unfounded claim (New York) · Go Syfert
← New York issues

unfounded claim in New York

15 New York opinions name it 8 courts 1843–2012 0 in the last five years

The cases below were cited by New York courts in a sentence that names this issue. Sides come from how each citing opinion treated the case (Syfertize flag on that citation), so a case can appear on both: that is where the law is contested. A red or yellow chip is the case's own overall treatment.

Followed or applied (5)

CaseFollowedCited
Brown v. Bethlehem Terrace Associatesgreen
nyappdiv · 1988 · cited in 2 New York opinions naming this issue, 1992–2011
2 sentences

2011However, the filing of a false lis pendens is sufficient to base a claim for slander of title, provided special damages are asserted. “ ‘There is no doubt that the act of wrongfully filing of record an unfounded claim to the property of another is actionable as slander of title’ (Annotation, Recording of Instrument Purporting to Affect Title as Slander of Title, 39 ALR2d 840, 842). ‘The wrongful filing for record of a document which casts a cloud upon another’s title to or interest in realty is clearly such an act of publication as to give rise to an action for slander of title, if provable da

1992"The wrongful filing for record of a document which casts a cloud upon another’s title to or interest in realty is clearly such an act of publication as to give rise to an action for slander of title, if provable damages result” (Annotation, Recording of Instrument Purporting to Affect Title as Slander of Title, 39 ALR2d 840, 843; see also, Brown v Bethlehem Terrace Assocs., 136 AD2d 222 ).

22
Hanbidge v. Huntgreen
nyappdiv · 1992 · cited in 2 New York opinions naming this issue, 2006–2011
2 sentences

2011However, the filing of a false lis pendens is sufficient to base a claim for slander of title, provided special damages are asserted. “ ‘There is no doubt that the act of wrongfully filing of record an unfounded claim to the property of another is actionable as slander of title’ (Annotation, Recording of Instrument Purporting to Affect Title as Slander of Title, 39 ALR2d 840, 842). ‘The wrongful filing for record of a document which casts a cloud upon another’s title to or interest in realty is clearly such an act of publication as to give rise to an action for slander of title, if provable da

2006The wrongful filing for record of a document which casts a cloud upon another’s title to or interest in realty is clearly such an act of publication as to give rise to an action for slander of title, if provable damages result” (Hanbidge v Hunt, supra at 701, quoting Annotation, Recording of Instrument Purporting to Affect Title as Slander of Title, 39 ALR2d 840, 842-843; cf. Brown v Bethlehem Terrace Assoc., supra).

22
Rosenbaum v. City of New Yorkgreen
nyappdiv · 2005 · cited in 1 New York opinions naming this issue, 2011–2011
1 sentence

2011However, the filing of a false lis pendens is sufficient to base a claim for slander of title, provided special damages are asserted. “ ‘There is no doubt that the act of wrongfully filing of record an unfounded claim to the property of another is actionable as slander of title’ (Annotation, Recording of Instrument Purporting to Affect Title as Slander of Title, 39 ALR2d 840, 842). ‘The wrongful filing for record of a document which casts a cloud upon another’s title to or interest in realty is clearly such an act of publication as to give rise to an action for slander of title, if provable da

11
Rosenbaum v. City of New Yorkgreen
ny · 2006 · cited in 1 New York opinions naming this issue, 2011–2011
1 sentence

2011However, the filing of a false lis pendens is sufficient to base a claim for slander of title, provided special damages are asserted. “ ‘There is no doubt that the act of wrongfully filing of record an unfounded claim to the property of another is actionable as slander of title’ (Annotation, Recording of Instrument Purporting to Affect Title as Slander of Title, 39 ALR2d 840, 842). ‘The wrongful filing for record of a document which casts a cloud upon another’s title to or interest in realty is clearly such an act of publication as to give rise to an action for slander of title, if provable da

11
Lowber v. Mayor of New Yorkgreen
nysupct · 1857 · cited in 1 New York opinions naming this issue, 1921–1921
1 sentence

1921See, also, Lowber v. Mayor, etc., 26 Barb. 262 .) The appellant has standing to invoke this power of the court in two capacities: As a stockholder of the company to prevent a judgment being taken against it, by reason of the fraudulent action of its officers, for an unfounded claim; and also as the indemnitor of the surety on the undertaking whereby he would be the person ultimately hable to pay.

11

Distinguished, questioned or overruled (0)

CaseNegativeCited
No negative-treatment citations attached to this issue in New York. Read the followed side critically anyway.

Also cited on this issue (18)

CaseCitedYears
Bank of America, N.A. v. Tornheim green
nyappdiv · 2011
1 sentence

2012In Bank of Am., N.A. v Tornheim ( 82 AD3d 1141 [2011]), the Second Department declined to dismiss a recently commenced foreclosure action since the defendants’ demands therefor were predicated upon an unfounded claim that the Helping Families Act created a moratorium on foreclosure actions.

12012–2012
People v. . Patrick green
ny · 1905
1 sentence

2000The court properly exercised its discretion in declining to recuse itself based on an unfounded claim that it had engaged in ex parte discussions of the case with a prosecutor (see, People v Moreno, 70 NY2d 403 ; People v Patrick, 183 NY 52, 54-55 ).

12000–2000
People v. Benevento green
ny · 1998
1 sentence

2000On the totality of the existing record, we find that defendant received meaningful representation (see, People v Benevento, 91 NY2d 708, 713-714 ).

12000–2000
People v. Moreno green
ny · 1987
1 sentence

2000The court properly exercised its discretion in declining to recuse itself based on an unfounded claim that it had engaged in ex parte discussions of the case with a prosecutor (see, People v Moreno, 70 NY2d 403 ; People v Patrick, 183 NY 52, 54-55 ).

12000–2000
Gabrelian v. Gabrelian green
nyappdiv · 1985
1 sentence

1998At the very least, the imposition and enforcement of a monetary sanction is appropriate (see, Jermosen v State of New York, 178 AD2d 810 ; Gabrelian v Gabrelian, 108 AD2d 445 , appeal dismissed 66 NY2d 741 ; see also, Judiciary Law §§ 750, 753 [defining conduct punishable as criminal and civil contempt respectively]).

11998–1998
Jermosen v. State green
nyappdiv · 1991
1 sentence

1998At the very least, the imposition and enforcement of a monetary sanction is appropriate (see, Jermosen v State of New York, 178 AD2d 810 ; Gabrelian v Gabrelian, 108 AD2d 445 , appeal dismissed 66 NY2d 741 ; see also, Judiciary Law §§ 750, 753 [defining conduct punishable as criminal and civil contempt respectively]).

11998–1998
Bisca v. Bisca green
ny · 1985
1 sentence

1998At the very least, the imposition and enforcement of a monetary sanction is appropriate (see, Jermosen v State of New York, 178 AD2d 810 ; Gabrelian v Gabrelian, 108 AD2d 445 , appeal dismissed 66 NY2d 741 ; see also, Judiciary Law §§ 750, 753 [defining conduct punishable as criminal and civil contempt respectively]).

11998–1998
People v. Weil neutral
nycountyct · 1952
1 sentence

1960(People v. Weil, 203 Misc. 68 , affd. 281 App. Div. 1054 .) It is not a vehicle for additional appeal or belated motion for a new trial which, although available to a defendant after verdict, was not made.

11960–1960
Powelson v. Lake Placid Co. green
nyappdiv · 1953
1 sentence

1960(People v. Weil, 203 Misc. 68 , affd. 281 App. Div. 1054 .) It is not a vehicle for additional appeal or belated motion for a new trial which, although available to a defendant after verdict, was not made.

11960–1960
People v. Lesser green
nyappdiv · 1952
1 sentence

1952(People v. Lesser, 280 App. Div. 441 .) The court finds no proof of fraud, nor does it find in the record a denial to the petitioner of his constitutional rights.

11952–1952
Farmers' Loan & Trust Co. v. New York & Northern Railway Co. green
ny · 1896
1 sentence

1931Co., 150 N. Y. 410 ; Modlin v. Licht, 224 App. Div. 614 ; Drucklieb v. Harris, 158 id. 873.) In violation of his duty to prevent, so far as he legitimately could, the commencement of an action against the corporation, the complaint alleged that he connived and procured such action to be brought upon an unfounded claim.

11931–1931
Modlin v. Licht green
nyappdiv · 1928
1 sentence

1931Co., 150 N. Y. 410 ; Modlin v. Licht, 224 App. Div. 614 ; Drucklieb v. Harris, 158 id. 873.) In violation of his duty to prevent, so far as he legitimately could, the commencement of an action against the corporation, the complaint alleged that he connived and procured such action to be brought upon an unfounded claim.

11931–1931
Winne v. Hills green
nysupct · 1895
1 sentence

1909But public policy requires that demands against deceased parties must be strictly proved, and to relax that rule-would give rise to evils far outweighing the inconveniences resulting from its strict enforcement; inconveniences which could be obviated by the exercise of ordinary care in procuring written or other evidence of contracts not dependent for validity upon the continuance of the life of either party.” “ It seems to be well settled that claims 'against the estates of deceased persons, in order to be upheld, must be clearly proved by competent evidence, and be free from any just or well

11909–1909
Clegg v. New York Newspaper Union neutral
nysupct · 1889
1 sentence

1892And there is certainly no justice in subjecting a person to what is really an unfounded claim, or for preventing him from maintaining an equally, well-founded defense,' because the evidence discovered by him by which that can be done may be of the same quality or description as that given upon the trial in which he has. been defeated.” And, again, it was said in Clegg v. Newspaper Union, (Sup.) 4 N. Y.

11892–1892
Ford v. . Belmont neutral
ny · 1877
1 sentence

1889Id. § 1639 of the Code prescribes what the complaint must set forth in actions for the determination of claims to real property.

11889–1889
Doren v. Mayor of New-York neutral
nychanct · 1842
1 sentence

1856This principle is also very well settled by authority. ( Van Doren v. The Mayor, c., of New-York, 9 Paige, 388 ; The Mayor, c., of Brooklyn v. Merserole, 26 Wend., 132 .) In both these classes of cases the party whose estate is questioned may naturally wish to have the matter speedily determined, as he may in the mean time suffer inconveniences and even actual damage on account of the discredit attaching to his title by reason of the unfounded claim.

11856–1856
Mayor of Brooklyn v. Meserole green
nysupct · 1841
1 sentence

1856This principle is also very well settled by authority. ( Van Doren v. The Mayor, c., of New-York, 9 Paige, 388 ; The Mayor, c., of Brooklyn v. Merserole, 26 Wend., 132 .) In both these classes of cases the party whose estate is questioned may naturally wish to have the matter speedily determined, as he may in the mean time suffer inconveniences and even actual damage on account of the discredit attaching to his title by reason of the unfounded claim.

11856–1856
Beekman v. Hudson green
nysupct · 1838
1 sentence

1843Ca. 223;) Abraham v. Alman, (1 Russ. 509;) Wood v. Richardson, (4 Beav. 174;) Pratt v. Church, (4 Ibid. 177 , note;) Hadon v. Hadon, (9 Simons, 438;) Raikes v. Ward, (1 Hare’s R. 445;) Crockett v. Crockett, (1 Ibid. 451.) And foi another class of cases, Hamley v. Gilbert, (Jacob, 354;) Broad v. Bevan, 1 Russ. 511, note;) Wetherell v. Wilson, (1 Keen, 80;) Woods v. Woods, (1 M. & Craig, 401;) Leach v. Leach, (7 Loud.

11843–1843

Where else courts name it

NC 47 (1978–2026) NY 15 (1843–2012) OH 14 (2000–2024) IL 13 (1888–2023) CA 11 (1890–2016) NM 11 (1969–2024) MD 10 (1871–2016) MO 9 (1956–2021) VA 7 (1925–2025) MI 6 (1881–2025) CO 5 (1994–2025) SC 5 (1995–2018) PA 4 (1877–2019) GA 3 (1947–1991) IN 3 (1899–2001) AZ 3 (1967–1971) AL 3 (1886–1982) IA 3 (1908–1996) OK 2 (1976–2018) TN 2 (1860–1860) OR 2 (1896–1960) KY 2 (1877–1914) KS 2 (1922–2021) WV 2 (1892–1946)

Opinions by the citing court's state. A doctrine retained in one state and abandoned in another shows up here as a year span that stalls.

← Caselaw search · G Cite Topics · Brief Check