State v. Clayton (1973)
green
· 113 citation events
across 8 courts.
Showing the 21 strongest citers on record.
Treatment trajectory · 1973 → 2026 · click a year to view the case as of then
197319992026
Sort:
By significance ·
Most recent
Thus, the Arizona Supreme Court has declared that “ ‘[t]he jury may not be instructed on a lesser degree of murder than first degree where, under the evidence, it was committed in the course of a robbery.’” State v. Clayton, 109 Ariz. 587, 595 , 514 P. 2d 720, 728 (1973), quoting State v. Kruchten, 101 Ariz. 186, 196 , 417 P. 2d 510, 520 (1966), cert. denied, 385 U. S. 1043 (1967) (emphasis added).
Peterson, 595 N.Y.S.2d at 384 , 611 N.E.2d at 285 ; State v. Clayton, 109 Ariz. 587 , 514 P.2d 720, 727-28 (1973).
Although the trial court was best equipped to evaluate L.’s demeanor and the tenor of her answers, see State v. Clayton, 109 Ariz. 587, 592 , 514 P.2d 720, 725 (1973), L. clearly had serious reservations about her ability to be objective and unbiased in deciding a case that involved considerable illegal drug use.
green
State of Arizona v. Christina Marie George, No. 2 CA-CR 2002-0307 (Ariz. Ct. App. Nov. 26, 2003).published
Although the trial court was best equipped to evaluate L.’s demeanor and the tenor of her answers, see State v. Clayton, 109 Ariz. 587, 592 , 514 P.2d 720, 725 (1973), L. clearly had serious reservations about her ability to be objective and unbiased in deciding a case that involved considerable illegal drug use.
E.g., State v. Clayton, 109 Ariz. 587, 592-93 , 514 P.2d 720, 725-26 (1973) (juror "would try" to follow instructions); State v. Poehnelt, 150 Ariz. 136, 146 , 722 P.2d 304, 314 (App.1985) (juror "believed" he could be fair and impartial).
juror "would try" to follow instructions
Clabourne, supra; State v. Clayton, 109 Ariz. 587, 593 , 514 P.2d 720, 727 (1973).
See also State v. Cook, 170 Ariz. 40, 54 , 821 P.2d 731, 745 (1991); State v. Comer, 165 Ariz. 413, 426 , 799 P.2d 333, 346 (1990); State v. Clabourne, 142 Ariz. 335, 344 , 690 P.2d 54, 63 (1984); State v. Clayton, 109 Ariz. 587, 592 , 514 P.2d 720, 725 (1973).
State v. Clayton, 109 Ariz. 587, 593 , 514 P.2d 720, 726 (1973) (juror rehabilitated who stated “I will try to follow the law the way it is, is all I can say.”) We find no abuse of discretion in the court’s failure to strike the prospective juror for cause.
juror rehabilitated who stated “I will try to follow the law the way it is, is all I can say.”
Flores v. State, 475 P.2d 37, 39 (Alaska 1970) (courtroom door locked during deliberations); State v. Clayton, 109 Ariz. 587, 594-95 , 514 P.2d 720, 727-28 (1973) (courtroom door locked during voir dire); People v. Frisco, 4 Ill.
State v. Clayton, 109 Ariz. 587, 598 , 514 P.2d 720, 731 (1973) (dismissal of premeditated murder count at conclusion of State’s case did not prevent jurors from finding defendant guilty of felony murder).
dismissal of premeditated murder count at conclusion of State’s case did not prevent jurors from finding defendant guilty of felony murder
The jurors were given two forms of verdicts concerning the homicide which read: “We the jury * * * do find the defendant -of the crime of murder, first degree. , “We the jury * * * do find the defendant -of the crime of murder, second degree.” While we have said: “The trial court should instruct the jury on every degree or grade of the offense which is supported by the evidence, * * State v. Clayton, 109 Ariz. 587, 595 , 514 P.2d 720, 728 (1973) (see also State v. Miniefield…
see also State v. Miniefield, 110 Ariz. 599 , 522P.2d 25 (1974
Id.; See State v. Clayton, 109 Ariz. 587, 593-94 , 514 P.2d 720, 726-27 (1973).
Accord, State v. Clayton, 109 Ariz. 587, 600 , 514 P.2d 720, 733 (1973).
See also State v. Clayton & Penrod, 109 Ariz. 587 , 514 P.2d 720 , filed September 27, 1973.
See id. at 458-59, ¶27 , 999 P.2d at 802-03 (juror stated “I think I can be fair”); State v. Trostle, 191 Ariz. 4, 13 , 951 P.2d 869, 878 (1997)(juror responded “I guess” when asked if he could keep an open mind despite pretrial publicity; another juror said he did not “believe” the publicity would affect his ability to do the same); State v. Clayton, 109 Ariz. 587, 592-93 , 514 P.2d 720, 725-26 (1973) (juror “would try” to follow instructions regarding the law of self-defen…
juror “would try” to follow instructions regarding the law of self-defense
See State v. Clayton, 109 Ariz. 587, 593 , 514 P.2d 720, 727 (1973).
See also State v. Clayton, 109 Ariz. 587, 600 , 514 P.2d 720, 733 (1973).
Accord, State v. Clayton, 109 Ariz. 587, 600 , 514 P.2d 720, 733 (1973).
See State v. Clayton, 109 Ariz. 587 , 514 P.2d 720 (1973). “[I]t is the law in this state that a man in a place where he has the right to be is not obliged to follow the old English doctrine of retreat to the wall, but may stand his ground and kill his assailant to avoid death or great bodily harm.
See State v. Clayton, 109 Ariz. 587, 592-93 , 514 P.2d 720 (1973).
See State v. Clayton, 109 *147 Ariz. 587, 514 P.2d 720 (1973); State v. Turrentine, 122 Ariz. 39 , 592 P.2d 1305 (App.1979).