient to undermine confidence in the outcome.
co-cited 5×
#11
green
Batson v. Kentucky, 476 U.S. 79 (1986)
The Equal Protection Clause prohibits a prosecutor from using peremptory challenges to exclude potential jurors solely on the basis of their race.
A black defendant challenged his conviction after the prosecutor used peremptory challenges to strike all black persons on the venire, resulting in an all-white jury. The Court holds that the Equal Protection Clause forbids a prosecutor from challenging potential jurors solely on account of their race or the assumption that black jurors cannot impartially consider the case. A defendant may establish a prima facie case of purposeful discrimination by showing they belong to a cognizable racial group and that the prosecutor used peremptory challenges to remove members of that race. Once established, the burden shifts to the State to provide a neutral explanation for the strikes.
co-cited 5×
#12
green
State v. Mease, 842 S.W.2d 98 (Mo. 1992)
A prosecutor may point out to the jury an absence of evidence to support a theory suggested by the defendant.
After a defendant was convicted of three counts of first-degree murder and three counts of armed criminal action, he appealed several rulings, including the admission of his confession and the refusal of a second-degree murder instruction. The defendant argued his confession was obtained via a pretextual arrest and that his right to counsel was violated. The court held that an officer's subjective motives are irrelevant if the arrest is objectively lawful under the Fourth Amendment and that a defendant who initiates communication with police after requesting counsel may validly waive his rights. Furthermore, because the defendant's conduct demonstrated clear deliberation, the trial court was not required to provide a lesser included offense instruction.
co-cited 5×