Already have an account? Sign in instead.
You stay signed in for 30 days on this browser.
Continue with Google Continue with MicrosoftNo account yet? Create a free one.
We sent a six-digit code.
It expires in ten minutes, works once, and only in this browser. Five wrong tries void it. Send another code.
Your account is live and the Cloudflare checks are off for this browser.
5 North Carolina opinions name it 2 courts 1909–2008 0 in the last five years
The cases below were cited by North Carolina courts in a sentence that names this issue. Sides come from how each citing opinion treated the case (Syfertize flag on that citation), so a case can appear on both: that is where the law is contested. A red or yellow chip is the case's own overall treatment.
| Case | Followed | Cited |
|---|---|---|
Gaither Corporation v. Skinnergreen2 sentences2008However, “[i]t is to be noted that the phase of the doctrine of res judicata which precludes relitigation of the same cause of action is broader in its application than a mere determination of the questions involved in the prior action.” Id. 2008“The bar of the judgment in such cases extends not only to matters actually determined, but also to other matters which in the exercise of due diligence could have been presented for determination in the prior action.” Id. at 535-36 , 85 S.E.2d at 911 ; see also Black’s Law Dictionary 1337 (8th ed. 2004) (“[T]he effect of foreclosing any litigation of matters that never have been litigated[] because of the determination that they should have been advanced in an earlier suit. . . has gone under the name, ‘true res judicata,’ or the names, ‘merger’ and ‘bar.’ ”) (quoting Charles Alan Wright, The | 1 | 2 |
| Case | Negative | Cited |
|---|---|---|
| No negative-treatment citations attached to this issue in North Carolina. Read the followed side critically anyway. | ||
| Case | Cited | Years |
|---|---|---|
Dean v. Dean
green
2 sentences1942Dec., 226, with a full and learned note on this phase of the doctrine; Dean v. Dean, 6 Conn., 285 ; Cain v. Cox, 23 West Va., 594, 605 ; Dyer v. Dyer, White and Tudor Leading Cases in Equity (part 1), pp. 314, 344, 354, 355, 356, etc.” See, also, Newton v. Clark, 174 N. C., 393 , 93 S. E., 951 ; Chilton v. Smith, 180 N. C., 472 , 105 S. E., 1 ; Sorrell v. Sorrell, 198 N. C., 460 , 152 S. E., 157 . 1926Dec., 226, with a full and learned note on this phase of the doctrine; Dean v. Dean, 6 Conn., 285 ; Cain v. Cox, 23 West Va., 594, 605 ; Dyer v. Dyer, White and Tudor Leading Cases in Equity (part 1), pp. 314, 344, 354, 355, 356, etc.” On this point the following additional authorities may be consulted: Jones v. Jones, 164 N. C., 320 ; Campbell v. Sigmon, 170 N. C., 348 ; Walters v. Walters, 172 N. C., 328 ; Chilton v. Smith, 180 N. C., 472 ; Swain v. Goodman, 183 N. C., 531 ; Blue v. Wilmington, 186 N. C., 321 . | 3 | 1909–1942 |
Cain v. Cox
green
2 sentences1942Dec., 226, with a full and learned note on this phase of the doctrine; Dean v. Dean, 6 Conn., 285 ; Cain v. Cox, 23 West Va., 594, 605 ; Dyer v. Dyer, White and Tudor Leading Cases in Equity (part 1), pp. 314, 344, 354, 355, 356, etc.” See, also, Newton v. Clark, 174 N. C., 393 , 93 S. E., 951 ; Chilton v. Smith, 180 N. C., 472 , 105 S. E., 1 ; Sorrell v. Sorrell, 198 N. C., 460 , 152 S. E., 157 . 1926Dec., 226, with a full and learned note on this phase of the doctrine; Dean v. Dean, 6 Conn., 285 ; Cain v. Cox, 23 West Va., 594, 605 ; Dyer v. Dyer, White and Tudor Leading Cases in Equity (part 1), pp. 314, 344, 354, 355, 356, etc.” On this point the following additional authorities may be consulted: Jones v. Jones, 164 N. C., 320 ; Campbell v. Sigmon, 170 N. C., 348 ; Walters v. Walters, 172 N. C., 328 ; Chilton v. Smith, 180 N. C., 472 ; Swain v. Goodman, 183 N. C., 531 ; Blue v. Wilmington, 186 N. C., 321 . | 3 | 1909–1942 |
Chilton v. . Smith
neutral
2 sentences1942Dec., 226, with a full and learned note on this phase of the doctrine; Dean v. Dean, 6 Conn., 285 ; Cain v. Cox, 23 West Va., 594, 605 ; Dyer v. Dyer, White and Tudor Leading Cases in Equity (part 1), pp. 314, 344, 354, 355, 356, etc.” See, also, Newton v. Clark, 174 N. C., 393 , 93 S. E., 951 ; Chilton v. Smith, 180 N. C., 472 , 105 S. E., 1 ; Sorrell v. Sorrell, 198 N. C., 460 , 152 S. E., 157 . 1942Dec., 226, with a full and learned note on this phase of the doctrine; Dean v. Dean, 6 Conn., 285 ; Cain v. Cox, 23 West Va., 594, 605 ; Dyer v. Dyer, White and Tudor Leading Cases in Equity (part 1), pp. 314, 344, 354, 355, 356, etc.” See, also, Newton v. Clark, 174 N. C., 393 , 93 S. E., 951 ; Chilton v. Smith, 180 N. C., 472 , 105 S. E., 1 ; Sorrell v. Sorrell, 198 N. C., 460 , 152 S. E., 157 . | 2 | 1926–1942 |
Kabatnik v. Westminster Co.
green
1 sentence1994App. 708 , 306 S.E.2d 513 (1983), which say: It is to be noted that the phase of the doctrine of res judicata which precludes relitigation of the same cause of action is broader in its application than a mere determination of the questions involved in the prior action. | 1 | 1994–1994 |
Newton v. . Clark
neutral
2 sentences1942Dec., 226, with a full and learned note on this phase of the doctrine; Dean v. Dean, 6 Conn., 285 ; Cain v. Cox, 23 West Va., 594, 605 ; Dyer v. Dyer, White and Tudor Leading Cases in Equity (part 1), pp. 314, 344, 354, 355, 356, etc.” See, also, Newton v. Clark, 174 N. C., 393 , 93 S. E., 951 ; Chilton v. Smith, 180 N. C., 472 , 105 S. E., 1 ; Sorrell v. Sorrell, 198 N. C., 460 , 152 S. E., 157 . 1942Dec., 226, with a full and learned note on this phase of the doctrine; Dean v. Dean, 6 Conn., 285 ; Cain v. Cox, 23 West Va., 594, 605 ; Dyer v. Dyer, White and Tudor Leading Cases in Equity (part 1), pp. 314, 344, 354, 355, 356, etc.” See, also, Newton v. Clark, 174 N. C., 393 , 93 S. E., 951 ; Chilton v. Smith, 180 N. C., 472 , 105 S. E., 1 ; Sorrell v. Sorrell, 198 N. C., 460 , 152 S. E., 157 . | 1 | 1942–1942 |
Sorrell v. . Sorrell
green
2 sentences1942Dec., 226, with a full and learned note on this phase of the doctrine; Dean v. Dean, 6 Conn., 285 ; Cain v. Cox, 23 West Va., 594, 605 ; Dyer v. Dyer, White and Tudor Leading Cases in Equity (part 1), pp. 314, 344, 354, 355, 356, etc.” See, also, Newton v. Clark, 174 N. C., 393 , 93 S. E., 951 ; Chilton v. Smith, 180 N. C., 472 , 105 S. E., 1 ; Sorrell v. Sorrell, 198 N. C., 460 , 152 S. E., 157 . 1942Dec., 226, with a full and learned note on this phase of the doctrine; Dean v. Dean, 6 Conn., 285 ; Cain v. Cox, 23 West Va., 594, 605 ; Dyer v. Dyer, White and Tudor Leading Cases in Equity (part 1), pp. 314, 344, 354, 355, 356, etc.” See, also, Newton v. Clark, 174 N. C., 393 , 93 S. E., 951 ; Chilton v. Smith, 180 N. C., 472 , 105 S. E., 1 ; Sorrell v. Sorrell, 198 N. C., 460 , 152 S. E., 157 . | 1 | 1942–1942 |
Swain v. . Goodman
neutral
1 sentence1926Dec., 226, with a full and learned note on this phase of the doctrine; Dean v. Dean, 6 Conn., 285 ; Cain v. Cox, 23 West Va., 594, 605 ; Dyer v. Dyer, White and Tudor Leading Cases in Equity (part 1), pp. 314, 344, 354, 355, 356, etc.” On this point the following additional authorities may be consulted: Jones v. Jones, 164 N. C., 320 ; Campbell v. Sigmon, 170 N. C., 348 ; Walters v. Walters, 172 N. C., 328 ; Chilton v. Smith, 180 N. C., 472 ; Swain v. Goodman, 183 N. C., 531 ; Blue v. Wilmington, 186 N. C., 321 . | 1 | 1926–1926 |
Blue v. City of Wilmington
neutral
1 sentence1926Dec., 226, with a full and learned note on this phase of the doctrine; Dean v. Dean, 6 Conn., 285 ; Cain v. Cox, 23 West Va., 594, 605 ; Dyer v. Dyer, White and Tudor Leading Cases in Equity (part 1), pp. 314, 344, 354, 355, 356, etc.” On this point the following additional authorities may be consulted: Jones v. Jones, 164 N. C., 320 ; Campbell v. Sigmon, 170 N. C., 348 ; Walters v. Walters, 172 N. C., 328 ; Chilton v. Smith, 180 N. C., 472 ; Swain v. Goodman, 183 N. C., 531 ; Blue v. Wilmington, 186 N. C., 321 . | 1 | 1926–1926 |
Walters v. . Walters
neutral
1 sentence1926Dec., 226, with a full and learned note on this phase of the doctrine; Dean v. Dean, 6 Conn., 285 ; Cain v. Cox, 23 West Va., 594, 605 ; Dyer v. Dyer, White and Tudor Leading Cases in Equity (part 1), pp. 314, 344, 354, 355, 356, etc.” On this point the following additional authorities may be consulted: Jones v. Jones, 164 N. C., 320 ; Campbell v. Sigmon, 170 N. C., 348 ; Walters v. Walters, 172 N. C., 328 ; Chilton v. Smith, 180 N. C., 472 ; Swain v. Goodman, 183 N. C., 531 ; Blue v. Wilmington, 186 N. C., 321 . | 1 | 1926–1926 |
Campbell v. . Sigmon
neutral
1 sentence1926Dec., 226, with a full and learned note on this phase of the doctrine; Dean v. Dean, 6 Conn., 285 ; Cain v. Cox, 23 West Va., 594, 605 ; Dyer v. Dyer, White and Tudor Leading Cases in Equity (part 1), pp. 314, 344, 354, 355, 356, etc.” On this point the following additional authorities may be consulted: Jones v. Jones, 164 N. C., 320 ; Campbell v. Sigmon, 170 N. C., 348 ; Walters v. Walters, 172 N. C., 328 ; Chilton v. Smith, 180 N. C., 472 ; Swain v. Goodman, 183 N. C., 531 ; Blue v. Wilmington, 186 N. C., 321 . | 1 | 1926–1926 |
Jones v. . Jones
neutral
1 sentence1926Dec., 226, with a full and learned note on this phase of the doctrine; Dean v. Dean, 6 Conn., 285 ; Cain v. Cox, 23 West Va., 594, 605 ; Dyer v. Dyer, White and Tudor Leading Cases in Equity (part 1), pp. 314, 344, 354, 355, 356, etc.” On this point the following additional authorities may be consulted: Jones v. Jones, 164 N. C., 320 ; Campbell v. Sigmon, 170 N. C., 348 ; Walters v. Walters, 172 N. C., 328 ; Chilton v. Smith, 180 N. C., 472 ; Swain v. Goodman, 183 N. C., 531 ; Blue v. Wilmington, 186 N. C., 321 . | 1 | 1926–1926 |
Opinions by the citing court's state. A doctrine retained in one state and abandoned in another shows up here as a year span that stalls.