cites § 198 4×cited by 380 cases
- Where it cites § 198
- “"Fear of future harm — no matter how great the fear and no matter how great the likelihood of the harm — will not suffice.”
- The case’s holding
- Expert testimony regarding battered women's syndrome is relevant to both the subjective existence and the objective reasonableness of a defendant's belief in the need to defend.
- Later courts cite it for
- “for killing to be in self-defense, the defendant must actually and reasonably believe in the need to defend. if the belief subjectively exists but is objectively unreasonable, there is 'imperfect self-defense,' i.e., 'the defendant is deemed to have acted without malice and cannot be convicted of murder,' but can be convicted of manslaughter.” · 12 citing courts
cites § 198 1×cited by 33 cases
- Where it cites § 198
- “We find the law to be settled that “[t]o be exculpated on a theory of self-defense one must have an honest and reasonable belief in the need to defend.”
- The case’s holding
- A person may use deadly force in self-defense if driven solely by reasonable fear, even if other emotions exist provided they are not causal factors in the decision.
- Later courts cite it for
- “the party killing is not precluded from feeling anger or other emotions save and except fear; however, those other emotions cannot be causal factors in his decision to use deadly force” · 4 citing courts
cites § 198 2×cited by 708 cases
Flagged on editorial review. Superseded by statute on other grounds: 20 citing opinions limit it to other grounds, 1 says in part, and 1 says superseded outright. As recognized in People v. Christian S.
- Where it cites § 198
- “" (Pen. Code, § 198.) This rule is not questioned here.”
- The case’s holding
- An honest but unreasonable belief that it is necessary to defend oneself from imminent peril to life or great bodily injury negates malice aforethought.
- Later courts cite it for
- “an honest but unreasonable belief that it is necessary to defend oneself from imminent peril to life or great bodily injury negates malice aforethought, the mental element necessary for murder, so that the chargeable offense is reduced to manslaughter.” · 10 citing courts
cites § 198 1×cited by 102 cases
- Where it cites § 198
- “” (Pen. Code, § 198, which was read as an instruction.”
- The case’s holding
- The negligence or lack of skill of an attending physician contributing to a death does not relieve a person of liability for inflicting a dangerous wound.
- Later courts cite it for
- “when a person inflicts a wound on another which is dangerous, or calculated to destroy life, the fact that the negligence, mistake, or lack of skill of an attending physician or surgeon contributes to the death affords no defense to a charge of homicide.” · 2 citing courts
cites § 198 1×cited by 102 cases
- Where it cites § 198
- “” (See also Pen. Code, § 198.) (2) Since a homicide is justifiable under the circumstances specified in section 197, a fortiori an attempt to commit a violent injury upon another under those circumstances is justifiable.”
- The case’s holding
- The use of a deadly mechanical device is only justified if the attempted crime reasonably creates a fear of great bodily harm.
- Later courts cite it for
- “cases, of course, are not authority for propositions not there considered.” · 6 citing courts
cites § 198 1×cited by 69 cases
- Where it cites § 198
- “nts be accepted in its entirety, argues the Attorney General, to establish adequate provocation it is also necessary to believe that upon seeing at her window and then opening her door to a man with whom she had just spent a companionable two hours of drinking in her…”
- The case’s holding
- The law presumes malice when a killing is proved, so the prosecution need not present specific evidence of malice to support a murder indictment.
- Later courts cite it for
- “the people also argue that ' "when the killing is proved to have been committed by the defendant, and nothing further is shown, the presumption of law is that it was malicious and an act of murder; . . .” · 2 citing courts
cites § 198 1×cited by 56 cases
- Where it cites § 198
- “rder of the first degree because it was committed in the perpetration of robbery, the killer must, at the time of the killing, have had the purpose to rob (although not necessarily the purpose to kill), whereas, as the jury were told, in the case of a justifiable killing in…”
- The case’s holding
- In a murder trial, if the evidence is sufficient to raise a reasonable doubt as to whether the defendant acted in self-defense, the defendant is entitled to an acquittal.
- Later courts cite it for
- “in a trial for murder it is not necessary for the defendant to establish self defense by evidence sufficient to satisfy the jury that the self defense was true, but if the evidence is sufficient to raise a reasonable doubt as to whether the defendant was justified, then he is entitled to an acquittal.” · 4 citing courts
cites § 198 1×cited by 42 cases
- Where it cites § 198
- “” (Pen. Code, § 198.) *588 Lawful resistance to the commission of a public offense may be made by the party about to be injured.”
- The case’s holding
- The prosecution is bound by a defendant's statement regarding the circumstances of a killing in the absence of proof to the contrary.
- Later courts cite it for
- “the prosecution, having presented as a part of its case the statement of defendant as to how the killing occurred, is bound by that evidence in the absence of proof to the contrary.” · 4 citing courts
cites § 198 1×cited by 13 cases
- Where it cites § 198
- “Defendant’s argument is meritless. Penal Code section 198 specifically states “‘the circumstances must be sufficient to excite the fears of a reasonable person, and the party killing must have acted under the influence of such fears alone.”
- Later courts cite it for
- “he did not act on the basis of fear alone but also on a desire to kill his rival.” · 2 citing courts
cites § 198 1×cited by 34 cases
- Where it cites § 198
- “” (Pen. Code, § 198.) Only if the jurors were required to accept defendant’s version of the killing would we be inclined to agree with defendant’s contention of justification.”
- The case’s holding
- Self-defense requires that a defendant have cause to believe a threat exists and that it is reasonable to predicate fear upon those reported matters.
- Later courts cite it for
- “the immediate issue was not the truth of the matters reported to him but whether he had cause to believe them and, if so, whether it was reasonable for him to predicate a fear thereon.” · 1 citing court
cites § 198 1×cited by 32 cases
- Where it cites § 198
- “” (Pen. Code, §198.) “ ‘If the defendant in any way challenged the fight, and went to it armed, he cannot afterward maintain that in taking his assailant’s life he acted in self defense.”
- The case’s holding
- A killer who intends to kill one person but kills an intervening victim instead is guilty of the same degree of murder as if the intended victim died.
cites § 198 1×cited by 10 cases
- Where it cites § 198
- “’ (Pen. Code, § 198; see also § 197, subds. 2, 3.”
cites § 198 1×cited by 24 cases
- Where it cites § 198
- “” (Pen. Code, § 198.) There is no evidence which would have indicated to the trial court that the keys which the victim had in his hand after he unlocked the passenger side door of his car for Florez, before the altercation, and which were found by his body after he was shot,…”
- The case’s holding
- Partial diminished-capacity instructions given through caution, neglect, or mistake when not warranted do not preclude appellate inquiry into whether the evidence deserved consideration, and such error is not reversible if unprejudicial.
- Later courts cite it for
- “if the court through an abundance of caution, or neglect or mistake, gives partial instructions on diminished capacity . . . when no such instructions are warranted, it should not be ruled as a matter of law that all inquiry into the nature of the evidence on the issue is precluded .... the people are entitled to a determination by an appellate court that the evidence of diminished capacity from intoxication was in this case unworthy of consideration.” · 1 citing court
cites § 198 1×cited by 20 cases
- Where it cites § 198
- “” (Pen. Code, §198.) This argument concludes with the following statement.”
- Later courts cite it for
- “petitioner fails to note that the evidence may be construed to support a charge of manslaughter on the theory that some of the ingredients necessary to excuse the act as a justifiable homicide may not have been accepted by the grand jury.” · 1 citing court
cites § 198 1×cited by 76 cases
Disapproved by People v. Johnson on another ground: 4 citing opinions limit it to another ground and 1 adds another limit ("to the extent").
- Where it cites § 198
- “” (Pen. Code, § 198, italics added; see also, People v.”
- The case’s holding
- Multiple firearm-use enhancements are prohibited during a continuous transaction if the uses are incident to a single objective and no independent motivation emerges.
- Later courts cite it for
- “felony drunk driving presupposes an entirely innocent and unsuspecting victim . . . .” · 2 citing courts
cites § 198 1×cited by 362 cases
Flagged on editorial review. Disapproved by statute on another point: 5 citing opinions limit it to another point and 1 says disapproved outright. As recognized in People v. Saille.
- Where it cites § 198
- “In a prosecution for felonious homicide a trier of fact may have to determine whether the accused had that state of mind which would make the killing justifiable in self-defense—whether he acted only under the influence of honest, reasonable fear (Pen.”
- The case’s holding
- Competent evidence tending to show a defendant possessed the required specific intent or motive is admissible during the first stage of a bifurcated trial.
- Later courts cite it for
- “evidence which tends to show legal insanity (likewise, sanity) is not admissible at the first stage of the trial because it is not pertinent to any issue then being litigated; but competent evidence, other than proof of sanity or insanity, which tends to show that a (then presumed) legally sane defendant either did or did not in fact possess the required specific intent or motive is admissible.” · 3 citing courts
cites § 198 1×cited by 2 cases
- Where it cites § 198
- “When he learned that Smith was dead, appellant surrendered to the police, but he gave a false statement that he had no knife, but only a ring on his finger when he struck Smith.”
cites § 198 1×cited by 78 cases
Disapproved by People v. Blakeley on another ground: 18 citing opinions limit it to another ground and 2 say disapproved outright.
- Where it cites § 198
- “(Pen. Code, § 198; People v. Collins, supra.”
- The case’s holding
- Issues regarding self-defense, including the necessity of defense and the reasonableness of force used, are normally questions of fact for the trier of fact.
- Later courts cite it for
- “issues arising out of self-defense, including whether the circumstances would cause a reasonable person to perceive the necessity of defense, whether the defendant actually acted out of defense of himself, and whether the force used was excessive, are normally questions of fact for the trier of fact to resolve.” · 4 citing courts
cites § 198 2×cited by 0 casesunpublished
- Where it cites § 198
- “8 Defendant’s argument includes a sprawling investigation into the pre-1872 legislative history of Penal Code section 198, early case authority, and federal due process.”
cites § 198 2×cited by 0 casesunpublished
- Where it cites § 198
- “” The Court of Appeal rejected the defendant’s argument as meritless because “Penal Code section 198 specifically states ‘the circumstances must be sufficient to excite the fears of a reasonable person, and the party killing must have acted under the influence of such fears…”
Show all 28 citing cases (list view) →
The flag is Syfertize’s treatment of the citing case itself, not of the statute. “Where it cites” is the passage in the opinion; the holding is a summary of the whole case and may concern another point. Annotations are extracted automatically from the opinions in the Syfert caselaw corpus.